The Effect of Price on Surgeons' Choice of Implants: A Randomized Controlled Survey

PURPOSE

Surgical costs are under scrutiny and surgeons are being held increasingly responsible for cost containment. In some instances, implants are the largest component of total procedure cost, yet previous studies reveal that surgeons' knowledge of implant prices is poor. Our study aims to (1) understand drivers behind implant selection and (2) assess whether educating surgeons about implant costs affects implant selection.

METHODS

We surveyed 226 orthopedic surgeons across 6 continents. The survey presented 8 clinical cases of upper extremity fractures with history, radiographs, and implant options. Surgeons were randomized to receive either a version with each implant's average selling price ("price-aware" group), or a version without prices ("price-naïve" group). Surgeons selected a surgical implant and ranked factors affecting implant choice. Descriptive statistics and univariate, multivariable, and subgroup analyses were performed.

RESULTS

For cases offering implants within the same class (eg, volar locking plates), price-awareness reduced implant cost by 9% to 11%. When offered different models of distal radius volar locking plates, 25% of price-naïve surgeons selected the most expensive plate compared with only 7% of price-aware surgeons. For cases offering different classes of implants (eg, plate vs external fixator), there was no difference in implant choice between price-aware and price-naïve surgeons. Familiarity with the implant was the most common reason for choosing an implant in both groups (35% vs 46%). Price-aware surgeons were more likely to rank cost as a factor (29% vs 21%).

CONCLUSIONS

Price awareness significantly influences surgeons' choice of a specific model within the same implant class. Merely including prices with a list of implants leads surgeons to select less expensive implants. This implies that an untapped opportunity exists to reduce surgical expenditures simply by enhancing surgeons' cost awareness.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Economic/Decision Analyses I.

Distal Peripheral Nerve Blocks in the Forearm as an Alternative to Proximal Brachial Plexus Blockade in Patients Undergoing Hand Surgery: A Prospective and Randomized Pilot Study

PURPOSE

Limited data exist regarding the role of perineural blockade of the distal median, ulnar, and radial nerves as a primary anesthetic in patients undergoing hand surgery. We conducted a prospective and randomized pilot study to compare these techniques to brachial plexus blocks as a primary anesthetic in this patient population.

METHODS

Sixty patients scheduled for hand surgery were randomized to receive either an ultrasound-guided supraclavicular, infraclavicular, or axillary nerve block (brachial plexus blocks) or ultrasound-guided median, ulnar, and radial nerve blocks performed at the level of the mid to proximal forearm (forearm blocks). The ability to undergo surgery without analgesic or local anesthetic supplementation was the primary outcome. Block procedure times, postanesthesia care unit length of stay, instances of nausea/vomiting, and need for narcotic administration were also assessed.

RESULTS

The 2 groups were similar in terms of the need for conversion to general anesthesia or analgesic or local anesthetic supplementation, with only 1 patient in the forearm block group and 2 in the brachial plexus block group requiring local anesthetic supplementation or conversion to general anesthesia. Similar durations in surgical and tourniquet times were also observed. Both groups reported similarly low numerical rating scale pain scores as well as the need for postoperative analgesic administration (2 patients in the forearm block group and 1 in the brachial plexus block group reported numerical rating scale pain scores > 0 and required opioid administration in the postanesthesia care unit). Block procedure characteristics were similar between the 2 groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Forearm blocks may be used as a primary anesthetic in patients undergoing hand surgery. Further research is warranted to determine the appropriateness of these techniques in patients undergoing surgery in the thumb or proximal to the hand.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic II.

A MODIFIED TENSION BAND WIRING TECHNIQUE FOR TREATMENT OF THE BONY MALLET FINGER

Purpose: To report the outcomes of mallet fractures treated with our modified tension band wiring technique.

Methods: Eleven men and two women (mean age; 33 years) with mallet fractures in which happened more than five weeks before surgery, or with fracture fragments involving more than 2/3 or less than 1/3 of the distal phalanx articular surface or with previous surgical intervention, were subjected to this study. The fracture fragment was fixed with a modified tension band wiring technique using a stainless steel wire and an injection needle.

