Viability Criteria during Liver Ex-Situ Normothermic and Hypothermic Perfusion

Viability Assessment During Normothermic Machine Liver Perfusion: A Literature Review

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The discrepancy between donor organ availability and demand leads to a significant waiting-list dropout rate and mortality. Although quantitative tools such as the Donor Risk Index (DRI) help assess organ suitability, many potentially viable organs are still discarded due to the lack of universally accepted markers to predict post-transplant outcomes. Normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) offers a platform to assess viability before transplantation. Thus, livers considered unsuitable for transplantation based on the DRI can be evaluated and potentially transplanted. During NMP, various viability criteria have been proposed. These criteria are neither homogeneous nor consensual. In this review, we aimed to describe the viability criteria during NMP and evaluate their ability to predict hepatic graft function following transplantation. We conducted a PubMed search using the terms 'liver transplantation', 'normothermic machine perfusion' and 'assessment', including only English publications up to February 2024. Viability assessment during NMP includes multiple hepatocellular and cholangiocellular criteria. Lactate clearance and bile production are commonly used indicators, but their ability to predict post-transplant outcomes varies significantly. The predictive value of cholangiocellular criteria such as bile pH, bicarbonate and glucose levels remains under investigation. Novel markers, such as microRNAs and proteomic profiles, offer the potential to enhance graft evaluation accuracy and provide insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying liver viability. Combining perfusion parameters with biomarkers may improve the prediction of long-term graft survival. Future research should focus on standardising viability assessment protocols and exploring real-time biomarker evaluations, which could enhance transplantation outcomes and expand the donor pool.

Normothermic Machine Perfusion in Orphan Liver Graft Viability Assessment

Background: Liver transplantation constitutes a well-established treatment for patients with end-stage liver disease and selected hepatic malignancies. The introduction of normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) offers a platform for both extracorporeal organ maintenance and viability assessment, especially for organs with suspicious malfunction. These organs, discarded by the majority of transplant centers (so-called 'orphan livers'), may help to safely expand the donor pool thanks to pre-transplant appraisal; Methods: We identified all grafts undergoing normothermic ma-chine perfusions performed in the Department of General, Transplant, and Liver Surgery between December 2022 and August 2023. Their perfusion characteristics and immediate postoperative periods, as well as complications that occurred in the 90-day postoperative periods, were analyzed; Results: There were eight orphan liver grafts that underwent NMP in our Department. Postoperative complications occurring in patients receiving grafts after NMP did not seem associated with the procedure. One patient required laparotomy within the 90-day postoperative period due to biliary fistula and underwent bile duct stenting due to both fistula and nonanastomotic stricture. In one patient we observed the occurrence of anastomotic biliary stricture more than 90 days after LTx; Conclusions: NMP allows for the viability assessment of grafts with suspicious prepreservation malfunction. Some of these organs may help to expand the donor pool.

Impact of donor transaminases on liver transplant utilisation and unnecessary organ discard: national registry cohort study

Background

Donor liver transaminases (ALT and AST) have been used to decline livers for transplant, despite evidence that they do not influence transplant outcomes. This study assesses the effect that raised donor transaminases have on the unnecessary decline of livers.

Methods

This retrospective cohort study used the National Health Service registry on adult liver transplantation (2016-2019). Logistic regression models were built to assess the impact of donor transaminases on the utilisation of organs donated following brain stem death (DBD) and circulatory death (DCD). A further model was used to simulate the impact on liver decline if raised donor ALT was not used to make utilisation decisions.

Results

5,424 adult livers were offered for transplant, of which 3,605 were utilised (2,841 DBD, 764 DCD). In multivariable analysis, adjusted for key factors, increasing peak donor ALT independently increased the odds of liver decline (DBD aOR = 1.396, 1.305-1.494, p < 0.001, DCD aOR = 1.162, 1.084-1.246, p < 0.001). AST was also a significant predictor of liver decline. 18.5% of livers from DBD donors with ALT > 40 U/L (n = 1,683) were declined for transplantation. In this group, our model predicted a 48% (38%-58%) decrease in decline if raised donor ALT was excluded from these decisions. This represents an additional 37 (30-45) liver transplants every year in the UK.

Conclusions

Raised donor ALT increased the likelihood of liver decline. As it does not influence transplant outcome, avoiding donor ALT-based organ decline is an immediate and effective way to expand the donor pool.

Assessment of hemodynamic and blood parameters that may reflect macroscopic quality of porcine kidneys during normothermic machine perfusion using whole blood

PURPOSE

Using ex vivo normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) with whole blood we assessed marginal porcine kidneys under reperfusion. The aim was to link measureable machine and clinical blood parameters with the currently used visual assessment. This could serve as a baseline for a standardized evaluation score to identify potentially transplantable kidneys in the future.

