Comparison of partial and modified radical mastectomy in the community setting--"10 years later"

Conservative surgery followed by postoperative radiation is considered equivalent to a modified radical mastectomy (MRM) for the treatment of early breast cancer. It cannot be assumed that results from selected academic centres are equivalent to those obtained in the general community setting, because there may be differences in patient selection or surgical or radiotherapy techniques that may adversely affect outcome. A quality-control study of women who were seen at the British Columbia Cancer Agency and were treated by partial mastectomy (PM) was begun in 1983. Eighty-four women who underwent conservative surgery between January 1979 and November 1982 and were referred to the British Columbia Cancer Agency were matched with 84 women who underwent MRM. The mean follow-up was 10.5 years. At 10 years disease-free survival in both groups was 63%. Survival overall for the PM group was 72.6% and for the MRM group was 69%. The survival rate decreased with increasing size of the tumour and increasing number of nodes. In women with lymph-node involvement there was a survival advantage for those treated by PM and radiation compared with those treated by MRM. The woman's age at diagnosis did not affect these findings. Recurrence and complication rates were similar in both groups, and treatment was considered equivalent.

Combined modality therapy of Hodgkin's disease: 10-year results of National Cancer Institute of Canada Clinical Trials Group multicenter clinical trial

The purpose of this study was to compare four methods of treatment for stage III-IV Hodgkin's disease. Between January 1972 and September 1976, 266 patients with stage IIIB, IVA, and IVB Hodgkin's disease from 21 cancer treatment centers across Canada were registered as eligible; 40 were found to be ineligible. Of the 226 remaining patients, only seven were followed for less than 10 years. All patients received three courses of mechlorethamine, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone (MOPP) chemotherapy, which induced a complete response (CR) in 36%; an additional 42% obtained adequate disease control. Patients were randomly assigned to (1) treatment with radiation to the abdomen and mantle (group AX3, 62 patients) or (2) continue their treatment with an additional three courses of MOPP (group A, 105 patients). For the A group, a second randomization took place 3 months later (regardless of status at that time) to (1) no further treatment (AC6, 23 patients), (2) radiotherapy to the abdomen and mantle (AX6, 48 patients), or (3) maintenance chemotherapy at 3-month intervals for 1 year (AC10, 26 patients). The survival of AX3 patients was somewhat better than for the A group, but the difference was not significant (P = .0565). However, there was a significant interaction (P = .0029) between age and treatment, so that among patients less than 30 years of age, the survival of the A group was better, whereas for older patients, treatment with AX3 resulted in improved survival. Age itself remained a significant prognostic factor for survival after controlling for the amount of radiotherapy delivered to the abdomen and the dose intensity of vincristine for the first three courses of chemotherapy. The addition of radiation therapy to MOPP significantly reduced the frequency of nodal relapses. These results suggest that combined modality therapy may be beneficial for some patients with Hodgkin's disease and that age must be carefully considered in interpreting the results of clinical trials in Hodgkin's disease.