12-Year clinical and radiological results of a double-blind randomized controlled trial comparing posterior cruciate-retaining versus posterior-stabilized total knee arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

A subject of ongoing debate among orthopedic surgeons is the importance of preserving the posterior cruciate ligament in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), but long-term survival studies are scarce. The aim of this study was to compare long-term survival rates, and clinical and radiological follow up of a double-blind randomized controlled trial comparing posterior cruciate-retaining (PCR) versus posterior-stabilizing (PS) implant design of an AGC TKA.

METHODS

A total of 114 patients were included in the survival analysis (PCR n = 61; PS n = 53). Forty-five patients (PCR n = 25; PS n = 20) participated in the long-term follow up using patient-reported outcome measures (Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36) and Kujala score (measuring anterior knee pain)). Thirty-one patients were assessed with a physical test (Knee Society Score (KSS)) and radiographs.

RESULTS

Overall survival rate was 95.6% (PCR 98.4% vs. PS 92.5%), with five patients having a major revision (PCR n = 1 vs. PS n = 4, respectively). Satisfying outcome scores for both groups were described at on average 12-year follow up with no significant differences in KSS knee and function scores, WOMAC, SF-36, or Kujala scores between groups. Radiographically, there were no findings of femoral or tibial loosening or polyethylene wear in either group.

CONCLUSIONS

Good long-term survival rates were described for the PCR and the PS design of an AGC TKA. There were no significant differences in clinical and radiological outcomes between a PCR and a PS design 12 years postoperatively.

The correlation between posterior tibial slope and dynamic anterior tibial translation and dynamic range of tibial rotation

Purpose

The amount of passive anterior tibial translation (ATT) is known to be correlated to the amount of posterior tibial slope (PTS) in both anterior cruciate ligament-deficient and reconstructed knees. Slope-altering osteotomies are advised when graft failure after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction occurs in the presence of high PTS. This recommendation is based on studies neglecting the influence of muscle activation. On the other hand, if dynamic range of tibial rotation (rTR) is related to the amount of PTS, a “simple” anterior closing-wedge osteotomy might not be sufficient to control for tibial rotation. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the correlation between the amount of PTS and dynamic ATT and tibial rotation during high demanding activities, both before and after ACL reconstruction. We hypothesized that both ATT and rTR are strongly correlated to the amount of PTS.

Methods

Ten subjects were studied both within three months after ACL injury and one year after ACL reconstruction. Dynamic ATT and dynamic rTR were measured using a motion-capture system during level walking, during a single-leg hop for distance and during a side jump. Both medial and lateral PTS were measured on MRI. A difference between medial and lateral PTS was calculated and referred to as Δ PTS. Spearman’s correlation coefficients were calculated for the correlation between medial PTS, lateral PTS and Δ PTS and ATT and between medial PTS, lateral PTS and Δ PTS and rTR.

Results

Little (if any) to weak correlations were found between medial, lateral and Δ PTS and dynamic ATT both before and after ACL reconstruction. On the other hand, a moderate-to-strong correlation was found between medial PTS, lateral PTS and Δ PTS and dynamic rTR one year after ACL reconstruction.

Conclusion

During high-demand tasks, dynamic ATT is not correlated to PTS. A compensation mechanism may be responsible for the difference between passive and dynamic ATT in terms of the correlation to PTS. A moderate-to-strong correlation between amount of PTS and rTR indicates that such a compensation mechanism may fall short in correcting for rTR. These findings warrant prudence in the use of a pure anterior closing wedge osteotomy in ACL reconstruction.

Trial registration

Netherlands Trial Register, Trial 7686. Registered 16 April 2016—Retrospectively registered.

Level of evidence

Level 2, prospective cohort study

[Two patients with an isolated traumatic rupture of the subscapular tendon]

A man aged 65 and a woman aged 55 were referred to the orthopaedic clinic because of persistent pain in the right shoulder following a fall, 5 and 16 months earlier respectively. On physical examination they were found to have a painful shoulder and loss of strength on endorotation of the right arm. Ultrasound examination of the shoulder revealed subscapular tendon rupture in both patients, this was confirmed by MRI scan in the first patient. Treatment was operative repair of the tendon by a deltopectoral approach, followed by wearing a exorotation-limiting sling. After six months the first patient was free of complaints and the second patient was still experiencing pain when laying on the right shoulder. An isolated traumatic rupture of the subscapular tendon is uncommon and is often misdiagnosed or only discovered later. This diagnostic delay negatively influences the success of operative treatment. Focusing attention on the typical trauma mechanism, the character of the symptoms and the use of simple physical examination such as the lift-offtest or the belly press test can lead to the correct diagnosis.

[Septic polyarthritis due to an infected nail bed around an ingrown toenail in a previously healthy boy]

A 17-year-old, previously healthy boy was admitted with complaints of fever, malaise and pain in the pubic region and groin. His left elbow was also warm and swollen and could not be extended fully. Cultures of fluid drained from both hips and the elbow, blood and inflamed tissue from the nail bed of the right big toe yielded Staphylococcus aureus. The patient was treated with intravenous antibiotics for septic arthritis of both hips, the left elbow and possibly the pubic symphysis. The infected nail bed, which was the most likely port of entry, was also treated. One year later, the original painful symptoms had disappeared but the right hip was almost immobile. In a patient with indications of septic arthritis, timely diagnosis and adequate therapy reduce the risk of permanent damage to the joint.

Adjusted transfusion triggers improve transfusion practice in orthopaedic surgery

Although blood transfusion has never been safer, there remains concern about adverse effects. We designed guidelines, the 6-8-10-Flexinorm, based on the conditions which are relevant to the decision to transfuse. To evaluate these new guidelines, we performed a case-control study in patients undergoing elective primary total hip replacement. The study consisted of two parts. In the first part, physicians were strongly encouraged to use the new guidelines; in the second part, only registration took place. During the first and second part of the study, the use of packed red cells (PRC) in Hospital A (study hospital) decreased from 1.1 +/- 1.5 to 0.6 +/- 1.2 and 0.3 +/- 0.9 units, whereas in Hospital B (control), the use of PRC remained unchanged (1 +/- 1.5, 1 +/- 1.7 and 1 +/- 2 units). In the prestudy groups, 43% of the patients in Hospital A were transfused compared to 45% in Hospital B. In the first and second part of the study, 27%, respectively, 14% of the patients in Hospital A were transfused compared to 40% in both periods in Hospital B. The new guidelines lead to a reduction in the use of allogeneic blood and a decrease in the number of patients transfused.