METHODS

Kidneys and autologous whole blood were procured from slaughterhouse pigs (n = 33) and were perfused for 4 h using NMP. The hemodynamic parameters arterial pressure (AP), renal blood flow (RBF) and intrarenal resistance (IRR) were measured. Activity of aspartate transaminase (AST), gamma-glutamyltransferase (GGT), alkaline phosphatase (ALP), lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and lactate were assessed in blood at 0/1/2/4 h. Kidneys were grouped into "potentially transplantable" (PT) or "not transplantable" (NT) based on their overall macroscopic appearance after NMP by an experienced physician.

RESULTS

PT-kidneys (n = 20) had a significantly lower IRR and higher RBF than NT-kidneys (n = 13). GGT, ALP and LDH did not differ significantly, but at 4 h, AST was significantly higher in PT-kidneys compared to NT-kidneys. Lactate levels kept increasing during NMP in NT-kidneys and were significantly higher at 1/2/4 h than in PT-kidneys.

CONCLUSION

The immediately assessed macroscopic aspects of examined kidneys correlated with hemodynamic parameters, increased lactate and lower AST in this study. In the future, NMP with whole blood could be a useful tool to extend the donor pool by allowing the assessment of otherwise unknown characteristics of marginal kidneys before transplantation.

Sequential Normothermic Regional Perfusion and End-ischemic Ex Situ Machine Perfusion Allow the Safe Use of Very Old DCD Donors in Liver Transplantation

BACKGROUND

In Italy, 20 min of continuous, flat-line electrocardiogram are required for death declaration. Despite prolonged warm ischemia time, Italian centers reported good outcomes in controlled donation after circulatory death (cDCD) liver transplantation by combining normothermic regional and end-ischemic machine perfusion (MP). The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and feasibility of the use of septuagenarian and octogenarian cDCD donors with this approach.

METHODS

All cDCD older than 70 y were evaluated during normothermic regional perfusion and then randomly assigned to dual hypothermic or normothermic MP.

RESULTS

In the period from April 2021 to December 2022, 17 cDCD older than 70 y were considered. In 6 cases (35%), the graft was not considered suitable for liver transplantation, whereas 11 (65%) were evaluated and eventually transplanted. The median donor age was 82 y, being 8 (73%) older than 80. Median functional warm ischemia and no-flow time were 36 and 28 min, respectively. Grafts were randomly assigned to ex situ dual hypothermic oxygenated MP in 6 cases (55%) and normothermic MP in 5 (45%). None was discarded during MP. There were no cases of primary nonfunction, 1 case of postreperfusion syndrome (9%) and 2 cases (18%) of early allograft dysfunction. At a median follow-up of 8 mo, no vascular complications or ischemic cholangiopathy were reported. No major differences were found in terms of postoperative hospitalization or complications based on the type of MP.

CONCLUSIONS

The implementation of sequential normothermic regional and end-ischemic MP allows the safe use of very old donation after circulatory death donors.

Incorporating a hemodialysis filter into a commercial normothermic perfusion system to facilitate long-term preservation of human split-livers

BACKGROUND

Normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) allows for the assessment and resuscitation of ex-vivo human livers prior to transplantation. Commercially available NMP systems are closed circuits that accumulate metabolic waste and cytokines over time, potentially limiting organ preservation times. Dialysis has been proposed as a method to remove waste and excess fluid from such systems. This study aimed to demonstrate the utility of integrating dialysis into a commercially available system by quantifying solute removal.

METHODS

A dialysis filter was attached in parallel to a commercially available liver perfusion system. Three livers declined for transplantation were split before undergoing long-term NMP with blood using the modified system. During perfusion, dialysate flow rates were set in the range of 100-600 mL/h for short periods of time. At each flow rate, perfusate and spent dialysate samples were collected and analyzed for solute clearance.

RESULTS

The addition of dialysis to a commercial NMP system removed water-soluble waste and helped regulate electrolyte concentrations. Interleukin-6 was successfully removed from the perfusate. Solute clearance was proportional to dialysate flow rate. A guide for our perfusion setup was created for the appropriate selection of dialysis flow rates and duration based on real-time perfusate composition.

CONCLUSIONS

Dialysis circuits can efficiently remove waste and regulate perfusate composition, and can be easily incorporated to improve the performance of commercially available systems. Quantification of the effect of dialysis on perfusate composition enables refined dialysis control to optimize electrolyte profiles and avoid the over- or under-correction of key solutes.

