Grading of Radiographic Osteolytic Changes after Silastic Metacarpophalangeal Arthroplasty and a Prospective Trial of Osteolysis Following Use of Swanson and Sutter Prostheses

The purpose of this study was to compare the incidence of radiographic osteolysis following insertion of 89 Swanson and 126 Sutter metacarpophalangeal implants in rheumatoid arthritis patients. The mean follow-up time in the two groups of patients was 57 (40–80) and 55 (36–79) months, respectively. This paper proposes a new method of classifying radiographic osteolysis. The remarkable number of osteolytic changes seen in the bones adjacent to MCP prostheses in this study would suggest that silastic prostheses should only be used when other surgical alternatives cannot be used and that long-term control by radiography be maintained after implantation of silicone prostheses into the MCP joint. In all grades of our classification, osteolysis was more frequent in the Sutter than in the Swanson group in this study, suggesting that use of the Sutter rather than the Swanson implant is questionable.

Survival and complications are similar after Swanson and Sutter implant replacement of metacarpophalangeal joints in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

We compared the survival, fracture, and deformation rates of Swanson and Sutter implants in a prospective series of 53 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Fifty-eight hands were operated on with 215 silastic implants. The Swanson group comprised 25 hands and 89 implants, and the Sutter group 33 and 126, respectively. Follow up was 58 (37-80) months. During a period of 48 months the survival of Swanson and Sutter prostheses did not differ significantly: 92% (95% CI 84% to 96%) and 97% (95% CI 92% to 99%), respectively. The fracture rate was high in both groups: 26 (34%) in the Swanson and 25 (26%) in the Sutter group. There was no significant difference between the groups in definite fracture rates of implants. The Sutter prosthesis appears to be at least as durable an implant in rheumatoid patients' metacarpophalangeal arthroplasty as the Swanson.