Long-term prevention of capsular opacification after lens-refilling surgery in a rabbit model

Purpose

To reduce capsular opacification by a peri‐surgical treatment of the lens capsule with drugs in an in vivo rabbit model. Lens‐refilling surgery is a potential therapeutic intervention to treat patients with a cataract lens. The lens material is replaced with an injectable (bio)polymer that retains the natural mechanical and optical lens properties, therewith allowing accommodation. The occurrence of capsular opacification mediated by lens epithelial cells negatively affects accommodation and vision and should be avoided in this lens restoration approach.

Methods

An in vivo rabbit animal model was used with lens replacement with a silicone‐based gel‐like polymer and concurrent treatment of the lens epithelium with drugs. A case‐study approach was applied as both drug combinations and implantation times were varied. The following drugs were investigated for their potential to prevent capsular opacification long‐term: actinomycin D, methotrexate, paclitaxel and Tween‐20. All were administered in a hyaluronic acid vehicle. The rabbits were clinically followed for periods up to 4 years postimplantation. Eyes, corneas and lenses were analysed post‐mortem using MRI and confocal microscopy.

Results

Treatment combinations containing actinomycin D generally led to the least appearance of capsular fibrosis. The use of Tween‐20 or paclitaxel without actinomycin D resulted in much earlier and pronounced fibrotic responses. The aspect of capsular opacification was highly variable in individual animals. Application of the drugs in a hyaluronic acid vehicle appeared to be a safe method that spared the corneal endothelium.

Conclusion

The feasibility of long‐term prevention of fibrosis over a period of more than 4 years has been demonstrated in lens refilling in the rabbit model.

Prevention of capsule opacification after accommodating lens refilling: pilot study of strategies evaluated in a monkey model

PURPOSE

To test 2 strategies to prevent capsule opacification after accommodating lens refilling in a rhesus monkey model.

SETTING

Animal laboratory and laboratory of European university medical centers.

DESIGN

Experimental study.

METHODS

Six rhesus monkeys had refilling of the lens capsular bag. In the first strategy, before it was filled with a silicone polymer, the capsular bag was treated with noncommercial sodium hyaluronate 1.0% containing cytotoxic substances. In the second strategy, the capsular bag was filled with clinically used sodium hyaluronate 1.0% (Healon) after treatment with actinomycin-D. Slitlamp inspection was performed during a follow-up of 40 to 50 weeks. After enucleation, magnetic resonance images were obtained and confocal fluorescence imaging was performed.

RESULTS

Using the first strategy, capsule opacification developed in all eyes. Using the second strategy, 1 monkey did not develop capsule opacification after a 9-month follow-up. In a second monkey, the lens capsule remained clear for 3 months, after which the hyaluronate refill material was exchanged with a silicone polymer and capsule opacification developed. Combining these results with those in a previous study, the difference in opacification between silicone and sodium hyaluronate as refilling materials was statistically significant (P<.01).

CONCLUSIONS

That no capsular bag fibrosis occurred in the presence of hyaluronate suggests that the properties of hyaluronate are the reason that remaining lens epithelial cells do not develop into fibrotic cells. The choice of a suitable lens-refilling material prevents the development of capsule opacification.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE

Mr. Terwee was an employee of Abbott Medical Optics B.V. during the study period. No other author has a financial or proprietary interest in any material or method mentioned.

[Optimisation of the visualisation technique for optical paths through intraocular lenses for characterisation of multifocal imaging properties of Fresnel-zone plates]

The utilisation of the diffractive properties of Fresnel zone plates offers the possibility of intraocular lens designs with multiple foci. Such intraocular lenses can be manufactured by two-photon polymerisation (2PP). This paper explains the underlying concept and shows the principles for visualisation of the focus properties of such implants.

[Effect of pseudophacic mini-monovision as an option for independence of spectacles in everyday life]

BACKGROUND

Modern day patients who undergo bilateral cataract surgery expect to be spectacles-independent after surgery. The options that are available to attain this goal are pseudophakic monovision, implanting multifocal IOLs or alternatively accommodative IOLs. The aim of this study is to establish the suitability in daily life when attaining minor monovision, named hereafter mini-monovision.

