Delay in the clinical diagnosis of breast cancer: estimating its effect on prognosis, with particular reference to medical litigation

Medical malpractice litigation is increasing. Delay in diagnosis is the commonest basis for litigation involving the treatment of breast cancer. When delay in diagnosis has occurred, any losses for which a plaintiff seeks compensation require estimates to be made of any change in prognosis over the period of the delay relative to the extent of disease found when treatment is finally undertaken. We have examined the natural history of breast cancer and have attempted to provide evidence-based quantitative guidelines for the evaluation of the losses which may be claimed in malpractice cases.

Symptoms 2 weeks, 3 months and 12 months after treatment of early breast cancer: the patients’ perspectives

The physical symptoms and side-effects reported by patients treated for early breast cancer with surgery (S), (breast conservation or mastectomy), radiotherapy (R) and chemotherapy (C) are reported. As part of a large quality-of-life study, eligible patients were invited to complete a questionnaire at three and 12 months after treatment for early breast cancer. Symptoms 2 weeks after surgery were retrospectively collected at the 3-month questionnaire. Comparing the commonly used different therapy combinations (S, S+R, S+C and S+R+C) we found the only loco-regional symptom to show a significant difference between these groups was chest tightness (P<0.001). Both anxiety about attending for and discomfort during C were significantly higher than during R (P<0.00005 and 0.00001 respectively). We found that the addition of R and, or, C to S resulted in surprisingly little variation in physical side-effects.

An assessment of the Basic Treatment Equivalent (BTE) model as measure of radiotherapy workload

Current methods of linear accelerator workload analysis in radiation oncology use patients per hour or fields per hour as the basic unit of measurement but fail to take account of the variations in complexity of different treatment techniques. The Basic Treatment Equivalent (BTE) model of productivity assessment has been derived as a potentially better measure of workload because it includes a complexity factor. This model has now been tested prospectively in ten radiation oncology departments in New South Wales and compared with the numbers of fields and patients per hour. Over a 4-week period there were 50,115 fields administrated in 18,466 fractions in 441 hours of machine time in ten radiation oncology departments. The average productivity results for all departments were 4.18 patients, 11.25 fields and 5.66 BTE per hour. When compared with patients per hour and fields per hour, there was less variability of BTE per patient per hour in all departments, suggesting that most departments deliver radiation therapy in a consistent way, which is not appropriately reflected in the numbers of fields or patients per hour. Departments that were able to treat a high number of patients or fields per hour were able to do so because they used less complicated techniques or had a less complicated casemix of patients. The BTE model allows for variations in the complexity of treatment techniques, is simple to apply, and is reproducible under different conditions in different departments. Following revision of the model, an Australasian study is now proposed. The confirmation of our findings will have significant implications for resource utilization comparisons, patient time allocations, waiting list estimates and cost-benefit analysis.

Basic Treatment Equivalent (BTE): a new measure of linear accelerator workload

The measurement of linear accelerator workload in radiation oncology departments is usually based on the number of fields treated per unit time. However, this approach ignores variations in treatment complexity. This prospective study, was designed to measure treatment workload directly, taking into account the variations in complexity of different treatment techniques. From this, a model was to be developed, which would be simple to apply and reproducible, both within and between radiation oncology departments in Australasia. It would provide a realistic basis for assessing treatment costs and enable the comparison of patient throughput between departments. This paper describes the derivation of the model. Over a 4-week period in the Radiation Oncology Department of Westmead Hospital, all fractions of radiotherapy were timed. The data collected included: tumour site; treatment intent; number of fields; number of wedges, compensators and shielding blocks; fraction number; patient age; performance status; and need for general anaesthesia. Multivariate modelling was performed to identify factors that significantly affected fraction duration, so that these could be used to develop a model of resource utilization. The durations of 2371 fractions were measured in 219 patients. Seventy-five per cent of fractions were given with radical intent. The factors found to influence fraction duration on multivariate modelling were: number of fields; number of shielding blocks; first treatment fraction; need for anaesthesia; and performance status. The number of wedges and compensators were also found to be significant but were not included in the model in order to maintain simplicity. This was felt to be necessary if the model is to be applied to the widest possible variety of machines. A model of resources utilization called 'Basic Treatment Equivalent' (BTE) was derived, which incorporated these factors. When tested at Westmead Hospital, this model accurately reflected the predicted BTE value over a further 1-week study period. This model of linear accelerator use, which incorporates complexity has been derived and evaluated in one radiation oncology department. This requires further prospective testing before its widespread use. The model appears to reflect linear accelerator workload better than previous measures. An Australasian study to validate the model further will be undertaken. If adopted, this model has implications for comparative workload reports, diagnostic-related groups, waiting list calculations, and patient scheduling.

