Two Decades of Deceased Donor Kidney Transplantation at Ahmedabad, India

Act Together and Act Now to Overcome Gender Disparity in Organ Transplantation

Gender disparity refers to the unequal treatment or a perception of individuals based on their gender and arises from differences in socially constructed gender roles. In the field of transplantation, gender inequality arises at different stages, affecting access to medical care, donation practices, and posttransplant followup care. Gender disparity in transplantation is not limited to any geographic region but is thought to be more prevalent in developing nations. An unusually high number of female donations with relatively fewer female recipients is not only attributable to the low economy but a congregation of medical, social, cultural, and psychological factors. Gender disparities can also be shown in transplant-related professional societies. This review highlights the complexities of spousal donation and vulnerability of women, especially in the developing world. There is a growing need to further modify transplant policies to tackle gender disparities, especially in living related donation. Systematic research in the context of gender-related concerns in transplantation will further aid in understanding the complexities and formulating policies for eliminating gender disparities. Gender disparity is a global problem and not merely limited to transplantation.

Bold policy changes are needed to meet the need for organ transplantation in India

Twenty-five years after India passed legislation to legalize brain death, deceased donor transplantation remains underdeveloped while the country has established formidable capacity for living donor transplantation. Because of a large number of potential deceased donors, there is hope that deceased donation could help meet India's enormous need for organ transplantation. However, significant policy and practical barriers limit progress. The vast majority of potential deceased donors are poor motor vehicle accident victims who present for care in hospitals without the necessary infrastructure or expertise to support deceased donation. In contrast, transplant infrastructure and expertise are concentrated in private hospitals and are only accessible to those with the ability to pay. Given these realities, the potential of deceased donor transplantation can only be recognized if Indians who are likely to donate organs are also provided access to transplantation. In this viewpoint, we review the current status of organ transplantation in India and propose new policies to establish a national organization to oversee deceased donor services in all states, to fund resources needed to support deceased donation, to leverage the existing living donor infrastructure to advance deceased donor transplantation, and call for establishment of government policy on funding for posttransplant care and immunosuppression.

Clinical Profiles and Outcomes of COVID-19 in Kidney Transplant Recipients: Experience From a High-Volume Public Sector Transplant Center in India

OBJECTIVES

Data are so far limited on outcomes of kidney transplant recipients with COVID-19 seen at public sector hospitals in developing countries with limited resources.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively investigated a cohort of 157 kidney transplant recipients (75% living and 25% deceased donors) seen at a public sector transplant hospital in India from March to December 2020 who had reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction tests that confirmed COVID-19. Demographic data, immunosuppression regimens, clinical profiles, treatments, and outcomes were analyzed. In our center, maintenance immunosuppression was reduced according to disease severity and case-by-case evaluations. There were also 53 patients with asymptomatic or mild COVID-19 symptoms who received home care to optimize the utilization of scarce resources during travel restrictions.

RESULTS

In our kidney transplant recipient group, median age was 43 years (133 male; 24 female patients); recipients presented at a median of 4 years after transplant. The most common comorbidities included arterial hypertension (73%) and diabetes (24%); presenting symptoms at the time of COVID-19 positivity included cough (49%), fever (58%), and sputum production (32%). Clinical severity ranged from asymptomatic (4%), mild (45%), moderate (31%), and severe (20%) disease. Statistically significant risk factors for mortality included older age, dyspnea, severe disease, obesity, allograft dysfunction prior to COVID-19, acute kidney injury, higher levels of inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein, interleukin 6, procalcitonin), abnormality in chest radiography, and intensive care/ventilator requirements (P < .05). Overall patient mortality was 9.5% (15/157) in hospitalized patients, 21% (15/71) in patients in the intensive care unit, 100% (15/15) in patients who required ventilation, and 0% among those in home treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

The mortality rate in kidney transplant recipients with COVID-19 was higher than in the nonimmunosuppressed general population (1.2%) in India. To our knowledge, this is a largest single-center study of kidney transplant recipients with COVID-19 so far.