MATERIAL/METHODS

In this clinical retrospective study 30 patients were examined. These subjects where bilaterally pseudophake and received either AcrySof®-IOL or Acreos® Adapt-IOL with a slight anisometropia of between 0.5 and 1.75 D and with a maximal astigmatism up to 1.5 D. Visual acuity (VA) for distance (ETDRS), intermediate (Jaeger 80 cm) and near (Jaeger 40 cm) as well as defocus curves were assessed. Furthermore were examined: the reading speed using the font size of the Radner reading chart, anisoconia (FA Oculus according to Esser), stereopsis (Titmus), subjective patient satisfaction (adapted VF-14-questionnaire) and the subjective dependence on having to wear spectacles.

RESULTS

The median anisometropia was at 0.75 D; the age was between 61 and 80 (median being at 73 years). 12 patients were male and 18 female. When examined with binocular vision 100 % could attain distance VA of at least decimal 1.0 (LogMAR 0) and an intermediate VA of at least decimal 0.8 (LogMAR 0.1), up to 86.57 % a near VA of at least Jaeger 5, (LogMAR 0.4); up to 63.33 % even managed at least Jaeger 3 (LogMAR 0.3). The median average reading speed for binocular uncorrected reading under photopic conditions was 145 words/minute and under mesopic conditions 117 words/minute. The critical font size was LogRAD 0.60 (Jaeger 5-6), the anisoconia at 2 % and stereopsis at 80 arc seconds. The general dependence on glasses was reduced from 100 % preoperatively to 13 %, postoperatively. Simultaneously a high patient satisfaction score of 93.18 in the VF-14 questionnaire was attained. The result is comparable to those quoted in the literature on full monovision and mulitifocal IOLs.

CONCLUSION

To attain spectacles independency, pseudophake mini-monovision is a cost efficient alternative to multifocal lenses for well selected patients. A relative reduction in near VA must be taken into account. To establish the refractive target further examinations are required. Establishing the accurate depth of vision will be helpful in attaining this.

A comparative study on the viscoelastic properties of human and animal lenses

A new method of compression between two parallel plates is used to measure the viscoelastic properties of whole and decapsulated human lenses and compare them with other animal species. Compressive load relaxation was performed by deforming the lens by 10% and measuring the force relaxation response for 100 s to obtain thickness, stiffness and relaxation of the induced loading force and Maxwell parameters for human, monkey, porcine and leporine whole and decapsulated lenses. Thickness and percentage loading force relaxation increased linearly with lens age, whereas stiffness and induced loading force increased exponentially. Human and monkey lenses aged at different rates. Loading force relaxation in a generalized Maxwell model was described by three time constants ranging from 1 to 1000 s. Compressive load relaxation is a very versatile method to study the viscoelastic properties of whole and decapsulated lenses and potentially also artificial accommodating lenses. The data presented in the study will help researchers choose the most suitable animal lenses based on the desired properties and age to be mimicked from the human lenses.

Drug-induced secondary cataract prevention: experimental ex vivo and in vivo results with disulfiram, methotrexate and actinomycin D

BACKGROUND/AIMS

A clinical approach to prevent secondary cataract after lens implantation involves the intraocular application of pharmacological agents. The goals of our study were to develop an ex vivo model to test the drug effectiveness for lens epithelial cell ablation from the basal membrane and to verify the data in rabbit intraocular lens implantation experiments.

METHODS

Human capsular rhexis specimens were incubated with drugs and the residual cells were differentiated by use of the Live-Dead assay and quantified by staining with Hoechst dye. After phakoemulsification of rabbit eyes and before intraocular lens implantation, capsular bags were filled with drug-loaded hyaluronic acid for 5 min.

RESULTS

An ex vivo model was established which allows the testing of drugs on lens epithelial cell ablation. Drug treatment reduced the number of viable cells on the specimens drastically, ranging between 0.44 ± 0.53% (6.0 ± 7.3 cells/mm²) for disulfiram, 0.27 ± 0.50% (3.7 ± 6.9 cells/mm²) for methotrexate and 0.07 ± 0.19% (0.1 ± 0.27 cells/mm²) for actinomycin D. Rabbit eyes treated with a mixture of methotrexate/actinomycin D showed no posterior capsule opacification at 4 months and a low opacification 6 months postoperatively. Without drug treatment low opacification starts 6 weeks postoperatively.

CONCLUSIONS

The drug screening in the described ex vivo model can help to reduce the number of preclinical studies for secondary cataract prevention. The successful ex vivo cell ablation by methotrexate/actinomycin D was confirmed by a delayed in vivo secondary cataract formation.

