No difference in health-related quality of life in hip osteoarthritis compared to degenerative lumbar instability at pre- and 1-year postoperatively: a prospective study of 101 patients

BACKGROUND

Total hip replacement (THR) is a very successful and refined surgical procedure when compared to crude bony fusion in degenerative lumbar segmental instability (LF). We compared the pre- and postoperative health-related quality of life status of THR and LF patients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We prospectively studied 51 THR patients and 50 LF patients. The outcome parameters were SF-36 and Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), measured preoperatively and at 1 year postoperatively. The status of the patients was compared to that of an age-matched healthy control group.

RESULTS

The preoperative SF-36 and ODI scores were similar between the groups, except for the subscale role emotional. One year postoperatively, only the differences in 3 subscales (physical functioning, role physical, and role emotional) and in the standardized physical component reached statistical significance; the THR-patients scored worse than the LF-patients. The improvements in SF-36 and ODI reached statistical significance in both groups.

INTERPRETATION

The differences in quality of life between the THR and LF patients were similar pre- and postoperatively. The quality of life of both cohorts improved considerably and significantly after the treatment, but they remained at a level significantly below that of a general age-matched population.

Trauma triage--a comparison of the trauma score and the vital signs score

A pilot study of the Trauma Score (TS) was performed from July to September 1983. The Vital Signs Score (VSS) used by the ambulance paramedics, was compared with TS. Of 266 patients suitable for study, TS data was collected for 110. Other exclusions resulted in a detailed analysis of data from 65 patients among whom there were eight deaths. There was a significant correlation between TS and VSS, however, TS more accurately defined the population at risk of death. A score greater than 12 correlated with a mortality of zero for the TS, but for the VSS it correlated with a mortality of 4.4%. A score less than or equal to 12 correlated with a mortality of 61.5% for the TS but only 30% for the VSS. Stepwise regression analysis of the TS, VSS and combinations of their components was performed to determine their capacities to predict death. A combination of three components of the TS, corresponding to the Triage Index of Champion, was a better predictor than the total TS. Neither the VSS nor any combinations of its components had the predictive capacity of the total TS. If the TS and the VSS were used to select high risk patients for a particular rescue or resuscitation protocol, and scores were selected which gave 100% sensitivity with the highest possible specificity, the positive predictive values of the TS and VSS would be respectively 61.5% and 26.7%. The protocol would be administered unnecessarily to 73.3% of patients selected by the VSS, but only to 38.5% of patients selected by the TS. The TS is proposed as an aid to triage.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)