Cost-effectiveness of point-of-care viscoelastic haemostatic assays in the management of bleeding during cardiac surgery: protocol for a prospective multicentre pragmatic study with stepped-wedge cluster randomised controlled design and 1-year follow-up (the IMOTEC study)

INTRODUCTION

During cardiac surgery-associated bleeding, the early detection of coagulopathy is crucial. However, owing to time constraints or lack of suitable laboratory tests, transfusion of haemostatic products is often inappropriately triggered, either too late (exposing to prolonged bleeding and thus to avoidable administration of blood products) or blindly to the coagulation status (exposing to unnecessary haemostatic products administration in patients with no coagulopathy). Undue exposition to transfusion risks and additional healthcare costs may arise. With the perspective of secondary care-related costs, the IMOTEC study (Intérêt MédicO-économique de la Thrombo-Elastographie, dans le management transfusionnel des hémorragies péri-opératoires de chirurgies Cardiaques sous circulation extracorporelle) aims at assessing the cost-effectiveness of a point-of-care viscoelastic haemostatic assay (VHA: RoTem or TEG)-guided management of bleeding. Among several outcome measures, particular emphasis will be put on quality of life with a 1-year follow-up.

METHODS AND ANALYSIS

This is a multicentre, prospective, pragmatic study with stepped-wedge cluster randomised controlled design. Over a 36-month period (24 months of enrolment and 12 months of follow-up), 1000 adult patients undergoing cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass will be included if a periprocedural significant bleeding occurs. The primary outcome is the cost-effectiveness of a VHA-guided algorithm over a 1-year follow-up, including patients' quality of life. Secondary outcomes are the cost-effectiveness of the VHA-guided algorithm with regard to the rate of surgical reexploration and 1-year mortality, its cost per-patient, its effectiveness with regard to haemorrhagic, infectious, renal, neurological, cardiac, circulatory, thrombotic, embolic complications, transfusion requirements, mechanical ventilation free-days, duration of intensive care unit and in-hospital stay and mortality.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

The study was registered at Clinicaltrials.gov and was approved by the Committee for the Protection of Persons of Nantes University Hospital, The French Advisory Board on Medical Research Data Processing and the French Personal Data Protection Authority. A publication of the results in a peer-reviewed journal is planned.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT02972684; Pre-results.

A critical appraisal of point-of-care coagulation testing in critically ill patients

Derangement of the coagulation system is a common phenomenon in critically ill patients, who may present with severe bleeding and/or conditions associated with a prothrombotic state. Monitoring of this coagulopathy can be performed with conventional coagulation assays; however, point-of-care tests have become increasingly attractive, because not only do they yield a more rapid result than clinical laboratory testing, but they may also provide a more complete picture of the condition of the hemostatic system. There are many potential areas of study and applications of point-of-care hemostatic testing in critical care, including patients who present with massive blood loss, patients with a hypercoagulable state (such as in disseminated intravascular coagulation), and monitoring of antiplatelet treatment for acute arterial thrombosis, mostly acute coronary syndromes. However, the limitations of near-patient hemostatic testing has not been fully appreciated, and are discussed here. The currently available evidence indicates that point-of-care tests may be applied to guide appropriate blood product transfusion and the use of hemostatic agents to correct the hemostatic defect or to ameliorate antithrombotic treatment. Disappointingly, however, only in cardiac surgery is there adequate evidence to show that application of near-patient thromboelastography leads to an improvement in clinically relevant outcomes, such as reductions in bleeding-related morbidity and mortality, and cost-effectiveness. More research is required to validate the utility and cost-effectiveness of near-patient hemostatic testing in other areas, especially in traumatic bleeding and postpartum hemorrhage.

[Bedside thrombelastography. Cost reduction in cardiac surgery]

BACKGROUND

Demographic changes and aggressive medication with platelet aggregation inhibitors have resulted in a marked increase in blood and coagulation product expenditure and costs in cardiac surgery. We analyzed the bedside coagulation test (ROTEM) in order to verify clot forming quality and to find a cost-effective treatment algorithm.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Annual treatment costs of all cardiosurgical patients were retrospectively analyzed before (729 patients) and after (693 patients) implementation of the bedside ROTEM test. Cumulative numbers and costs of platelet concentrates (PltC), fresh frozen plasma (FFP), red blood cell units (RBC), and the coagulation factors prothrombin complex concentrates (PCC), recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa), factor XIII (FXIII), and fibrinogen were assessed. Average monthly numbers and costs were compared. The number of rethoracotomies and early mortality were assessed and compared in both periods.

RESULTS

After ROTEM implementation cumulative RBC expenditure showed a 25% decrease and PltC a 50% decrease. FFP expenditure remained unchanged. PCC, FXIII were markedly reduced (-80%) while rFVIIa was entirely omitted. Fibrinogen, however, showed a two-fold increase. Cumulative average monthly costs of all blood products decreased from 66,000 EUR to 45,000 EUR (-32%). Coagulation factor average monthly costs decreased from 60,000 EUR to 30,000 EUR (-50%) yielding combined savings of 44%. In contrast, average monthly costs for ROTEM were 1,580 EUR. The total number of rethoracotomies decreased from 6.6% to 5.5% while early mortality (5.9%; 6.0%) remained stable.

CONCLUSIONS

Cumulative costs for treatment of perioperative coagulation disorders were reduced by bedside ROTEM analysis to achieve a selective substitution management. Saved costs for blood and coagulation products clearly outweighed the expenses of ROTEM. Adequate differential coagulation management can therefore be cost-effective.

Cost reduction of perioperative coagulation management in cardiac surgery: value of "bedside" thrombelastography (ROTEM)

OBJECTIVE

Demographic changes and aggressive platelet inhibition have resulted in a marked increase in blood- and coagulation product expenditure and costs in cardiac surgery. We analyzed "bedside" coagulation test (ROTEM) in order to verify clot forming quality for the purpose of finding a cost-effective treatment path.

METHODS

Annual treatment costs of all cardiosurgical patients were analyzed before (729 patients) and after (693 patients) implementation of "bedside" ROTEM. Cumulative numbers and costs of platelet concentrates (PltC), fresh frozen plasma (FFP), red blood cell units (RBC), and coagulation factors: pooled coagulation concentrates (PCC), recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa), factor XIII (FXIII), and fibrinogen were assessed. Average monthly numbers and costs were compared. Number of resternotomies and early mortality was assessed and compared in both periods.

RESULTS

After ROTEM implementation cumulative RBC expenditure showed 25% decrease while PltC exhibited 50% decrease. FFP expenditure remained unchanged. PCC, FXIII were markedly reduced (-80%) while rFVIIa were entirely omitted. Fibrinogen, however, increased two-fold. Cumulative average monthly costs of all blood products decreased from 66,000 euro to 45,000 euro (-32%). Coagulation factor average monthly costs decreased from 60,000 euro to 30,000 euro (-50%) yielding combined savings of 44%. In contrast, average monthly costs for ROTEM were 1.580 euro. Total number of resternotomies decreased from 6.6% to 5.5% while early mortality (5.9%; 6.0%) remained stable.

CONCLUSION

Cumulative costs for treatment of perioperative coagulation disorders can be reduced by "bedside" ROTEM analysis to achieve a selective substitution management. Saved costs for blood- and coagulation products clearly outweighed the expenses of ROTEM. Adequate differential coagulation management can therefore be cost-effective.

Thromboelastography A means to transfusion reduction

Consider using thromboelastography to improve care outcomes for cardiac surgery patients.