PD vs HD in Post-Economic Crisis Greece-Differences in Patient Characteristics and Estimation of Therapy Cost

Cost Analysis of End-Stage Renal Disease in Pediatric Patients in Greece

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

The cost resulting from peritoneal dialysis (PD), conventional hemodialysis (HD) and online hemodiafiltration (OL-HDF) in pediatric patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) has not been estimated to date in Greece. The present single-center retrospective study aimed to estimate the mean annual cost of the above methods, as well as the individual components of this cost.

METHODS

Twenty pediatric patients undergoing the three different methods of renal replacement therapy were included in this study. Their mean total annual cost was estimated by the method of micro-costing and the bottom-up approach.

RESULTS

The mean total annual cost for PD patients (n = 7) was estimated at EUR 56,676.04; for conventional HD patients (n = 9), it was EUR 39,786.86; and for OL-HDF patients (n = 4), it was EUR 43,894.73. The PD method was found to be more expensive than the other two methods (p < 0.001 vs. conventional HD and p = 0.024 vs. OL-HDF). PD consumables used for daily application had the greatest contribution to the total annual cost. The total mean annual cost in the groups of patients undergoing HD and OL-HDF did not differ significantly (p = 0.175). The total operating cost of the renal dialysis unit had the greatest contribution to the total mean annual costs of both the conventional HD and OL-HDF techniques.

CONCLUSIONS

This cost analysis provides useful information to healthcare policymakers who make decisions about the treatment of children with ESRD.

APD or CAPD: one glove does not fit all

The use of Automated Peritoneal Dialysis (APD) in its various forms has increased over the past few years mainly in developed countries. This could be attributed to improved cycler design, apparent lifestyle benefits and the ability to achieve adequacy and ultrafiltration targets. However, the dilemma of choosing the superior modality between APD and Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis (CAPD) has not yet been resolved. When it comes to fast transporters and assisted PD, APD is certainly considered the most suitable Peritoneal Dialysis (PD) modality. Improved patients’ compliance, lower intraperitoneal pressure and possibly lower incidence of peritonitis have been also associated with APD. However, concerns regarding increased cost, a more rapid decline in residual renal function, inadequate sodium removal and disturbed sleep are APD’s setbacks. Besides APD superiority over CAPD in fast transporters, the other medical advantages of APD still remain controversial. In any case, APD should be readily available for all patients starting PD and the most important indication for its implementation remains patient’s choice.

Identification of children with chronic kidney disease through school urinary screening using urinary protein/creatinine ratio measurement: an observational study

Background

School urinary screening has been performed in Japan.

Methods

Ikeda City and Toyono Town introduced, in 2012 and 2013, urinary protein/creatinine (Cr) ratio measurement into the urine-screening protocols designed for students aged between 4 and 15 years. For each student whose urinary protein/Cr ratio was ≥ 0.15 g/gCr (positive case), an appointment was made with a specialist at Ikeda City Hospital. The results of these screening urinalyses conducted through 2018 are summarized.

Results

14,606 junior high and elementary school students aged between 6 and 15 years were included. On average, they underwent 4.16 screening tests. 77 positive cases were detected, and seven students were diagnosed with high-risk chronic kidney disease (CKD). Of these, four underwent renal biopsy, and two, one, and one were diagnosed with IgA nephropathy, MPGN, and FSGS, respectively. In three students, detection of CKD would have been difficult without urinary screening. Incident rates of high-risk CKD and IgA nephropathy are estimated as 11.5 and 3.3 cases/100,000 students/year. 78.0% of positive cases without high-risk CKD showed no urinary abnormality after one year. 2301 kindergarten students aged between 4 and 6 years received an average of 1.74 screening urinalyses; none was positive or high-risk CKD. The estimated cost of detecting one high-risk CKD student whose detection would have been difficult without this screening was 3,156,711 Japanese yen.

Conclusion

School urinary screening using the urinary protein/Cr ratio can efficiently refer to a specialist. It detects a few children with high-risk CKD early with spending high cost.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s10157-020-01852-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.