Using musculoskeletal modelling to estimate knee joint loading pre and post high tibial osteotomy

BACKGROUND

Both medial knee osteoarthritis and associated varus alignment have been proposed to alter knee joint loading and consequently overloading the medial compartment. Individuals with knee osteoarthritis and varus deformity are candidates for coronal plane corrective surgery, high tibial osteotomy. This study evaluated knee loading and contact location for a control group, a pre-surgery cohort and the same cohort 12 months post-surgery using a musculoskeletal modelling approach.

METHODS

Joint kinematics during gait were measured in 30 knee osteoarthritis patients, before and after high tibial osteotomy, and 28 healthy adults. Using a musculoskeletal model that incorporated patient-specific mechanical tibial femoral angle, the resulting muscle, ligament, and contact forces were calculated and the medial - lateral condyle load distribution was analysed.

FINDINGS

Surgery changed medial compartment contact force throughout stance relative to pre-surgery. This reduction in medial compartment contact force pre- vs post-HTO is observed despite a significant increase in post-surgery walking speed compared to pre-HTO, where increased speed is typically associated with increased joint loading.

INTERPRETATION

This study has estimated the effects of high tibial osteotomy on knee loading using a generic model that incorporates a detailed knee model to better understand tibiofemoral contact loading. The findings support the aim of surgery to unload the medial knee compartment and lateralise joint contact forces.

The relationship between alignment, function and loading in total knee replacement: In-vivo analysis of a unique patient population

The purpose of this study was to quantify the effect of total knee replacement (TKR) alignment on in-vivo knee function and loading in a unique patient cohort who have been identified as having a high rate of component mal-alignment. Post-TKR (82.4 ± 6.7 months), gait analysis was performed on 25 patients (27 knees), to calculate knee kinematics and kinetics. For a step activity, video fluoroscopic analysis quantified in-vivo implant kinematics. Frontal plane lower-limb alignment was defined by the Hip-Knee-Ankle angle (HKA) measured on long leg static X-rays. Transverse plane component rotation was calculated from computed tomography scans. Sagittal plane alignment was defined by measuring the flexion angle of the femoral component and the posterior tibial slope angle (PTSA). For gait analysis, a more varus HKA correlated with increased peak and dynamic joint kinetics, predicting 47.6% of Knee Adduction Angular Impulse variance. For the step activity, during step-up and single leg loaded, higher PTSA correlated with a posterior shift in medial compartment Anterior-Posterior (AP) translation. During step-down, higher PTSA correlated with reduced lateral compartment AP translation with a posterior shift in AP translation in both compartments. A more varus HKA correlated with a more posterior medial AP translation and inter-component rotation was related to transverse plan range of motion. This in-vivo study found that frontal plane lower-limb alignment had a significant effect on joint forces during gait but had minimal influence on in-vivo implant kinematics for step activity. PTSA was found to influence in-vivo TKR translations and is therefore an important surgical factor.

Does Gait Retraining Have the Potential to Reduce Medial Compartmental Loading in Individuals With Knee Osteoarthritis While Not Adversely Affecting the Other Lower Limb Joints? A Systematic Review

Objectives

To review the literature regarding gait retraining to reduce knee adduction moments and their effects on hip and ankle biomechanics.

Data Sources

Twelve academic databases were searched from inception to January 2019. Key words “walk*” OR “gait,” “knee” OR “adduction moment,” “osteoarthriti*” OR “arthriti*” OR “osteo arthriti*” OR “OA,” and “hip” OR “ankle” were combined with conjunction “and” in all fields.

Study Selection

Abstracts and full-text articles were assessed by 2 individuals against a predefined criterion.

Data Synthesis

Of the 11 studies, sample sizes varied from 8-40 participants. Eight different gait retraining styles were evaluated: hip internal rotation, lateral trunk lean, toe-in, toe-out, increased step width, medial thrust, contralateral pelvic drop, and medial foot weight transfer. Using the Black and Downs tool, the methodological quality of the included studies was fair to moderate ranging between 12 of 25 to 18 of 28. Trunk lean and medial thrust produced the biggest reductions in first peak knee adduction moment. Studies lacked collective sagittal and frontal plane hip and ankle joint biomechanics. Generally, studies had a low sample size of healthy participants with no osteoarthritis and assessed gait retraining during 1 laboratory visit while not documenting the difficulty of the gait retraining style.

