The validity of Engagement and Feedback Assessments (EFAs): identifying students at risk of failing

BACKGROUND

Imperial College School of Medicine, London UK, introduced a new curriculum in 2019, with a focus on the GMC outcomes for graduates, and pedagogy best practice. The new curriculum included formative assessments, named engagement and feedback assessments (EFAs), to support learning, and attainment in the summative examinations. The aims of this study were to assess the validity of EFAs and to determine whether they have utility as a modified form of programmatic assessment to inform decision-making regarding possible interventions by measuring and analysing attendance at and performance in these formative events.

METHODS

Seven hundred and sixty-one students were included in the study and assessment results were included for academic years 2019/20 to 2020/21. Forty-one data points per student, (27 in Year 1 and 14 in Year 2) were used, to compare EFA scores with the summative performance. Attendance was monitored through engagement with the EFAs.

RESULTS

Cohort 1 (enrolled 2019): In year 1, EFAs were associated with summative exam scores (overall r = 0.63, p < 0.001). Year 2, EFA scores were also associated with summative scores (overall r = 0.57, p < 0.001), including the clinical practical assessment (r = 0.45, p < 0.001). Missing two or more EFAs was associated with a significant increase in the likelihood of failing one or more summative examinations in the first year (OR: 7.97, 95% CI 2.65-34.39) and second year (OR: 3.20, 95% CI 1.74-5.95). Missing more than two EFAs in their first year was also associated with a higher risk of failing a summative examination in the second year (OR: 2.47, 95% CI 1.33-4.71). Students who increased their attendance between year 1 and 2 fared better in summative assessment than those who maintained poor attendance, whereas those that reduced their attendance fared worse than those that maintained high attendance. Cohort 2 (enrolled 2020): Analysis of cohort 2 supported these findings and in this cohort missing two or more EFAs was again associated with an increased likelihood of failing a summative examination (OR = 4.00, 95% CI = 2.02-7.90).

CONCLUSION

Our EFA model has validity in predicting performance in summative assessments and can inform prospective interventions to support students' learning. Enhancing attendance and engagement can improve outcomes.

735 An Unusual Case of Cervical Potts Disease in A Pediatric Patient

Pott’s disease is a form of extrapulmonary tuberculosis (TB) affecting the spine. Approximately 10% of individuals with extrapulmonary TB will have skeletal manifestations with the most common area affected being the spine, followed by the hip and knee. Within the spine, Pott’s disease has a predilection for affecting the thoraco-lumbar region, with the cervical spine being the least affected. Here, we report a case of cervical Pott’s disease in a 16-year-old child, with no risk factors for TB, presenting with neck pain and stiffness. Initial blood results were unremarkable, but a CT scan showed a C5 vertebral body fracture and mild canal stenosis. A sagittal MRI scan demonstrated canal stenosis and a pathologic compression fracture of the C5 vertebrae, a soft tissue mass extending into the epidural and prevertebral spaces and associated cervical cord compression. A trans-oral biopsy confirmed TB and a diagnosis of Pott’s disease. She underwent HALO placement and needed further fusion surgery. She was started on anti-tuberculous therapy and made a good recovery post-operatively.

Transition for patients with congenital heart disease in the UK: need for a universal model with adequate training and support

Background

Adolescence is a vulnerable period for patients with congenital heart disease (CHD). Transition is a process that guides these patients through adolescence and ensures a smooth transfer to adult services, in order improve adherence to medical care and reduce loss to follow-up. While the importance of a formal Transition process is widely recognised and a requirement for specialist services in the UK, the optimal structure and delivery of Transition remains a matter of debate.

Aims

To examine the different models of Transition currently in place in specialist CHD centres around the UK.

Methods

A survey of Adult CHD centres in the UK was performed. A focus was placed on the structure of the Transition service, relevant training and areas of perceived improvement.

Results

There were 10 responses to our survey covering 10 specialist CHD centres. All respondents were consultant adult CHD specialists, looking after patients from the age of 16 [14–17] years. All centres have a specialised Transition service, which runs from the age 13 [11–15] to 18 [16–25] years (duration of transition 5 [2–13] years). The majority of centres (80%) report providing transition care “well before” transfer to adult care, whereas 20% provide transition care at or immediately before transfer (i.e. first adult CHD appointment). Transition is delivered by physicians and clinical specialist nurses in approximately equal numbers in 9 (90%) centres and exclusively by clinical nurse specialists in 1 (10%) centre. A median of 2 [1–5] visits are planned for each patient, with 7 (70%) centres seeing patients at least twice during transition. The majority, but not all centres (70%) provide a health passport during transition. A significant number of centres felt they werer not receiving sufficient support in the following domains: financial (50%), training (30%), clinical space (30%), referrals from paediatrics (50%). All respondents felt that their Transition service had room for improvement. Other areas of improvement highlighted included reduction in loss to follow-up, difficulties in providing a Transition service to patients followed in peripheral hospitals, the need for more support from paediatric services in referring all appropriate patients, and dedicated administrative support. The vast majority of respondents (9, 90%) felt equipped with the appropriate skills to care for transition patients. However, few (2, 20%) had completed formal training in more than one area related to adolescent health and transition.