WART revisited: the treatment of epithelial ovarian cancer by whole abdominal radiotherapy

The present study investigated outcomes for 78 women with epithelial ovarian carcinoma treated by whole abdominal radiotherapy (WART) after cyto-reductive surgery at Westmead Hospital between 1980 and 1993. These patients had 5-year relapse-free and overall survival rates of 52 and 55%, respectively. The median follow-up was 7.5 years. Fifty-eight of the 78 women fulfilled the criteria as defined by the Princess Margaret Hospital's intermediate risk' category. These patients had both a relapse-free and overall survival rate of 62% at 5 years (P = 0.001 as compared with the remaining 20 women). Mild gastrointestinal upset was common during radiotherapy. Five women did not complete treatment. Late toxicity (grade 3 or more, using the Radiotherapy Oncology Group (RTOG) system) occurred in eight women, and five women required surgery for intestinal complications (6.4%). There were no deaths due to late side effects. In conclusion the results are consistent with those of other series in the treatment of epithelial ovarian cancer by adjuvant WART. When compared to a similar-stage disease treated with cisplatin-based chemotherapy, there is no evidence to support the exclusive use of chemotherapy.

Breast conservation: long-term results from Westmead Hospital

BACKGROUND

Breast conservation has been shown to be a safe and effective alternative to mastectomy in early-stage breast cancer. The present study reviews the long-term outcome and toxicity after treatment of early breast cancer by conservative surgery and radiation.

METHODS

Between November 1979 and December 1989, 438 patients with Union Internationale Contre le Cancer (UICC) stage I or II breast cancer were treated with conservative surgery and radiation therapy (CS+RT) at Westmead Hospital. Surgery to the breast varied from a local excision to a quadrantectomy, depending on the preference of the referring surgeon. The axilla was surgically dissected in 299 patients (68%). All patients received postoperative breast irradiation. The whole breast was irradiated to 46-54 Gy (median dose, 50 Gy) using 6 Mev photons for 5-6.5 weeks. Boosts were given at the primary tumour site in 336 patients (78%), by electron therapy (88 patients), iridium-192 (247 patients) or photons (one patient). A total of 44 patients (10%) received adjuvant chemotherapy.

RESULTS

The median follow-up period for surviving patients was 84 months (range: 56-172 months). The 5-year actuarial rate of local recurrence was 6% (312 patients at risk), and the 10-year rate was 10% (52 patients at risk). Very young patients (aged 34 years at diagnosis) had a 5-year actuarial rate of local recurrence of 13% compared to 5% for older patients (P = 0.04). Neither the total dose to the primary site nor the boost technique influenced local recurrence. The 5-year freedom from distant relapse was 83%. The side effects included rib fractures (2%), symptomatic pneumonitis (3%), fatty necrosis or fibrosis requiring surgery (4%), and moderate-severe oedema of the arm (7%).

CONCLUSIONS

The long-term data show that CS+RT for UICC stage I or II breast cancer results in low rates of local recurrence which are influenced by age at diagnosis, but not by radiation dose or boost technique. These results confirm those of other international series that CS+RT is a safe alternative to mastectomy for most women with operable breast cancer.

Concurrent 5-fluorouracil, mitomycin C and irradiation in locally advanced cervix cancer

We reviewed 177 patients treated with radical radiotherapy for locally advanced (FIGO stages IIB, IIIA, IIIB) cervix cancer between January 1979 and December 1989. The radiotherapy was given by external beam treatment to the pelvis and by an intracavitary caesium insertion. Ninety-three patients also received chemotherapy which consisted of infusional 5-fluorouracil during the first and last weeks of the external beam component of the radiotherapy, combined with bolus mitomycin C (group A, 64 patients) or without mitomycin C (group B, 29 patients). These groups were compared with patients treated by radiotherapy alone (group C, 84 patients). The median follow-up was 7.2 years. The median survival time for all patients was 47 months, but was significantly higher (87 months, p = 0.004) for group A. Rates of relapse-free survival and local control were also higher in group A. Toxicity was assessed in detail using the Franco-Italian glossary. There was a relatively high rate of complications, particularly in group A, with 36% of patients having grade 3 or 4 complications. This increase in toxicity persisted through all follow-up time intervals. Patients in group B also demonstrated a higher rate of toxicity than group C, but this increase was limited to the first 6 months of follow-up. The use of mitomycin C in addition to radiotherapy and 5-fluorouracil should be regarded with caution, as other studies have also shown that toxicity is increased, but without improvements in survival.