Conclusions

Gait retraining techniques may reduce knee joint loading; however, the biomechanical effects to the pelvis, hip, and ankle is unknown, and there is a lack of understanding for the ease of application of the gait retraining styles.

Impact of rear wheel axle position on upper limb kinematics and electromyography during manual wheelchair use

Manual wheelchair propulsion is an important form of mobility for people with lower limb disabilities. Changes in the wheelchair configuration can affect, range of motion (ROM) of the upper limb joints, muscle actions and system stability. The purpose of this study is to investigate the impact of adjusting wheelchair configurations on upper body joints kinematics and muscle recruitment for able-bodied non experienced manual wheelchair users through applying a marker-based 3D motion analysis technique. Ten healthy male subjects were characterised for three wheelchair configurations, set by adjusting the horizontal axle position of both rear wheels by (3 cm) and (6 cm) posteriorly from the original position set by the manufacturer. Selected 3D kinematic and surface electromyography (sEMG) parameters of the upper body joints and shoulder muscles were measured in the Cardiff University Motion Analysis Laboratory. During the propulsion trials, trunk flexion/extension, lateral bending and axial rotation were evaluated within the average range of (7.50°±1.4°), (5.91°±1.23°) and (7.01°±3.91°), respectively. Dominant shoulder abduction/adduction, flexion/extension and internal/external rotation were evaluated within the average range of (24.63°±6.38°), (17.31°±4.27°) and (40.02°±12.35°), respectively. Dominant elbow pronation/supination and flexion/extension were evaluated within the range of (15.49°±7.70°) and (34.37°±8.38°), respectively. Dominant wrist radial/ulnar deviation and flexion/ extension were evaluated within the average range of (29.82°±8.97°) and (53.59°±9.65°), respectively. With normalising the muscle EMG to the percentage of MVC activity, posterior deltoid had the highest average EMG muscle activity (11.43 ± 5.33) during the propulsion trials and at the three wheel adjustments relative to the other dominant shoulder muscles. Other average muscles activities were evaluated as (6.99 ± 2.37) for upper trapezius, (6.89 ± 2.51) for triceps brachii, (5.39 ± 2.95) for anterior deltoid, (3.26 ± 1.00) for biceps brachii and (3.14 ± 1.26) for pectoralis major as the lowest average activity. The findings of this study indicate that changing rear wheel axle position posteriorly is correlated with increasing the kinematic ROMs of the trunk and dominant upper limb and the sEMG activities of the muscles predominantly involved with the recovery phase of propulsion which could be linked with higher risks of musculoskeletal disorders. This knowledge may help professionals when designing and prescribing wheelchairs that are more proper to users’ functional characteristics, accordingly profiting them improved quality of life.

Combined effect of toe out gait and high tibial osteotomy on knee adduction moment in patients with varus knee deformity

BACKGROUND

Gait adaptations, including toe out gait, have been proposed as treatments for knee osteoarthritis. The clinical application of toe out gait, however, is unclear. This study aims to identify the changes in Knee adduction moment in varus knee deformity assessing toe out gait as an alternative to high tibial osteotomy, and if any change in dynamic loading persists post operatively, when anatomical alignment is restored.

METHODS

Three-dimensional motion analysis was performed on 17 patients with medial compartment knee osteoarthritis and varus deformity prior to undergoing high tibial osteotomy, 13 patients were assessed post-operatively, and results compared to 13 healthy controls.

FINDINGS

Pre-operatively, there was no significant difference between natural and toe out gait for measures of knee adduction moment. Post high tibial osteotomy, first (2.70 to 1.51% BW·h) and second peak (2.28 to 1.21% BW·h) knee adduction moment were significantly reduced, as was knee adduction angular impulse (1.00 to 0.52% BW·h·s), to a healthy level. Adopting toe out gait post-operatively reduced the second peak further to a level below that of healthy controls.

