Delay in the diagnosis and outcome of colorectal cancer: a prospective study

AIMS

The aim of this study was to examine the incidence of the delay in the diagnosis of colorectal carcinoma, possible causes of this delay and its effects on outcome.

METHODS

A prospective study was performed on 100 patients affected by colorectal cancer. Duration of symptoms was calculated from the date of onset of symptoms to the date of surgery.

RESULTS

Sixty-nine patients suffered delays in treatment of more than 12 weeks from the onset of symptoms. In patients with symptoms of less than 12 weeks' duration there was a higher incidence of radical surgery and none of these patients presented, at the time of surgery, a neoplastic dissemination. Multivariate analysis, however, showed that the only factors with an independent effect on 5-year survival and disease-free survival were Dukes' stage and the presence of pre-operative complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study suggest that, independent of the diagnostic delay, the outcome of the colorectal cancer is only conditioned by tumour stage and by complicated cancer.

Adenocarcinoma of the colon and rectum: some reflections on the immediate and long-term results of surgery

Colorectal cancer continues to be a major public health problem in western countries. Although some studies have reported an improvement in disease-free and overall survival, few of the diagnostic and therapeutic procedures proposed have found unanimous consent. We report some reflections on both the immediate and the long-term results of colorectal cancer surgery on the basis of our experience, represented by 1164 patients with histologically proven colorectal carcinoma, admitted to the Institute of General Surgery of Parma University between 1976 and 1993 and operated on by the same surgical team, in order to provide data for scientific discussion. A curative resection was possible in 67.9% of the cases. Our experience shows that many colorectal cancer patients will be cured with aggressive surgery, although, in recent years, adjuvant therapy for colorectal cancer has advanced considerably. Statistical analyses reveal that an unfavourable prognosis is correlated with variables indicative of advanced disease. Concerning the problem of local recurrences, our results demonstrate that surgery is the only therapeutic option providing tangible results, and that intense follow-up leads to a greater number of resections carried out for local recurrence and to improved 5-year survival. Comparison of studies and scientific discussions can prove useful, above all regarding secondary prevention and, in particular, the identification of patients at risk who should undergo screening for early diagnosis and early surgical treatment.

Curative surgery for colorectal cancer: long-term results and life expectancy in the elderly

PURPOSE

The long-term prognosis after curative surgery for colorectal cancer was evaluated in relation to age and life expectancy as a possible basis for assessing the risk to benefit ratios in the elderly.

METHODS

Data relating to 1,256 patients operated on from 1976 to 1994 were stored in a computer database prospectively from 1987. Patients were subdivided into four age groups (A = <60 years; B = 60-69; C = 70-79; D = > or =80). Distribution of general contraindications to curative surgery was examined. In the 869 patients who underwent curative treatment (A = 206; B = 256; C = 289; D = 118), distribution of tumor stage and elective/emergency surgery and the operative mortality rate were evaluated. Crude and age-corrected survival curves were calculated in 794 patients. The median crude survival of each group was related by gender and tumor stage to demographic life expectancy, assuming as "relative median survival index" the ratio between the two values.

RESULTS

General contraindications to curative surgery increased significantly with age. The operative mortality rate was higher in Group D than in Groups A, B, plus C over the total series (P < 0.001) and in both elective (P < 0.001) and emergency surgery (P < 0.05). Intergroup analysis of long-term survival rates showed significant differences between "crude" (P = 0.0057) but not age-corrected (P = 0.66) curves. The relative median survival index increased with age, up to approximately 1 in the local stages of Groups C and D.

CONCLUSIONS

To evaluate long-term results, elderly patients should be compared with unaffected, same-age subjects. Because the risks may be very high, the surgical policy in the elderly should be carefully weighed and related to life expectancy and actual results.

Laparoscopic hernia repair: a prospective comparison of TAPP and IPOM techniques

The aim of the study was to evaluate the safety and efficacy of two techniques of laparoscopic hernia repair: the transabdominal preperitoneal technique (TAPP) and the intraperitoneal onlay mesh technique (IPOM). In May 1992 a prospective randomized trial was initiated to compare TAPP and IPOM. Until October 1994, 115 patients with 148 hernias took part in the trial (59 TAPP and 56 IPOM). The TAPP took significantly longer than did the IPOM. There were no intraoperative complications, conversions to open repair, or postoperative deaths in either group. There were 10 (16.9% of patients) postoperative complications in the TAPP group and 14 (25%) in the IPOM group. The difference was not statistically significant. Neuralgias occurred in 3 cases of TAPP and 11 cases of IPOM (p < 0.05), local hematoma in 6 cases of TAPP and 3 cases of IPOM (NS), and urinary retention in 1 case of TAPP and in no case of IPOM (NS). Recurrences occurred in no cases of TAPP and in 8 cases (11.1% of hernias) of IPOM (p < 0.01). The results of the present report suggest that the IPOM technique for laparoscopic hernia repair should be avoided, whereas TAPP appears to be an excellent technique with no early recurrences.