Prognostic factors and the curability of breast cancer

Over the years three different concepts regarding the cure of treated breast cancer have emerged. These are clinical cure, personal cure and statistical cure. The latter is the most accurate estimate of the curability of a disease which is presumed to be fatal unless treated. Statistical cure is the elimination of the hazard of death in a treated group compared with an age-matched control population. When statistical cure is studied in patients treated for early breast cancer, it is clear that breast cancer is an incurable disease. The expected gains from the relatively recent introduction of adjuvant therapy are too small to alter this concept. The significance of prognostic factors in a disease deemed to be incurable therefore requires re-examination. The conventional prognostic factors of tumour size, nodal status and a combination of those two in staging systems significantly discriminates in terms of survival in the short term. However, when the characteristics of long-term survivors are examined, neither tumour size nor nodal status discriminates effectively. If this is the case, then we need to reconsider novel treatment strategies which have been introduced in the hope of increasing the curability of the disease and the selection for those treatment strategies of patients using the conventional prognostic factors of tumour size or nodal involvement.

Combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy for patients with breast cancer and extensive nodal involvement

PURPOSE

This retrospective review examines local control, freedom from distant failure, and survival for patients with nonmetastatic breast cancer with extensive nodal disease (> 10 nodes, 45 patients; or > or = 70% involved nodes, if < 10 nodes found, 19 patients). All patients received chemotherapy and radiotherapy following mastectomy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Sixty-four patients were treated between January 1980 and December 1988 at Westmead Hospital, Westmead, NSW Australia. The median follow-up duration for surviving patients was 91.5 months (range, 56 to 121). The median age was 51 years, and the median number of positive nodes was 11. Four successive protocols evolved, each with three phases, as follows: induction chemotherapy (doxorubicin or mitoxantrone, plus cyclophosphamide; three cycles), radiotherapy (50 Gy in 25 fractions to chest wall and regional nodes), then chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and fluorouracil [CMF]) of progressively shorter duration. Radiotherapy and chemotherapy were concurrent in the fourth regimen.

RESULTS

One patient (1.5%) developed local recurrence before distant relapse, and seven patients (11%) developed local and/or regional recurrence simultaneously or after distant relapse. The 5-year actuarial freedom from distant relapse and overall survival rates were 45% and 65%, respectively. Overall survival did not vary significantly by menopausal status, nodal subgroup, or dose-intensity. There were no treatment-related deaths.

CONCLUSION

Combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy in standard dosage is an acceptable approach following mastectomy for patients with extensive nodal involvement at high risk for local recurrence and distant relapse. This approach should be considered standard best therapy for any randomized trials that examine high-dose chemotherapy or bone marrow transplantation for this subgroup of patients.

Radical radiotherapy for early nonsmall cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

To evaluate the results of a departmental treatment policy in a consecutive series of patients with nonsmall cell carcinoma of the lung. A second purpose was to estimate the survival of patients treated with radical intent. A third purpose was to estimate the impact of comorbidity on the selection of patients for treatment and on its outcome.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The records of 720 consecutive patients referred to a single Department of Radiation Oncology between 1979 and 1985 were reviewed. One hundred fifty patients with early stage (Stage I and II disease) were studied in detail and the results are presented for the outcome of 103 patients treated by radical radiotherapy. All patients were followed for a minimum period of five years or until death.

RESULTS

Patients referred for radiation therapy were elderly and usually had squamous cell carcinoma of the lung. Comorbidity was significant as was weight loss which occurred in a third of patients. The overall survival of patients treated with radical intent was 13%. In a small subgroup of patients with T1 tumors without weight loss and aged under 70 survival reached 50% at 5 years with no treatment-related mortality and with insignificant treatment-related morbidity.

CONCLUSION

Highly selected subsets of patients suitable for treatment with radiotherapy can be defined equally as well as highly selected subsets of patients can be selected for surgery. Treatment outcome can be surprisingly good in these subsets indicating that the treatment of nonsmall cell lung cancer, particularly in older patients without comorbidity should not automatically be by a surgical approach.

Sarcomas following radiation therapy for breast cancer: a report of three cases and a review of the literature

PURPOSE

First to describe clinical and pathologic features of sarcomas arising after radiation therapy for breast cancer and to report three cases of sarcoma arising 7, 15, and 20 years following radiation therapy for breast cancer. Second, to review the literature on this treatment complication.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Medline literature search.

RESULTS

The most frequent histology is osteosarcoma and bone is affected more commonly than soft tissue at a median latency of 11 years. The scapula is the most frequently affected bone. The most frequently affected soft tissue site is now the conserved breast with a median latency of 5.5 years. The aetiologic factors relating to these sarcomas are not fully defined with factors of beam energy, radiation dose, chemotherapy and regional edema being inconsistently reported.

CONCLUSION

The frequency of radiation-induced sarcoma at 10 years of follow-up is approximately 0.2%. This is an overestimate by an unknown factor because of the description of sarcomas arising metachromously in breast cancer patients, in nonirradiated areas.

