Phylogenomics and plastomics offer new evolutionary perspectives on Kalanchoideae (Crassulaceae)

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Kalanchoideae is one of three subfamilies within Crassulaceae and contains four genera. Despite previous efforts, the phylogeny of Kalanchoideae remains inadequately resolved with persistent issues including low support, unstructured topologies and polytomies. This study aimed to address two central objectives: (1) resolving the pending phylogenetic questions within Kalanchoideae by using organelle-scale 'barcodes' (plastomes) and nuclear data; and (2) investigating interspecific diversity patterns among Kalanchoideae plastomes.

METHODS

To explore the plastome evolution in Kalanchoideae, we newly sequenced 38 plastomes representing all four constituent genera (Adromischus, Cotyledon, Kalanchoe and Tylecodon). We performed comparative analyses of plastomic features, including GC and gene contents, gene distributions at the IR (inverted repeat) boundaries, nucleotide divergence, plastomic tRNA (pttRNA) structures and codon aversions. Additionally, phylogenetic inferences were inferred using both the plastomic dataset (79 genes) and nuclear dataset (1054 genes).

KEY RESULTS

Significant heterogeneities were observed in plastome lengths among Kalanchoideae, strongly correlated with LSC (large single copy) lengths. Informative diversities existed in the gene content at SSC/IRa (small single copy/inverted repeat a), with unique patterns individually identified in Adromischus leucophyllus and one major Kalanchoe clade. The ycf1 gene was assessed as a shared hypervariable region among all four genera, containing nine lineage-specific indels. Three pttRNAs exhibited unique structures specific to Kalanchoideae and the genera Adromischus and Kalanchoe. Moreover, 24 coding sequences revealed a total of 41 lineage-specific unused codons across all four constituent genera. The phyloplastomic inferences clearly depicted internal branching patterns in Kalanchoideae. Most notably, by both plastid- and nuclear-based phylogenies, our research offers the first evidence that Kalanchoe section Eukalanchoe is not monophyletic.

CONCLUSIONS

This study conducted comprehensive analyses on 38 newly reported Kalanchoideae plastomes. Importantly, our results not only reconstructed well-resolved phylogenies within Kalanchoideae, but also identified highly informative unique markers at the subfamily, genus and species levels. These findings significantly enhance our understanding of the evolutionary history of Kalanchoideae.

Plastome evolution of Aeonium and Monanthes (Crassulaceae): insights into the variation of plastomic tRNAs, and the patterns of codon usage and aversion

This study reported 13 new plastomes from Aeonium and Monanthes, and observed new markers for phylogeny and DNA barcoding, such as novel tRNA structures and codon usage bias and aversion. The Macaronesian clade of Crassulaceae consists of three genera: Aichryson, with about 15 species; Monanthes, with about 10 species; Aeonium, with about 40 species. Within this clade, Aeonium, known as "the botanical equivalent of Darwin's finches", is regarded as an excellent model plant for researching adaptive evolution. Differing from the well-resolved relationships among three genera of the Macaronesian clade, the internal branching patterns within the genus Aeonium are largely unclear. In this study, we first reported 13 new plastomes from genus Aeonium and the closely related genus Monanthes. We further performed comprehensive analyses of the plastomes, with focuses on the secondary structures of pttRNAs and the patterns of codon usage and aversion. With a typical circular and quadripartite structure, the 13 plastomes ranged from 149,900 to 151,030 bp in size, and the unique pattern in IR junctions might become a family-specific marker for Crassulaceae species. Surprisingly, the π values of plastomes from Monanthes were almost twice those from Aeonium. Most importantly, we strongly recommend that highly polymorphic regions, novel putative pttRNA structures, patterns of codon usage bias and aversion derived from plastomes might have phylogenetic implications, and could act as new markers for DNA barcoding of plants. The results of phylogenetic analyses strongly supported a clear internal branching pattern in Macaronesian clade (represented by Aeonium and Monanthes), with higher nodal support values. The findings reported here will provide new insights into the variation of pttRNAs, and the patterns of codon usage and aversion of the family Crassulaceae.