[Prospective randomized comparative study of laparoscopic hernioplasty and Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty]

To compare the laparoscopic transabdominal preperitoneal inguinal hernioplasty (TAPP) and the open Lichtenstein technique, in 1992 a prospective randomized trial was initiated. Until 1995 108 patients with 130 hernias took part in the trial: 64 TAPP (group A) and 66 Lichtenstein (group B). 22 patients had simultaneous bilateral repairs. Laparoscopic approach (group A) was able to expose otherwise-occult controlateral hernias in 3 cases and discovered a complex hernia (a hernia with more than one defect in the wall) in 2 patient in whom a direct hernia had been diagnosed before the operation. Mean operating time for monolateral operations was significantly longer in group A (p < 0.05). The corresponding figures for bilateral operations were longer in group B (p < 0.01). No intraoperative complications, conversions from TAPP to open repair, postoperative deaths. There were not less pain quicker mobility and shorter period of disability in the laparoscopic group (group A). Ten (15.6%) postoperative complications occurred in group A: local hematoma (6 cases, 9.3%), neuralgias (3 cases, 4.7%), urinary retention (1 case, 1.6%). Eight (12.1%) postoperative complications: hematomas (3 cases, 4.5%), urinary retention (3 cases, 4.5%), neuralgias (2 cases, 3%) occurred in group B. Differences were not significant. The current follow-up period is 36 months (15-54) in median. In both groups no recurrences occurred, but 3 patients in group B who were operated on for monolateral hernia (6.5%) discovered to be affected by contralateral hernia. The results of the present report suggest that TAPP does not appear to be associated with better results in terms of complications, pain or period of disability as compared to open tension free hernia repair, but the ability of the laparoscopic approach to expose otherwise-occult defects eliminated the risk of recurrences due to missed hernias.

[Rouxel-Coadou method of ileal neobladder: clinico-functional considerations]

Twelve patients are submitted to orthotopic ileal neobladder, performed using staplers. The simplicity and speed of automatic stapling devices in the Rouxel-Coadou's surgical technique are reported. All patients underwent clinical and urodynamic evaluation at 3, 6, 12 months, after surgery (mean follow-up 6 months). They preferred complete daytime continence and 2 pts/4 night-time continence too. At one year, postvoid residual volume was absent, mean neobladder capacity was 450 ml and mean pressure at maximum capacity was 30-40 cm H2O. These preliminary results indicate that this technique guarantees a low-pressure reservoir with good capacity and compliance.

[Surgery of loco-regional recurrences in colorectal cancer]

By the term of local recurrence (LR), after apparently curative resection of a colorectal cancer, we mean the recurrence of the disease at the site of the original tumor, in correspondence to the regional lymph nodes or to intestinal anastomosis. The frequency of LR, which differs widely from one case to another because of the unhomogenity of the samples under examination, is on average around 16%, although this figure is to be considered an underestimation since it is not supported by routine autopsies. The authors analyse, together with the data in the literature, the results of their personal experience relating to 1164 patients undergoing surgery for colorectal cancer in the space of 18 years, in order to evaluate the true effectiveness of surgery on patients affected by LR. Surgery on the original tumor had a curative aim in 791 (68%) of these cases, 33 patients died during the postoperative period and 37 were lost to follow-up. Among the remaining 721 patients, recurrence was observed in 218 cases (30.2%): in 81 of these was confirmed a LR, with simultaneous distant metastasis in 45. During the same time span, 15 patients were admitted who were affected by LR from colorectal cancers treated surgically in other hospitals. Of these, only 2 had concomitant distant metastasis. 58 of these 96 patients (60.4%) underwent surgery, which had a curative aim in 22 cases (37.9%)/ Up to present, 12 patients undergoing curative surgery are still alive, 4 (33.3%) being affected by further relapse. The data reported demonstrate that in patients with proven LR surgical intervention is widely indicated, being the only therapeutic approach able to provide tangible results. However, the choice of exeresis must be carefully weighed: surgery of LR can be said to be truly curative in few cases, and thus the operative risks may not be acceptable in situations where limited results, in terms of duration and quality, are foreseen.