Comparison of pharmacological thrombolysis with mechanical thrombectomy in thrombosed arteriovenous fistulas and grafts: a systemic review and meta-analysis

AIM

To compare the effectiveness and safety of pharmacological thrombolysis and mechanical thrombectomy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This review was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. Pooled proportions and subgroup analysis were calculated for primary and secondary patency rates, technical success, clinical success, major and minor complications rates.

RESULTS

This systematic review identified a total of 6,492 studies of which 17 studies were included for analysis. A total of 1,089 patients comprising 451 (41.4 %) and 638 (58.6 %) patients who underwent thrombolysis and mechanical thrombectomy procedures, respectively, were analysed. No significant differences were observed between thrombolysis and mechanical thrombectomy procedures in terms of technical success, clinical success, major and minor complications rates, primary and secondary patency rates; however, subgroup analysis of overall arteriovenous fistulas (AVFs) and arteriovenous grafts (AVGs) demonstrated a significantly higher rate of major complications within the AVF group (p=0.0248).

CONCLUSION

The present meta-analysis suggests that pharmacological thrombolysis and mechanical thrombectomy procedures are similarly effective and safe; however, AVFs are subject to higher major complications compared to AVGs.

Initial experience of thrombectomy using vascular snare with multiple loops for chronic organized thrombi in patients with thrombosed native hemodialysis fistulas

BACKGROUND

Thrombi in native hemodialysis access frequently exhibit chronic organized feature because they have formed over a long period. Removal of these is quite difficult owing to relatively large volume, resilient feature, limitations of the introducer sheath size, etc. In this study, we report our experience using a vascular snare for the removal of these thrombi in native arteriovenous fistula (AVF).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The medical records of patients who underwent recanalization for thrombosed AVFs from January 2019 to August 2023 were reviewed. During the study period, a total of 29 native fistulas (19 brachiocephalic, nine radiocephalic, and one radiobasilic) in 25 patients were treated using a vascular snare with multiple loops (19 men and six women). Characteristics of the AVFs, endovascular procedures, technical and clinical results, and complications were evaluated.

RESULTS

Anatomic and clinical success rates were 96.6% and 100%, respectively. Total thrombosis was observed in 21 (72.4%) fistulas. Aneurysmal changes were found in 22 (75.9%) fistulas. The mean fistula age at the time of the procedure was 60.9 months (standard deviation, 52.2). Thrombectomy was initiated using a vascular snare in 14 fistulas. In 15 fistulas for which the procedures were initiated using a rotational percutaneous thrombectomy device (PTD), a vascular snare was subsequently used because recanalization failed or was insufficient due to chronic organizing thrombi. Additional aspiration and balloon angioplasty were performed in 27 (93.1%) and 28 (96.6%), respectively. Pharmacological thrombolysis was performed in one fistula for long segmental thrombosis combined with arterial thrombosis. The mean procedure time, excluding thrombolysis, was 91.9 min (standard deviation, 55.5). No complications related to the use of the vascular snare was observed.

CONCLUSION

The use of a vascular snare with multiple loops was safe and highly effective for the removal of chronic organized thrombi in the recanalization of thrombosed AVFs.

The role of vacuum-assisted mechanical thrombectomy in the management of acutely thrombosed arteriovenous fistulas and grafts

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the safety and efficacy of the mechanical thrombectomy with the Indigo System in the treatment of thrombosed arteriovenous fistulas and grafts.

METHODS

A retrospective search of endovascular procedures performed from November 2018 to June 2020 was conducted. Inclusion criteria were: acute arteriovenous fistula or graft thrombosis that underwent endovascular mechanical thrombectomy with Indigo System. The following information was collected from each case: sex, age, fistula modality, fistula location, treatment modality, and outcomes. Endpoints evaluated were: technical and clinical success rates; primary, assisted primary, and secondary patency rates; complication rates.

