Validity and Reliability of the Diagnostic Tests for Ménière's Disease

Predictive nomograms and an algorithm for managing patients with probable Meniere's disease

PURPOSE

To explore the efficacy of diagnostic tests in accurately reclassifying patients initially diagnosed with probable Meniere's disease (MD) into either definite or non-MD categories.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was conducted at a neurotology clinic between 1/2016 and 5/2022. Patients underwent a battery of tests, from which sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, as well as positive and negative likelihood ratios, were calculated. Additionally, prediction nomograms were developed.

RESULTS

Of the 69 patients, 25 (36.2 %) were initially classified as definite MD, 21 (30.4 %), probable MD, and 23 (33.4 %) non-MD. The mean follow-up was 3.5 years. The sensitivity of electrocochleography (ECochG) was the highest (92 %), with a negative likelihood ratio of 15 %. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with MD-protocol had the highest specificity (100 %), with a positive likelihood ratio of 100 %. Videonystagmography, video head impulse test, and cervical vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials, had lower sensitivity and specificity. We were able to reclassify 18 (86 %) patients with probable MD: 12 (57 %) were diagnosed with definite MD, and 6 (29 %) were diagnosed with non-MD, consistent with their clinical course.

CONCLUSIONS

The combination of ECochG and MRI with MD-protocol provides the most reliable approach to reclassify patients with Probable MD, ensuring a precise and accurate diagnosis. Vestibular tests express the functional status of the labyrinth and may not be reliable. Our findings provide valuable insights into clinical decision-making for patients with Probable MD and raise the consideration of additional diagnostic tests as supplementary to the existing clinical-only diagnosis criteria.

ChatGPT Responses to Frequently Asked Questions on Ménière's Disease: A Comparison to Clinical Practice Guideline Answers

Objective

Evaluate the quality of responses from Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT) models compared to the answers for "Frequently Asked Questions" (FAQs) from the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPG) for Ménière's disease (MD).

Study Design

Comparative analysis.

Setting

The AAO-HNS CPG for MD includes FAQs that clinicians can give to patients for MD-related questions. The ability of ChatGPT to properly educate patients regarding MD is unknown.

Methods

ChatGPT-3.5 and 4.0 were each prompted with 16 questions from the MD FAQs. Each response was rated in terms of (1) comprehensiveness, (2) extensiveness, (3) presence of misleading information, and (4) quality of resources. Readability was assessed using Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL) and Flesch Reading Ease Score (FRES).

Results

ChatGPT-3.5 was comprehensive in 5 responses whereas ChatGPT-4.0 was comprehensive in 9 (31.3% vs 56.3%, P = .2852). ChatGPT-3.5 and 4.0 were extensive in all responses (P = 1.0000). ChatGPT-3.5 was misleading in 5 responses whereas ChatGPT-4.0 was misleading in 3 (31.3% vs 18.75%, P = .6851). ChatGPT-3.5 had quality resources in 10 responses whereas ChatGPT-4.0 had quality resources in 16 (62.5% vs 100%, P = .0177). AAO-HNS CPG FRES (62.4 ± 16.6) demonstrated an appropriate readability score of at least 60, while both ChatGPT-3.5 (39.1 ± 7.3) and 4.0 (42.8 ± 8.5) failed to meet this standard. All platforms had FKGL means that exceeded the recommended level of 6 or lower.

Conclusion

While ChatGPT-4.0 had significantly better resource reporting, both models have room for improvement in being more comprehensive, more readable, and less misleading for patients.

