Simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fracture

Simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fracture in a male teenager: case report and literature review

Tibial tuberosity avulsion fractures are injuries accounting for less than 3% of all epiphyseal and 1% of all physeal injuries in adolescents. Bilateral injuries are very rare, with only 19 cases described in the literature. These types of fractures occur commonly in male teenagers during sport activities and are often associated with other orthopaedic disorders. We report the case of a male teenager with simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle fractures, describe the evolution and treatment of this injury and review the literature on this subject.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Case report.

Surgical Fixation of Bilateral Simultaneous Avulsion Fractures of the Proximal Tibia in a 12-Year-Old with History of Conservatively Managed Unilateral Tibial Avulsion Fracture

Fractures of the proximal tibial epiphysis are rare, representing less than 3% of all epiphyseal and 1% of all physeal injuries in adolescents. Bilateral injuries are extremely rare. The specific anatomical and histological features of the proximal tibial epiphysis make it vulnerable to a specific fracture pattern that occurs when the tensile force of the quadriceps is greater than the fibrocartilaginous tissue underlying the tibial tuberosity. We report the first case to our knowledge of a 12-year-old boy who sustained simultaneous bilateral tibial avulsion fractures on the background of a previous conservatively managed unilateral tibial tuberosity avulsion fracture. We report this case for its uniqueness and as an educational review of the anatomy, the mechanism of injury, and the development of classifying these fractures and discussion of the stages of the growing physis that determine the treatment approach.

Tibial tuberosity fractures in adolescents: is a posterior metaphyseal fracture component a predictor of complications?

BACKGROUND

Tibial tuberosity fractures have been described as uncommon injuries, but their frequency appears to be increasing. Because of the relatively few cases reported in the literature, little is known regarding risk factors for complications. In a large group of adolescents with tibial tuberosity fractures, we noted more frequent complications in patients who had posterior metaphyseal fractures in addition to tibial tuberosity avulsion fractures. The purpose of this study was to examine the outcomes associated with this fracture pattern and compare them with tibial tuberosity fractures without the posterior component.

METHODS

All patients who had closed or open reduction and internal fixation of a tibial tuberosity fracture between January 2003 and December 2010 were identified. All radiographs and medical records were reviewed.

RESULTS

Fifty-three tibial tuberosity fractures had radiographs available for review; 15 (28%) fractures had a posterior component identified by either radiograph or computed tomography scan. Four of these combined injuries had an adverse event: 1 patient had compartment syndrome affecting all 4 compartments and 3 patients had refractures after closed reduction and casting. None of the 38 tibial tuberosity fractures without a posterior metaphyseal component had these complications. All patients had complete fracture healing and had returned to full activity at last follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, a posterior metaphyseal fracture associated with a tibial tuberosity fracture was a marker for potential complications. If radiographs suggest that a fracture line extends through the posterior metaphysis, computed tomography imaging is recommended to confirm the fracture pattern. Open reduction and internal fixation that includes both the anterior and posterior fragments is recommended for all fractures with these combined components, including nondisplaced fractures, because of an increased risk of refracture.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV (case study).

Simultaneous bilateral avulsion fracture of the tibial tubercle in adolescent: a case report

Acute avulsion of the tibial tubercle is an uncommon injury, accounting for less than 1% of all physeal injuries. Simultaneous bilateral avulsion fractures of the tibial tubercle are extremely rare. Only 10 cases have been reported in the literature to date. We report a case of a 15-year-old boy who suffered from the bilateral avulsion fractures of the tibial tubercle during basketball in take-off phase of the high jump. He went through surgery and 4 years after index procedures he has no deformities, the knee is painless and he participates in sport activities on daily basis.

Acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures in the sporting adolescent

INTRODUCTION

The authors report 7 cases of acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures. The fracture occurred in 6 out of the 7, after an abrupt tension of the patellar tendon in male sporting adolescents (age 13-17 years). Two patients presented symptoms of homolateral Osgood-Schlatter's disease before the lesion.

METHOD

According to Ogden's classification, the tibial tubercle avulsion fracture was not displaced in 3 cases (stage IA) and was treated conservatively by immobilization for 6 weeks. In 4 cases, the fracture was displaced and necessitated an internal fixation with plaster for about 6 weeks. A torn patellar tendon was noted in one adolescent having a stage IIIB avulsion fracture.