RESULTS

Twenty-six mechanical thrombectomy procedures for declotting of arteriovenous fistula thrombosis, using the Indigo System, were performed in 22 patients. Technical and clinical success was achieved in 23/26 cases (88%). Mean follow-up was 9 months (range 11-539 days). The 6-month primary, primary assisted, and secondary patency rates were 71%, 86%, 93% and the 12-month primary, primary assisted, and secondary patency rates were 71%, 72%, 80%, respectively. No technical or device-related complications were observed during thrombectomy, however two venous ruptures occurred on the angioplasty of the underlying stenosis.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, vacuum-assisted thrombectomy of acutely thrombosed arteriovenous fistulas and grafts with Indigo System is safe and effective, providing good short term patency rates.

Trans-radial percutaneous intervention for thrombosed hemodialysis access: A single-center experience

BACKGROUND

Traditionally, percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) is a first-line approach for stenosed dialysis accesses and has been performed through the non-thrombosed vein segment. For thrombosed accesses, thrombectomy (whether open or percutaneous) is a standard approach. The primary objective of our study is to determine the clinical and technical outcomes of the trans-radial approach of PTA among thrombosed dialysis accesses, in terms of safety and feasibility, technical and clinical aspects and factors influencing them, as well as assisted primary patency, secondary patency at 6 and 12 months.

METHODS

This is a single-center retrospective study that included 150 patients over 3 years. About 123 patients underwent successful percutaneous balloon angioplasty through the radial access.

RESULTS

We report an overall technical and clinical success rate of 82%, assisted primary patency rate of about 90.25% at 3 months, 82.93% at 6 months, 73.18% at 1 year, and secondary patency rate of 94% at 1 year. Twenty-seven patients were referred for surgical revisions/creation of a new fistula for reasons like inability to pass wire (6 patients), unfavorable anatomical variations like aneurysms at the proximal segments (5 patients), inability to cross the fistula (5 patients), and persistent fistula dysfunction with no flow after initial balloon dilatation (11 patients). Three patients had hematoma at the radial access site (2.5%) while two patients had the AV fistula segment rupture and were successfully treated conservatively.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that PTA through the trans-radial approach to completely thrombosed hemodialysis accesses is a good alternative to transvenous access and has a very good assisted primary patency and secondary patency at 1 year without major complications.

Management of Thrombosed Dialysis Access Circuits

Thrombotic occlusion of autologous arteriovenous fistulas or synthetic arteriovenous grafts is a serious adverse event in hemodialysis patients and declotting should be performed before next hemodialysis session, in order to avoid a central venous catheter. Various techniques exist to declot a thrombosed vascular access, including open surgical thrombectomy, catheter-directed thrombolysis and use of different types of percutaneous thrombo-aspiration catheters and mechanical thrombectomy devices. These devices can be categorized as devices with direct wall contact and hydrodynamic devices without direct wall contact. Technical and early clinical outcome results of percutaneous hemodialysis declotting are high and ranging between 70 and 100%; late clinical patency results are much lower related to restenosis or re-thrombosis; these patency results are higher for autologous arteriovenous fistulas compared to synthetic arteriovenous grafts and mainly depend on the combined efficacy of successful thrombectomy and durable treatment of the underlying stenoses, associated with the acute thrombosis.

Comparing Patency Rates of Arteriovenous Dialysis Access following Percutaneous Thrombectomy Using Various Catheter Directed Therapies

BACKGROUND

Arteriovenous fistulas often require frequent interventions to maintain patency for hemodialysis. Interventions may include open or percutaneous thrombectomy with additional targeted interventions as indicated. We evaluated the primary and cumulative functional patency rates following three unique approaches to percutaneous thrombectomy of thrombosed dialysis access.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 236 unique patients who presented with thrombosed hemodialysis access was analyzed over a period of 4 years from 2016 to 2020. We analyzed a total of 413 procedures that utilized 3 separate percutaneous thrombectomy devices to assist with restoring patency. The Indigo System CAT-D Aspiration Thrombectomy Catheter (Penumbra; Alameda, CA), the Arrow-Trerotola Rotational Thrombectomy System (Teleflex; Wayne, PA) and the Angiojet Rheolytic Thrombectomy Catheter (Boston Scientific, Marlborough, MA) devices were compared for primary and cumulative functional patency. Primary patency was defined as time from percutaneous thrombectomy to next intervention (Angioplasty, stenting, and repeat thrombectomy). Cumulative functional patency was defined as time from percutaneous thrombectomy to time of access abandonment. Medical record chart review was utilized to determine patency rates.