Changes in spherical aberration after lens refilling with a silicone oil

PURPOSE

It may be possible to restore accommodation to presbyopic human eyes by refilling the lens capsular bag with a soft polymer. In the present study, optical changes were measured that occurred in a pig eye model after the refilling of the capsular bag.

METHODS

The optical power and spherical aberration in 10 isolated pig lenses were measured under different conditions. They were first determined by using a scanning laser ray-tracing technique over an effective pupil size of 6 mm. Second, the contours of the anterior and posterior lens surface were photographed, and a mathematical ray-tracing was performed by using a polynomial fit through the digitized surface contours, to determine optical power and spherical aberration. Third, the lenses were refilled with a silicone oil until their preoperative lens thickness was reached, and scanning laser ray-tracing, contour photography, and mathematical ray-tracing were repeated. Comparisons between the measurements were made to determine how the change from a gradient refractive index to a homogeneous refractive index influenced spherical aberration. The influence of the change in lens contour on spherical aberration after lens refilling was also studied.

RESULTS

The natural lenses had a higher lens power than the refilled lenses (49.9 +/- 1.5 D vs. 36.8 +/- 1.5 D; P < 0.001). Moreover, there was a change in sign from negative spherical aberration before lens refilling (-3.6 D) to positive spherical aberration after lens refilling (7.9 D; P < 0.001). The comparison between scanning laser ray-tracing of the natural lens and mathematical ray-tracing of the photographed surface contours of the natural lens to determine the effect of refractive index substitution (i.e., replacement of a gradient refractive index by a homogeneous refractive index) showed a significant change in spherical aberration from -3.6 +/- 2.0 to 11.0 +/- 2.1 D (P < 0.001). The change in lens contour did not result in a significant change in spherical aberration (P = 0.08) before and after lens refilling with an equal refractive index.

CONCLUSIONS

The lower lens power of refilled pig lenses compared to natural lenses was due to the lower refractive index of the refill material. Refilling pig lenses with the silicone oil used in this study resulted in an increase in spherical aberration. This increase was mainly caused by the change from a gradient refractive index to a homogeneous refractive index. The change in lens curvature after lens refilling did not result in an increase in spherical aberration. The influence of lens refilling on spherical aberration of human lenses must be determined in similar experiments in human eyes.

Accommodative lens refilling in rhesus monkeys

PURPOSE

Accommodation can be restored to presbyopic human eyes by refilling the capsular bag with a soft polymer. This study was conducted to test whether accommodation, measurable as changes in optical refraction, can be restored with a newly developed refilling polymer in a rhesus monkey model. A specific intra- and postoperative treatment protocol was used to minimize postoperative inflammation and to delay capsular opacification.

METHODS

Nine adolescent rhesus monkeys underwent refilling of the lens capsular bag with a polymer. In the first four monkeys (group A) the surgical procedure was followed by two weekly subconjunctival injections of corticosteroids. In a second group of five monkeys (group B) a treatment intended to delay the development of capsular opacification was applied during the surgery, and, in the postoperative period, eye drops and two subconjunctival injections of corticosteroids were applied. Accommodation was stimulated with carbachol iontophoresis or pilocarpine and was measured with a Hartinger refractometer at regular times during a follow-up period of 37 weeks in five monkeys. In one monkey, lens thickness changes were measured with A-scan ultrasound.

RESULTS

In group A, refraction measurement was possible in one monkey. In the three other animals in group A, postoperative inflammation and capsular opacification prevented refraction measurements. In group B, the maximum accommodative amplitude of the surgically treated eyes was 6.3 D. In three monkeys the accommodative amplitude decreased to almost 0 D after 37 weeks. In the two other monkeys, the accommodative amplitude remained stable at +/-4 D during the follow-up period. In group B, capsular opacification developed in the postoperative period, but refraction measurements could still be performed during the whole follow-up period of 37 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

A certain level of accommodation can be restored after lens refilling in adolescent rhesus monkeys. During the follow-up period refraction measurements were possible in all five monkeys that underwent the treatment designed to prevent inflammation and capsular opacification.

