Rabbits as Animal Models for Anti-Tick Vaccine Development: A Global Scenario

Fourteen anti-tick vaccine targets are variably conserved in cattle fever ticks

BACKGROUND

Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) microplus causes significant cattle production losses worldwide because it transmits Babesia bovis and B. bigemina, the causative agents of bovine babesiosis. Control of these ticks has primarily relied on treatment of cattle with chemical acaricides, but frequent use, exacerbated by the one-host lifecycle of these ticks, has led to high-level resistance to multiple classes of acaricides. Consequently, new approaches for control, such as anti-tick vaccines, are critically important. Key to this approach is targeting highly conserved antigenic epitopes to reduce the risk of vaccine escape in heterologous tick populations.

METHODS

We evaluated amino acid conservation within 14 tick proteins across 167 R. microplus collected from geographically diverse locations in the Americas and Pakistan using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplicon sequencing and in silico translation of exons.

RESULTS

We found that amino acid conservation varied considerably across these proteins. Only the voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) was fully conserved in all R. microplus samples (protein similarity 1.0). Four other proteins were highly conserved: the aquaporin RmAQP1 (0.989), vitellogenin receptor (0.985), serpin-1 (0.985), and subolesin (0.981). In contrast, the glycoprotein Bm86 was one of the least conserved (0.889). The Bm86 sequence used in the original Australian TickGARD vaccine carried many amino acid replacements compared with the R. microplus populations examined here, supporting the hypothesis that this vaccine target is not optimal for use in the Americas. By mapping amino acid replacements onto predicted three-dimensional (3D) protein models, we also identified amino acid changes within several small-peptide vaccines targeting portions of the aquaporin RmAQP2, chitinase, and Bm86.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings emphasize the importance of thoroughly analyzing protein variation within anti-tick vaccine targets across diverse tick populations before selecting candidate vaccine antigens. When considering protein conservation alone, RmAQP1, vitellogenin receptor, serpin-1, subolesin, and especially VDAC rank as high-priority anti-tick vaccine candidates for use in the Americas and perhaps globally.

Evaluation of tick salivary and midgut extracellular vesicles as anti-tick vaccines in White-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus)

Current tick control measures are focused on the use of synthetic acaricides and personal protective measures. However, the emergence of acaricide resistance and the maintenance of tick populations in wildlife has precluded the efficient management of ticks. Thus, host-targeted, non-chemical control measures are needed to reliably reduce ticks parasitizing sylvatic reservoirs. This project aimed to evaluate extracellular vesicles (EVs) from Amblyomma americanum as vaccine candidates for white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus; WTD). Salivary gland (SG) and midgut (MG) EVs were isolated by ultracentrifugation. Three deer were vaccinated with SG and MG EVs and received two boosters at days 28 and 50. Two control deer were injected with adjuvant and PBS only. On day 58, WTD were infested with 100 A. americanum nymphs, 50 females, and 50 males that were allowed to feed to repletion. On-host and off-host mortality, tick engorgement weight, nymph molting, time to oviposition, and egg hatchability were evaluated. Serum samples were recovered every seven days until the last day of tick drop off, and then at one year (Y1) and 1-year and 1-month (Y1M1). Vaccination resulted in seroconversion and significant increases in total IgG levels that remained significantly higher than controls and pre-vaccination levels at Y1 and Y1M1. No negative effects were observed in nymphs, but on-host mortality of female A. americanum was significantly higher in vaccinated animals. No effects were observed on reproductive parameters. These results indicate that proteins within female tick SG and MG vesicles are not good candidates for vaccine design against nymphs; however, the on-host adult mortality suggests that tick EVs harbor protective antigens against A. americanum females.

In vitro identification of neutralizing epitopes of Rhipicephalus microplus serpin 17 (RmS-17)

BACKGROUND

Rhipicephalus microplus poses a significant problem for livestock worldwide and is primarily controlled with synthetic acaricides. The continuous use of acaricides results in the selection of resistance and causes environmental harm. Vaccination presents an alternative solution to this problem, although searching for the suitable antigen is still a work in progress. Salivary proteins hold promise for inclusion in vaccine formulation due to their roles in modulating host responses, assisting blood feeding and pathogen transmission. Serpins are a class of proteinase inhibitors and are among the molecules found in tick saliva that modulate host blood coagulation, inflammation, and adaptive immune responses. Previous studies have demonstrated the potential of R. microplus serpin 17 (RmS-17) to interfere with the host's defenses, and antibodies have been shown to neutralize its effects. This makes RmS-17 an putative target for vaccine development.

METHODS

Epitope mapping of RmS-17 was achieved using in silico approach combining linear B-cell epitope and antigenicity predictor. In addition, epitope mapping using overlapping peptides in an ELISA screening was used. The serpin tridimensional structure and the epitopes spatial location within the molecule were determined. Peptides were synthetized based on the predictions and used for the production of rabbit anti-sera. Purified IgG's were used to assess the antibodies capacity to neutralize RmS-17.

