Comparison of Minimally Invasive Procedures for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: A Cost-effectiveness Analysis

Background Benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) is a disease that affects millions of U.S. men and is costly to treat. Purpose To compare the cost-effectiveness of four minimally invasive therapies (MITs) and medical management for the treatment of BPH. Materials and Methods A cost-effectiveness analysis from a payer's perspective with Markov modeling was performed, comparing prostatic artery embolization (PAE), prostatic urethral lift, aquablation, water vapor thermal therapy, and medical management for BPH spanning a time horizon of 5 years. The model incorporated the probability of procedural complications and recurrent symptoms necessitating retreatment, which were extracted from published studies with long-term follow-up. Costs were based on Medicare reimbursements using CPT codes for ambulatory surgery centers. Outcomes were measured using the quality-adjusted life year (QALY), incorporating both life quality and expectancy. Statistical analyses included a base case calculation (using the most probable value of each parameter) and probabilistic and deterministic sensitivity analyses. Results In the base case calculation, outcomes for the strategies were comparable, with a difference of 0.030 QALY (11 days of life in perfect health) between the most (PAE) and least (medical management) effective strategies. PAE was the most cost-effective strategy relative to medical management, with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of $64 842 per QALY. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed PAE was more cost-effective compared with prostatic urethral lift, aquablation, water vapor therapy, and medical management in pairwise comparisons. In sensitivity analysis of retreatment risk, PAE remained the most cost-effective strategy until its repeat treatment rates exceeded 2.30% per 6 months, at which point water vapor therapy became the optimal choice. PAE was the most cost-effective procedure when its procedural cost was lower than $4755. Aquablation and prostatic urethral lift became more cost-effective when their procedural costs were lower than $3015 and $1097, respectively. Conclusion This modeling-based study showed that PAE appears to be a cost-effective modality among medical management and MITs for patients with BPH, with comparable outcomes to prostatic urethral lift, water vapor therapy, and aquablation at a lower expected cost. © RSNA, 2023 Supplemental material is available for this article. See also the editorial by Gemmete in this issue.

Prostatic Artery Embolization Versus Transurethral Resection of the Prostate for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

PURPOSE

To compare the cost effectiveness of prostatic artery embolization (PAE) with that of transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP) for the treatment of medically refractory benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A cost-effectiveness analysis with Markov modeling was performed, comparing the clinical course after PAE with that after TURP for 3 years. Probabilities were obtained from the available literature, and costs were based on Medicare reimbursements and published cost analyses. Outcomes were measured using quality-adjusted life-year (QALY). Statistical analyses included base case calculation, probabilistic sensitivity analysis, and deterministic sensitivity analysis to assess the robustness of the conclusion under different clinical scenarios.

RESULTS

Base case calculation showed comparable outcomes (PAE, 2.845 QALY; TURP, 2.854 QALY), with a cost difference of $3,104 (PAE, $2,934; TURP, $6,038). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was $360,249/QALY. PAE was dominant in 23.2% and more cost effective in 48.4% of the probabilistic sensitivity analysis simulations. PAE was better if its recurrence risk was <20.4% per year and even when the TURP recurrence risk was assumed to be 0%. TURP would be more cost effective when its procedural cost was <$3,367 or the PAE procedural cost >$4,409. PAE remained cost effective when varying the risks and costs of the minor and major short-term or long-term adverse events of both procedures. TURP would be the better strategy if the utility of BPH recurrence was <0.85 QALY.

CONCLUSIONS

PAE is a cost-effective strategy to treat medically refractory BPH, resulting in comparable health benefits at a lower cost than that of TURP even when accounting for extreme alterations in adverse events, costs, and recurrence rates.

Large thrombosed portomesenteric venous aneurysm treated with pharmacomechanical thrombolysis combined with TIPS placement

Background

Aneurysms are rare anomalies of the portomesenteric venous system. Thrombotic complications of these lesions can lead to mesenteric venous ischemia and bowel infarction, potentially requiring surgical intervention. Herein we describe a case of mesenteric ischemia due to a large thrombosed portomesenteric aneurysm treated with endovascular techniques.

Case presentation

A 37-year-old previously healthy male who presented with abdominal pain to his local emergency department was found to have a thrombosed 12.0 × 5.1 cm portomesenteric venous aneurysm with evidence of mesenteric ischemia on CT. When conservative management with anticoagulation failed, transhepatic pharmacomechanical thrombolysis was initially performed. This was followed by TIPS placement with additional trans-TIPS thrombectomy to improve sluggish portal outflow and prevent re-thrombosis. The patient’s symptoms and imaging findings of ischemia resolved after endovascular therapy. No surgical intervention was required, and the patient was discharged on enoxaparin before being transitioned to apixaban. The TIPS remained patent at 2-year follow-up, with no change in the size of the aneurysm or re-thrombosis noted. The patient’s synthetic liver function was preserved with no evidence of hepatic encephalopathy during the follow-up period.

Conclusions

Endovascular therapies may be used to manage thrombotic complications of portomesenteric venous aneurysms, obviating the need for surgical intervention in selected patients.

Intracranial hemorrhage due to central venous occlusion from hemodialysis access: A case report

Central venous stenosis in hemodialysis patients rarely causes venous hypertension and intracranial hemorrhage. A 54 year-old male with right arm arteriovenous fistula was transferred to our institution in a comatose state following right parietal venous infarction. Fistulography showed right brachiocephalic vein (BCV) occlusion with reflux into the right transverse sinus and obstruction of left internal jugular vein outflow due to the styloid process. Balloon venoplasty of the right BCV occlusion failed to improve the patient's status because of the delayed diagnosis. Headaches and neurologic symptoms in hemodialysis patients can herald intracranial hypertension due to central venous occlusion and needs prompt assessment with fistulography.