Radiation therapy: are we getting value for money?

The aim of this study was to examine the long term cost effectiveness of radiotherapy (RT) in the treatment of cancer at the Department of Radiation Oncology, Westmead Hospital, from its inception in 1980 to December 1993. A Kaplan-Meier survival curve was constructed for all patients treated by RT during the study period. The area under this curve represented the average survival. The total number of life years was calculated by multiplying the number of patients by the average survival. Costing for one RT treatment field had previously been derived. The cost included capital costs, building costs and overheads as well as labour, goods and services, and operating costs. The cost per field was multiplied by the total number of fields given each year and the yearly total summed to give the total cost. The total cost was divided by the number of life years to give a cost per life year. An overall percentage survival gain was estimated from departmental results and the literature. Cost per life year gained (LYG) was derived by dividing the cost per life year by the percentage survival gain. Sensitivity analysis was performed with best- and worst-case survival scenarios, and high and low cost per field estimates. A total of 9868 patients were treated by radiotherapy between January 1980 and December 1993. Median follow-up was 4.2 years. Median survival was 2 years. The 5- and 10-year survival rates were 35% and 22%, respectively. The area under the survival curve (the average survival) was 4.75 years. The total number of life years of survival was thus 4.75 x 9868 = 46,873. In 1993, the cost per field was $71.52 (Australian dollars). The total number of fields treated in the study period was 758,097. Hence, the total cost in 1993 dollars was $54,219,097. The survival gain (excluding skin cancer) with RT was 16.1% and the cost/LYG was $7186. Sensitivity analysis of best and worst case scenarios gave costs/LYG of $3920 and $15,632 respectively. Efficient resource allocation can be aided by examining the relative cost-effectiveness of different prevention and treatment strategies. RT is shown to have a lower cost/LYG than other accepted treatments in current practice. Other major treatment modalities should be subjected to the same scrutiny of cost effectiveness as has been applied to RT.

Delayed cerebral radiation necrosis

The clinical features and long-term outcome of seven patients with delayed cerebral radiation necrosis (DCRN) are described. Radiotherapy had been given for pituitary tumour (1), astrocytoma (2), pinealoma (2), craniopharyngioma (1) and parotid carcinoma (1). The mean latency to onset of the first neurological symptoms was 22 months (range 6-40 months), and mean duration of follow-up was 86 months (range 60-126). Three patients died at a mean of 84 months after radiotherapy (range 62-98). A fourth patient probably died from metastatic disease. Three patients remain alive, albeit severely disabled, after 5-10 years. The illness typically ran a stepwise course, with fits and stroke-like episodes occurring against a background of progressive dementia and somnolence. CT and MRI scans showed progressive ventricular dilatation associated with cerebral atrophy and diffuse or focal changes in the white matter. Four patients had had two or more neurosurgical procedures after the radiotherapy. In only one of the seven patients was the diagnosis made at presentation. DCRN produces a distinctive clinical picture, yet remains a poorly recognized complication of cranial irradiation.

Multiple primary tumours in patients treated with radiotherapy for breast cancer

Between January 1954 and March 1964, 3926 patients with primary breast cancer were referred to The Department of Clinical Oncology, Edinburgh. One hundred and eighty patients developed 195 malignancies subsequent to the treatment of their initial breast cancer. Overall, the total number of second tumours was not significantly in excess of the expected incidence in the general population. However, statistical analysis revealed a significant increase in the incidence of rectal, skin and bone tumours. The excess of bone tumours was likely due to radiation exposure. There was not an overall excess of tumours within the irradiated or scattered radiation volume.

Undergraduate education about cancer. A survey of clinical oncologists and clinicians responsible for cancer teaching in Australian medical schools

Undergraduate cancer education in Australian medical schools is not integrated and there is little evidence of change in content or structure in recent years in spite of major changes in knowledge about cancer epidemiology and cancer biology, and in cancer management. A recent survey of graduating students/interns from all Australian medical schools revealed a disturbing variability in experience and lack of important knowledge. There was evidence of substantial differences in knowledge of, and rating of teaching between the different disciplines involved in cancer control and cancer management. To examine possible reasons for this, we surveyed cancer clinicians and teachers of oncology in the undergraduate curriculum at Australian medical schools. We asked them the same questions of knowledge as the students, and also to comment on the type and emphasis of teaching desirable in the medical students' cancer curriculum. The results indicate not only that the survey instrument was seen to be relevant, but also that some of the bias and misinformation detected in the student experiences may be attributed to attitude, knowledge and differences of opinion of the teachers. The results highlight the need for an integrated cancer curriculum to inform graduates about an illness which will be diagnosed in more than a quarter of the Australian population.