Conclusions

While all CHD centres have a Transition service, Transition models and delivery differs significantly. There is urgent need for research in this area to develop a unified model, greater financial support and relevant training to optimise care.

Figure 1. Participating UK centres

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding source: None

Outcome of ACHD patients with non-inducible versus inducible IART undergoing cavo-tricuspid isthmus ablation: the role of empiric ablation

PURPOSE

Catheter ablation for supraventricular tachycardia (SVT) in adults with congenital heart disease (ACHD) is an important therapeutic option. Cavo-tricuspid isthmus (CTI)-dependent intraatrial re-entrant tachycardia (IART) is common. However, induction of sustained tachycardia at the time of ablation is not always possible. We hypothesised that performing an empiric CTI line in case of non-inducibility leads to good outcomes. Long-term outcomes of empiric versus entrained CTI ablation in ACHD patients were examined.

METHODS

Retrospective, single-centre, case-control study over 7 years. Arrhythmia-free survival after empiric versus entrained CTI ablation was compared.

RESULTS

Eighty-seven CTI ablations were performed in 85 ACHD patients between 2010 and 2017. The mean age of the cohort was 43 years and 48% were male. Underlying aetiology included ASD (31%), VSD (11.4%), AVSD (9.1%), AVR (4.8%), Fallot's (18.4%), Ebstein's (2.3%), Fontan's palliation (9.2%) and atrial switch (13.8%). CTI-dependent IART was entrained in 59 patients whereas it was non-inducible in 28. The latter had an empiric CTI ablation. Forty-three percent of procedures were performed under general anaesthesia. There were no reported procedural complications. There was no significant difference in the mean procedure or fluoroscopy times between the groups (empiric vs entrained CTI; 169.1 vs 183.3 and 28.1 vs 19.9 min). Arrhythmia-free survival was 64.3% versus 72.8% (p value 0.44) in the empiric and entrained groups at 21 months follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term outcomes after empiric and entrained CTI ablation for IART in ACHD patients are comparable. This is a safe and effective therapeutic option. In the case of non-inducibility of IART, an empiric CTI line should be considered in this cohort.

Characteristics of the positive ion source at reduced gas feed

The neutral beam injector of steady state superconducting tokamak (SST1-NBI) at IPR is designed for injecting upto 1.7 MW of neutral beam (Hº, 30-55 keV) power to the tokamak plasma for heating and current drive. Operations of the positive ion source (PINI or Plug-In-Neutral-Injector) of SST1-NBI were carried out on the NBI test stand. The PINI was operated at reduced gas feed rate of 2-3 Torr l/s, without using the high speed cryo pumps. Experiments were conducted to achieve a stable beam extraction by optimizing operational parameters namely, the arc current (120-300 A), acceleration voltage (16-40 kV), and a suitable control sequence. The beam divergence, power density profiles, and species fractions (H(+):H2(+):H3(+)) were measured by using the diagnostics such as thermal calorimetry, infrared thermography, and Doppler shift spectroscopy. The maximum extracted beam current was about 18 A. A further increase of beam current was found to be limited by the amount of gas feed rate to the ion source.

The four-variable modification of diet in renal disease formula underestimates glomerular filtration rate in obese type 2 diabetic individuals with chronic kidney disease

AIMS/HYPOTHESIS

GFR is commonly estimated using the four-variable Modification of Diet in Renal Disease (MDRD) formula and this forms the basis for classification of chronic kidney disease (CKD). We investigated the effect of obesity on the estimation of glomerular filtration rate in type 2 diabetic participants with CKD.

METHODS

We enrolled 111 patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus in different stages of CKD. GFR was measured using (51)Cr-labelled EDTA plasma clearance and was estimated using the four-variable MDRD formula.

RESULTS

The bias between estimated and measured GFR was -22.4 (-33.8 to -11.0) p < 0.001 in the obese group compared with -6.04 (-17.6 to -5.5) p = 0.299 in the non-obese group. When GFR was indexed to body surface area of 1.73 m(2), the bias remained significant at -9.4 (-13.4 to -5.4) p < 0.001 in the obese participants.

CONCLUSIONS/INTERPRETATION

This study suggests that the four-variable MDRD formula significantly underestimates GFR in obese type 2 diabetic participants with CKD.

Retroperitoneal Castleman's disease mimicking soft tissue tumour

Castleman's disease is a type of non-neoplastic lymphoproliferative disease having lymph nodal hyperplasia. It has two distinct microscopic types: hyaline-vascular type and plasma cell type. Clinically, it may present either as a solitary mass, most commonly in the mediastinum, or as a multicentric form whose features are generalized lymph-adenopathy, splenomegaly and involvement of other organs like the lungs and kidneys. Here we report a case of isolated retroperitoneal Castleman's disease, which presented as a lump in the iliac fossa in a young female. A clinico-radio-logical diagnosis of retroperitoneal soft tissue tumour was made and the patient underwent complete surgical excision. The exact diagnosis was only obtained at histopathology and there is no evidence of recurrence at six months follow-up.