Systematic review of the diagnostic value of hydrops MRI in relation to audiovestibular function tests (electrocochleography, cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential and caloric test)

The objective of this systematic review is to compare the diagnostic value of endolymphatic hydrops (EH) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with audiovestibular function tests, including electro cochleography (ECochG), cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential (cVEMP) and caloric tests for the diagnosis of definite Meniere's disease (DMD). An electronic search was performed in the PubMed, Embase and Cochrane databases in August 2022. Original studies which reported the efficacy of gadolinium MRI for diagnosis of DMD were compared with ECochG, cVEMP and caloric tests from 2007 to 2022 published in English. Two reviewers extracted the methodology and results of MRI and functional tests, assessing them independently. A modified version of the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS-2) was used for the assessment of the quality and the risk of bias of each study. The proportion of DMD cases diagnosed by MRI hydrops vs corresponding functional tests were calculated and the relationship between MRI and functional tests were evaluated using the Cohen's Kappa test. Concerning the MRI, the proportion diagnostic of DMD was 0.67 by cochlear EH and 0.80-0.82 by vestibular EH. Regarding the functional test, the propotiojn diagnostic of DMD was 0.48 by ECochG, 0.76 by cVEMP and 0.65 by caloric test. The findings of this systematic review were that the vestibular EH on imaging most effectively assisted in diagnosing DMD. Among the functional tests, cVEMP was the second most effective test. The agreement between imaging and cVEMP was moderate (0.44), indicating a gap between the patients identified by the imaging and functional tests based on the relatively small number of patients.

Cross-Sectional Analysis of Videonystagmography (VNG) Findings in Balance Disorders

OBJECTIVE

To understand the videonystagmography (VNG) findings in various balance disorders in 67 patients who presented to the outpatient department of an otorhinolaryngology clinic.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This cross-sectional study was conducted in the outpatient department of the otorhinolaryngology clinic of a tertiary care center. A total of 67 patients between the age group of 18 and 70 years with balance disorders were included in the study. VNG findings in different balance disorders were observed and analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 67 patients were enrolled in the study. Findings like caloric inversion and optokinetic nystagmus do not always indicate a central balance disorder due to technical errors and other limitations during the test. However, abnormal saccades seem to be a more relevant finding in central disorders. Rare variants of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) like multiple canal BPPV were also diagnosed using VNG.

CONCLUSION

VNG has come out as a very useful test in our study aiding in 75% of diagnoses. The overall benefits of VNG in balance disorders are immense and necessitate their inclusion in every vertigo clinic.

Comparison of Glycerol Test, ECochG and VEMP Findings in Patients with Meniere’s Disease

Present study aimed to find if multiple audio-vestibular tests can be used to improve in diagnosing Meniere's disease. The study compares the results of four test procedures of glycerol test, Electrocochleography (ECochG), cervical Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potential (c-VEMP) and ocular Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potential (o-VEMP) individually and also together to see whether the diagnosis of Meniere's disease can be improved. Experimental group consist of 16 participants (32 ears) diagnosed with Meniere's disease as per American Academy of Otolaryngology (AAO) -Head and Neck Foundation (2020) guidelines. Control group consist of 16 participants with compliant of only vertigo participated in the study. Participants in both group underwent glycerol test, Electrocochleography (ECochG), cervical Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potential (c-VEMP) and ocular Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potential (o-VEMP). Glycerol test showed a 38% positive rate for the presence of Meniere's disease. ECochG indicated the presence of endolymphatic hydrops in 62% of the participants. Abnormal finding in c-VEMP and o-VEMP was seen in 31% and 56% of the participants respectively. The combination of two tests such as ECochG and o-VEMP has increased the positive rate upto 87%. Adding one more test of c-VEMP or combining all four audiovestibular tests had a positive rate of 94% only. The present study indicated ECochG is a more sensitive tool in the diagnosis of Meniere disease followed by o-VEMP. Thus, the present study indicated that combination ECochG and o-VEMP could be used to find the presence of Meniere's disease successfully.

