Costochondral graft with green-stick fracture used in reconstruction of the mandibular condyle: experience in 13 clinical cases

Long term complications of costochondral graft reconstruction in temporomandibular joint ankylosis of the young- a systematic review

Costochondral graft has been a popular reconstruction choice in the past for temporomandibular joint ankylosis in young individuals. However, accounts of growth hampering complications have also been observed. Our systematic review aims to compile all existing evidence to determine the occurrence of these unfavourable clinical outcomes as well as factors affecting them to provide a better judgement on further use of these grafts. A systematic review was conducted following PRISMA guidelines where databases like PubMed, Web of science and Google Scholar were searched for the purpose of data extraction. Observational studies performed on patients younger than 18 years of age with a minimum follow-up of one year were selected. Incidence of long term complications like reankylosis, abnormal graft growth, facial asymmetry and others were considered as outcome variables. Eight articles with a total of 95 patients were selected where complications like reankylosis (6.32%), graft overgrowth (13.70%), insufficient graft growth (22.11%), no graft growth (3.20%) and facial asymmetry (20%) were reported. Other complications like mandibular deviation (3.20%), retrognathia (1.05%) and prognathic mandible (3.20%) were also observed. Our review concludes that the occurrence of these complications was noteworthy. Thus use of costochondral graft for reconstruction in temporomandibular ankylosis in young patients holds significant risk in development of growth abnormalities. However, modifications in surgical procedure such as use of appropriate graft cartilage thickness and the presence and type of interpositional material can favourably affect the frequency and type of growth abnormality.

Growth Outcome and Jaw Functions Are Better After Gap Arthroplasty Plus Costochondral Graft Reconstruction Than Gap Arthroplasty Alone in Pediatric Temporomandibular Joint Ankylosis Patients: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial

PURPOSE

It is not known if the muscle matrix that becomes functional after gap arthroplasty (GA) in temporomandibular joint ankylosis (TMJA), induces growth of the mandible or the reconstructive arthroplasty with costochondral graft (CCG) is responsible for growth. The study aimed to evaluate the mandibular growth and functional outcome with the use of CCG/GA in the management of pediatric TMJA.

METHODS

The investigators designed a cluster randomized controlled trial on pediatric (3 to 16 years) TMJA patients. Treatment applied (CCG and GA), was the primary predictor variable. Patients were divided into CCG and GA groups. The primary outcome variable was growth. Secondary outcome variables included etiology and duration of ankylosis, maximal incisal opening (MIO), reankylosis, occlusion, laterotrusion, chin deviation, facial asymmetry, occlusal tilt, and complications. The distance condylion (Co) to gnathion (Gn) was used to measure mandibular length. Ramal height was measured from Co- gonion (Go). Lower facial height was measured from the anterior nasal spine to Gn. Generalized estimating equations were used to calculate the regression coefficient adjusted for the cluster. The patient was considered as a cluster and the unit of analysis was joint.

RESULTS

Fifty-six {n = 28 in each group, (n = 33 joint in the CCG group and n = 31 joints in GA group)} patients were analyzed. The median follow-up was 33-months (31.93 ± 15.24) in CCG and 32-months (32.85 ± 17.84) in the GA group. Intergroup comparison between the CCG and GA group showed a statistically significant difference in mandibular length (CCG = 77.51 ± 9.31 and GA = 66.66 ± 8.32 mm, P < .001), ramal height (CCG = 44.21 ± 7.3 and GA = 31.87 ± 8.4 mm, P < .001), and statistically insignificant difference in lower facial height (CCG = 52.53 ± 6.1 and GA = 50.19 ± 6.3 mm, P = 0.14) at follow-up. Statistically, significant improvement was seen in MIO in both groups (<.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study concluded that growth and jaw functions were better in reconstructive arthroplasty with CCG than GA in pediatric TMJA.

Application of Bidirectional Distraction Osteogenesis for the Treatment of Mandibular Micriognathia Caused by Temporomandibular Joint Ankylosis

BACKGROUND

Temporomandibular joint (TMJ) ankylosis is a joint disorder that refers to bone or fibrous adhesion of the anatomic joint components and the ensuing loss of function. When it happens on children, it is always accompanied by dentofacial deformities. The objective of this study was to describe the authors' experience of bidirectional distraction osteogenesis for the treatment of mandibular deformities caused by TMJ ankylosis.

METHODS

Sixteen patients with TMJ ankylosis and severe secondary mandibular deformities were treated with bidirectional distraction osteogenesis and release of joint from January 2013 to December 2015. Clinical outcomes were assessed based on the oral function, radiography, and medical photography.

RESULTS

No reankylosis was found during the follow-up period. Sufficient volume and density new bone had been formed after the consolidation period. All patients have maintained stable improvement in oral function during the follow-up period. Most of the patients achieved satisfactory outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

Bidirectional transport distraction osteogenesis technique is a good and effective therapeutic option in treatment of bilateral or unilateral TMJ ankylosis patients associated with mandibular micrognathia.