RESULTS

A total of 413 percutaneous thrombectomy procedures were performed. Of the procedures performed, 98 utilized Angiojet, 103 utilized Trerotola, and 212 used Penumbra. The mean primary patency rates in (days) for the devices were as follows: Angiojet (194), Trerotola (204), and Penumbra (107). The mean cumulative functional patency rates (in days) for the devices were as follows: rheolytic thrombectomy (450 days), aspiration thrombectomy (292 days), and rotational thrombectomy (475 days). Angiojet versus Penumbra and Trerotola versus Penumbra both showed diminished patency rates when using the Penumbra catheter that were statistically significant (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

All percutaneous thrombectomy approaches do not result in the same primary or cumulative functional patency rates. Approaches with Trerotola and Angiojet resulted in improved primary and cumulative functional patency rates compared to those using Penumbra.

The related factors to the re-thrombosis of hemodialysis arteriovenous graft after endovascular salvage

BACKGROUND

Only a few issues of the related factors to hemodialysis access dysfunction have been evaluated, and the effects of antiplatelets to improve the patency of hemodialysis access remained controversial. Hence, this study aimed to determine the related factors to the re-thrombosis of arteriovenous grafts (AVGs) after endovascular treatment.

METHODS

This retrospective study was conducted at a university-affiliated teaching hospital in Southern Thailand. All patients who underwent hemodialysis with thrombosed AVG, who had pharmacomechanical thrombolysis from January 2016 to December 2018, were enrolled. Post-intervention primary patency was analyzed by the Kaplan-Meier method, and the related factors to the re-thrombosis of AVG were evaluated using logistic regression.

RESULTS

A total of 157 patients with thrombosed hemodialysis AVG were enrolled. The most common graft location and configuration was a forearm loop graft (65%). Post-intervention primary patency rate at 1, 3, and 6 months were 79.0%, 67.1%, and 54.0%, respectively. Diabetes mellitus (DM) was a significant related factor for re-thrombosis (hazard ratio [HR], 1.89; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.20-2.98; p = 0.006). A single antiplatelet after the procedure was a protective factor for re-thrombosis (HR, 0.58; 95% CI, 0.38-0.89; p = 0.013). The median post-intervention primary patency was 15.7 months in the group of single antiplatelet usage, which was better than that of the non-antiplatelet group (p = 0.012).

CONCLUSION

DM and antiplatelet usage were significant related factors to the re-thrombosis of hemodialysis AVG after endovascular salvage.

Outcomes after endovascular mechanical thrombectomy in occluded vascular access used for dialysis purposes

Purpose

Endovascular mechanical thrombectomy using the AngioJet™ system can be considered to reestablish patency in occluded vascular access. The aim of this study was to review our results for endovascular mechanical thrombectomy using the AngioJet™ system in patients with arteriovenous fistulae (AVF) and arteriovenous grafts (AVG).

Methods

Data collected in a database of patients requiring hemodialysis for renal failure were analyzed. Patients who underwent endovascular mechanical thrombectomy procedures with the AngioJet™ system for occlusion of vascular access were included. Clinical and technical success rates and patency rates were calculated. Multivariate analysis was used to identify factors of influence.

Results

A total of 92 AngioJet™ procedures in 60 patients with thrombosed vascular access were reviewed during a mean follow‐up period of 21.5 months in patients with an AVF and 11.9 months in patients with an AVG. Technical and clinical success was achieved in 92.6% of AVF cases and 92.0 and 90.8% of AVG cases with an AVG, respectively. Significantly higher primary and primary‐assisted patency rates were observed in the AVF group. Multivariate regression analysis indicated that left‐sided vascular access and female sex were independent predictors for failure regarding primary patency in AVG patients. Immunosuppressive drugs and older age were negative predictors for secondary patency in AVG patients.