RESULT

The mean follow-up was of 4.5 years (1.5-7.5 years). The results were satisfactory: complete functional recovery, resumption of sport at the previous level and absence of recurvatum.

Bilateral Avulsion Fractures of the Tibial Tuberosity: A Double Case for Open Reduction and Fixation

Tibial tuberosity fractures are rare and occur mainly in adolescent males during vigorous quadriceps contraction. So far, only ten simultaneous bilateral fractures have been reported. We report the case of a 16-year-old male who avulsed both tibial tuberosities when he landed on his feet after a gymnastics routine. Diagnostic imaging demonstrated Ogden Type IIIA fractures. He underwent bilateral open reduction and screw fixation with a good functional result after 3 months. While closed reduction and percutaneous fixation has been proposed by some, the intraoperative findings in our patient would have prevented correct adaptation of the fragments because of a flap of periosteum impinged in both fracture gaps. This case emphasizes that minimally invasive techniques may sometimes be inappropriate in the management of these types of fractures.

Simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fracture in an adolescent: a case report and review of the literature

Avulsion fractures of the tibial tubercle are uncommon. Bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fractures are extremely rare. In this article, we describe Watson-Jones type III simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fractures in a 17-year-old boy who fell on the ground while taking off in high jump in sport. An open anatomic reduction and internal fixation was performed. We report here on the successful surgical treatment of a simultaneous bilateral fracture of the tibial tuberosity in an adolescent. These types of fractures involve a growth plate, extend through the articular surface and appear to do well with open reduction and secure internal fixation despite their bilateral nature, with recovery and functional outcome comparable to results from unilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fractures.

Comminuted simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fractures: a case report

A 16-year-old male had simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fractures after making a sudden stop while running at full speed. The left knee injury (type V) was minimally displaced, was treated conservatively with closed reduction, and the patient recovered uneventfully. The right tibial tubercle injury was unusual. The tuberosity and anterior aspect of the proximal epiphysis remained as one, but there was severe intra-articular comminution posterior to the displaced tubercle fragment. The right knee injury (type III) required open reduction and internal fixation to reduce the apophyseal fragment and 2 intra-articular displaced fragments. The patient's recovery was complicated by a severe, persistent flexion deformity on the right side. Eventually, the patient required manipulation under anaesthesia, extensive continuous passive mobilisation and a turnbuckle extension splint. A residual 5-degree flexion deformity remained at 16 months post-injury. This case highlights the importance of identifying any intra-articular fragments, their careful anatomical reduction, and aggressive mobilisation when treating tibial tubercle avulsion fractures.

Simultaneous bilateral avulsion fractures of the tibial tuberosity in adolescence: A case report and review of over 50 years of literature

Simultaneous bilateral avulsion fractures of the tibial tuberosity is a rare injury. Since it was first described in 1955, there have been eight similar cases. We have reviewed each of these reports and describe an additional case of a 13-year-old boy, who sustained simultaneous bilateral avulsion fractures of the tibial tuberosity from jumping while playing soccer. Like the previous reports, our patient had a satisfactory result from open reduction and internal fixation of both fractures. Despite being bilateral, these injuries have a low complication rate and good outcome comparable with that of unilateral avulsion fractures of the tibial tuberosity.

[Avulsion fracture of the tibial tubercle in adolescents: 22 cases and review of the literature]

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

Fracture of the anterior tibial tubercle is exceptional in adolescents. The purpose of this work was to better understand the circumstances of such fractures, identify potential complications, and assess outcome of different therapeutic options.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

This was a retrospective analysis of a consecutive series of 22 children with avulsion fracture of the anterior tibial tubercle. The circumstances of the fracture were noted. The Ogden classification was used to establish the radiological type. Associated lesions were also noted as were any complications. Two types of treatment were given: orthopedic or surgical (several types). The functional outcome was assessed at last follow-up.

