Mass-spectrometry-based quantitation of Her2 in gastroesophageal tumor tissue: comparison to IHC and FISH

BACKGROUND

Trastuzumab has shown a survival benefit in cases of Her2-positive gastroesophageal cancer (GEC). Immunohistochemistry (IHC) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) currently determine eligibility for trastuzumab-based therapy. However, these low-throughput assays often produce discordant or equivocal results.

METHODS

We developed a targeted proteomic assay based on selected reaction monitoring mass spectrometry (SRM-MS) and quantified levels (amol/μg) of Her2-SRM protein in cell lines (n = 27) and GEC tissues (n = 139). We compared Her2-SRM protein expression with IHC/FISH, seeking to determine optimal SRM protein expression cutoffs in order to identify HER2 gene amplification.

RESULTS

After demonstrating assay development, precision, and stability, Her2-SRM protein measurement was observed to be highly concordant with the HER2/CEP17 ratio, particularly in a multivariate regression model adjusted for SRM expression of the covariates Met, Egfr, Her3, and HER2 heterogeneity, as well as their interactions (cell lines r (2) = 0.9842; FFPE r (2) = 0.7643). In GEC tissues, Her2-SRM protein was detected at any level in 71.2 % of cases. ROC curves demonstrated that Her2-SRM protein levels have a high specificity (100 %) at an upper-level cutoff of >750 amol/µg and sensitivity of 75 % at a lower-level cutoff of <450 amol/μg for identifying HER2 FISH-amplified tumors. An "equivocal zone" of 450-750 amol/µg of Her2-SRM protein was analogous to IHC2+ but represented fewer cases (9-16 % of cases versus 36-41 %).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to IHC, targeted SRM-Her2 proteomics provided more objective and quantitative Her2 expression with excellent HER2/CEP17 FISH correlation and fewer equivocal cases. Along with its multiplex capability for other relevant oncoproteins, these results demonstrate a refined HER2 protein expression assay for clinical application.

Her2 expression in gastroesophageal cancer (GEC) FFPE tissue using mass spectrometry (MS) and correlation with HER2 gene amplification

82

Background: HER2+ GEC derived benefit from trastuzumab. Her2 IHC is semi-quantitative, subjective, and sensitive to antigen instability; HER2 FISH is laborious, expensive, and subjective. False positivity/negativity have been described. Also, these are low throughput assays; there is known molecular heterogeneity, with several putative biomarkers, and only scarce tissue to assess for each. We sought to evaluate the association of Her2 MS expression with HER2 FISH, along with other markers within the ‘GEC-plex’. Methods: We utilized a previously described unique Her2 peptide and quantification method (Hembrough et al J Clin Oncol 32,2014(suppl 3;abstr17)). The assay was run on 27 cell lines, in parallel with HER2:CEP17 FISH. Her2 expression thresholds were established for HER2 amplification using ROC curves. We adjusted for Her3, Egfr, and Met MS expression levels and sample HER2:CEP17 ratio heterogeneity in a multiple linear regression model. The model/cut-offs were then validated prospectively on GEC tissues (n=142). Results: Her2 MS on cell lines revealed concordance with FISH (HER2:CEP17) ratio (R2=0.75), which improved by adjusting for Her3 MS, Egfr MS, Met MS and HER2:CEP17 heterogeneity (R2>0.98), with significant interactions. IHC correlation with HER2:CEP17 ratio was poor (R2=0.12). A wide range of expression was noted within IHC3+ patients (<150-24671amol/ug). Her2 MS expression (>150 amol/ug) was seen in 72.9% (102/142) of tissues (range <150-24671amol/ug); 9.9% (14/142) had Her2 > 750 amol/ug - all were HER2 FISH amplified. 6/142 (4%) cases <500 amol/ug were clinically ‘HER2amplified’. IHC/FISH results for cases with 550-750 amol/ug demonstrated an ‘equivocal’ zone, not unlike ‘IHC 2+’, but less frequent (8/142, 5.6% vs 46/142 32.4%). Conclusions: The MS HER2 assay can be multiplexed with other GEC biomarkers. A robust model was developed that showed strong correlation of Her2 MS with HER2:CEP17 ratio, particularly when adjusting for covariates Egfr MS, Met MS, Her3 MS, and HER2 FISH heterogeneity. Future analysis will assess the established model as a tool for better prediction of therapeutic benefit from anti-Her2 therapy compared to current methods.