INTERPRETATION

Increasing the foot progression angle from 20° (natural) to 30° in isolation did not significantly alter the knee adduction moment or angular impulse. This suggests that adopting a toe out gait, in isolation, in an already high natural foot progression angle, is not of benefit. Adopting toe out gait post-operatively, however, resulted in a further reduction in the second peak to below that of the healthy control cohort, however, this may increase lateral compartment load.

Assessing changes in subjective and objective function from pre- to post-knee arthroplasty using the Cardiff Dempster-Shafer theory classifier

The purpose of this study is to assess changes in subjective and objective function from pre- to post-knee arthroplasty (KA) using a combined classifier technique. Twenty healthy adults (50-80 years) and 31 KA patients (39-81 years) were studied (4 weeks pre- and 6 months post-KA). Questionnaire measures of subjective pain, joint stability, activity and function were collected. Objective functional assessment included goniometry, ultrasound imaging and 3-D motion analysis/inverse modelling of gait and sit-stand. An optimal set of variables were used to classify function using the Cardiff Dempster-Shafer theory (DST) method. Out of sample accuracy of the classifiers ranged between 90% and 94% for segregating healthy individuals and pre-KA patients. Post-KA subjective function improved with 74% classified as healthy. However, there was minimal improvement in objective measures (23% classified as healthy). The novel use of Cardiff DST segregated KA patients from healthy individuals and estimated changes in function from pre- to post-surgery. KA patients had improved pain and function post-operation but objective knee joint measures remained different to healthy individuals.

A novel objective classification method to discriminate and monitor recovery in subgroups of chronic low back pain

Background:

The heterogeneity of chronic low back pain (CLBP) can be deleterious to its successful management. Classification systems (CSs) that subclassify CLBP in order to target treatments rely on clinical judgement; therefore, less subjective classification is preferable. This study aims to determine whether the Cardiff Classifier (CC), which is an objective classification system based on Dempster-Shafer theory can discriminate between CLBP subgroups on the basis of spinal-pelvic repositioning errors (RE), and establish the most sensitive parameters for discriminating subgroups of CLBP and predicting recovery.

Methods:

Baseline and post-motor learning intervention (MLI) REs from 87 CLBP individuals with flexion (FP, n=50); passive extension (PEP, n=14); and active extension (AEP, n=23) pattern disorder (subclassified by a clinical multi-dimensional CS); and REs from 31 healthy (H) participants were recorded. These REs were inputted into the CC to provide objective and visual indicators of CLBP subgroups and MLI effect. REs were transformed into a set of three belief values: healthy (H); CLBP; and uncertainty. Each participant's status was visually represented as a single point in a simplex plot. Participants on the left of the central line were considered healthy and those on the right of it were considered to have CLBP characteristics.

Results:

The CC's accuracy in discriminating between: FP and H was 85.2%; AEP and H was 96.3%; and PEP and H was 100%. Combining all CLBP reduced the CC's accuracy to 68.6%. The most distinguishing parameter for FP was sitting lumbar RE, and for AEP/PEP it was standing lumbar RE. CC distinguished pre- and post-intervention REs with 85.7% accuracy for FP and 90% for AEP with respective sitting lumbar and standing pelvic RE as the most sensitive predictors of recovery.

Conclusions:

This is the first application of CC in CLBP. The CC accurately discerned three clinical CLBP subgroups and identified parameters that most accurately characterise each subgroup and best predict post-intervention recovery. The CC enhanced classification accuracy to discern between CLBP and H when patients were subclassified. CC should be further tested using clinical classification data.

Implications:

CLBP classification is a complex process requiring high level clinical expertise to synthesize a unique set of physical/clinical characteristics in each CLBP person. The CC can order complex data sets to aid clinicians’ interpretation to target therapy and identify the most sensitive parameters for monitoring recovery thus enhancing classification robustness.