Development of an accommodating intra-ocular lens--in vitro prevention of re-growth of pig and rabbit lens capsule epithelial cells

Cataract surgery is routinely performed to replace the clouded lens by a rigid polymeric intra-ocular lens unable to accommodate. By implanting a silicone gel into an intact capsular bag the accommodating properties of the natural lens can be maintained or enhanced. The implantation success of accommodating lenses is hampered by the occurrence of capsular opacification (PCO) due to lens epithelial cell (LEC) growth. In order to prevent LEC proliferation, a treatment regime using actinomycin D, cycloheximide and water was developed. The effectiveness of treatment was analyzed using an in vitro, MTT-based cell culture system and an ex vivo pig eye model in which the implanted lens-in-the-bag is cultured as a whole. LEC were exposed to treatment solutions for 5 min, then the cells were allowed to recover and to re-colonize the substratum. MTT conversion by cells was transiently inhibited by cycloheximide dissolved in water and by water alone. Exposure to actinomycin D resulted in a lasting inhibition of MTT conversion and consequently cell proliferation. These in vitro data could not be fully reproduced in the ex vivo pig eye model due to essential differences between both models. Treatment with actinomycin D containing solutions, however, resulted in a nearly complete absence of cells on the capsular wall. The pig eye model is a promising approach to further evaluate the effects of peri-surgical treatment during the accommodating intra-ocular lens implantation.

Artificial crystalline lens

If presbyopia is caused by hardening of the crystalline lens, replacing it with a material with mechanical properties similar to the young crystalline lens should restore accommodative ability. Such a silicone material has been developed. Refilling the capsular bag with this material results in 3 to 5 D of accommodation in primates in response to pilocarpine.

Comparison of the accommodation theories of Coleman and of Helmholtz by finite element simulations

PURPOSE

The accommodation process of the human eye is still a controversial subject. Coleman assumes that the lens, together with the zonula fibers, forms a diaphragm which is held in a catenary shape due to the pressure difference between the aqueous and vitreous body of the lens. The aim of the paper is to compare the results of two simulations (according to the Helmholtz and to the Coleman theories) with ultrasonographic data.

METHODS

An axisymmetric static finite element model of the lens was generated using the literature data for geometry, material properties and loads. The refractive power of the lens was calculated for two different ages (29 and 45 years).

RESULTS

The application of a pressure to the posterior lens surface did not yield an increase in refractive power change during accommodation. Rather a decrease in accommodation related refractive power was found.

CONCLUSIONS

Physiologically relevant refractive power changes are obtained by a simulation in accordance with the Helmholtz theory. A simulation in accordance with the Coleman theory does not yield physiological values of refractive power change.

Relation between injected volume and optical parameters in refilled isolated porcine lenses

PURPOSE

This study was performed to elucidate the correlation between added lens refill material and enhanced lens power as well as the correlation between lens refilling volume and accommodative amplitude as determined by equatorial stretching of ex vivo refilled pigs' lenses.

METHODS

Nine porcine lenses were refilled with increasing amounts of silicone oil. After each refill step, the lens power, the lens power change, and the lens thickness were measured both in the relaxed state and with a 3-mm larger ciliary body diameter. In addition, the spherical aberration of the refilled lenses was also quantified.

RESULTS

Injection of 0.04 mL silicone material into the relaxed lens enhanced the lens power by 1 D. A 0.54-mm increase of the lens thickness in relaxed lenses added 1 D to the lens power. Increasing the lens refilling volume decreased the lens power changes measured at 3-mm ciliary body stretch. Spherical aberration was positive in the refilled lenses and increased with increasing lens refilling volume.

CONCLUSION

The correlation found between the refilling volume and the lens power (0.04 mL D(-1)), as well as the correlation between the lens thickness and the lens power (0.54 mm D(-1)), might be important factors to be controlled in conjunction with surgery, as these also determine the lens power in the presence of this refill material. An increasing lens filling volume is associated with decreasing accommodative amplitude. The positive spherical aberration of refilled porcine lenses presents a sharp contrast to the negative aberration of natural pigs' lenses. Different lens contours and the transition from a gradient to a homogeneous refractive index might be responsible for this change in spherical aberration.

Effect of infusion bottle height on lens power after lens refilling with and without a plug

PURPOSE

To evaluate the influence of intraoperative infusion bottle height on the power of refilled pig lenses.

SETTING

Research Laboratory, Pharmacia Intraocular Lens Manufacturing Plant, Groningen, The Netherlands.

METHODS

This study comprised 2 groups of pig eyes. In 1 group, the lens was refilled with silicone oil using a plug to close the capsulorhexis; in the other group, no plug was used. The anterior chamber depth, lens thickness, and vitreous chamber depth were measured by A-scan ultrasound. The total refraction was measured with a Hartinger refractometer. Measurements were performed with the infusion bottle at 0 cm, 25 cm, 50 cm, 75 cm, and 100 cm above eye level. Calculations using a model eye were performed to evaluate the change in lens power based on empirical data.