Abstract 918: Clinical validation of a multiplexed ChemoPlex SRM assay in FFPE human tumor tissue

Background: Current cancer treatment regimens rely on the use of chemotherapy agents that inhibit DNA replication and repair machinery. Several proteins are involved in this mechanism, such as TOPO1, TOPO2A, RRM1, FR-alpha and hENT1. The expression levels and activities of these proteins can greatly affect the success of chemotherapy; however current treatment indications are not based on tumor expression levels of these proteins. We have developed a quantitative, multiplexed ChemoPlex SRM method to evaluate these markers in a host of solid tumors from a limited amount of FFPE biopsy tissue using our Liquid Tissue®-SRM (LT-SRM) platform. Use of this method will enable a physician to understand individual tumor molecular machinery and ultimately could lead to individualized treatment decisions leading to better patient care.

Methods: We used trypsin digestion mapping of recombinant proteins to identify optimal quantitative peptides for the ChemoPlex SRM assay. Standard curves were generated to determine the LOD, LOQ, accuracy, precision and linearity of the assay. The assay was pre-clinically validated on 14 cell lines with known expression levels of these Chemo-targets, and the assay was then run on microdissected archived FFPE human tissue samples from lung, gastro-esophageal cancer (GEC), breast, liver, colorectal, and ovarian tumors.

Results: The peptides chosen for the 5 Chemo-Plex targets had LOD values of 150, 50, 300, 200, and 100 amol (CV&lt;20%) for FR alpha, hENT1, TOPO1, TOPO2A, and RRM1, respectively. Fourteen cell lines were assayed for the Chemo-target expressions by LT-SRM, and regression analysis between protein and mRNA analysis for each target demonstrated varying correlations (R2=0.91(FR alpha); 0.78 (hENT1); 0.16 (TOPO1); 0.56 (TOPO2A); 0.59 (RRM1)) suggesting that RT-PCR measurements of mRNA levels would not be representative of cellular protein levels and therefore not useful for biomarker analysis for physicians. Our initial clinical analysis shows that FR alpha was detectable only in certain lung tumors (especially adenocarcinoma) and ovarian tumors; breast cancer tumors were found to have a wide range of hENT1 expression (LOD -1,284 amol/ug) while hENT1 expression in other tissues ranged from 90 to 377 amol/ug. TOPO1 had fairly ubiquitous expression (359 -1,300 amol/ug) except for one GEC and one breast cancer tissue. TOPO2A was identified in all tissue types (227-1,057 amol/ug). All samples except 1 GEC tissue express RRM1 (160 - 958 amol/ug)

Discussion: We describe the development and initial clinical validation of a quantitative proteomic ChemoPlex SRM assay which accurately measures the expression of five chemotherapy targets in FFPE tumor tissue. When multiplexed along with other druggable biomarkers, the ChemoPlex SRM assay will allow more accurate identification of patients that are likely to benefit from the combination of chemotherapy and targeted therapies.

Citation Format: Eunkyung An, Wei-Li Liao, Sheeno Thyparambil, Adele Blackler, Jamar Uzzell, Kathleen Bengali, Marlene Darfler, Jon Burrows, Todd Hembrough. Clinical validation of a multiplexed ChemoPlex SRM assay in FFPE human tumor tissue. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 105th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2014 Apr 5-9; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2014;74(19 Suppl):Abstract nr 918. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2014-918

Absolute quantitation of Met using mass spectrometry for clinical application: assay precision, stability, and correlation with MET gene amplification in FFPE tumor tissue

Background

Overexpression of Met tyrosine kinase receptor is associated with poor prognosis. Overexpression, and particularly MET amplification, are predictive of response to Met-specific therapy in preclinical models. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) of formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissues is currently used to select for ‘high Met’ expressing tumors for Met inhibitor trials. IHC suffers from antibody non-specificity, lack of quantitative resolution, and, when quantifying multiple proteins, inefficient use of scarce tissue.

