Nasal airflow patterns during the velopharyngeal closing phase in speech in children with and without cleft palate

OBJECTIVES

(1) To study the nasal airflow patterns during the velopharyngeal closing phase in speech produced by children with and without cleft palate. (2) To compare the nasal airflow patterns in bilabial, dental, and velar articulation in these children.

DESIGN

Prospective, cross-sectional study of a consecutive series of children with cleft palate referred for routine speech evaluation and controls.

SETTING

Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Göteborg, Sweden.

PARTICIPANTS

Seventeen children with cleft lip and palate or cleft palate only and 22 controls aged 7 and 10 years.

METHOD

Nasal airflow was transduced with a pneumotachograph attached to a nose mask and registered together with the acoustic speech signal. Sentences containing nasal-to-stop combinations in bilabial, dental, and velar articulatory positions were used.

MAIN OUTCOMES MEASURES

The duration from peak to 5% nasal airflow, the maximum flow declination rate, and the nasal airflow at selected points in time during the transition from nasal-to-stop consonants.

RESULTS

In the cleft palate group, duration from peak to 5% nasal airflow was clearly longer than among the controls (p <.0001). The declination of airflow was slower (p <.006) and the rate of nasal airflow at the release of the stop consonant was higher (p <.004) in the cleft palate group. Differences between bilabial versus dental and velar articulation were found in the control group.

CONCLUSION

Studies of the temporal and dynamic characteristics of the nasal airflow variations during speech appear potentially useful for the assessment of velopharyngeal function.

Aerodynamic assessment of velopharyngeal function during normal speech containing different places of articulation

The aim of this study was to describe the aerodynamics related to velopharyngeal function during speech in bilabial, dental, and velar articulatory positions in Swedish speakers. Repeated syllables including voiceless stop consonants and sentences including combinations of voiceless stops and nasal consonants were uttered by 11 normal adults. Oropharyngeal pressure was assessed with a miniature pressure transducer positioned transnasally, in combination with measurement of nasal pressure and nasal airflow. The corresponding velopharyngeal opening area was estimated. The results suggest that the velopharyngeal function during stop consonants is similar in different articulatory positions. Differences in oropharyngeal pressure and nasal airflow between bilabial versus dental and velar positions were found, presumably due to differences in volume and compliance of the vocal tract.

Acoustic and perceptual evaluation of voice and speech quality: a study of patients with laryngeal cancer treated with laryngectomy vs irradiation

OBJECTIVE

To compare voice and speech function in patients who underwent laryngectomy with that of 2 control groups.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional study comparing acoustic and temporal variables with perceptual evaluations in 3 subject groups.

SETTING

University hospital in Göteborg, Sweden.

SUBJECTS

Two groups of patients with laryngeal carcinoma were examined: 12 male patients who had laryngectomy and were using a tracheoesophageal prosthesis and 12 male patients treated with radical radiotherapy who had a preserved larynx. The third group consisted of 10 normal controls without laryngeal disease.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Acoustic variables were fundamental frequency, absolute fundamental frequency perturbation, speech rate, and maximum phonation time. Perceptual evaluation included 15 listeners' perceptual evaluation and the patients' self-assessment of speech intelligibility, voice quality, and speech acceptability.

RESULTS

No significant acoustic or temporal differences were found between the laryngectomy and radical radiotherapy groups. There was a significant difference between the patient groups in perceptual evaluation. Both groups of patients differed from normal controls in acoustic and temporal measures, where the laryngectomy group generally deviated more from the normal controls than the patient group treated with radiotherapy. There was a weak, but significant, correlation between absolute fundamental frequency perturbation and perceived voice quality.

CONCLUSIONS

Perceptual evaluations could indicate significant differences between the patients who underwent laryngectomy and irradiated patients, where the acoustic analysis failed to reflect these differences. Both patient groups could be distinguished according to acoustic and temporal measures when compared with normal controls. The acoustic analyses were more sufficient in voices without severe dysfunction.

Intelligibility and perceptual ratings after treatment for laryngeal cancer: laryngectomy versus radiotherapy

In Sweden the most common treatment for T3-T4 laryngeal carcinoma is radical radiotherapy (with surgery for salvage), because the voice is thus preserved. A Swedish study showed that surgery yielded a significantly better 5-year survival and locoregional control at 3 years in T4 laryngeal carcinoma than radical radiotherapy. With these results in mind, we wanted to compare the different modes of treatment (surgery with a tracheoesophageal [TE] fistula and radical radiotherapy) with respect to the patients' speech proficiency. Twenty-eight subjects (with 14 patients in each treatment group) were judged by inexperienced and experienced listeners according to intelligibility by transcription and three perceptual ratings. From the perceptual ratings of speech intelligibility, voice quality, and speech acceptability we conclude that there is a significant difference, the irradiated speakers being rated higher than the tracheoesophageal speakers. It is also clear that most of the TE and irradiated laryngeal speaking patients are comparable to normal laryngeal speakers in intelligibility by transcription. Experienced and inexperienced listeners are able to rate TE and irradiated laryngeal speech reliably and similarly according to intelligibility by transcription. The inexperienced listeners rated the TE speakers significantly higher than did the experienced listeners.

Speech and velopharyngeal function in children with an open residual cleft in the hard palate, and the influence of temporary covering

The influence of an open residual cleft in the hard palate on speech was studied in nine children with cleft lip and palate at about 7 years of age. The subjects were treated by early repair of the velum (before 12 months of age), whereas the repair of the cleft in the hard palate was postponed until about 8 years of age. Speech and velopharyngeal function were assessed systematically with the residual cleft open and temporarily covered with an oral bandage. Listeners' judgments, the Nasal Oral RAtio Meter (NORAM), videofluoroscopy, and cephalometrics were used for the analyses. Four patients were also examined with a pressure-flow technique. Nasality registered by NORAM, nasal escape, and weak pressure consonants judged by listeners were common but decreased appreciably when the residual cleft was covered. Retracted articulation was found in four patients (44%) and glottal compensations in one (11%), with no improvement after covering.