Results: All patients achieved bone union in nine weeks in average. All patients had no pain except one with mild pain. No patient showed a gap or step-off greater than 1 mm.

Conclusions: Our tension band wiring technique can be used regardless of the size of the dorsal fracture fragment or the interval between injury and surgery.

Minimally invasive reduction and osteosynthesis of articular fractures of the distal radius

Treatment of displaced fractures of the distal radius has changed over the course of time. For many years, closed reduction with plaster immobilization was considered the treatment of choice. Subsequent use of pins and plaster, percutaneous pin fixation, and the development of external fixation devices all contributed to improving fracture stability. More recently a new generation of external fixation devices has been developed to permit distraction and palmar translation. In addition, over the past twenty years, we have seen the development of more sophisticated internal fixation devices for the treatment of displaced fractures of the distal radius. The indications for open reduction and internal fixation have been defined largely on the basis of numerous studies which support the concept that articular malreduction is predictive of traumatic arthritis and poor functional result. Knirk and Jupiter have reported poor results for intra-articular fractures of the distal radius having an articular step-off greater than 2 mm. More recently, wrist arthroscopy has been used to improve visualization of articular surfaces and aid fracture reduction. In addition, bone grafting techniques have been employed more frequently to accelerate fracture healing. With improvement in techniques, we are able to provide our patients with better functional results and return them to their activities of daily living and vocation more rapidly.

Capitolunate arthrodesis with scaphoid and triquetrum excision

A retrospective two-center outcome study was designed to evaluate the results of capitolunate arthrodesis with scaphoid and triquetrum excision mainly for scapholunate advanced collapse patterns of arthritis. Fourteen wrists in 14 patients were evaluated objectively by standard parameters and subjectively by the Short Musculoskeletal Functional Assessment at an average of 28 months after surgery (range, 14-51 months). All patients were men between the ages of 20 and 70 years (average, 49 years). Two patients had a painful nonunion and one had persistent pain despite conversion to a solid wrist arthrodesis. One patient had x-ray evidence of progressive radiolunate narrowing, but only occasional pain. Postoperative wrist flexion-extension arc was 53 degrees and radioulnar deviation arc was 18 degrees. Grip and pinch strengths were 71% and 75%, respectively, of the normal contralateral wrist. The results of our study indicate that capitolunate arthrodesis with scaphoid and triquetrum excision is comparable to other motion-preserving operative procedures for scapholunate advance collapse.

Isolated nondisplaced capitate waist fracture diagnosed by magnetic resonance imaging

Isolated capitate fractures are rare and may be underdiagnosed, especially when fracture displacement is minimal or absent. Our case report of a nondisplaced capitate waist fracture exemplifies the need for careful evaluation because initial plain radiographs were considered normal and appropriate treatment was delayed. This report also documents the use of magnetic resonance imaging in diagnosing such fractures.

Men's changing social roles in the 1990s: emerging issues in the psychiatric treatment of men

In the last two decades, men's social roles have changed to incorporate the increasing time they spend with their families, their greater concern about adult children's leaving or returning home, and alternative sexual preferences and life-styles. One related development is the increased amounts of psychiatric distress reported by men in recent years. Mental health professionals should be familiar with these and other complex issues specific to men and with how such issues might manifest themselves in psychotherapy.

In vitro and in vivo evaluation of latex condoms using a two-phase nonoxynol 9 system

In vitro studies were carried out that indicated that a lubricant system consisting of 0.45 +/- 0.1 ml of silicon fluid containing 6.6% +/- 0.5% by volume of nonoxynol 9 and a spermicidal cream consisting of 0.45 +/- 0.1 ml made up of 63.4% polyethylene glycol 400 and 30.0% polyethylene glycol 3350 containing 6.6% +/- 0.5% nonoxynol 9 was effective in reducing sperm motility and viability. This system was tested in vivo with the use of simulated rupture techniques and was found to be equally as effective. Double-blind preference studies were carried out in vivo which showed that the condom system is convenient and comfortable to use, nonirritating to the vagina or urethral mucosa, and esthetically pleasing to the young, reproductive-age population.