Conclusions

The AngioJet™ system can be deemed an effective technique to reestablish patency in occluded vascular access with minimal use of central venous catheters for dialysis. Good technical and clinical success rates were achieved with acceptable patency rates, especially in AVF patients.

Factors influencing outcomes of rheolytic thrombectomy on thrombosed dialysis access grafts: Door to angiographic bed time and what else?

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of the time interval from clinical presentation of arteriovenous graft thrombosis and the thrombectomy procedure by the AngioJet system in terms of technical and clinical success and to identify factors influencing success.

METHODS

A total of 60 consecutive patients (35 men and 25 women; mean age = 52 ± 7.89 years) who had undergone percutaneous thrombectomy by the AngioJet device from 2016 to 2019 were retrospectively enrolled. Demographics and fistula data, previous treatments, time from clinical onset of thrombosis to intervention, procedural details and complications were recorded. Technical and clinical success and primary and secondary patency rates were calculated. One-way analysis of variance was performed to test any correlation between patient-related and fistula/procedure-related variables and technical/clinical success. Odds ratio and relative risk were also calculated when necessary.

RESULTS

Technical success and clinical success were 95% and 91.7%, respectively. Post-interventional primary and secondary patency rates at 1 year were 72.5% and 84.3%, respectively. Complication rate was 6.7%. One-way analysis of variance showed that clinical success was higher in patients with no previous treatment (p = 0.015). Furthermore, clinical success was significantly associated with door to angiographic bed time (p = 0.002): p-value for the 24-h and the 72-h cut-off was 0.012 and 0.006, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Percutaneous rheolytic thrombectomy is safe and effective for thrombosed arteriovenous grafts, with acceptable primary and secondary patency rates. Higher clinical success was found in patients never treated before and when the procedure was carried out within 24 h from the clinical onset of thrombosis.

Vacuum-assisted mechanical thrombectomy in extensively occlusive thrombosis of dialysis arteriovenous grafts with indigo system

PURPOSE

To present a selected series of extensively occlusive thrombosis of arteriovenous graft treated with the Penumbra's Indigo System.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ten patients with acute (within 72 h) extensively occlusive thrombosis of arteriovenous graft (mean extension = 30.1 (range = 15-45) cm) were treated at our institution with the Indigo System. Of the 10 cases, thrombosis was extended to venous outflow in 7 cases and to both arterial inflow and venous outflow in 3 cases.

RESULTS

Both anatomic and clinical success were achieved in 8 of the 10 procedures (80.0%). In the 2 cases of technical failure, the patients underwent surgical thrombectomy with the finding of arteriovenous graft exhaustion, which was then replaced. The 6-month primary patency, primary-assisted patency, and secondary patency rates were 37.5% (3/8), 50.0% (4/8), and 62.5% (5/8). We reported 2 complications (one minor and one major adverse event).

CONCLUSION

Percutaneous mechanical thrombectomy aspiration with Indigo System is a relatively safe and effective procedure and can be used even in extensively thrombosed arteriovenous graft.

Safety and Efficacy of the Percutaneous Manual Aspiration Thrombectomy Technique to Treat Thrombotic Occlusion of Native Arteriovenous Fistulas for Hemodialysis

목적

대상과 방법

결과

결론

Thrombosed native hemodialysis fistulas: Technical and clinical outcomes of endovascular recanalization and factors influencing patency

Purpose:

To evaluate the technical and clinical results of endovascular recanalization of thrombosed native hemodialysis fistula and the factors influencing patency.

Methods:

A retrospective study was conducted with 73 patients who had thrombosed arteriovenous fistulas and were treated with endovascular methods. Patient characteristics, arteriovenous fistula-related characteristics, and endovascular procedures were analyzed. Technical and clinical results and patency rates were evaluated. The factors influencing patency were analyzed using a univariate and multivariate Cox proportional hazards model.