Delayed radiation necrosis of the central nervous system in patients irradiated for pituitary tumours

Four cases of delayed radiation necrosis involving the CNS were found in a group of 46 patients irradiated for pituitary tumours over a six year period. This occurred in three of 11 patients with Cushing's disease representing an incidence of 27% in this group. There were no cases among 11 patients with acromegaly or among seven with prolactinomas. One case (6%) was found in the 17 patients with chromophobe adenomas. Standard doses of radiation were delivered to these patients and the findings support suggestions that the metabolic disturbances of Cushing's disease may reduce tolerance to radiation. Our results and a literature review indicate that if radiotherapy is used to treat Cushing's disease, the total dose should be less than 50 Gy at 2 Gy per day fractionation.

Intravenous or oral adjuvant CMF for node-positive breast cancer

To assess the optimal duration and method of administration of adjuvant cyclophosphamide, methotrexate and 5-fluorouracil (CMF) chemotherapy, 116 patients with positive axillary nodes after total mastectomy and axillary dissection were reviewed retrospectively. CMF was administered in three progressively shorter regimens, which consisted of oral CMF for either 12 or six cycles and intravenous (i.v.) CMF for six cycles. Median follow-up for surviving patients was 62 months. The three groups were matched for major prognostic factors. There was no advantage in using more than six cycles of adjuvant CMF. There was an improved crude 3 year disease-free survival (84 vs 65%, P = 0.05) and a trend towards improved overall survival (92 vs 85%, P = NS) in patients treated with six cycles of oral CMF compared with i.v. CMF. Survival rates were not significantly different beyond 3 years. Leucopenia and alopecia were more severe with oral CMF (P less than 0.01), and compliance worse with oral CMF x 12 (P = 0.01). Since the data suggest that i.v. CMF is at least as equal as oral CMF a randomized controlled trial should be undertaken.

Breast cancer: the role of radiation therapy after treatment by conservative surgery

The role of conservative surgery (CS) as definitive treatment of invasive breast cancer has not been established. Previous studies have demonstrated high rates of local tumour recurrence if CS is not followed by radiotherapy (RT). At present, it is impossible to identify subsets of patients who may be at acceptably low risk of recurrence after CS. The treatment of breast cancer by CS alone remains an important research question as this may avoid over-treatment by radiation for some patients. In Australia, a trial has been proposed by the ANZ Breast Cancer Trials Group, comparing CS alone to CS+RT. This paper reviews all available data on CS alone in order to stimulate debate as to the appropriateness of the trial and its end-points. Given that all prospective randomized trials have failed to show a survival disadvantage for CS alone it is essential to consider the value of all outcomes after CS or CS+RT. The conventional end-points proposed in the Australian study (mastectomy rate, disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS)) are selective. Without the addition of quality of life measures, the utilities of the strategies addressed in the trial cannot be evaluated. Data are presented on the desirability (utility) of the alternative approaches of CS or CS+RT based on data obtained from a questionnaire completed by Westmead Hospital staff. This preliminary study indicates that the majority of respondents to the questionnaire perceived that the strategy of CS+RT to have a higher utility than the strategy of CS alone.

The cost of treating small cell lung cancer

OBJECTIVE

To determine the cost of treating small cell lung cancer (SCLC) and to assess quality-adjusted survival in these patients.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis.

SETTING

Westmead Hospital, a tertiary referral institution.

PATIENTS

Consecutive sample of 31 patients with histologically proved SCLC, treated between January 1987 and December 1987.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The cost of investigation, hospitalisation, chemotherapy, radiotherapy and follow-up of patients overall and for those with limited and extensive disease respectively. Quality-adjusted survival was based on a Q-TWiST analysis.

RESULTS

The median overall cost per patient was $14,413 (range, $1188-$39,598) for all patients and for limited disease and extensive disease was $18,234 (range, $1914-$39,598) and $13,177 (range, $1188-$32,798) respectively. The two major costs were hospitalisation (42%) and chemotherapy (18%). Radiotherapy accounted for 11% of all costs. The Q-TWiST analysis suggests that for patients with limited disease, quality-adjusted survival is similar to absolute survival.

CONCLUSIONS

The treatment of SCLC at our institution was expensive but the cost may be reduced by reduction in the duration of hospitalisation, the use of less expensive combination drug regimens, or the use of "true" outpatient chemotherapy. Despite intensive therapy, patients with limited disease maintained a reasonable quality of life.