Discarded livers tested by normothermic machine perfusion in the VITTAL trial: Secondary end points and 5-year outcomes

Normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) enables pretransplant assessment of high-risk donor livers. The VITTAL trial demonstrated that 71% of the currently discarded organs could be transplanted with 100% 90-day patient and graft survivals. Here, we report secondary end points and 5-year outcomes of this prospective, open-label, phase 2 adaptive single-arm study. The patient and graft survivals at 60 months were 82% and 72%, respectively. Four patients lost their graft due to nonanastomotic biliary strictures, one caused by hepatic artery thrombosis in a liver donated following brain death, and 3 in elderly livers donated after circulatory death (DCD), which all clinically manifested within 6 months after transplantation. There were no late graft losses for other reasons. All the 4 patients who died during the study follow-up had functioning grafts. Nonanastomotic biliary strictures developed in donated after circulatory death livers that failed to produce bile with pH >7.65 and bicarbonate levels >25 mmol/L. Histological assessment in these livers revealed high bile duct injury scores characterized by arterial medial necrosis. The quality of life at 6 months significantly improved in all but 4 patients suffering from nonanastomotic biliary strictures. This first report of long-term outcomes of high-risk livers assessed by normothermic machine perfusion demonstrated excellent 5-year survival without adverse effects in all organs functioning beyond 1 year (ClinicalTrials.gov number NCT02740608).

Donation after circulatory death: Novel strategies to improve the liver transplant outcome

In many countries, donation after circulatory death (DCD) liver grafts are used to overcome organ shortages; however, DCD grafts have been associated with an increased risk of complications and even graft loss after liver transplantation. The increased risk of complications is thought to correlate with prolonged functional donor warm ischaemia time. Stringent donor selection criteria and utilisation of in situ and ex situ organ perfusion technologies have led to improved outcomes. Additionally, the increased use of novel organ perfusion strategies has led to the possibility of reconditioning marginal DCD liver grafts. Moreover, these technologies enable the assessment of liver function before implantation, thus providing valuable data that can guide more precise graft-recipient selection. In this review, we first describe the different definitions of functional warm donor ischaemia time and its role as a determinant of outcomes after DCD liver transplantation, with a focus on the thresholds proposed for graft acceptance. Next, organ perfusion strategies, namely normothermic regional perfusion, hypothermic oxygenated perfusion, and normothermic machine perfusion are discussed. For each technique, clinical studies reporting on the transplant outcome are described, together with a discussion on the possible protective mechanisms involved and the functional criteria adopted for graft selection. Finally, we review multimodal preservation protocols involving a combination of more than one perfusion technique and potential future directions in the field.

Induced Coma, Death, and Organ Transplantation: A Physiologic, Genetic, and Theological Perspective

In the clinic, the death certificate is issued if brain electrical activity is no longer detectable. However, recent research has shown that in model organisms and humans, gene activity continues for at least 96 h postmortem. The discovery that many genes are still working up to 48 h after death questions our definition of death and has implications for organ transplants and forensics. If genes can be active up to 48 h after death, is the person technically still alive at that point? We discovered a very interesting parallel between genes that were upregulated in the brain after death and genes upregulated in the brains that were subjected to medically-induced coma, including transcripts involved in neurotransmission, proteasomal degradation, apoptosis, inflammation, and most interestingly, cancer. Since these genes are involved in cellular proliferation, their activation after death could represent the cellular reaction to escape mortality and raises the question of organ viability and genetics used for transplantation after death. One factor limiting the organ availability for transplantation is religious belief. However, more recently, organ donation for the benefit of humans in need has been seen as “posthumous giving of organs and tissues can be a manifestation of love spreading also to the other side of death”.

Novel, Innovative Models to Study Ischemia/Reperfusion-Related Redox Damage in Organ Transplantation

The implementation of ex vivo organ machine perfusion (MP) into clinical routine undoubtedly helped to increase the donor pool. It enables not just organ assessment, but potentially regeneration and treatment of marginal organs in the future. During organ procurement, redox-stress triggered ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) is inevitable, which in addition to pre-existing damage negatively affects such organs. Ex vivo MP enables to study IRI-associated tissue damage and its underlying mechanisms in a near to physiological setting. However, research using whole organs is limited and associated with high costs. Here, in vitro models well suited for early stage research or for studying particular disease mechanisms come into play. While cell lines convince with simplicity, they do not exert all organ-specific functions. Tissue slice cultures retain the three-dimensional anatomical architecture and cells remain within their naïve tissue-matrix configuration. Organoids may provide an even closer modelling of physiologic organ function and spatial orientation. In this review, we discuss the role of oxidative stress during ex vivo MP and the suitability of currently available in vitro models to further study the underlying mechanisms and to pretest potential treatment strategies.