Performance of physical examination versus ultrasonography to detect stenosis in haemodialysis arteriovenous fistula

Color Doppler ultrasound evaluation of arteriovenous grafts for hemodialysis

Although arteriovenous fistula (AVF) continues to be the vascular access of choice for the hemodialysis, arteriovenous graft (AVG) can be the best choice in certain categories of patients and could have several advantages over AVF in a "patient centered approach" to vascular access. In the clinical management of prosthetic fistulas, color Doppler ultrasound (CDU) is the imaging method of choice for identifying stenosis and other AVG complications. In this review, besides highlighting the pivotal role of CDU in the diagnosis of AVG complications, we will underline the key role that ultrasound can play in identifying those stenosis most likely to cause AVG thrombosis. Furthermore, we will emphasize the support that CDU can play in distinguishing the different types of grafts and prosthetic devices such as stent-grafts, in identifying AVG with lower survival, CDU utilities and limitations in the evaluation of freshly-implanted grafts, the different sites available for AVG volume flow measurement and their use based on the configuration of the prosthesis, the time interval elapsed from the surgical intervention and the integrity of the prosthetic walls.

A scoping review of outcomes with routine surveillance of arterio-venous fistulas

The arteriovenous fistula (AVF) is the preferred venous access for maintenance haemodialysis. AVF dysfunction can progress to access failure, with all the associated morbidity and costs of revising vascular accesses. Routine surveillance of AVFs using specialised equipment has the potential to enable early detection of potential problems. The KDOQI Clinical Practice Guidelines for Vascular Access: Update 2019 suggest that surveillance may be useful to supplement regular clinical monitoring but acknowledge a lack of evidence to make firm recommendations. This scoping review of peer-reviewed literature explored outcomes with the routine surveillance of AVFs using specialised equipment in haemodialysis dependent adults. A systematic search was undertaken using terms such as 'vascular access', haemodialysis, surveillance and 'access flow', utilising the data bases ProQuest (Medline), CINAHL and Embase to include original research articles published between October 2016 and August 2022. A total of eight papers were identified for comprehensive analysis, including two randomised controlled trials, two cross-sectional studies, two retrospective reviews and two evaluations. Themes identified include the incidence of thrombotic events, the role of access blood flow measurements, the need for follow-up angiograms after surveillance and identification of the at-risk access. This review of research published in recent years demonstrated an ongoing paucity of evidence for the benefits of routine AVF surveillance. More research focused on actual outcomes is needed in this important area that is a routine part of dialysis unit workloads everywhere.

Association of risk stratification score with dialysis vascular access stenosis

BACKGROUNDS

Clinical monitoring is the recommended standard for identifying dialysis access dysfunction; however, clinical monitoring requires skill and training, which is challenging for understaffed clinics and overburdened healthcare personnel. A vascular access risk stratification score was recently proposed to assist in detecting dialysis access dysfunction.

PURPOSE

Our objective was to evaluate the utility of using vascular access risk scores to assess venous stenosis in hemodialysis vascular accesses.

METHODS

We prospectively enrolled adult patients who were receiving hemodialysis through an arteriovenous access and who had a risk score ⩽3 (low-risk) or ⩾8 (high-risk). We compared the occurrence of access stenosis (>50% on ultrasonography or angiography) between low-risk and high-risk groups and assessed clinical monitoring results for each group.

RESULTS

Of the 38 patients analyzed (18 low-risk; 20 high-risk), 16 (42%) had significant stenosis. Clinical monitoring results were positive in 39% of the low-risk and 60% of the high-risk group (p = 0.19). The high-risk group had significantly higher occurrence of stenosis than the low-risk group (65% vs 17%; p = 0.003). Sensitivity and specificity of a high score for identifying stenosis were 81% and 68%, respectively. The positive predictive value of a high-risk score was 65%, and the negative predictive value was 80%. Only 11 (58%) of 19 subjects with positive clinical monitoring had significant stenosis. In a multivariable model, the high-risk group had seven-fold higher odds of stenosis than the low-risk group (aOR = 7.38; 95% CI, 1.44-37.82; p = 0.02). Positive clinical monitoring results and previous stenotic history were not associated with stenosis. Every unit increase in the score was associated with 34% higher odds of stenosis (aOR = 1.34; 95% CI, 1.05-1.70; p = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

A calculated risk score may help predict the development of hemodialysis vascular access stenosis and may provide a simple and reliable objective measure for risk stratification.