Nosological Diagnosis, Theories of Categorization, and Argumentations by Analogy

The nosological diagnosis is a particular type of nontheoretical diagnosis consisting of identifying the disease that afflicts the patient without explaining the underlying etiopathological mechanisms. Its origins are within the essentialist point of view on the nature of diseases, which dates back at least to 18th-century taxonomy studies. In this article, we propose a model of nosological diagnosis as a two-phase process composed of the categorization of inductive inferences and argumentations by analogy. In the inductive phase, disease entities are identified by means of typicality-based categorization processes, and meaningful clinical samples are learned (abstract clinical cases, i.e., syndromes and actual cases); in the subsequent phase, those samples are used as the bases of argumentations by analogy to obtain a diagnosis for a given patient. This model extends the prototype resemblance theory of disease including also the exemplar theory proposed in cognitive science and, moreover, it frames the clinical activity of nosological diagnosis and how it can be explained within the theory of argumentation. According to it, diagnosis based on the recognition of a typical syndrome is explained in terms of the prototype theory of categorization and the antisymmetrical argumentation by analogy, while diagnosis based on a comparison with a previous clinical case is explained by the exemplar theory of categorization and by the symmetrical argumentation by analogy.

Wideband tympanometry as a diagnostic tool for Meniere's disease: a retrospective case-control study

PURPOSE

The main purpose of this study was to investigate the usefulness of wide band tympanometry (WBT) as a diagnostic tool for Ménière's disease (MD) by comparing differences in absorbance measures between normal hearing ears and patient diagnosed with MD.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective case-control study. From a cohort of 116 patients diagnosed with Ménière disease, 52 MD patients and 99 normal hearing adults with no history of otological disease served as subjects. Wideband tympanometry was conducted using at Titan Impedance module and audiometry was performed with a MADSEN Astera². Mean energy absorbance curves with 95% confidence intervals were computed across cases with MD and controls in the frequency range 226-8000 Hz. An overall test for difference between curves of cases and controls was calculated by multivariate analysis of variance.

RESULTS

The MD group and the subpopulations of MD patients who fulfilled the International criteria for MD showed a statistically significant lower absorbance at tympanic peak pressure compared to the control group (p < 0.001). No overlap of confidence intervals between mean curves was found within the frequency range of 2000-4000 Hz.

CONCLUSION

Absorbance measures obtained by WBT were able to distinguish between MD ears and normal ears within the frequency range of 2000-4000 Hz. The results indicate that WBT potentially could be a useful and simple non-invasive diagnostic tool for MD. However, more research on the association between absorbance measures and inner ear pathologies is needed.

The Reliability and Validity of "Dokuz Eylül University Meniere's Disease Disability Scale"

OBJECTIVE

Ménière's Disease (MD) is a chronic, non-life threatening inner ear disease, with attacks of disabling vertigo, progressive hearing loss, and tinnitus as the major symptoms. All three symptoms, separately or in combination, cause great distress and have a considerable impact on the quality of life of the patients. The aims of this study were to develop a disease-specific quality of life survey for patients with MD and to analyze the relationships between the audiovestibular findings and the survey.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Following Ear-Nose-Throat examination and audiovestibular tests, the Dokuz Eylül University Meniere's Disease Disability Scale (DEU-MDDS) and Turkish version of the Dizziness Handicap Inventory (DHI-T) were administered to 93 patients with definite MD. Reliability and validity analyses of the scale were performed.

RESULTS

There were 45 (48.4%) male and 48 (51.6%) female patients and the mean age was 48.9±12.1 years. Cronbach's alpha was 0.92 and intraclass correlation coefficients of the DEU-MMDS were significant (p<0.001). Results of the Goodness of Fit Statistics showed that the expression levels of the items were high and the correlation coefficients of each item with the scale were sufficient. There was a statistically significant correlation between DHI-T scores and MDDS. DEU-MDDS was not related to the vestibular tests, age or gender (p>0.05).

CONCLUSION

The MDDS is a valid and reliable scale as a disease-specific quality of life questionnaire for patients with MD.

