Color Doppler energy: computer analysis for detection of volume flow variations

Determining the relationship between three-dimensional power Doppler data and true blood flow characteristics: an in-vitro flow phantom experiment

OBJECTIVES

Three-dimensional (3D) ultrasound can be used to acquire power Doppler data which can be quantified to give an objective impression about blood flow within a tissue or organ. Proprietary software can be used to calculate three indices of vascularity: vascularization index (VI), flow index (FI) and vascularization flow index (VFI). Although these indices appear to have a predictive value in the clinical setting and can be shown to vary between different patient populations and over time within the same population, their relationship with true in-vivo blood flow characteristics has not been established. The objective was to examine the effect of flow rate, vessel number, attenuation and erythrocyte density on these indices.

METHODS

A computer-driven flow phantom was used to continuously pump a nylon particle-based blood mimic (Orgasol(trade mark)) around a closed system through three different ultrasound test tanks. These tanks were designed specifically for these experiments and contained C-Flex(trade mark) tubing, in a variety of arrangements, encased in an agar-based tissue mimic. The test tanks were insonated with a modified 3D transvaginal 4-8-MHz ultrasound transducer and 3D power Doppler data were then acquired over a graduated series of flow rates, depths and blood mimic concentrations. Regression analysis was used to determine the resulting relationships.

RESULTS

The VI increased linearly with an increase in flow rate (P < 0.05), whereas the FI increased in a cubic manner with a more rapid initial increase (P < 0.05). The VI demonstrated a similar linear increase with an increase in the erythrocyte mimic density (P < 0.05), whereas the FI increased markedly with a small change in erythrocyte mimic density and then plateaued (P < 0.01). There was a significant reduction in each index as the distance between the transducer and vessel increased (P < 0.05). Patterns similar to those seen in relation to the change in flow rate were evident, with a more linear relationship between depth and the VI and VFI than between depth and the FI, although the FI remained relatively constant and was not significantly affected by distance from the transducer until a depth of 55 mm was reached. Although a positive linear relationship was seen between vessel number and VI and VFI (P < 0.05) the FI demonstrated a very different and complex, cubic relationship (P < 0.001), increasing linearly until a maximum of three vessels were present when it decreased, and no overall correlation was seen (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The VI, FI and VFI are all significantly affected by volume flow, attenuation, vessel number and erythrocyte density, but in different ways. The VI and VFI seem to have a more predictable relationship, whereas the FI often demonstrates a more complex cubic relationship that is not always logical. Further work is required to establish the effect of other confounding parameters before valid conclusions may be made and a better understanding of 3D power Doppler ultrasound imaging achieved.

Standardization of power Doppler quantification of blood flow in the human fetus using the aorta and inferior vena cava

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to test the applicability to the fetus of mathematical techniques developed to standardize power Doppler indices of adult regional perfusion.

METHOD

Fetal power Doppler imaging was performed on 14 fetuses (25-37 weeks' gestation) using a standardized parasagittal plane, examining renal and aortic blood flow, and additionally inferior vena caval (IVC) flow in one fetus. Images were stored and transferred for off-line computer analysis using purpose-designed software. We first tested the need for techniques to remove the effects of red blood cell clumping on power Doppler amplitude, then performed further analyses to: (1) investigate cardiac cycle effects on aortic amplitude; (2) determine the spatial consistency of, and influence of angle of insonation on, maximal pixel value; (3) quantify temporal consistency; and (4) compare peak pixel values in the fetal aorta and IVC.

RESULTS

No rouleaux effect on the vascular profile was detectable, in contrast to that identified in the adult. Within each fetus a consistent value was seen in the center of the aorta corresponding to 100% vascular amplitude, which was unaltered by the phase of the cardiac cycle, with a coefficient of variation of 28.9% at 89 degrees and 6.5% at 73 degrees . This value was constant in the aorta and IVC.

CONCLUSION

Fetal blood does not appear to form rouleaux to any significant degree, so there is no artificially elevated maximal value for power Doppler amplitude as seen in the adult. We propose that the value representing 100% amplitude may be consistently measured in the center of large fetal vessels such as the aorta, allowing the direct measurement of fractional moving blood volumes in the human fetus.

Quantitative digital analysis of regional placental perfusion using power Doppler in placental abruption

PURPOSE

To apply digital imaging techniques to the quantification of placental vascularity using power Doppler.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Regional placental blood flow was measured in a case of large placental abruption, shortly after presentation and 1 week later. Images were stored digitally and analysed using purpose-designed software (CQ Analysis) to extract and measure vascular energy information. The integrated color energy (ICE) was determined in the main body of placental tissue and in a cotyledon isolated by the retroplacental clot.