Arteriovenous Hemodialysis Access Stenosis Diagnosed by Duplex Doppler Ultrasonography: A Review

Arteriovenous fistula (AVF) is currently the hemodialysis access with the longest life expectations for the patients. However, even the AVF is at risk for many complications, especially the development of stenosis. The latter can not only lead to inadequate hemodialysis but also lead to AVF thrombosis. Duplex Doppler ultrasonography is a very precise method, in the hands of experienced professionals, for the diagnosis of AVF complications. In this review, we summarize the ultrasound diagnostic criteria of significant stenoses and their indication for procedural therapy.

Role and Mechanism of Epithelial-Mesenchymal Transition Mediated by Inflammatory Stress-Induced TGF-β1 in Promoting Arteriovenous Fistula Stenosis

Objective

To explore the role and mechanism of epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) mediated by inflammatory stress-induced TGF-β1 in promoting arteriovenous fistula stenosis.

Methods

The inflammatory cells HK-2 were cultured by adding TGF-β1. The optimal stimulation time was determined after TGF-β1 was added. HK-2 cells were divided into two groups, DMEM/F12 medium was added to one group (the control group), and the other group was treated with TGF-β1 (10 ng/ml) in serum-free DMEM/F12 medium to stimulate cell differentiation to mesenchymal.

Results

TGF-β1 was stably expressed after being transfected into EMT. The expression of TGF-β1 in the experimental group was higher than that in the control group (P < 0.05) 7 days after transfection. Western blot showed that TGF-β1 protein expression was higher in the experimental group 7 days after transfection, and no TGF-β1 protein expression was detected in the control group. The smooth muscle cells showed α-SMA expression in the control group, but no cells with expression of SMA and CD31/vWF were found at the same time; α-SMA expression was shown in smooth muscle cells and proliferative myofibroblasts, but no cells with expressions of SMA and CD31/vWF were found at the same time. The observation group showed that the expression of α-SMA was detected in smooth muscle cells and proliferative myofibroblasts, CD31/vWF was also expressed in endothelial cells, and α-SMA and vWF were also observed in endothelial cells, but no CD31 expression was found.

Conclusion

The inflammatory stress-induced TGF-β1 could act on epithelial-mesenchymal transition and promote the degree of arteriovenous fistula stenosis.

Arteriovenous fistula maturation: Physical exam versus flow study

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to determine the utility of routine duplex flow study 4 to 6 weeks after primary AVF creation and to compare physical exam against a duplex flow study in predicting fistula maturation. A surveillance algorithm was established to evaluate the naïve fistula after primary creation.

METHODS

This was a single institution retrospective review of 155 veterans with primary autogenous AVF creation from 2016 to 2018. All patients received a duplex flow study evaluation after primary creation. A comparison was made between physical exam (PE) and flow study at 4 to 6 weeks post creation. Sensitivities and specificities of physical exam and duplex flow study were compared head-to-head in predicting unassisted fistula maturation. A mature AVF was defined as a fistula that could be repetitively cannulated and provided adequate flow for dialysis. Failure of maturation was defined as an AVF that was never usable for dialysis. An abnormal duplex included thrombosis, stenosis (> 50% on gray scale imaging), inadequate vein diameter (< 4 mm), inadequate vein length or superficialization, or poor flow (< 500 ml/min). Bivariate comparisons were conducted using Pearson's χ², Fishers exact test, and Wilcoxon test depending on distribution. Significance was defined as P < 0.05.