Breast conservation: long-term Australian data

Long-term data on the management of early breast cancer in Australia by conservative surgery and radiation therapy is limited. To examine this issue we reviewed our experience of 131 patients with Stage I or II breast cancer treated between November 1979 and December 1985. Ninety patients had a T1 tumor and 41 a T2 tumor. The extent of surgery varied from a local excision (LE), a wide local excision, to a quadrantectomy or partial mastectomy. Sixty-two per cent of patients also had an axillary dissection. One hundred and nineteen patients were treated using 6Mev photons to the whole breast (Median dose; 50 Gy) +/- regional nodes followed by a single plane Iridium-192 boost to the primary tumor site (median dose; 30 Gy). Ten patients did not receive a boost and two elderly patients were treated with an implant only. The median follow-up of surviving patients was 83 months (range, 51-133 months). Six other patients were lost to follow-up at a median of 48 months (range, 4-62). The pattern of first relapse is: breast alone, 7.0%; breast + distant, 0.75%; breast + nodes, 0.75%; regional nodes only, 0.75%; and distant disease, 18%. The extent of surgery did not influence the probability of a recurrence in the primary tumor region. The time to a breast recurrence ranged from 12 to 127 months (median, 61 months). The 5-year actuarial rate of a breast recurrence was 4.5%. The 5-year freedom from distant relapse was 80%. The complications of treatment were acceptable. These included rib fracture (5%), symptomatic pneumonitis (4%), fat necrosis or fibrosis requiring surgery (4.5%), severe arm edema (4.5%). The treatment of the axilla by both surgery plus radiation therapy was associated with a moderate or severe arm edema rate of 29% compared to 8% for surgery alone and 6% for radiation therapy alone. Our long-term data indicate that conservative surgery plus radiation therapy is associated with low rates of breast cancer recurrence which are independent of the extent of surgical resection. Complications were acceptably low provided that the axilla was treated by surgery or radiation therapy but not by both modalities.

Single institutional experience with non-seminomatous germ cell tumours of the testis: local perspectives on a curable cancer

We have reviewed 77 patients with Non-seminomatous germ cell tumour of the testis (NSGCTT) treated at a single institution. A residual mass following definitive treatment occurred in 16 patients (35%), 13 of whom had a resection of the mass, yielding active tumour in only one patient. Nine patients (12%) relapsed including four of the 14 with Stage I disease who were treated by orchidectomy alone. Four relapses occurred at more than two and a half years after primary treatment. Relapse prior to the development of clinical symptoms or signs was evident in three of nine patients; in two patients by routine imaging and one with elevated routine serum markers. Three of the nine patients who relapsed had elevated serum markers. Two patients died from disease but there were four treatment-related deaths (7%). Overall, 64 patients (83%) remain disease free at the time of follow-up. A further seven (9%) have been lost to follow-up but were disease-free at a minimum of 26 months after diagnosis. This study confirms features of this disease including the excellent prognosis when adequately treated. However, it also reveals the problems of late or marker negative relapses, the implementation of an observation policy in Stage I disease and treatment related mortality in young men.

Undergraduate education about cancer

The quality, quantity and balance of undergraduate cancer teaching in Australian Medical Schools were investigated by a survey, using a self-administered questionnaire, of recent graduates from all Australian medical schools. Stratified random cluster sampling was used and a response rate of 84% (389 respondents) was achieved. The results revealed substantial differences in knowledge, experience in, and rating of teaching between the medical, surgical, radiotherapeutic and palliative components of cancer management. The proportions of graduates who had never attended radiotherapy and palliative care clinics or units (42.3% and 49.9%, respectively) were more than double the proportion who had never attended medical and surgical cancer clinics or units (17.5% and 10.9%, respectively). More than twice as many graduates rated their instruction in the palliative management of cancer as poor or very poor (29.4%) compared with those rating their instruction as poor or very poor in both cancer prevention (8.4%) and treatment for cure (14.6%). The respondents displayed a considerable lack of knowledge about radiotherapy treatment options, and reported a lack of perceived competence in doing cervical smears. Their answers to questions about 5-year survival of selected cancers, about the existence of screening tests validly shown to reduce mortality, and the ages at which breast and cervical cancers are likely to develop all revealed worrying levels of incorrect knowledge. There was some important disturbing variation in levels of knowledge, experience and rating of cancer instruction between states and between universities.

The role of bipedal lymphangiography in testicular seminoma

Determining the extent of intra-abdominal spread of testicular seminoma by radiographic studies is an essential step in planning rational treatment following orchidectomy. CT scanning is generally accepted as being superior to lymphangiography in assessing the retroperitoneal space. We reviewed the relative contribution of these two procedures in a retrospective analysis of 73 consecutive patients with testicular seminoma managed at Westmead Hospital between January 1980 and September 1987. Abdominal CT scans and bipedal lymphangiography (LAG) were carried out in 72 and 51 patients respectively, 50 patients undergoing both procedures. We found concordance between the two techniques to be 88%. Upstaging occurred in 5 patients using CT (10%), 7 patients using LAG (14%), and in 8 patients (16%) when both tests were utilised. Four patients were upstaged by both techniques while the remaining 4 patients were upstaged using one technique alone. Serum beta-HCG was not a reliable screen for residual disease. Residual disease in the few patients with an elevated serum beta-HCG was easily detected by CT scanning. We conclude that there is a continuing role for LAG in assessing patients with clinical Stage I seminoma when the abdominal CT scan is equivocal or normal.