Results:

Technical and clinical success rates were 93% (68/73) and 85% (62/73), respectively. At 3, 6, and 12 months, the primary patency rates were 87.9%, 73.3%, and 64.8%; assisted primary patency rates were 89.2%, 78.6%, and 70.7%; and secondary patency rates were 90.8%, 87.2%, and 83.1%, respectively. Previous intervention and cephalic arch stenosis were risk factors for lower primary and assisted primary patency ( p < 0.05 for all). Cephalic arch stenosis was the only risk factor for lower secondary patency ( p < 0.05). No major complications associated with the procedures were noticed.

Conclusion:

Endovascular treatment was effective for the immediate recanalization of thrombosed arteriovenous fistula. In addition, previous intervention and cephalic arch stenosis were significantly related to lower arteriovenous fistula patency.

Transcatheter Thrombolysis with Percutaneous Transluminal Angioplasty Using a Trans-Brachial Approach to Treat Thrombosed Arteriovenous Fistulas

Background

Arteriovenous fistulas (AVFs) are used to provide vascular access for hemodialysis in patients with end-stage renal failure. However, stenosis and thrombosis can compromise long-term AVF patency. The objective of this study was to evaluate catheter thrombolysis with percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA), using a trans-brachial approach, for acutely thrombosed AVFs.

Material/Methods

This retrospective study examined 30 cases of AVF thrombosis treated between January 1, 2015 and January 1, 2017. All patients received transcatheter thrombolysis with PTA using a trans-brachial approach. AVF patency was assessed after 6 months.

Results

Thrombolysis with PTA was performed at 2 to 72 h after diagnosis of AVF occlusion due to acute thrombosis, and AVF patency was restored in all patients. After 6 months, the primary and secondary patency rates were 76.7% and 93.3%, respectively. For type I stenosis, primary patency was achieved in 10 of 16 patients (62.5%) and secondary patency was achieved in 14 of 16 patients (87.5%). For type II stenosis, primary patency was achieved in 13 of 14 patients (92.9%) and secondary patency was achieved in 14 of 14 patients (100%). Comparing type I and II stenosis, a significant difference was detected in the rates of primary patency (odds ratio=0.909, 95% confidence interval 0.754–1.096, P=0.049), but not secondary patency (P=0.178), after 6 months.

Conclusions

Our study provides preliminary evidence that catheter-directed thrombolysis with PTA using a trans-brachial approach can achieve high patency rates when used to treat acutely thrombosed AVFs.

Safety and efficacy of the AngioJet device in the treatment of thrombosed arteriovenous fistula and grafts: A systematic review

PURPOSE

The AngioJet Hemolytic Thrombectomy Device "AngioJet" (Boston Scientific, Malborough, MA, USA) is a rheolytic thrombectomy device that can be used in the treatment of hemodialysis arteriovenous fistula and graft thrombosis. We aim to appraise the current evidence on AngioJet thrombectomy in hemodialysis vascular access thrombosis, and to determine its safety, including complications and efficacy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An electronic literature search was performed on the MEDLINE and Embase databases. References of retrieved articles were also reviewed. Articles using AngioJet for the treatment of arteriovenous fistula or graft were included. Patients less than 18 years old, non-English articles, single case reports, small case series (<5 cases), conference publications, and nonhuman models were excluded.

RESULTS

A total of 688 articles were initially evaluated and 10 articles fulfilled the inclusion criteria, which included 836 patients with 431 grafts and 234 fistulas. Results were heterogeneously reported. The adjusted mean primary patency rates for 1, 3, 6, and 12 months were 64.6%, 43.8%, 42.5%, and 30.5%, respectively; adjusted mean secondary patency rates for 3, 6, and 12 months were 76.5%, 75.1%, and 74.5%, and assisted primary patency rates were 61.9%, 47.3%, and 35.3%, respectively. There were 126 complications, most were minor. There were seven deaths, but were unable to be attributable to the AngioJet.