Wideband Tympanometry in Meniere's Disease

The aim of our study was to obtain wideband tympanometry (WBT) findings in Meniere's disease (MD). It also aimed to evaluate whether the data obtained have diagnostic significance. 21 patients who were followed-up for unilateral Meniere's Disease were evaluated. The ears with Meniere disease were grouped as the MD group and the opposite ears were grouped as the control group. WBT results were recorded as resonance frequency (RF) and frequency-specific absorbance values at 10 different frequencies in the 0.25-8.0 kHz range. Statistical analysis was performed with t test and receiver-operating characteristic analysis. Considering the WBT results, RF was significantly lower in the MD group compared to the control group (p < 0.001). Frequency-specific absorbance values at 0.25, 0.5, 0.75 and 1 kHz were significantly lower in the MD group compared to the control group (p <  0.05). No significant difference was found at 1.5 kHz and above (p > 0.05). For the MD, the RF below 598 Hz was 85.7% sensitive and 76.2% specific, the absorbance at 0.25 kHz below 8% was 66.7% sensitive and 61.9% specific, the absorbance below 17% at 0.5 kHz was 71.4% sensitive and 62.1% specific, the absorbance below 36% at 0.75 kHz was 81% sensitive and 57.8% specific, and the absorbance below 46% at 1 kHz was 71.5% sensitive and 66.7% specific. When MD was compared with intact ears, it was observed that RF was lower, and absorbance decreased in low frequencies. These data is statistically significant, but the sensitivity level is not enough for diagnostic use. Therefore, it is considered as an complementary test for the diagnosis.

Approach to Ménière disease management

OBJECTIVE

To provide family physicians with an updated approach to the diagnosis and management of Ménière disease (MD), detailing the natural course of MD and describing how to initiate medical therapy while awaiting consultation with otolaryngology-head and neck surgery.

SOURCES OF INFORMATION

The approach is based on the authors' clinical practices and review articles from 1989 to 2018. Most of the cited studies provided level II or III evidence.

MAIN MESSAGE

Ménière disease is an uncommon disorder of the inner ear causing vertigo attacks with associated unilateral hearing loss, tinnitus, and aural fullness. It has a degenerative course that often results in permanent sensorineural hearing loss. On average, MD stabilizes with no further vestibular attacks by about 8 years after the onset of symptoms; however, this is highly variable. Vertigo symptoms can be controlled through a combination of dietary salt restriction, stress reduction, and medical therapy (betahistine, diuretics, or both). These can be initiated by family physicians before consultation with otolaryngology-head and neck surgery. Symptoms refractory to such strategies can be treated using nonablative, and occasionally ablative, therapies.

CONCLUSION

A thorough history is key to the approach to and management of MD and permits differentiating MD from other vestibular and nonvestibular conditions.

[Not Available]

Objectif

Fournir aux médecins de famille une approche actualisée pour le diagnostic et la prise en charge de la maladie de Ménière, décrivant en détail l’évolution naturelle de la maladie de Ménière et la façon d’instaurer un traitement médical en attendant une consultation en otorhinolaryngologie–chirurgie cervico-faciale.

Sources de l’information

L’approche se base sur les pratiques cliniques des auteurs et sur des articles de synthèse publiés entre 1989 et 2018. La plupart des études citées ont fourni des données probantes de niveau II ou III.

Message principal

La maladie de Ménière est une affection peu fréquente de l’oreille interne, qui cause des crises de vertige et qui est associée à une perte auditive unilatérale, un acouphène et une sensation de plénitude auditive. La maladie est dégénérative et entraîne souvent une perte auditive neurosensorielle permanente. En moyenne, la maladie de Ménière se stabilise sans autre crise vestibulaire environ 8 ans après l’apparition des symptômes; cela est cependant très variable. Les symptômes de vertige peuvent être maîtrisés en combinant une alimentation hyposodée, une réduction du stress et un traitement médical (bétahistine, diurétiques ou les 2). Ces interventions peuvent être instaurées par le médecin de famille avant la consultation en otorhinolaryngologie–chirurgie cervico-faciale. Les symptômes réfractaires à ces interventions sont traités par l’entremise de traitements non ablatifs et, occasionnellement, ablatifs.

Conclusion

Une anamnèse détaillée est la clé de l’approche à adopter pour la prise en charge de la maladie de Ménière et permet de différencier la maladie de Ménière des autres affections vestibulaires et non vestibulaires.