The American 'Patterns of Care' Study: a model for the assessment of the quality of patient care in radiation oncology

There are well documented manpower and equipment deficiencies in the specialty of Radiation Oncology in Australia. These deficiencies persist despite numerous reports over the last decade detailing their existence. The Patterns of Care Study (PCS) from the United States of America (USA) is a unique, comprehensive review of Radiation Oncology services in that country. It has clearly demonstrated that substantial benefits not only in survival but also in reduced treatment morbidity accrue when a full range of modern techniques and equipment is used. The present paper is a review of the PCS: this study has immense implications for patient care in particular and cancer services in general, in Australia. There seems little point in continuing to fund cancer research in the hope of gains in survival rates while continuing to ignore the fact that gains of a similar magnitude can be obtained by the maximum use of current knowledge and the provision of modern equipment.

Pulmonary blastoma

Pulmonary blastoma (PB) is the least common malignant pulmonary neoplasm, with less than 100 reported cases. This tumour occurs up to three times more commonly in males. There exists an age peak in the third and fourth decades, although approximately one quarter of cases occur in children, often in association with congenital lung disease. Although the clinical features of PB are not specific, the histopathological appearance is distinctive, showing an admixture of both epithelial and mesenchymal (sarcomatous) elements. Historically, surgery has been the most commonly used modality for localized disease: however, useful data on local control rates are lacking. Extrathoracic metastases are the major cause of treatment failure in PB, with chemotherapy having little impact in this disease. The role of radiation therapy in the management of PB has not been established, however, early radioresponsiveness was demonstrated in the palliative treatment of soft tissue and bone metastases in the case presented: radiation therapy should be considered in the management of this disease.

Persisting cyclical uterine bleeding in patients treated with radical radiation therapy and hormonal replacement for carcinoma of the cervix

Radical radiation therapy used for carcinoma of the cervix will ablate ovarian function. Since January 1986, our policy has been to administer oral combination oestrogen-progesterone replacement hormonal therapy to all premenopausal patients undergoing radical radiation with or without synchronous chemotherapy, for invasive cervix cancer. Five out of 22 (23%) such patients unexpectedly experienced between one and four episodes of cyclical per vaginal bleeding after the completion of radiation therapy. Bleeding episodes occurred in the absence of persistent tumor or radiation reaction, and suggest persisting endometrial response to exogenous hormonal stimulation. Uterine activity was temporarily retained in these five patients despite a minimal endometrial surface dose of between 4800 and 6490 cGy. The limited number of cycles before bleeding spontaneously ceased may represent the slow death of endometrial cells subsequent to radiation or radiochemotherapy treatment, and has not previously been described. In view of the paucity of data on the radiosensitivity of normal endometrium, we have carefully examined these patients who appear to have retained endometrial sensitivity to hormonal stimuli after radical radiation-chemotherapy for uterine cervix cancer.

Treatment of hepatic cavernous haemangioma with radiation therapy: case report and literature review

Cavernous haemangiomas are the most common benign tumours of the liver, most of which are found incidentally during abdominal imaging, laparotomy or autopsy. A patient with a large, symptomatic lesion, which responded well to radiation therapy, is described. In view of the fact that a large proportion of these vascular malformations are unresectable and response to radiation therapy is well documented, the latter modality should be considered for symptomatic lesions.

The misuse of mammography in the management of breast cancer revisited

A second study of the use of mammography as a diagnostic procedure in women with breast symptoms is reported. In a two-year period during which 468 patients with a new diagnosis of breast cancer were seen, 238 women had undergone mammography before referral to the Department of Radiation Oncology, Westmead Hospital. For 73 (30.7%) patients the mammographic report was falsely negative. Among those 73 patients with a falsely negative mammographic report, 40 women experienced a mean treatment delay of 12.7 months (range, three to 60 months). A negative mammographic result was significantly (P less than 0.001) more likely to be obtained in younger women. When the women with an initially negative mammographic result represented, they did so with disease of a more advanced stage. This, we contend, is related to the delay in their definitive treatment as caused by the first falsely negative mammographic report. Theoretical calculations are presented; under varying conditions of sensitivity and specificity, these show that, even with the addition of specialist opinion, significant proportions of patients with breast cancer will have a mammographic result which is falsely reassuring. The identification of these subsets depends on histological or cytological examination of the tumour. This is a decision that best is made, in our opinion, by a specialist in breast-cancer management.