RESULTS

Mean age at fracture of the anterior tibial tubercle was 13 years (range 12-16) in 14 boys and 7 girls. It occurred after a jump or reception after a jump in 22 of the children. Five patients presented symptomatic homo- or contralateral anterior tibial apophysitis before the accident. The fracture was not displaced (type IA) in ten patients and was treated orthopedically. In twelve patients, the fracture was displaced (type IB, II, or III) and required osteosynthesis. Immobilization was maintained for four weeks on average (range 3-7). Associated lesions were observed in half of the twelve displaced fractures, with five cases of patellar ligament avulsion and three cases of meniscal injury. There were no complications with type IA fractures. For the twelve displaced fractures, complications were observed in seven children: hematoma (n = 2), infrapatellar hypoesthesia (n = 2), complete rupture of the patellar ligament 38 months after surgery (n = 1), recurvatum with leg length discrepancy (n = 1), and stiff knee (n = 1). Mean follow-up was two years (range 9 months-8 years). The functional outcome was excellent in all patients with a non-displaced fracture and in seven of the twelve patients who underwent surgical treatment.

DISCUSSION

Non-displaced fracture of the anterior tibial tubercle I children (type IA) should be considered as a separate entity responding very well to orthopedic treatment. The other cases of displaced fracture generally require surgery which enables an assessment of often associated lesions. The prognosis of displaced fractures of the anterior tibial tubercle is more sever due to the associated lesions and potential complications. We describe the second case of recurvatum and leg length discrepancy following fracture of the anterior tibial tubercle.

CONCLUSION

Displaced fracture of the anterior tibial tubercle in adolescents is often associated with soft tissue injury (patellar ligament, menisci). Surgery is indispensable and provides good functional results.

Acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures

A retrospective analysis of 18 patients with 19 acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures was performed. Mean age at injury was 13 years 8 months. Mean follow-up time was 2 years 8 months. A group of four preadolescent patients ages 9 to 12 years at injury was identified. Participation in athletics, particularly basketball, resulted in 77% of fractures. There were one type IA, three type IB, two type IIA, six type IIB, two type IIIA, four type IIIB, and one type IV fractures. Fifteen fractures were treated with open reduction and internal fixation and four by closed reduction and cylinder cast immobilization. Three cases (15.7%) of extensor mechanism disruption were noted, two patellar tendon avulsions and one quadriceps avulsion. Final outcome was good in all patients regardless of fracture type or treatment. There were no complications.

Acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures

Acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures are uncommon, and these injuries typically occur in mature-appearing adolescent boys involved in jumping sports, particularly basketball. The developmental anatomy of the tibial tuberosity and the changes surrounding normal physiologic epiphysiodesis render this structure susceptible to acute avulsion fractures. Possible associated injuries include patellar and quadriceps avulsions, collateral and cruciate ligament tears, and meniscal damage. The treatment of this injury is based on the amount of displacement and associated injuries. Nondisplaced fractures are treated nonoperatively with cast immobilization. Displaced fractures require open reduction and internal fixation. Even in Type III injuries, the outcome is usually excellent.

Simultaneous bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fracture in a basketball player

A 16-year-old male basketball player had sustained an injury upon landing after a forceful jump. Plain radiography demonstrated bilateral tibial tubercle avulsion fracture involving partially proximal physis. Open reduction and internal fixation were performed at once. Continuous passive motion was started immediately after operation, and the patient was ambulated with hinged knee extension braces. After 27 months follow-up his knees completely regained normal range of motion except a 3 degrees extension loss in the left knee. He resumed all daily functional activities (Lysholm functional score of 99), but he slightly lost his level of activity (Tegner activity level from 7 to 6). No angular deformity at all on the frontal plane was determined upon radiological examination. Tibial slope angles were symmetrical and within the normal range. There were visible small bone fragments inside the left patellar tendon.

The immature athlete

The skeletally immature athlete poses unique problems in diagnosis and treatment of injuries to the extensor mechanism of the knee. An accurate and detailed history and physical examination of the knee are essential for making a specific diagnosis and formulating an appropriate treatment plan. This article presents an overview of acute and chronic injuries of the extensor mechanism of the knee that are unique to skeletally immature athletes. The subjects of femoral trochlear dysplasia and medial subluxation of the patella are briefly discussed. The etiopathology, clinical evaluation, and management (non-operative and operative) of sleeve fractures of the patella and avulsion fractures of the tibial tubercle in children and adolescents are discussed. The pathoanatomy, clinical features, and management of synovial plica syndrome, Hoffa's syndrome, Osgood-Schlatter disease, and Sinding-Larsen-Johansson disease are presented.