RESULTS

Initial assessment at 25 weeks showed only a small difference in integrated energy between normal placenta and the isolated cotyledon (ICE ratio 1.44, P < 0.04). One week later, perfusion in the isolated cotyledon had fallen both on qualitative and quantitative assessment (ICE ratio 3.98, P < 0.0001). This area subsequently became devascularized.

CONCLUSION

Placental perfusion may be quantified using digital power Doppler analysis. Further studies are indicated to evaluate its role in assessing regional and/or global placental perfusion as well as fetal organ perfusion.

Comparison of harmonic and conventional power Doppler ultrasonography for assessment of slow flow in hyperechoic tissue: experimental study using a Doppler phantom

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Despite the advantages of depicting slow flow in small vessels, conventional power Doppler ultrasound (US) has a basic limitation, specifically that artifactual power Doppler signals mimic blood flow, especially in hyperechoic tissue. The purpose of this study was to compare harmonic power Doppler US with power Doppler US using a Doppler phantom under various parameter settings, focusing on the assessment of slow flow in the hyperechoic tissue.

METHODS

While controlling the flow velocity (5 and 10 cm/s), pulse repetition frequency (500, 700, and 1,000 Hz), wall filter (low and medium), and Doppler gain (90%, 96%, and 100%), the authors performed both harmonic Doppler US and power Doppler US by using a Doppler phantom/flow control system. We measured and compared the relative intensities of the Doppler signals (0-250 scale) in both the vessels and hyperechoic tissue-mimicking materials with the two different imaging modalities.

RESULTS

Power Doppler US with any combination of the four parameters evaluated depicted strong flow signals (mean, 213) that were superior to harmonic Doppler US (mean, 61). Relatively strong artifactual signals within the hyperechoic tissue-mimicking materials were noted on all power Doppler US studies (mean, 106) but nearly none on harmonic Doppler US (mean, 3). The contrast-to-noise ratio of harmonic Doppler US was significantly greater than that of power Doppler US.

CONCLUSIONS

Harmonic Doppler US is more useful in assessing slow flow in hyperechoic tissue than power Doppler US because it produces fewer artifactual Doppler signals originating from stationary hyperechoic tissues, which can be misjudged as true signals on power Doppler US.

Influence of instrument settings on flow signal and background noise in power Doppler US. An experimental study using a flow phantom with hyperechoic background

OBJECTIVE

To determine the influence of various power Doppler instrument settings on intensities of flow signal and background noise in flow with a tissue-equivalent phantom.

METHODS

Power Doppler images were obtained with changing wall filter level (low, medium, high, and maximum), pulse repetition frequency (PRF; 500, 700, 1000, 1500, 3000, and 6000 Hz), and Doppler gain (60%, 70%, 80%, 90%, and 100%) at different flow velocities (13.3, 26.5, and 49.8 cm/sec). To make a quantitative comparison of different settings, the authors measured the intensities of flow signal and background noise in obtained power Doppler images using the scanner and a computer program, calculated signal-to-noise difference (SND; intensity of flow signal--intensity of background noise), and evaluated the relation between SND and power Doppler settings.

RESULTS

The intensities of flow signal and background noise were proportional to flow velocity and power Doppler gain but were inversely proportional to PRF and wall filter level. At constant wall filter level (medium), changes of PRF and Doppler gain to the same directions resulted in a high SND. At constant PRF (1000 Hz), changes of wall filter and Doppler gain to the same directions also resulted in a high SND. However, at constant Doppler gain (80%), a high SND was obtained with changing wall filter level and PRF to the opposite directions.

CONCLUSIONS

Three Doppler instrument settings--wall filter level, pulse repetition frequency, and Doppler gain--have reciprocal influences on SND.

Signal from hepatic hemangiomas on power Doppler US: real or artefactual?

To describe imaging findings of hepatic hemangiomas on power Doppler (PD) ultrasound (US) with revised Doppler parameters for preventing PD artefacts from stationary hyperechoic tissue, we prospectively evaluated 48 hemangiomas by PD US with predetermined PD settings to prevent artefactual signals from stationary hyperechoic tissue (pulse repetition frequency of 1000 Hz, medium wall filter, and PD gain of 60-85%). Intratumoral PD signals were not seen in 32 lesions (67%). Minimal (n = 15) or moderate (n = 1) intratumoral PD signals were seen in 16 lesions (33%) and were distributed in the peripheral portion only in 12 lesions (75%) and in the peripheral and central portion in 4 lesions (25%). Due to the lack of sensitivity of PD to detect slow flow in hemangiomas, PD US should no longer be used for the evaluation of echogenic liver masses caused by hemangiomas from other hypovascular malignant lesions of the liver.