Look Alike, Sound Alike: Phenocopies in Steroid-Resistant Nephrotic Syndrome

Hidden genetics behind glomerular scars: an opportunity to understand the heterogeneity of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis?

Focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) is a complex disease which describes different kinds of kidney defects, not exclusively linked with podocyte defects. Since nephrin mutation was first described in association with early-onset nephrotic syndrome (NS), many advancements have been made in understanding genetic patterns associated with FSGS. New genetic causes of FSGS have been discovered, displaying unexpected genotypes, and recognizing possible site of damage. Many recent large-scale sequencing analyses on patients affected by idiopathic chronic kidney disease (CKD), kidney failure (KF) of unknown origin, or classified as FSGS, have revealed collagen alpha IV genes, as one of the most frequent sites of pathogenic mutations. Also, recent interest in complex and systemic lysosomal storage diseases, such as Fabry disease, has highlighted GLA mutations as possible causes of FSGS. Tubulointerstitial disease, recently classified by KDIGO based on genetic subtypes, when associated with UMOD variants, may phenotypically gain FSGS features, as well as ciliopathy genes or others, otherwise leading to completely different phenotypes, but found carrying pathogenic variants with associated FSGS phenotype. Thus, glomerulosclerosis may conceal different heterogeneous conditions. When a kidney biopsy is performed, the principal objective is to provide an accurate diagnosis. The broad spectrum of phenotypic expression and genetic complexity is demonstrating that a combined path of management needs to be applied. Genetic investigation should not be reserved only to selected cases, but rather part of medical management, integrating with clinical and renal pathology records. FSGS heterogeneity should be interpreted as an interesting opportunity to discover new pathways of CKD, requiring prompt genotype-phenotype correlation. In this review, we aim to highlight how FSGS represents a peculiar kidney condition, demanding multidisciplinary management, and in which genetic analysis may solve some otherwise unrevealed idiopathic cases. Unfortunately there is not a uniform correlation between specific mutations and FSGS morphological classes, as the same variants may be identified in familial cases or sporadic FSGS/NS or manifest a variable spectrum of the same disease. These non-specific features make diagnosis challenging. The complexity of FSGS genotypes requires new directions. Old morphological classification does not provide much information about the responsible cause of disease and misdiagnoses may expose patients to immunosuppressive therapy side effects, mistaken genetic counseling, and misguided kidney transplant programs.

Molecular diagnostic results of a nephropathy gene panel in patients with suspected hereditary kidney disease

OBJECTIVE

Clinical diagnosis of hereditary kidney disease can be difficult because of its rarity and severe phenotypic variability. Identifying mutated causative genes can provide diagnostic and prognostic information. In this study, we report the clinical application and outcome of a next-generation sequencing-based, targeted multi-gene panel test for the genetic diagnosis of patients with hereditary kidney disease.

METHODS

A total of 145 patients evaluated for hereditary kidney disease who underwent a nephropathy panel with 44 different genes were retrospectively reviewed and included in the study.

RESULTS

Genetic diagnosis of other hereditary kidney diseases, particularly autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease, was made in 48% of patients. The nephropathy panel changed the preliminary diagnosis in 6% of patients. The variants in 18 (12%) patients had not been previously reported in the literature.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates the utility of the nephropathy panel in identifying patients diagnosed with hereditary kidney disease who are referred for genetic testing. A contribution was made to the variant spectrum of genes associated with hereditary kidney disease.

The genetics and pathogenesis of CAKUT

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) comprise a large variety of malformations that arise from defective kidney or urinary tract development and frequently lead to kidney failure. The clinical spectrum ranges from severe malformations, such as renal agenesis, to potentially milder manifestations, such as vesicoureteral reflux. Almost 50% of cases of chronic kidney disease that manifest within the first three decades of life are caused by CAKUT. Evidence suggests that a large number of CAKUT are genetic in origin. To date, mutations in ~54 genes have been identified as monogenic causes of CAKUT, contributing to 12-20% of the aetiology of the disease. Pathogenic copy number variants have also been shown to cause CAKUT and can be detected in 4-11% of patients. Furthermore, environmental and epigenetic factors can increase the risk of CAKUT. The discovery of novel CAKUT-causing genes is challenging owing to variable expressivity, incomplete penetrance and variable genotype-phenotype correlation. However, such a discovery could ultimately lead to improvements in the accurate molecular genetic diagnosis, assessment of prognosis and multidisciplinary clinical management of patients with CAKUT, potentially including personalized therapeutic approaches.

A Clinical Workflow for Cost-Saving High-Rate Diagnosis of Genetic Kidney Diseases

SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT

To optimize the diagnosis of genetic kidney disorders in a cost-effective manner, we developed a workflow based on referral criteria for in-person evaluation at a tertiary center, whole-exome sequencing, reverse phenotyping, and multidisciplinary board analysis. This workflow reached a diagnostic rate of 67%, with 48% confirming and 19% modifying the suspected clinical diagnosis. We obtained a genetic diagnosis in 64% of children and 70% of adults. A modeled cost analysis demonstrated that early genetic testing saves 20% of costs per patient. Real cost analysis on a representative sample of 66 patients demonstrated an actual cost reduction of 41%. This workflow demonstrates feasibility, performance, and economic effect for the diagnosis of genetic kidney diseases in a real-world setting.