Methods

After describing the development of the Liquid-Tissue-Selected Reaction Monitoring-mass spectrometry (LT-SRM-MS) Met assay, we evaluated the expression level of Met in 130 FFPE gastroesophageal cancer (GEC) tissues. We assessed the correlation of SRM Met expression to IHC and mean MET gene copy number (GCN)/nucleus or MET/CEP7 ratio by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH).

Results

Proteomic mapping of recombinant Met identified ⁴¹⁸TEFTTALQR⁴²⁶ as the optimal SRM peptide. Limits of detection (LOD) and quantitation (LOQ) for this peptide were 150 and 200 amol/µg tumor protein, respectively. The assay demonstrated excellent precision and temporal stability of measurements in serial sections analyzed one year apart. Expression levels of 130 GEC tissues ranged (<150 amol/µg to 4669.5 amol/µg. High correlation was observed between SRM Met expression and both MET GCN and MET/CEP7 ratio as determined by FISH (n = 30; R² = 0.898). IHC did not correlate well with SRM (n = 44; R² = 0.537) nor FISH GCN (n = 31; R² = 0.509). A Met SRM level of ≥1500 amol/µg was 100% sensitive (95% CI 0.69–1) and 100% specific (95% CI 0.92–1) for MET amplification.

Conclusions

The Met SRM assay measured the absolute Met levels in clinical tissues with high precision. Compared to IHC, SRM provided a quantitative and linear measurement of Met expression, reliably distinguishing between non-amplified and amplified MET tumors. These results demonstrate a novel clinical tool for efficient tumor expression profiling, potentially leading to better informed therapeutic decisions for patients with GEC.

Quantification of HER2 from gastroesophageal cancer (GEC) FFPE tissue by mass spectrometry (MS)

17

Background: Trastuzumab had a survival benefit in ‘HER2 positive’ GEC, determined by IHC/FISH. These companion diagnostics have limitations. IHC is semi-quantitative, subjective, and sensitive to antigen instability in FFPE; FISH is laborious, expensive, and subjective. Gene amplification may not correlate to protein expression. Moreover these are low throughput assays. There is increased recognition of profound interpatient molecular heterogeneity with several putative biomarkers, and only scarce tissue to assess for each one. We sought to evaluate our MS platform on GEC FFPE tissues for HER2 status compared to IHC/FISH. We also applied the “GEC-plex” of 11 other potentially predictive/prognostic markers for GEC. Methods: We utilized trypsin digestion mapping of rHER2 to identify unique peptides for SRM development. Stable isotope-labeled peptides were synthesized as internal standards, and standard curves were generated in a complex eukaryotic matrix (PC3 cells) to determine LOD, LLOQ, accuracy, precision and linearity of the assays. The assay was run on 17 GEC cell lines, in parallel with FISH/IHC, and expression thresholds were established for HER2+/HER2-; the sensitivity/specificity of the established cutoffs were then tested prospectively in FFPE GEC tissues on 10uM FFPE LCM slides (n=121). HER2 stability from FFPE sections was assessed by assaying 33 freshly cut FFPE samples; the adjacent sections were processed one year later. Results: The HER2 peptide chosen (ELVSEFSR) had a LOD of 100 amol and CV<20%. HER2 MS on GEC cell lines revealed concordance with FISH (HER2:CEP17) ratio (R2=0.96). The analysis suggested HER2 expression > 750 amol/ug was indicative of HER2 amplification. The assay was stable in archival FFPE sections (R2=0.76). For GEC FFPE cases, ‘any’ HER2 expression was seen in 69.4% of cases; 8.2% showed HER2 > 750 amol (10/121) - all were HER2 amplified. No cases <550 amol/ug were HER2 amplified. IHC/FISH results for cases with 550-750 amol/ug demonstrated a heterogeneous ‘equivocal’ zone, not unlike ‘IHC 2+’, which may require FISH confirmatory testing. Conclusions: ‘GEC-plex’ has a quantitative, sensitive, and specific HER2 assay that can be multiplexed along with other GEC biomarkers.