In-vivo confirmation of the use of the dart thrower's motion during activities of daily living

The dart thrower's motion is a wrist rotation along an oblique plane from radial extension to ulnar flexion. We report an in-vivo study to confirm the use of the dart thrower's motion during activities of daily living. Global wrist motion in ten volunteers was recorded using a three-dimensional optoelectronic motion capture system, in which digital infra-red cameras track the movement of retro-reflective marker clusters. Global wrist motion has been approximated to the dart thrower's motion when hammering a nail, throwing a ball, drinking from a glass, pouring from a jug and twisting the lid of a jar, but not when combing hair or manipulating buttons. The dart thrower's motion is the plane of global wrist motion used during most activities of daily living. Arthrodesis of the radiocarpal joint instead of the midcarpal joint will allow better wrist function during most activities of daily living by preserving the dart thrower's motion.

Objective classification of scapular kinematics in participants with movement faults of the scapula on clinical assessment

The aim of this study was to assess the potential of employing a classification tool to objectively classify participants with clinically assessed movement faults (MFs) of the scapula. Six participants with a history of shoulder pain with MFs of the scapula and 12 healthy participants with no movement faults (NMFs) performed a flexion movement control test of the scapula, while scapular kinematic data were collected. Principal component scores and discrete kinematic variables were used as input into a classifier. Five out of the six participants with a history of pain were successfully classified as having scapular MFs with an accuracy of 72%. Variables related to the upward rotation of the scapula had the most influence on the classification. The results of the study demonstrate the potential of adopting a multivariate approach in objective classification of participants with altered scapular kinematics in pathological groups.

A 3D motion analysis study comparing the effectiveness of cervical spine orthoses at restricting spinal motion through physiological ranges

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effectiveness of the Aspen, Aspen Vista, Philadelphia, Miami-J and Miami-J Advanced collars at restricting cervical spine movement in the sagittal, coronal and axial planes.

METHODS

Nineteen healthy volunteers (12 female, 7 male) were recruited to the study. Collars were fitted by an approved physiotherapist. Eight ProReflex (Qualisys, Sweden) infrared cameras were used to track the movement of retro-reflective marker clusters placed in predetermined positions on the head and trunk. 3D kinematic data were collected during forward flexion, extension, lateral bending and axial rotation from uncollared to collared subjects. The physiological range of motion in the three planes was analysed using the Qualisys Track Manager System.

RESULTS

The Aspen and Philadelphia were significantly more effective at restricting flexion/extension than the Vista (p < 0.001), Miami-J (p < 0.001 and p < 0.01) and Miami-J Advanced (p < 0.01 and p < 0.05). The Aspen was significantly more effective at restricting rotation than the Vista (p < 0.001) and the Miami-J (p < 0.05). The Vista was significantly the least effective collar at restricting lateral bending (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Our motion analysis study found the Aspen collar to be superior to the other collars when measuring restriction of movement of the cervical spine in all planes, particularly the sagittal and transverse planes, while the Aspen Vista was the least effective collar.

Abnormal loading of the major joints in knee osteoarthritis and the response to knee replacement

Knee osteoarthritis is common and patients frequently complain that they are 'overloading' the joints of the opposite leg when they walk. However, it is unknown whether moments or co-contractions are abnormal in the unaffected joints of patients with single joint knee osteoarthritis, or how they change following treatment of the affected knee. Twenty patients with single joint medial compartment knee osteoarthritis were compared to 20 asymptomatic control subjects. Gait analysis was performed for normal level gait and surface EMG recordings of the medial and lateral quadriceps and hamstrings were used to investigate co-contraction. Patients were followed up 12 months post-operatively and the analysis was repeated. Results are presented for the first 14 patients who have attended follow-up. Pre-operatively, adduction moment impulses were elevated at both knees and the contra-lateral hip compared to controls. Co-contraction of hamstrings and quadriceps was elevated bilaterally. Post-operatively, moment waveforms returned to near-normal levels at the affected knee and co-contraction fell in the majority of patients. However, abnormalities persisted in the contra-lateral limb with partial or no recovery of both moment waveforms and co-contraction in the majority. Patients with knee osteoarthritis do experience abnormal loads of their major weight bearing joints bilaterally, and abnormalities persist despite treatment of the affected limb. Further treatment may be required if we are to protect the other major joints following joint arthroplasty.