BACKGROUND

Whole-exome sequencing (WES) increases the diagnostic rate of genetic kidney disorders, but accessibility, interpretation of results, and costs limit use in daily practice.

METHODS

Univariable analysis of a historical cohort of 392 patients who underwent WES for kidney diseases showed that resistance to treatments, familial history of kidney disease, extrarenal involvement, congenital abnormalities of the kidney and urinary tract and CKD stage ≥G2, two or more cysts per kidney on ultrasound, persistent hyperechoic kidneys or nephrocalcinosis on ultrasound, and persistent metabolic abnormalities were most predictive for genetic diagnosis. We prospectively applied these criteria to select patients in a network of nephrology centers, followed by centralized genetic diagnosis by WES, reverse phenotyping, and multidisciplinary board discussion.

RESULTS

We applied this multistep workflow to 476 patients with eight clinical categories (podocytopathies, collagenopathies, CKD of unknown origin, tubulopathies, ciliopathies, congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract, syndromic CKD, metabolic kidney disorders), obtaining genetic diagnosis for 319 of 476 patients (67.0%) (95% in 21 patients with disease onset during the fetal period or at birth, 64% in 298 pediatric patients, and 70% in 156 adult patients). The suspected clinical diagnosis was confirmed in 48% of the 476 patients and modified in 19%. A modeled cost analysis showed that application of this workflow saved 20% of costs per patient when performed at the beginning of the diagnostic process. Real cost analysis of 66 patients randomly selected from all categories showed actual cost reduction of 41%.

CONCLUSIONS

A diagnostic workflow for genetic kidney diseases that includes WES is cost-saving, especially if implemented early, and is feasible in a real-world setting.

How I treat thrombotic microangiopathy in the era of rapid genomics

Thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA) encompasses various genetically-driven diseases. The emergence of ultrafast genomic sequencing has recently opened up new avenues of research for genetic investigations in the setting of intensive care units. TMA is likely to be a suitable focus for fast-track genomic sequencing. By establishing an expeditious molecular diagnosis of patients with the complement-dependent hemolytic uremic syndrome, fast-track genomic sequencing allows for the timely implementation or withdrawal of anti-C5 treatment while averting unnecessary, costly, and potentially harmful therapy in patients testing negative for the syndrome. Furthermore, genomics has the potential to reshape the taxonomic classification of TMA owing to comprehensive genomic analysis. The most significant results from such analysis can be categorized as (1) new descriptions of genetic diseases previously not recognized as associated with TMA and (2) an enrichment of the phenotypic spectrum of diseases traditionally related to TMA. The latter draws on the concept of retrophenotyping, wherein genomic investigation precedes full clinical description. By taking precedence over a phenotypic approach, an unbiased genomic-focused analysis maximizes the chances of discovering new descriptions of a given variant. Presented here are 4 cases of TMA which highlight these issues and substantiate the promise of fast-track genomic sequencing.

Expectations in children with glomerular diseases from SGLT2 inhibitors

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a global public healthcare concern in the pediatric population, where glomerulopathies represent the second most common cause. Although classification and diagnosis of glomerulopathies still rely mostly on histopathological patterns, patient stratification should complement information supplied by kidney biopsy with clinical data and etiological criteria. Genetic determinants of glomerular injury are particularly relevant in children, with important implications for prognosis and treatment. Targeted therapies addressing the primary cause of the disease are available for a limited number of glomerular diseases. Consequently, in the majority of cases, the treatment of glomerulopathies is actually the treatment of CKD. The efficacy of the currently available strategies is limited, but new prospects evolve. Although the exact mechanisms of action are still under investigation, accumulating data in adults demonstrate the efficacy of sodium-glucose transporter 2 inhibitors (SGLT2i) in slowing the progression of CKD due to diabetic and non-diabetic kidney disease. SGLT2i has proved effective on other comorbidities, such as obesity, glycemic control, and cardiovascular risk that frequently accompany CKD. The use of SGLT2i is not yet approved in children. However, no pathophysiological clues theoretically exclude their application. The hallmark of pediatric CKD is the inevitable imbalance between the metabolic needs of a growing child and the functional capacity of a failing kidney to handle those needs. In this view, developing better strategies to address any modifiable progressor in kidney disease is mandatory, especially considering the long lifespan typical of the pediatric population. By improving the hemodynamic adaptation of the kidney and providing additional beneficial effects on the overall complications of CKD, SGLT2i is a candidate as a potentially innovative drug for the treatment of CKD and glomerular diseases in children.