Evolutionary characteristics and phylogeny of cotton chloroplast tRNAs

The novel structural variations were identified in cotton chloroplast tRNAs and gene loss events were more obvious than duplications in chloroplast tRNAs. Transfer RNAs (tRNA) have long been believed an evolutionary-conserved molecular family, which play the key roles in the process of protein biosynthesis in plant life activities. In this study, we detected the evolutionary characteristics and phylogeny of chloroplast tRNAs in cotton plants, an economic and fibered important taxon in the world. We firstly annotated the chloroplast tRNAs of 27 Gossypium species to analyze their genetic composition, structural characteristics and evolution. Compared with the traditional view of evolutionary conservation of tRNA, some novel tRNA structural variations were identified in cotton plants. I.g., tRNA^Val-UAC and tRNA^Ile-GAU only contained one intron in the anti-condon loop region of tRNA secondary structure, respectively. In the variable region, some tRNAs contained a circle structure with a few nucleotides. Interestingly, the calculation result of free energy indicated that the variation of novel tRNAs contributed to the stability of tRNA structure. Phylogenetic analysis suggested that chloroplast tRNAs have evolved from multiple common ancestors, and the tRNA^Met seemed to be an ancestral tRNA, which can be duplicated and diversified to produce other tRNAs. The chloroplast tRNAs contained a group I intron in cotton plants, and the evolutionary analysis of introns indicated that group I intron of chloroplast tRNA originated from cyanobacteria. Analysis of gene duplication and loss events showed that gene loss events were more obvious than duplications in Gossypium chloroplast tRNAs. Additionally, we found that the rate of transition was higher than the ones of transversion in cotton chloroplast tRNAs. This study provided new insights into the structural characteristics and evolution of chloroplast tRNAs in cotton plants.

Evolution and structural variations in chloroplast tRNAs in gymnosperms

Background

Chloroplast transfer RNAs (tRNAs) can participate in various vital processes. Gymnosperms have important ecological and economic value, and they are the dominant species in forest ecosystems in the Northern Hemisphere. However, the evolution and structural changes in chloroplast tRNAs in gymnosperms remain largely unclear.

Results

In this study, we determined the nucleotide evolution, phylogenetic relationships, and structural variations in 1779 chloroplast tRNAs in gymnosperms. The numbers and types of tRNA genes present in the chloroplast genomes of different gymnosperms did not differ greatly, where the average number of tRNAs was 33 and the frequencies of occurrence for various types of tRNAs were generally consistent. Nearly half of the anticodons were absent. Molecular sequence variation analysis identified the conserved secondary structures of tRNAs. About a quarter of the tRNA genes were found to contain precoded 3′ CCA tails. A few tRNAs have undergone novel structural changes that are closely related to their minimum free energy, and these structural changes affect the stability of the tRNAs. Phylogenetic analysis showed that tRNAs have evolved from multiple common ancestors. The transition rate was higher than the transversion rate in gymnosperm chloroplast tRNAs. More loss events than duplication events have occurred in gymnosperm chloroplast tRNAs during their evolutionary process.

Conclusions

These findings provide novel insights into the molecular evolution and biological characteristics of chloroplast tRNAs in gymnosperms.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12864-021-08058-3.

Structural variation and evolution of chloroplast tRNAs in green algae

As one of the important groups of the core Chlorophyta (Green algae), Chlorophyceae plays an important role in the evolution of plants. As a carrier of amino acids, tRNA plays an indispensable role in life activities. However, the structural variation of chloroplast tRNA and its evolutionary characteristics in Chlorophyta species have not been well studied. In this study, we analyzed the chloroplast genome tRNAs of 14 species in five categories in the green algae. We found that the number of chloroplasts tRNAs of Chlorophyceae is maintained between 28-32, and the length of the gene sequence ranges from 71 nt to 91 nt. There are 23-27 anticodon types of tRNAs, and some tRNAs have missing anticodons that are compensated for by other types of anticodons of that tRNA. In addition, three tRNAs were found to contain introns in the anti-codon loop of the tRNA, but the analysis scored poorly and it is presumed that these introns are not functional. After multiple sequence alignment, the Ψ-loop is the most conserved structural unit in the tRNA secondary structure, containing mostly U-U-C-x-A-x-U conserved sequences. The number of transitions in tRNA is higher than the number of transversions. In the replication loss analysis, it was found that green algal chloroplast tRNAs may have undergone substantial gene loss during the course of evolution. Based on the constructed phylogenetic tree, mutations were found to accompany the evolution of the Green algae chloroplast tRNA. Moreover, chloroplast tRNAs of Chlorophyceae are consistent with those of monocotyledons and gymnosperms in terms of evolutionary patterns, sharing a common multi-phylogenetic pattern and rooted in a rich common ancestor. Sequence alignment and systematic analysis of tRNA in chloroplast genome of Chlorophyceae, clarified the characteristics and rules of tRNA changes, which will promote the evolutionary relationship of tRNA and the origin and evolution of chloroplast.