RESULTS

The mean change in the power of refilled lenses caused by varying the height of the infusion bottle was 1.8 diopters. Lenses refilled with a plug had a thickness similar to that of natural lenses. Lenses refilled without a plug were significantly thinner (P<.05). The power of lenses refilled with a plug was significantly higher that of lenses refilled without a plug (P<.05).

CONCLUSIONS

During lens refilling, infusion bottle height influenced the resulting lens power. Using a plug to close the capsulorhexis resulted in refilled lens dimensions similar to those of the natural lens.

Polymer refilling of presbyopic human lenses in vitro restores the ability to undergo accommodative changes

PURPOSE

Because presbyopia is thought to be accompanied by increased lens sclerosis this study was conducted to investigate whether refilling the capsule of the presbyopic human lens with a soft polymer would restore the ability of the lens to undergo accommodative changes.

METHODS

Accommodative forces were applied to natural and refilled lenses by circumferential stretching through the ciliary body and zonular complex. Nine natural lenses and 10 refilled lenses from donors ranging in age from 17 to 60 years were studied. Two refill polymers with a different Young's modulus were used. The lens power was measured by a scanning laser ray-tracing technique, and lens diameter and lens thickness were measured simultaneously while the tension on the zonules was increased stepwise by outward pull on the ciliary body.

RESULTS

In the natural lenses the older lenses were not able to undergo power changes with stretching of the ciliary body, whereas in the refilled lenses, all lenses showed power changes comparable to young, natural lenses. The refilled human lenses had a higher lens power than the age-matched natural lenses. The Young's modulus of the polymers influenced the lens power change when measured with the ciliary body diameter increased by 4 mm.

CONCLUSIONS

Refilling presbyopic lenses with a soft polymer enabled restoration of lens power changes with mechanical stretching. Because sclerosis of the lens is an important factor in human presbyopia, refilling the lens during lens surgery for cataract could enable restoration of clear vision and accommodation in human presbyopia.

Monitoring accommodative ciliary muscle function using three-dimensional ultrasound

BACKGROUND

Our objective was to develop a three-dimensional high-resolution ultrasonic imaging technique to be utilized for in-vivo characterization of the ciliary body and the posterior iris. The benefit of this imaging in enhancing the quantification of the configurational changes in the ciliary body during accommodation is demonstrated.

METHODS

Sequential ultrasound biomicroscopic images of the ciliary body region were obtained with a computer-controlled scanning device designed for use with a standard ultrasound biomicroscope for 3D imaging. Custom-made software allows online data collection, data analysis and 3D reconstruction in conjunction with commercially available VoxelView software.

RESULTS

The three-dimensional presentation allows a close approximation of the ciliary muscle inside the ciliary body in vivo. We are able to distinguish and to analyze the changes in the muscle contour in different accommodation states. During accommodation a shift in the ciliary muscle center of gravity in a range of 0.04-0.26 mm (mean 0.13+/-0.06 mm) in the direction of the lens equator, with an interindividual variation and a small decrease with age, was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

High-resolution ultrasound is a well established technique for in-vivo investigation of the anterior segment. Three-dimensional ultrasound biomicroscopy allows an assessment of the individual ciliary muscle activity in consideration of the ciliary processes. In combination with a contour analysis tool we improved the muscle contour determination during different accommodation states. The investigation showed an activity of the ciliary muscle in young volunteers as well as those of presbyopic age.

[Analysis of the dynamics of the ciliary muscle during accommodation]

BACKGROUND

The magnitude of anterioaxial shift of the human ciliary muscle during accommodation and its ceasing of ciliary function with advanced age are still unknown.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total 105 patients (aged 10-91 years) were examined by high-resolution ultrasound biomicroscopy during disaccommodation and voluntary accommodation. Accommodative changes in the total area of the ciliary muscle and in the outer contour were quantified with a specially developed software program for automatic contour determination.

RESULTS

A significant anterior shift independent of age was observed in the total area of the ciliary muscle and defined points on the outer contour of the muscle in the range of 56-121 microns, while the inward displacement was less obvious. A decrease in the magnitude of configurational changes during accommodation was observed with age.

CONCLUSION

The new software program could be useful in further investigations of the accommodative process and evaluation of the potential causes of presbyopia.