The Clinical and Genetic Features in Chinese Children With Steroid-Resistant or Early-Onset Nephrotic Syndrome: A Multicenter Cohort Study

Steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome (SRNS) is one of the major causes of end-stage kidney disease (ESKD) in children and young adults. For approximately 30% of children with SRNS results from a genetic cause. In this study, genotype-phenotype correlations in a cohort of 283 pediatric patients with SRNS or early-onset NS (nephrotic syndrome presenting within the first year of life) from 23 major pediatric nephrology centers in China were analyzed. All patients were performed with next-generation sequencing and Sanger sequencing. The overall mutation detection rate was 37.5% (106 of 283 patients). WT1 was the most frequently detected mutation, followed by NPHS1, NPHS2, and ADCK4, and these four major causative genes (WT1, NPHS1, NPHS2, and ADCK4) account for 73.6% of patients with monogenic SRNS. Thirteen of 106 individuals (12.3%) carried mutations in ADCK4 that function within the coenzyme Q10 biosynthesis pathway. In the higher frequently ADCK4-related SRNS, two mutations, c.737G>A (p.S246N) and c.748G>C (p.D250H), were the most prevalent. Our study provides not only definitive diagnosis but also facilitate available targeted treatment for SRNS, and prediction of prognosis and renal outcome. Our indications for genetic testing are patients with FSGS, initial SRNS, cases of positive family history or those with extra-renal manifestations.

Clinical and Genetic Characterization of Patients with Bartter and Gitelman Syndrome

Bartter (BS) and Gitelman (GS) syndrome are autosomal recessive inherited tubulopathies, whose clinical diagnosis can be challenging, due to rarity and phenotypic overlap. Genotype-phenotype correlations have important implications in defining kidney and global outcomes. The aim of our study was to assess the diagnostic rate of whole-exome sequencing (WES) coupled with a bioinformatic analysis of copy number variations in a population of 63 patients with BS and GS from a single institution, and to explore genotype-phenotype correlations. We obtained a diagnostic yield of 86% (54/63 patients), allowing disease reclassification in about 14% of patients. Although some clinical and laboratory features were more commonly reported in patients with BS or GS, a significant overlap does exist, and age at onset, preterm birth, gestational age and nephro-calcinosis are frequently misleading. Finally, chronic kidney disease (CKD) occurs in about 30% of patients with BS or GS, suggesting that the long-term prognosis can be unfavorable. In our cohort the features associated with CKD were lower gestational age at birth and a molecular diagnosis of BS, especially BS type 1. The results of our study demonstrate that WES is useful in dealing with the phenotypic heterogeneity of these disorders, improving differential diagnosis and genotype-phenotype correlation.

Reverse phenotyping facilitates disease allele calling in exome sequencing of patients with CAKUT

PURPOSE

Congenital anomalies of the kidneys and urinary tract (CAKUT) constitute the leading cause of chronic kidney disease in children. In total, 174 monogenic causes of isolated or syndromic CAKUT are known. However, syndromic features may be overlooked when the initial clinical diagnosis of CAKUT is made. We hypothesized that the yield of a molecular genetic diagnosis by exome sequencing (ES) can be increased by applying reverse phenotyping, by re-examining the case for signs/symptoms of the suspected clinical syndrome that results from the genetic variant detected by ES.

METHODS

We conducted ES in an international cohort of 731 unrelated families with CAKUT. We evaluated ES data for variants in 174 genes, in which variants are known to cause isolated or syndromic CAKUT. In cases in which ES suggested a previously unreported syndromic phenotype, we conducted reverse phenotyping.

RESULTS

In 83 of 731 (11.4%) families, we detected a likely CAKUT-causing genetic variant consistent with an isolated or syndromic CAKUT phenotype. In 19 of these 83 families (22.9%), reverse phenotyping yielded syndromic clinical findings, thereby strengthening the genotype-phenotype correlation.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that employing reverse phenotyping in the evaluation of syndromic CAKUT genes by ES provides an important tool to facilitate molecular genetic diagnostics in CAKUT.

OUP accepted manuscript

Podocytopathies are glomerular disorders in which podocyte injury drives proteinuria and progressive kidney disease. They encompass a broad spectrum of aetiologies, resulting in pathological pictures of minimal-changes, focal segmental glomerulosclerosis, diffuse mesangial sclerosis or collapsing glomerulopathy. Despite improvement in classifying podocytopathies as a distinct group of disorders, the histological definition fails to capture the relevant biological heterogeneity underlying each case, manifesting as extensive variability in disease progression and response to therapies. Increasing evidence suggests that podocytopathies can result from a single causative factor or a combination of multiple genetic and/or environmental risk factors with different relative contributions, identifying complex physiopathological mechanisms. Consequently, the diagnosis can still be challenging. In recent years, significant advances in genetic, microscopy and biological techniques revolutionized our understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying podocytopathies, pushing nephrologists to integrate innovative information with more conventional data obtained from kidney biopsy in the diagnostic workflow. In this review, we will summarize current approaches in the diagnosis of podocytopathies, focusing on strategies aimed at elucidating the aetiology underlying the histological picture. We will provide several examples of an integrative view of traditional concepts and new data in patients with suspected podocytopathies, along with a perspective on how a reclassification could help to improve not only diagnostic pathways and therapeutic strategies, but also the management of disease recurrence after kidney transplantation. In the future, the advantages of precision medicine will probably allow diagnostic trajectories to be increasingly focused, maximizing therapeutic results and long-term prognosis.