Retrospective comparison of autogenous cosotochondral graft and coronoid process graft in the management of unilateral ankylosis of the temporomandibular joint in adults

We retrospectively compared the clinical outcomes of autogenous coronoid process grafts (n=32) and costochondral grafts (n=28) in condylar reconstruction for the treatment of unilateral ankylosis of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) in adults. Preoperative and postoperative assessments included diet scores, cone-beam computed tomography (CT), maximal interincisal opening, lateral excursion, and mandibular deviation on opening the mouth. There were no significant differences between the 2 groups in the measurements before and after the operation with respect to incisal opening, lateral excursion, mandibular deviation, diet scores, or recurrence rate, but in both the postoperative incisal opening, lateral excursion, and diet scores had improved significantly compared with preoperatively. After costochondral graft 3 patients developed intraoperative plural tears, and 6 had temporary pain at the donor site. The frontal branch of the facial nerve was temporarily affected in 5 patients after costochondral graft and 3 after coronoid process grafts, all of which recovered in 3-6 months. There was no recurrence after coronoid process grafting, and one after costochondral grafting. The clinical outcomes in both groups were satisfactory and comparable. Autogenous coronoid process grafting may therefore be a good alternative for condylar reconstruction in patients with ankylosis of the TMJ.

Comparison of Costochondral Graft and Customized Total Joint Reconstruction for Treatments of Temporomandibular Joint Replacement

Purpose:

We review published research on temporomandibular joint (TMJ) total replacement that compares costochondral graft and customized total joint reconstruction (especially TMJ concepts), focusing on effectiveness.

Methods:

We searched PubMed databases, including prospective, retrospective, case-control or longitudinal studies and significant statistical analysis. In data analysis, we divided outcomes into ‘Acceptable’ or ‘Non-acceptable’.

Results:

There were seven articles found dealing with costochondral graft and 180 patients. The majority of patients had satisfactory treatment outcomes (n=109, 61%). There were six articles including 275 patients using the alloplastic material TMJ concepts. Almost all patients had satisfactory treatment outcomes (n=261, 95%).

Conclusion:

Comparing customized total joint reconstruction with costochondral graft, use of TMJ concepts resulted in increased quality of life and fewer complications. In conclusion, we judged that alloplastic material such as TMJ concepts is more effective device in total joint replacement than costochondral graft.

Nonsyndromic facial asymmetry with unilateral condylar aplasia

Introduction. The temporomandibular joint (TMJ) is the most complex elegantly designed joint in the human body. Abnormal development and growth of TMJ may lead to condyle aplasia present in several syndromes expressions, but it is extremely rare when not connected to any underlying pathological disorder or in conjunction with any syndrome. Objective. A rare case of aplasia of the mandibular condyle is presented, along with 3D computed tomography (3D CT) findings. Conclusion. Based on clinical and radiological findings we suggest the abnormal development of the TMJ as the origin. The 3D CT has provided high-quality images, which made diagnosis and a prompt treatment plan possible.

Autogenous grafts for condylar reconstruction in treatment of TMJ ankylosis: current concepts and considerations for the future

Temporomandibular joint (TMJ) ankylosis is characterized by difficulty or inability to open the mouth due to fusion of the temporal and the mandible, resulting in facial symmetry/deformity, malocclusion and dental problems. The only treatment option for TMJ ankylosis is surgical with or without condylar reconstruction. Various autogenous grafts are available for condylar reconstruction after freeing the ankylotic mass such as costochondral, sternoclavicular, fibular, coronoid, and metatarsophalangeal. Costochondral graft is preferred by surgeons, but distraction osteogenesis is slowly gaining popularity and may ultimately become the standard procedure, providing a cost-effective approach with low morbidity and excellent functional outcomes. Tissue engineering is another budding field which has shown promising results in animal studies but has not been applied to humans. To date, there is no ideal autogenous graft for condylar reconstruction that satisfies the complex anatomy and the myriad of functions of a missing condyle.

Mandibular reconstruction using nonvascularized autogenous bone grafting

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This paper will discuss reconstruction of the mandible with autogenous nonvascularized bone grafting. New developments in this area will be investigated by reviewing the most recent literature on this topic as compared with other techniques currently employed. With the advances of vascularized free flap reconstruction it is important to investigate the indication for nonvascularized techniques.

RECENT FINDINGS

Replacement of a portion of the mandibular bone is a common procedure for patients undergoing ablative cancer surgery or for infection as well as temporomandibular joint replacement secondary to disease or trauma. The subject of mandibular reconstruction has seen great advances in recent years with the advent of vascularized free tissue transfer. Other newer areas of mandibular replacement include tissue engineering and distraction osteogenesis. Traditional nonvascularized autogenous bone graft replacement can still play a vital role in rehabilitating these patients.

SUMMARY

Although vascularized free flap reconstruction of mandibular defects has become the more common method of treating the postablative cancer surgery patient, there remain indications for nonvascularized reconstruction of mandibular defects as well as other techniques.