CONCLUSION

The AngioJet is an effective and safe treatment option for thrombosed fistulas and grafts. However, the quality of the current evidence is poor. Further research with prospective randomized controlled trials using standardized data reporting methods is needed to prove its safety and efficacy.

Maintaining Patency of Vascular Access for Haemodialysis

All types of vascular access, a necessity for haemodialysis, are prone to thrombosis and if untreated this results in failure. Thrombosis results from the combination of impaired blood flow, endothelial and vessel wall injury and a propensity towards pro-coagulative states, either intrinsic or aggravated by dialysis or dehydration. The treatment of access thrombosis relies on removal of the clot (thrombectomy) and treatment of the underlying problem. In most cases this is stenosis secondary to neointimal hyperplasia which can occur early (failure to mature) or later. Pharmacological approaches have largely been shown to be ineffective at prevention of thrombosis. The mainstay of preventing access failure may be in surveillance and detecting stenosis prior to occlusion although the optimal protocol to achieve this remains undefined. Management of thrombosed access is via either surgical and radiological approaches. Multiple techniques and devices are available for thrombectomy and the choice is usually based on local expertise and availability rather than evidence as few trials have been performed to allow robust comparisons. This paper outlines the basis of access thrombosis and discusses the currently available techniques for treatment.

Percutaneous treatment of thrombosed hemodialysis arteriovenous fistulas: use of thromboaspiration and balloon angioplasty

Background

Endovascular strategies have been used to manage patients with thrombosed vascular access for hemodialysis. We analyzed primary success rate and patency rates of balloon angioplasty following mechanical thrombectomy for the treatment of thrombosed native arteriovenous fistulas.

Methods

This was a retrospective study of 24 patients with thrombosed native arteriovenous fistulas who were referred for treatment in the intervention unit of the Radiology Department. All patients had been performed percutaneous thrombo-aspiration and balloon angioplasty. Technical and clinical success rates as well as the 6th and 12th months primary and secondary patency of fistulas were evaluated.

Results

Technical and clinical success was 83%. In the 6 of 20 patients, early re-thrombosis were detected. Patent AVF with primary and secondary patency rates at 6 and 12 months was 55%-40%. The secondary patency rates at 6 and 12 months were 75% and 70%.

Conclusion

Mechanical thrombectomy with balloon angioplasty is a minimally invasive and effective procedure for the treatment of thrombosed native arteriovenous fistula. Advantages of this technique are minor complication rates, cost effectiveness, high technical success rate.

Thermal Changes during Rheolytic Mechanical Thrombectomy

PURPOSE

To characterize thermal changes induced by rheolytic thrombectomy (RT) within an ex vivo venous model and evaluate resultant changes of endothelial and vessel wall injury.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patent human saphenous vein segments without thrombus were mounted in an ex vivo perfusion system with a temperature probe apposed to the adventitial surface. RT was performed over a guide wire to facilitate device centering. Continuous RT was performed for 4 minutes with temperature recorded every 10 seconds. Pulsed RT was performed for eight cycles of 30 seconds followed by 10 seconds of deactivation. Mean temperature increase, maximum temperature (Tmax), intimal/medial thickness, endothelial cell staining (CD31), and heat shock protein 90 (HSP90) expression were compared between untreated and RT-treated venous segments.

RESULTS

Continuous RT produced a mean 7.6°C increase in temperature above baseline with mean Tmax of 44.1°C. Pulsed RT produced a mean 7.3°C increase in temperature and mean Tmax of 43.8°C. Differences in mean temperature increase (P = .66) and Tmax (P = .71) between the two groups were not statistically significant. RT-treated segments showed intima/media thinning (0.32 mm before RT and 0.18 mm after RT; P = .004) and reduction in intact endothelium (38.8% before RT and 13.8% after RT; P = .002). Staining for HSP90 showed a 3.1% increase in expression after RT (P = .31).

CONCLUSIONS

RT in this venous model showed reproducible increases in vessel temperature and evidence of endothelial and vessel wall injury. Avoiding prolonged RT application to a focal vascular segment during clinical use may be beneficial.