Modelling the relationships between haemoglobin oxygen affinity and the oxygen cascade in humans

KEY POINTS

Haemoglobin affinity is an integral concept in exercise physiology that impacts oxygen uptake, delivery and consumption. How chronic alterations in haemoglobin affinity impact physiology is unknown. Using human haemoglobin variants, we demonstrate that the affinity of haemoglobin for oxygen is highly correlated with haemoglobin concentration. Using the Fick equation, we model how altered haemoglobin affinity and the associated haemoglobin concentration influences oxygen consumption at rest and during exercise via alterations in cardiac output and mixed-venous P O 2 . The combination of low oxygen affinity haemoglobin and reduced haemoglobin concentration seen in vivo may be unable to support oxygen uptake during moderate or heavy exercise.

ABSTRACT

The physiological implications, with regard to exercise, of altered haemoglobin affinity for oxygen are not fully understood. Data from the Mayo Clinic Laboratories database of rare human haemoglobin variants reveal a strong inverse correlation (r = -0.82) between blood haemoglobin concentration and P₅₀ , an index of oxygen affinity [Hb = -0.3135(P₅₀ ) + 23.636]. In the present study, observed P₅₀ values for high, normal and low oxygen-affinity haemoglobin variants (13, 26 and 39 mmHg) and corresponding haemoglobin concentrations (19.5, 15.5 and 11.4 g dL^-1 respectively) are used to model oxygen consumption as a fraction of delivery at rest ( V ̇ O 2  = 0.25 L min^-1 , cardiac output = 5.70 L min^-1 ) and during exercise ( V ̇ O 2  = 2.75 L min^-1 , cardiac output = 18.9 l min^-1 ). With high-affinity haemoglobin, the model shows that normal levels of oxygen consumption can be achieved at rest and during exercise at the assumed cardiac output levels, with reduced oxygen extraction both at rest (16.8% high affinity vs. 21.7% normal) and during exercise (55.8% high affinity vs. 72.2% normal). With low-affinity haemoglobin, which predicts low haemoglobin concentration, oxygen consumption at rest can be sustained with the assumed cardiac output, with increased oxygen extraction (31.1% low affinity vs. 21.7% normal). However, exercise at 2.75 l min^-1 cannot be achieved with the assumed cardiac output, even with 100% oxygen extraction. In conclusion, the model indicates chronic alterations in P₅₀ associate directly with Hb concentration, highlighting that human Hb variants can serve as 'experiments of nature' to address fundamental hypotheses on oxygen transport and exercise.

Restoring pulsatility and peakVO2 in the era of continuous flow, fixed pump speed, left ventricular assist devices: 'A hypothesis of pump's or patient's speed?'

Despite significant improvement in survival and functional capacity after continuous flow left ventricular assist device implantation, the patient's quality of life may remain limited by complications such as aortic valve insufficiency, thromboembolic episodes and gastrointestinal bleeding attributed to high shear stress continuous flow with attenuated or absence of pulsatile flow and by a reduced peak oxygen consumption (peakVO₂) primarily associated with a fixed pump speed operation. Revision of current evidence suggests that high technology pump speed algorithms, a 'hypothesis of decreasing pump's speed' to promote pulsatile flow and a 'hypothesis of increasing pump's speed' to increase peakVO₂, may only partially reverse these barriers. A 'hypothesis of increasing patient's speed' is introduced, suggesting that exercise training may further contribute to the patient's recovery, enhancing peakVO₂ and pulsatile flow by improving skeletal muscle oxidative capacity and strength, peripheral vasodilatory and ventilatory responses, favour changes in preload/afterload and facilitate native flow, formulating the rationale for further studies in the field.

Difference in Physiological Components of VO2 Max During Incremental and Constant Exercise Protocols for the Cardiopulmonary Exercise Test

[Purpose] VO₂ is expressed as the product of cardiac output and O₂ extraction by the Fick equation. During the incremental exercise test and constant high-intensity exercise test, VO₂ results in the attainment of maximal O₂ uptake at exhaustion. However, the differences in the physiological components, cardiac output and muscle O₂ extraction, have not been fully elucidated. We tested the hypothesis that constant exercise would result in higher O₂ extraction than incremental exercise at exhaustion. [Subjects] Twenty-five subjects performed incremental exercise and constant exercise at 80% of their peak work rate. [Methods] Ventilatory, cardiovascular, and muscle oxygenation responses were measured using a gas analyzer, Finapres, and near-infrared spectroscopy, respectively. [Results] VO₂ was not significantly different between the incremental exercise and constant exercise. However, cardiac output and muscle O₂ saturation were significantly lower for the constant exercise than the incremental exercise at the end of exercise. [Conclusion] These findings indicate that if both tests produce a similar VO₂ value, the VO₂ in incremental exercise would have a higher ratio of cardiac output than constant exercise, and VO₂ in constant exercise would have a higher ratio of O₂ extraction than incremental exercise at the end of exercise.