Meta-analysis of radiocesium contamination data in Japanese cedar and cypress forests over the period 2011-2017

Since Fukushima accident, dozens of field studies have been conducted in order to quantify and understand the behaviour of atmospheric radiocesium (¹³⁷Cs) fallouts in contaminated forests of Fukushima and neighbouring prefectures. In this paper, we carry out a detailed review of data acquired over 2011-2017 in Japanese cedar and cypress plantations, focusing on aerial tree organs, soil layers and tree-to-soil depuration fluxes. To enable comparison and reinforce the consistency between sites, radiological measurements were normalized by the deposit and interpolated onto the same spatio-temporal frame. Despite some (poorly explained) residual variability, we derived a "mean" pattern by log-averaging data among sites. These "mean" results were analysed with the help of a simple mass-balance approach and discussed in the light of post-Fukushima literature. We demonstrated that the activity levels and dynamics in all compartments were consistent and generally well reproduced by the mass balance approach, for values of the interception fraction between 0.7 and 0.85. The analysis indicated that about 5% of the initial deposit remained in the aerial vegetation after 6 years, more than two thirds of intercepted ¹³⁷Cs being transferred to the soil due to throughfall. The simulations indicated that foliar uptake might have contributed between 40% and 100% to the activity transferred to stem wood. The activity concentration in canopy organs rapidly decreased in the first few months then more slowly, according to an effective half-life of about 1.6 years. The activity level in the organic layer peaked in summer 2011 then decreased according to an effective half-life of 2.2 years. After a rapid increase in 2011, the contamination of mineral horizons continued to increase more slowly, 85% of ¹³⁷Cs incoming through the organic layer being retained in the 0-5 cm layer according to a mean residence time longer than in the upper layer (7 against 1.5 years).

Meta-analysis of radiocesium contamination data in Japanese forest trees over the period 2011-2013

The fate and dispersion of radiocesium in forests affected by the Fukushima atmospheric fallouts have been efficiently characterized by Japanese scientists thanks to monitoring surveys of radioactive contents in contaminated soil, water, and vegetation samples at numerous sites. In this paper, we carry out a meta-analysis of the field surveys conducted over the period 2011-2013 in evergreen coniferous and deciduous broadleaf forests of Fukushima or neighboring prefectures. The review focuses on contamination data acquired in tree vegetation - about 1500 spatio-temporal measurements of concentrations, inventories and depuration fluxes - with a particular interest for organs that were directly exposed to the atmospheric fallouts and subjected to depuration mechanisms (foliage, branches and outer bark). To reduce the spatial variability between the sites, radioactive data were normalized by the total deposit estimated at each site. Our analysis highlights the overall consistency of field observations despite the variety of experimental protocols, disparate sampling periods, differences in the forest stand characteristics and variability of the atmospheric deposition conditions. Assuming that the sites conformed to the same dynamics (within the range of residual variability), we then derive, discuss, and compare the mean representative evolutions of radiocesium contamination in the two categories of forest. Thanks to a simple mass balance approach, we finally demonstrate that: (i) about 90% of the radiocesium deposit was intercepted by evergreen coniferous vegetation, (ii) 80% of the deposit was gradually transferred to the forest floor in 3years, according to a well characterized depuration kinetics, and (iii) about 4% was readily absorbed by the foliage and translocated to internal organs (inner bark, stem wood and roots) at a rate of about 10^-4d^-1.