Structure-Activity Relationship Study of an Alkynylphosphonate and Vynilphosphonate Analogues of Calcitriol

BACKGROUND

1α,25-dihydroxy vitamin D3 (calcitriol) shows potent growth-inhibitory properties on different cancer cell lines, but its hypercalcemic effects have severely hampered its therapeutic application. Therefore, it is important to develop synthetic calcitriol analogues that retain or even increase its antitumoral effects and lack hypercalcemic activity. Based on previous evidence of the potent antitumor effects of the synthetic alkynylphosphonate EM1 analogue, we have now synthesized a derivative called SG.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the present work is to evaluate the calcemic activity and the antitumor effect of SG, comparing these effects with those exerted by calcitriol and with those previously published for EM1. In addition, we propose to analyze by in silico studies, the chemical structure-biological function relationship of these molecules.

METHODS

We performed the synthesis of vinylphosphonate SG analogue; in vitro assays on different cancer cell lines; in vivo assays on mice; and in silico assays applying computational molecular modeling.

RESULTS

The SG compound lacks hypercalcemic activity, similar to the parent compound EM1. However, the antitumor activity was blunted, as no antiproliferative or anti-migratory effects were observed. By in silico assays, we demonstrated that SG analogue has a lower affinity for the VDRligand- binding domain than the EM1 compound due to lack of interaction with the important residues His305 and His397.

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate that the chemical modification in the lateral side chain of the SG analogue affects the antitumoral activity observed previously for EM1 but does not affect the calcemic activity. These results contribute to the rational design and synthesis of novel calcitriol analogues.

Phosphonate analogues of 1α, 25 dihydroxyvitamin D3 are promising candidates for antitumoural therapies

The active metabolite of vitamin D, 1α, 25 dihydroxyvitamin D3 (calcitriol) is classically known to regulate calcium and phosphate homeostasis and bone mineralization. In addition, calcitriol has also been documented to act as a potent anticancer agent in multiple cell culture and animal models of cancer. However, major side effects, such as hypercalcemia, hinder broad-spectrum therapeutic uses of calcitriol in cancer chemotherapy. Synthesis of calcitriol analogues with the same or increased antiproliferative and pro-differentiating activities, and with reduced undesired effects on calcium and bone metabolism, is getting significant attention towards rational therapeutics to treat cancer. In this regard, phosphonate analogues have been shown to display a certain degree of dissociation between the vitamin D activity in vitro and undesired hypercalcemia in vivo. However, few phosphonates have been described in the literature and fewer of them tested for antitumoral effects. Our group has synthesized a novel vitamin D analogue (EM1) bearing an alkynylphosphonate moiety that combines the low calcemic properties of phosphonates with the decreased metabolic inactivation due to the presence of a triple bond between C-23 and C-24. Biological assays demonstrated that this analogue has potent antiproliferative effects in a wide panel of tumour cell lines, even in those resistant to calcitriol treatment. Importantly, EM1 does not show toxic effects in animals, even administered at high doses and for extended periods of time. In the current review we discuss the effects and the potential application in cancer of vitamin D and its derivatives, with an emphasis on phosphonate analogues.

Novel alkynylphosphonate analogue of calcitriol with potent antiproliferative effects in cancer cells and lack of calcemic activity

Here, we describe the design and synthesis of diethyl [(5Z,7E)-(1S,3R)-1,3-dihydroxy-9,10-secochola-5,7,10(19)-trien-23-in-24-yl] phosphonate (compound 10), which combines the low calcemic properties of phosphonates with the decreased metabolic inactivation due to the presence of a triple bond in C-24 and studied its in vitro effects on several cancer cell lines and its in vivo effects on blood calcium levels. We demonstrate that this compound is a potent antiproliferative vitamin D analogue, showing lack of calcemic effects in vivo.