Secondary renal revascularization for recurrent renal artery stenosis

Renal artery repair: consequence of operative failures

OBJECTIVE

This report examines the blood pressure and renal function response in 20 consecutive patients after secondary renal revascularization following failed operative repair.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Most reports describing operative failure of renal artery (RA) repair emphasize the technical aspects of redo RA reconstruction and the immediate blood-pressure response to secondary operation. This report examines the eventual renal function and estimated survival after secondary intervention.

METHODS

Primary methods of RA reconstruction, primary blood pressure and renal function responses, and causes of failed RA repair were defined for 20 patients requiring reoperation for recurrent hypertension or renal insufficiency. These parameters were compared with secondary procedures and eventual blood pressure and renal function response. The eventual outcome for these 20 patients was compared with 514 patients managed by primary renal revascularization during the same period.

RESULTS

Failure of primary RA repair correlated with complex fibromuscular dysplasia requiring branch ex vivo reconstruction (p = 0.020). RA thrombosis frequently required nephrectomy (83%), whereas RA stenosis was successfully reconstructed (91 %; p = 0.001). Primary and secondary blood-pressure responses were equivalent (94% vs. 95% cured or improved); however, primary and eventual renal function responses differed significantly (p = 0.015), with seven patients dialysis-dependent on follow-up. Eventual dialysis dependence was associated with preoperative azotemia (p = 0.022), bilateral failure of primary RA repair (p = 0.007), and an increased risk of follow-up death (p = 0.002). Considering all 534 patients, failed RA repair demonstrated a significant and independent association with eventual dialysis dependence and decreased dialysis-free survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Contemporary rates of reoperation after surgical RA repair are low. In properly selected patients, beneficial blood-pressure response is reliably observed after both primary and secondary operative procedures. However, secondary procedures are associated with a significant and independent risk of eventual dialysis dependence.

Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty and surgery of the renal artery

The management of patients with renal artery disease has changed in recent years. This has occurred due to the advent of PTA as an effective method of treatment for certain patients, an enhanced appreciation of advanced atherosclerotic renal artery disease as a correctable cause of renal failure, and improved results of surgical revascularisation in both older patients with severe aortic atherosclerosis and younger patients with branch renal artery disease. PTA currently yields excellent results and is the treatment of choice for patients with fibrous dysplasia of the main renal artery and non-ostial atherosclerotic lesions. Most reports in the literature indicate that surgical revascularisation provides more effective therapy for patients with ostial atherosclerotic lesions. Surgical revascularisation also remains the treatment of choice for the majority of patients with branch renal artery disease, a renal artery aneurysm, renal artery occlusion, and recurrent renal artery stenosis after failed PTA or surgery. Excellent clinical results can be achieved with both PTA and surgical revascularisation in properly selected patients.