Be2+ Causes Hypersensitivity but Mg2+ and Ca2+ Do Not─Favorable Metal Coordination Is the Key for Differential Allosteric Modulation and Binding Affinities

Although the ion selectivity of metalloproteins has been well established, selective metal antigen recognition by immunoproteins remains elusive. One such case is the recognition of the Be2+ ion against its heavier congeners, Mg2+ and Ca2+, by the human leukocyte antigen immunoprotein (HLA-DP2), leading to immunotoxicity. Integrating with our previous mechanistic study on Be2+ toxicity, herein, we have explored the basis of characteristic nontoxicity of Mg2+ and Ca2+ ions despite their in vivo abundance. The ion binding cleft of the HLA-DP2-peptide complex is composed of four acidic residues, p4D and p7E from the peptide and β26E and β69E from the protein. While the tetrahedral coordination site of the smaller Be2+ ion is located deep inside the cavity, hexa- to octa-coordination sites of Mg2+ and Ca2+ ions are located closer to the protein surface. The intrinsic high coordination number of Mg2+/Ca2+ ions induces allosteric modifications on the HLA-DP2_M2 surface, which are atypical for TCR recognition. Furthermore, the lower binding energy of larger Mg2+ and Ca2+ ions with the cavity residues can be correlated to the lower charge density and reduced covalent bonding nature as compared to those of the smaller Be2+ ion. In short, weak binding of Mg2+ and Ca2+ ions and the unfavorable allosteric surface modifications are probably the major determinants for the absence of Mg2+/Ca2+ ion-mediated hypersensitivity in humans.

The dubious origin of beryllium toxicity

Four mechanisms have been proposed in the literature to explain beryllium toxicity; they can be divided in two groups of two mechanisms: (i) replacement type: models 1 and 2; (ii) addition type: models 3 and 4. At this moment is not possible to select the best model not even to establish if one of these models will be the ultimate mechanism of beryllium toxicity. However, it is important to know the still open discussion about something so important associated with one of the simplest elements of the periodic table.

Sorption of beryllium in cementitious systems relevant for nuclear waste disposal: Quantitative description and mechanistic understanding

Beryllium has applications in fission and fusion reactors, and it is present in specific streams of radioactive waste. Accordingly, the environmental mobility of beryllium needs to be assessed in the context of repositories for nuclear waste. Although cement is widely used in these facilities, Be(II) uptake by cementitious materials was not previously investigated and was hence assumed negligible. Sorption experiments were performed under Ar-atmosphere. Ordinary Portland cement, low pH cement, calcium silicate hydrated (C-S-H) phases and the model system TiO₂ were investigated. Sorption kinetics, sorption isotherms and distribution ratios (R_d, in kg⋅L^-1) were determined for these systems. Molecular dynamics were used to characterize the surface processes driving Be(II) uptake. A strong uptake (5 ≤ log R_d ≤ 7) is quantified for all investigated cementitious systems. Linear sorption isotherms are observed over three orders of magnitude in [Be(II)]_aq, confirming that the uptake is controlled by sorption processes and that solubility phenomena is not relevant within the investigated conditions. The analogous behaviour observed for cement and C-S-H support that the latter are the main sink of beryllium. The two step sorption kinetics is explained by a fast surface complexation process, followed by the slow incorporation of Be(II) in C-S-H. Molecular dynamics indicate that Be(OH)₃^- and Be(OH)₄^2- are sorbed to the C-S-H surface through Ca-bridges. This work provides a comprehensive quantitative and mechanistic description of Be(II) uptake by cementitious materials, whose retention properties can be now reliably assessed for a wide range of boundary conditions of relevance in nuclear waste disposal.

Speciation of Be2+ in acidic liquid ammonia and formation of tetra- and octanuclear beryllium amido clusters

The hexa-μ₂-amido-tetraammine-tetraberyllium compounds [Be₄(NH₂)₆(NH₃)₄]X₂ (X = Cl, Br, I, CN, SCN, N₃) have been prepared from beryllium metal and NH₄X or [Be(NH₃)₄]X₂ in liquid ammonia at ambient temperature. The obtained compounds feature an adamantyl shaped complex cation, which was examined via X-ray diffraction, IR, Raman and NMR spectroscopy. The speciation in solution was studied via¹⁵N labeling experiments supplemented with quantum chemistry. Hereby, the intermediates [Be₂(NH₂)(NH₃)₆]³⁺ and [Be₃(NH₂)₃(NH₃)₆]³⁺ were identified. Reactivity studies provided bis(N-acetimidoylacetamidinato-N,N′)-beryllium(ii), when [Be₄(NH₂)₆(NH₃)₄]²⁺ was treated with acetonitrile. While the unprecedented octa-nuclear complex cation [Be₈O(NH₂)₁₂(C₅H₅N)₄]²⁺ was received from pyridine. This cluster proves that the [Be₄O]⁶⁺ core can be stabilized without bidentate O-donor ligands.

The boundaries of beryllium metal oxidation in acidic ammonia have been explored. This enabled the isolation of the tetra- and octa-nuclear beryllium amide complexes. The latter exhibits a completely new structural motive in coordination chemistry.

A consistent model for the key complex in chronic beryllium disease

A hypothesis on the structure of the key complex in chronic beryllium disease (CBD) is discussed with respect to the current knowledge on CBD, and with respect to the constraints implied by the coordination chemistry of beryllium and experimental data on the engaged protein complexes. The structure hypothesis is based on the [Be4O]6+ moiety as a coordination center, which is also found in the so called “basic beryllium carboxylates”. The structure of a small molecular model, optimized at the DFT level of theory, is used to compare the structural demands of this coordination center with a structure of the in vitro model of a beryllium immunoprotein complex determined previously by protein crystallography (Clayton & al., Cell 2014, 158, 132). 9Be NMR chemical shielding values, quadrupole coupling constants and asymmetry parameters (η) have been calculated.

Beryllium-associated diseases from a chemist’s point of view

Beryllium has long been considered the most toxic non-radioactive element to humans. However, it is shown that the acute toxicity of beryllium ions does not exceed that of other toxic cations like Cd2+, Ba2+, Hg2+ or As3+. The physiological mechanisms liable for the development of beryllium-associated diseases are discussed. Additionally an overview over proposed low-molecular model system for the beryllium species responsible for beryllioses is presented.

Beryllium coordination chemistry and its implications on the understanding of metal induced immune responses

The coordination chemistry of beryllium with ligands containing biologically relevant functional groups is discussed. The geometry, speciation and reactivity of these compounds, aids a better understanding of metal ion induced immune reactions.