RESULTS

There were 53 patients with radiocephalic (RC) fistulas, 41 patients with brachiocephalic (BC) fistulas, and 6 patients with brachiobasilic (BB) fistulas. Of patients with a confirmed abnormal duplex ultrasound, 53% had an abnormal PE (sensitivity 53%; PPV 96.3%, P < 0.001). Of the patients with a confirmed normal duplex, 98% had a normal PE (specificity 98%; NPV 68.5%, P < 0.001). An abnormal duplex flow study had a 67% sensitivity for predicting AVF failure or need for reintervention while an abnormal physical examination had a 42% sensitivity in predicting AVF failure or need for reintervention (P < 0.001). In total, 48 fistulas needed reintervention, however only 20 (42%) were associated with an abnormal physical examination. Of those 48 reinterventions, 20 (42%) fistulas exhibited primary assisted maturation (P < 0.001). On duplex flow study alone, 32 patients had hemodynamically significant lesions necessitating reintervention, which went on to afford 9 (28%) primary assisted mature fistulas (P = 0.69).

CONCLUSION

Abnormal duplex flow studies have a better sensitivity for detecting AVF failure or the need for reintervention compared to physical exam alone. An abnormal duplex correlates more with needing a reintervention to achieve maturation than physical exam. Therefore, we advocate routine use of a postoperative duplex flow study to identify potentially correctable issues and optimize fistula maturation.

The role of Doppler ultrasonography in vascular access surveillance-controversies continue

Chronic hemodialysis therapy required regular entry into the patient’s blood stream with adequate flow. The use of arteriovenous fistulas and grafts is linked with lower morbidity and mortality than the use of catheters. However, these types of accesses are frequently affected by stenoses, which decrease the flow and lead to both inadequate dialysis and access thrombosis. The idea of duplex Doppler ultrasound surveillance is based on the presumption that in-time diagnosis of an asymptomatic significant stenosis and its treatment prolongs access patency. Details of performed trials are conflicting, and current guidelines do not support ultrasound surveillance. This review article summarizes the trials performed and focuses on the reasons of conflicting results. We stress the need of precise standardized criteria of significant access stenosis and the weakness of the metaanalyses performed.

Vascular sound visualization system is useful for monitoring and surveillance of vascular access

BACKGROUNDS

Vascular access (VA) is a lifeline for maintenance hemodialysis patients. Monitoring and surveillance of VA, therefore, play an important role for maintaining VA patency. Surveillance needs special apparatus to estimate the VA function, while, monitoring including physical examination does not usually need such devices but highly skill-dependent and qualitative.

PURPOSE

We report the clinical utility in monitoring and surveillance of VA using a newly developed electronic stethoscope and vascular sound visualization application.

METHODS

One hundred eight patients participated in the study. The vascular sounds were collected using the electronic stethoscope, converted into digital data, sent wirelessly to a personal computer, and then calculated. The units for the calculated intensity of the vascular sound were decibel [dB]. The intensity, however, was normalized as INDEX values ranging from 0 to 99 for practical use. Correlation between INDEX and the mean flow volume (mFV) and resistance index (RI) of brachial artery measured by Doppler ultrasound sonography were examined for VA surveillance. INDEX was continually measured at each dialysis session in ten patients who underwent the angioplasty for VA monitoring.

RESULTS

INDEX significantly correlated with the mFV (coefficient of correlation value = 0.68, p < 0.001) and RI (coefficient of correlation value = -0.51, p < 0.001) of brachial artery. Using the calculated cut-off values, the accuracy of INDEX for the diagnosis of AVF dysfunction ranged from 66% to 82%. INDEX attained the peak just after the angioplasty of culprit lesions and gradually decreased from one patient to another.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that vascular sound visualization system can be useful in VA monitoring and surveillance for detecting and predicting the access stenosis.

KDOQI Clinical Practice Guideline for Vascular Access: 2019 Update

The National Kidney Foundation's Kidney Disease Outcomes Quality Initiative (KDOQI) has provided evidence-based guidelines for hemodialysis vascular access since 1996. Since the last update in 2006, there has been a great accumulation of new evidence and sophistication in the guidelines process. The 2019 update to the KDOQI Clinical Practice Guideline for Vascular Access is a comprehensive document intended to assist multidisciplinary practitioners care for chronic kidney disease patients and their vascular access. New topics include the end-stage kidney disease "Life-Plan" and related concepts, guidance on vascular access choice, new targets for arteriovenous access (fistulas and grafts) and central venous catheters, management of specific complications, and renewed approaches to some older topics. Appraisal of the quality of the evidence was independently conducted by using a Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) approach, and interpretation and application followed the GRADE Evidence to Decision frameworks. As applicable, each guideline statement is accompanied by rationale/background information, a detailed justification, monitoring and evaluation guidance, implementation considerations, special discussions, and recommendations for future research.