Complications of Retrievable Inferior Vena Cava Filters: A Retrospective Comparison of Denali and Option-ELITE Filters

Purpose To compare the complication rate of the Denali and Option-ELITE inferior vena cava (IVC) filters.

Materials and Methods All patients who had a Denali or Option-ELITE IVC filter placed between March 2014 and March 2016 were retrospectively identified from the electronic medical records. Of the 245 IVC filters placed, the positions of 93 devices (21 Denali and 72 Option-ELITE) were documented on follow-up computed tomography (CT) examinations obtained for reasons unrelated to filter placement. In situations where multiple CT studies were obtained after placement, each study was reviewed, for a total of 200 examinations. Images were assessed for filter complication including caval wall penetration by filter components, associated damage to pericaval tissues, filter tilt, migration, and fracture.

Results Penetration of at least one strut was observed in 13% of all filters imaged by CT, (Denali: 14%; Option-ELITE: 13%; p = 1.00). No patients had damage to pericaval tissues or documented symptoms attributed to penetration. Neither the Denali nor the Option-ELITE filters demonstrated significant tilt (> 15 degrees of tilt), migration, or fracture. Compared with Denali; the Option-ELITE filter demonstrated an increasing strut penetration rate with longer indwell times (z = –3.67, p < 0.01).

Conclusions No significant difference was observed between the rates of caval penetration of the Denali and Option-ELITE IVC filters assessed by CT. Additionally, no findings of filter fracture or migration were noted, suggesting that the Denali filter is non-inferior to the Option-ELITE filter with respect to penetration, fracture, tilt, and migration. The Option-ELITE filter demonstrated a time-dependent tendency toward greater strut penetration with longer indwell times.

Radiation Dose Reduction during Uterine Fibroid Embolization Using an Optimized Imaging Platform

PURPOSE

To assess radiation dose reduction during uterine fibroid embolization (UFE) using an optimized angiographic processing and acquisition platform.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Radiation dose data for 70 women (mean age, 46 y; range, 34-67 y) who underwent UFE were retrospectively analyzed. Twenty-one patients underwent UFE using the baseline fluoroscopic and angiographic image acquisition platform, and 49 underwent UFE after implementing an optimized imaging platform in otherwise identical angiography suites. Cumulative kerma-area product (CKAP), cumulative air kerma (CAK), total fluoroscopy time, and image exposure number were collected for each procedure. Image quality was assessed by 3 interventional radiologists blinded to the platform used for image acquisition and processing.

RESULTS

Patients undergoing UFE using the new x-ray fluoroscopy platform had significantly lower CKAP and CAK indicators than patients for whom baseline settings were used. Mean CKAP decreased by 60% from 438.5 Gy · cm² (range, 180.3-1,081.1 Gy · cm²) to 175.2 Gy · cm² (range, 47.1-757.0 Gy · cm²; P < .0001). Mean CAK decreased by 45% from 2,034.2 mGy (range, 699.3-5,056.0 mGy) to 1,109.8 mGy (range, 256.6-4,513.6 mGy; P = .001). No degradation of image quality was identified through qualitative evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

Significant reduction in patient radiation dose indicators can be achieved with use of an optimized image acquisition and processing platform.

Catheter directed interventions for acute deep vein thrombosis

Venous thromboembolism (VTE) is an extremely common form of vascular disease and impacts a great number of patients worldwide. Acute deep vein thrombosis (DVT) is a subset of VTE and is traditionally been treated with anticoagulation. There is good quality data which suggests the use of catheter directed interventions for the treatment of acute DVT with the aim of reducing post-thrombotic syndrome (PTS). The present review will discuss the various therapies available for acute DVT, focusing on catheter directed interventions, ranging from traditional anticoagulation to the most novel forms of aspiration thrombectomy.

Computer-aided measurement of liver volumes in CT by means of geodesic active contour segmentation coupled with level-set algorithms

PURPOSE

Computerized liver extraction from hepatic CT images is challenging because the liver often abuts other organs of a similar density. The purpose of this study was to develop a computer-aided measurement of liver volumes in hepatic CT.

METHODS

The authors developed a computerized liver extraction scheme based on geodesic active contour segmentation coupled with level-set contour evolution. First, an anisotropic diffusion filter was applied to portal-venous-phase CT images for noise reduction while preserving the liver structure, followed by a scale-specific gradient magnitude filter to enhance the liver boundaries. Then, a nonlinear grayscale converter enhanced the contrast of the liver parenchyma. By using the liver-parenchyma-enhanced image as a speed function, a fast-marching level-set algorithm generated an initial contour that roughly estimated the liver shape. A geodesic active contour segmentation algorithm coupled with level-set contour evolution refined the initial contour to define the liver boundaries more precisely. The liver volume was then calculated using these refined boundaries. Hepatic CT scans of 15 prospective liver donors were obtained under a liver transplant protocol with a multidetector CT system. The liver volumes extracted by the computerized scheme were compared to those traced manually by a radiologist, used as "gold standard."

RESULTS

The mean liver volume obtained with our scheme was 1504 cc, whereas the mean gold standard manual volume was 1457 cc, resulting in a mean absolute difference of 105 cc (7.2%). The computer-estimated liver volumetrics agreed excellently with the gold-standard manual volumetrics (intraclass correlation coefficient was 0.95) with no statistically significant difference (F = 0.77; p(F < or = f) = 0.32). The average accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and percent volume error were 98.4%, 91.1%, 99.1%, and 7.2%, respectively. Computerized CT liver volumetry would require substantially less completion time (compared to an average of 39 min per case by manual segmentation).

CONCLUSIONS

The computerized liver extraction scheme provides an efficient and accurate way of measuring liver volumes in CT.