1
|
Francis JR, Whalley GA, Kaethner A, Fairhurst H, Hardefeldt H, Reeves B, Auld B, Marangou J, Horton A, Wheaton G, Robertson T, Ryan C, Brown S, Smith G, Dos Santos J, Flavio R, Embaum K, da Graca Noronha M, Lopes Belo S, Madeira Santos C, Georginha Dos Santos M, Cabral J, do Rosario I, Harries J, Francis LA, Draper ADK, James CL, Davis K, Yan J, Mitchell A, da Silva Almeida I, Engelman D, Roberts KV, Ralph AP, Remenyi B. Single-View Echocardiography by Nonexpert Practitioners to Detect Rheumatic Heart Disease: A Prospective Study of Diagnostic Accuracy. Circ Cardiovasc Imaging 2021; 14:e011790. [PMID: 34384239 PMCID: PMC8373443 DOI: 10.1161/circimaging.120.011790] [Citation(s) in RCA: 8] [Impact Index Per Article: 2.7] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Affiliation(s)] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Download PDF] [Figures] [Journal Information] [Submit a Manuscript] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 11/25/2022]
Abstract
Supplemental Digital Content is available in the text. Background: Echocardiographic screening can detect asymptomatic cases of rheumatic heart disease (RHD), facilitating access to treatment. Barriers to implementation of echocardiographic screening include the requirement for expensive equipment and expert practitioners. We aimed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of an abbreviated echocardiographic screening protocol (single parasternal-long-axis view with a sweep of the heart) performed by briefly trained, nonexpert practitioners using handheld ultrasound devices. Methods: Participants aged 5 to 20 years in Timor-Leste and the Northern Territory of Australia had 2 echocardiograms: one performed by an expert echocardiographer using a GE Vivid I or Vivid Q portable ultrasound device (reference test), and one performed by a nonexpert practitioner using a GE Vscan handheld ultrasound device (index test). The accuracy of the index test, compared with the reference test, for identifying cases with definite or borderline RHD was determined. Results: There were 3111 enrolled participants; 2573 had both an index test and reference test. Median age was 12 years (interquartile range, 10–15); 58.2% were female. Proportion with definite or borderline RHD was 5.52% (95% CI, 4.70–6.47); proportion with definite RHD was 3.23% (95% CI, 2.61–3.98). Compared with the reference test, sensitivity of the index test for definite or borderline RHD was 70.4% (95% CI, 62.2–77.8), specificity was 78.1% (95% CI, 76.4–79.8). Conclusions: Nonexpert practitioners can be trained to perform single parasternal-long-axis view with a sweep of the heart echocardiography. However, the specificity and sensitivity are inadequate for echocardiographic screening. Improved training for nonexpert practitioners should be investigated.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Joshua R Francis
- Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Australia (J.R.F., H.F., J.M., J.Y., A.P.R., B.R.).,Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.).,Maluk Timor, Timor-Leste (J.R.F., J.D.S., R.F., K.E.)
| | - Gillian A Whalley
- Dunedin School of Medicine, University of Otago, New Zealand (G.A.W.)
| | | | - Helen Fairhurst
- Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Australia (J.R.F., H.F., J.M., J.Y., A.P.R., B.R.)
| | - Hilary Hardefeldt
- Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.)
| | | | - Benjamin Auld
- Department of Cardiology, Queensland Children's Hospital, Australia (B.A.)
| | - James Marangou
- Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Australia (J.R.F., H.F., J.M., J.Y., A.P.R., B.R.).,NT Cardiac, Australia (A.K., J.M., B.R.)
| | - Ari Horton
- Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.)
| | - Gavin Wheaton
- Department of Cardiology, Women's and Children's Hospital, Australia (G.W., T.R.)
| | - Terry Robertson
- Department of Cardiology, Women's and Children's Hospital, Australia (G.W., T.R.)
| | - Chelsea Ryan
- Maningrida Health Center (C.R., S.B., G.S.), Top End Health Services, Australia
| | - Shannon Brown
- Maningrida Health Center (C.R., S.B., G.S.), Top End Health Services, Australia
| | - Greg Smith
- Maningrida Health Center (C.R., S.B., G.S.), Top End Health Services, Australia
| | | | | | | | - Mario da Graca Noronha
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | - Sonia Lopes Belo
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | - Carla Madeira Santos
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | - Maria Georginha Dos Santos
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | - Jose Cabral
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | - Ivonia do Rosario
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | | | - Laura A Francis
- Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.).,Center for Disease Control (L.A.F., A.D.K.D., C.L.J.), Top End Health Services, Australia
| | - Anthony D K Draper
- Center for Disease Control (L.A.F., A.D.K.D., C.L.J.), Top End Health Services, Australia
| | - Christian L James
- Center for Disease Control (L.A.F., A.D.K.D., C.L.J.), Top End Health Services, Australia
| | - Kimberly Davis
- Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.)
| | - Jennifer Yan
- Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Australia (J.R.F., H.F., J.M., J.Y., A.P.R., B.R.).,Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.)
| | | | - Ines da Silva Almeida
- Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Nacional Guido Valadares, Timor-Leste (M.d.G.N., S.L.B., C.M.S., M.G.d.S., J.C., I.d.R., I.d.S.A.)
| | - Daniel Engelman
- Tropical Diseases, Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Australia (D.E.)
| | - Kathryn V Roberts
- Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.)
| | - Anna P Ralph
- Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Australia (J.R.F., H.F., J.M., J.Y., A.P.R., B.R.).,Division of Medicine, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (A.P.R.)
| | - Bo Remenyi
- Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Australia (J.R.F., H.F., J.M., J.Y., A.P.R., B.R.).,Department of Pediatrics, Royal Darwin Hospital, Australia (J.R.F., H.H., A.H., L.A.F., K.D., J.Y., K.V.R., B.R.).,NT Cardiac, Australia (A.K., J.M., B.R.).,Department of Pediatrics, Cairns Base Hospital, Australia (B.R.)
| |
Collapse
|