Flexible, Skin Coupled Microphone Array for Point of Care Vascular Access Monitoring

Point-of-care screening for hemodialysis vascular access dysfunction requires tools that are objective and efficient. Listening for bruits during physical exam is a subjective examination which can detect stenosis (vascular narrowing) when properly performed. Phonoangiograms (PAGs)-mathematical analysis of bruits-increases the objectivity and sensitivity and permits quantification of stenosis location and degree of stenosis (DOS). This work describes a flexible and body-conformal multi-channel sensor and associated signal processing methods for automated DOS characterization of vascular access. The sensor used an array of thin-film PVDF microphones integrated on polyimide to record bruits at multiple sites along a vascular access. Nonlinear signal processing was used to extract spectral features, and cardiac cycle segmentation was used to improve sensitivity. PAG signal processing algorithms to detect stenosis location and severity are also presented. Experimental results using microphone arrays on a vascular access phantom demonstrated that stenotic lesions were detected within 1 cm of the actual location and graded to three levels (mild, moderate, or severe). Additional PAG features were also used to define a simple binary classifier aimed at patients with failing vascular accesses. The classifier achieved 90% accuracy, 92% specificity, and 91% sensitivity at detecting stenosis greater than 50%. These results suggest that point-of-care screening using microphone arrays can identify at-risk patients using automated signal analysis.

Physical examination of the hemodialysis arteriovenous fistula to detect early dysfunction

The maintenance of vascular access patency for end-stage renal disease patients on hemodialysis is necessary for survival. Many nephrologists, nurse practitioners, and nurses have limited experience with the physical examination of the arteriovenous fistula. In this review, we define key terms used in the assessment of an arteriovenous fistula. We discuss the arteriovenous fistula physical exam, including details of inspection, palpation, and auscultation. Using these concepts, we review the abnormal findings that can assist practitioners in determining the location of a stenosis. We review the existing literature that validates physical exam findings with gold standard tests such as ultrasound and angiography. Finally, we review data supporting the value of training physicians and nurses in arteriovenous fistula physical examination.

Fistulography of a Patent Hemodialysis Access: When Not to Treat and Implications for Establishing a Nontreatment Rate

PURPOSE

To establish a rate of nonintervention in patients referred for hemodialysis access fistulography and to report clinical and fistulographic variables associated with nonintervention.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Encounters for fistulography were reviewed from 2001 to 2016 to determine annual rates of nontreatment over 15 years. Next, an access database was used to retrospectively identify patients undergoing fistulography from 2010 to 2016. Patients who underwent fistulography without intervention (angioplasty or stent placement) served as the nontreatment group (NTG; n = 76). Patients who underwent fistulography with intervention served as the control group (CG; n = 77). Patients with thrombosed accesses were excluded. Clinical indications for intervention and physical examination findings were correlated with fistulography. Need for subsequent percutaneous intervention was recorded.

RESULTS

Annual nontreatment rates ranged from 3% to 14% (median, 10%). Preprocedure thrill was encountered in 45 patients in the NTG (59%) vs 6 in the CG (7.8%; P < .01). Aneurysm as indication for fistulography was more common in the NTG than the CG (19 [25%] vs 4 [5%]; P < .01). The NTG had a higher proportion of aneurysms noted on fistulography as well (38 [50%] vs 19 [25%]; P < .01). The CG had a higher proportion of patients needing subsequent percutaneous intervention vs the NTG (73 [96%] vs 38 [50%]; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

A suggested nonintervention rate for hemodialysis access fistulography is 10%. Patients in the NTG were more likely to have a thrill on physical examination or to present with aneurysms as the clinical indicator. NTG patients were less likely to require subsequent percutaneous intervention.