RESULTS

Through in silico mapping, nine potential B cell epitope regions were screened, with p1RmS-17 and p2RmS-17 selected for the experiment based on antigen prediction. In the ELISA screening using overlapping peptides, eight antibody-binding regions were identified, and p3RmS-17 and p4RmS-17 were chosen. Antibodies raised against p3RmS-17 and p4RmS-17 partially neutralized RmS-17 activity.

CONCLUSION

It was found that antibodies against a single epitope are sufficient to partially neutralize RmS-17 activity. These findings support the possibility of using an epitope-based vaccine for immunization against R. microplus.

Immunologic characterization of the Bm05br protein using the Rhipicephalus linnaei (Audouin, 1826) species as a tick model

The identification and characterization of tick proteins allow us to discover new physiological targets useful for the development of tick control methods. Bm05br (Brazil Rhipicephalus microplus protein 05) is a protein with unknown function identified in the saliva of R. microplus. Rs05br (Brazil Rhipicephalus sanguineus protein 05), a protein with 99 % similarity to Bm05br, was identified in Rhipicephalus linnaei egg, larval, and nymphal stages, as well as in adult saliva. To improve the knowledge about both proteins, immunological characterization was performed, including antigenicity analysis, vaccination trials, and artificial feeding. The sequence and antigenicity analysis of Bm05br and Rs05br proteins showed that R. linnaei could serve as a tick model for cross-protection studies. The recombinant Bm05br protein was immunogenic. Anti-Bm05br antibodies recognized the homologous protein Rs05br in different stages, organs, and in the saliva of R. linnaei. Although rBm05br did not induce a protective response against infestation in R. linnaei in this study, further experiments could be developed taking into account new formulations and animal models for vaccination. These results also serve as a reference for future research on the function of these proteins in R. microplus and R. linnaei physiology, as well as other species of the genus Rhipicephalus.

Rhipicephalus microplus thyropin-like protein: Structural and immunologic analyzes

Tick saliva has a pivotal function in parasitism. It has pharmacological and immunomodulatory properties, with several proteins reported in its composition. Thyroglobulin type-1 domain protease inhibitor (thyropin)-like proteins are found in tick saliva, but their function, properties and structures are poorly characterized. It has been reported that thyropins are capable of inhibiting cysteine peptidases present in antigen-presenting cells. To elucidate the role of thyropin-like proteins in ticks, we conducted in silico analysis and cloned an open reading frame from a thyropin-like protein found in Rhipicephalus microplus. The recombinant protein was successfully expressed, followed by immunological characterization and a vaccine trial against Rhipicephalus sanguineus in rabbits. Several differences are observed between thyropin-like proteins from hard and soft ticks, especially the number of thyroglobulin domains and predicted glycosylation pattern. Thyropin-like proteins also differ between postriata and metastriata ticks, the latter having a coil-domain at the C-terminal region and high number of predicted glycosylation sites. Overall, the data suggested divergence in thyropin-like proteins functions among ticks. The recombinant thyropin-like protein is immunogenic and the antibodies against it are able to recognize the native protein in tick saliva and tissues. While the recombinant protein does not elicit a protective response against R. sanguineus infestation, its characterization paves the way for further investigations aimed at determining the precise function of this protein in tick physiology.

Cross-species immunoprotective antigens (subolesin, ferritin 2 and P0) provide protection against Rhipicephalus sanguineus sensu lato

BACKGROUND

Tick control is mostly hampered by the rise of acaricide-resistant tick populations. Significant efforts have focused on developing alternative control methods, including cross-species protective and/or cocktail-based anti-tick vaccines, to achieve protection against various tick species.

METHODS

In this study, full-length open reading frames encoding subolesin (SUB) from Rhipicephalus microplus and ferritin 2 (FER2) from Hyalomma anatolicum as well as the partial 60S acidic ribosomal protein (P0) from R. microplus were cloned, expressed in Escherichia coli and used as vaccine antigens against Rhipicephalus sanguineus sensu lato (R. sanguineus s.l.) infestation in rabbits.

RESULTS

In silico analyses revealed that the SUB, P0 and FER2 proteins were antigenic and displayed limited similarity to the host's homologous proteins. The proteins shared identities of 97.5%, 100% and 89.5% with their SUB, P0 and FER2 R. sanguineus s.l. orthologous sequences, respectively. Antibodies against each recombinant protein cross-recognized the native proteins in the different tissues and developmental stages of R. sanguineus s.l. Overall efficacy of the SUB, FER2 and cocktail (SUB+FER2+P0) vaccines against R. sanguineus s.l. infestation was 86.3%, 95.9% and 90.9%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Both mono-antigen and the cocktail anti-tick vaccines affected the biological parameters of R. sanguineus s.l. infestation in the rabbit model, which could be extrapolated to its infested host under natural conditions. These findings support the possibility of using mono-antigenic and cocktail-based vaccines for large-scale anti-tick vaccine development against multiple tick species.