The management of oesophageal carcinoma: radiotherapy or surgery? Cost considerations

A cost comparison has been made between two treatment modalities used with curative intent for carcinoma of the oesophagus, for 144 patients seen between December 1979 and December 1985. Forty-two patients were selected for radical oesophagectomy. In this paper these are compared with 50 patients who underwent radical radiotherapy. The median survival of both groups was identical (12 months). The remaining 52 patients underwent a variety of palliative procedures and are not considered further. Components of management were identified and costed on the basis of direct resource use by the hospital. Surgically treated patients on average cost $A13,638 in 1987 dollars, whereas those treated by radiotherapy cost $A3533. The major factors accounting for this cost difference were the necessary perioperative intensive management in the surgical group, the inevitable perioperative complications and the subsequent prolonged hospitalization of a proportion of patients. The cost of the management of the complications of radiation therapy are included but were not a major factor in overall costs for the irradiated group. This cost differential must influence the continuation of current strategies in which radical surgery, rather than irradiation, is the selected routine curative approach for oesophageal cancer particularly in the absence of evidence of higher survival.

On the yield of new information from the selective requesting of post mortem examinations in oncology patients

Traditionally, a high rate of post mortem (PM) examinations has been advocated, primarily for the quality control of clinical diagnosis. In days of increasing scrutiny of medical costs, the role of the 'routine' requesting of any investigation must be questioned, and we report here the results of a policy to request post mortem examinations selectively when there was a reasonable expectation that it would yield new information. Between 21/3/82 and 12/2/86 there were 1356 deaths in patients registered with the Department of Radiation Oncology, Westmead Hospital. During this period, 100 PM examinations were performed. The overall post mortem rate is thus 6.7%, but for patients dying whilst under our direct care it is 23%. The cause of death was changed in 9% of cases following PM examination. The ante mortem assessment of the remission status of irradiated volumes was confirmed in 69% but was not recorded in the post mortem report in 22%, in spite of the medical record being available to the pathologist. Minor modifications were made by PM examination to the establishment of primary tumor site, sites of metastatic disease, histological diagnosis and other significant pathological states. The autopsy is an expensive investigation: we conclude that the low yield of relevant new information in this selective series is a powerful argument against the traditional routine request. Indeed the yield of new information in cases when the histological tumour type was known was even lower. The necessity for a problem-orientated approach is apparent from the data on the remission status of treated sites.

Synchronous 5-fluorouracil, mitomycin-C and radiation therapy in the treatment of locally advanced carcinoma of the cervix

Locally advanced carcinoma of the cervix has a poor prognosis with a high incidence of persistent or recurrent local disease contributing to distressing symptoms and poor survival. This has remained unaltered over the past 30 years in spite of the addition of other therapeutic modalities. Between 1983 and January 1986, 38 patients with locally advanced carcinoma of the cervix were treated with synchronous 5-fluorouracil, mitomycin-C, and radiotherapy. The results of this pilot study indicate both an improvement in pelvic control and in 3-year survival rate for the chemosensitized therapy compared to conventional radiotherapy alone (55% v 28%) using historical controls. Improved survival was only significant for bulky FIGO Stage IIb tumors. The toxicity of this combination was predominantly gastro-intestinal and led to modification of both radiation dose and technique with subsequent improvement in the incidence of side effects. The results suggest that the combination of synchronous chemotherapy with radiotherapy is an improved method of treatment for locally advanced carcinoma of the cervix and that a prospective randomized trial is now justified.

Fat necrosis of the breast following lumpectomy and radiation therapy for early breast cancer

Between January 1980 and December 1985, 121 patients with early breast cancer were treated in the Department of Radiation Oncology at Westmead Hospital by external beam irradiation and an iridium wire boost following "lumpectomy". After a median follow-up of 26 months, 14 patients have developed recurrent masses in the treated breast. In four, recurrent carcinoma was strongly suspected and subsequently confirmed by fine needle aspiration biopsy, but in only two was a subsequent salvage mastectomy possible. The remaining 10 patients developed a nodule which was usually tender. With three exceptions, the nodule was at the primary tumour site and developed 4-43 months after treatment. In seven, tumour recurrence was suspected but not confirmed by biopsy and the other three were accepted as having post-treatment "radiation fibrosis". Excision biopsy was undertaken in eight of the 10 patients. Another patient underwent partial mastectomy for presumed local recurrence. The histological appearance in all cases was similar, with areas of fat necrosis and fibrosis with atypical stromal fibroblasts. Suture material was present microscopically in eight patients and was noted macroscopically (that is, by mammogram) in the one patient who did not undergo surgery. This complication is most likely caused by a combination of surgical and radiation factors. The difficulty in management is differentiation between tumour recurrence and a benign condition.