CtsR, the Gram-positive master regulator of protein quality control, feels the heat

Thermal control of microbial development and virulence: molecular mechanisms of microbial temperature sensing

Temperature is a critical and ubiquitous environmental signal that governs the development and virulence of diverse microbial species, including viruses, archaea, bacteria, fungi, and parasites. Microbial survival is contingent upon initiating appropriate responses to the cellular stress induced by severe environmental temperature change. In the case of microbial pathogens, development and virulence are often coupled to sensing host physiological temperatures. As such, microbes have developed diverse molecular strategies to sense fluctuations in temperature, and nearly all cellular molecules, including proteins, lipids, RNA, and DNA, can act as thermosensors that detect changes in environmental temperature and initiate relevant cellular responses. The myriad of molecular mechanisms by which microbes sense and respond to temperature reveals an elegant repertoire of strategies to orchestrate cellular signaling, developmental programs, and virulence with spatial and temporal environmental cues.

Structural basis for intrinsic thermosensing by the master virulence regulator RovA of Yersinia

Pathogens often rely on thermosensing to adjust virulence gene expression. In yersiniae, important virulence-associated traits are under the control of the master regulator RovA, which uses a built-in thermosensor to control its activity. Thermal upshifts encountered upon host entry induce conformational changes in the RovA dimer that attenuate DNA binding and render the protein more susceptible to proteolysis. Here, we report the crystal structure of RovA in the free and DNA-bound forms and provide evidence that thermo-induced loss of RovA activity is promoted mainly by a thermosensing loop in the dimerization domain and residues in the adjacent C-terminal helix. These determinants allow partial unfolding of the regulator upon an upshift to 37 °C. This structural distortion is transmitted to the flexible DNA-binding domain of RovA. RovA contacts mainly the DNA backbone in a low-affinity binding mode, which allows the immediate release of RovA from its operator sites. We also show that SlyA, a close homolog of RovA from Salmonella with a very similar structure, is not a thermosensor and remains active and stable at 37 °C. Strikingly, changes in only three amino acids, reflecting evolutionary replacements in SlyA, result in a complete loss of the thermosensing properties of RovA and prevent degradation. In conclusion, only minor alterations can transform a thermotolerant regulator into a thermosensor that allows adjustment of virulence and fitness determinants to their thermal environment.

Comparative proteomic analysis of Lactobacillus plantarum WCFS1 and ΔctsR mutant strains under physiological and heat stress conditions

Among Gram-positive bacteria, CtsR (Class Three Stress gene Repressor) mainly regulates the expression of genes encoding the Clp ATPases and the ClpP protease. To gain a better understanding of the biological significance of the CtsR regulon in response to heat-shock conditions, we performed a global proteomic analysis of Lactobacillus plantarum WCFS1 and ΔctsR mutant strains under optimal or heat stress temperatures. Total protein extracts from bacterial cells were analyzed by two-dimensional gel fractionation. By comparing maps from different culture conditions and different L. plantarum strains, image analysis revealed 23 spots with altered levels of expression. The proteomic analysis of L. plantarum WCFS1 and ctsR mutant strains confirms at the translational level the CtsR-mediated regulation of some members of the Clp family, as well as the heat induction of typical stress response genes. Heat activation of the putative CtsR regulon genes at transcriptional and translational levels, in the ΔctsR mutant, suggests additional regulative mechanisms, as is the case of hsp1. Furthermore, isoforms of ClpE with different molecular mass were found, which might contribute to CtsR quality control. Our results could add new outlooks in order to determine the complex biological role of CtsR-mediated stress response in lactic acid bacteria.

The mcsB gene of the clpC operon is required for stress tolerance and virulence in Staphylococcus aureus

The clpC operon in Staphylococcus aureus comprises four genes, denoted ctsR, mcsA, mcsB and clpC. A mutation within the mcsB gene resulted in hypersensitivity to heavy metal stress, temperature stress, osmotic pressure stress and oxidative stress. This mutation also resulted in sensitivity to variations in pH and lowered expression of the clpC operon under adverse extracellular conditions, as determined by quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). Additionally, virulence traits such as haemolytic activity, proteolysis, biofilm formation, and evasion from peritoneal fluid killing were substantially reduced in the ΔmcsB strain. Interestingly, mutated mcsB also caused a significant reduction in expression of virulence determinants hla and saeS. To be a successful pathogen, S. aureus must effectively overcome these types of stresses that are encountered within the host. These data show that an S. aureus strain lacking functional mcsB is stress hypersensitive and therefore less viable when introduced into hostile environments. For the first time, these studies have identified mcsB as a crucial and necessary component of stress and pathogenicity mechanisms.

Determinants of interaction specificity of the Bacillus subtilis GlcT antitermination protein: functionality and phosphorylation specificity depend on the arrangement of the regulatory domains

The control of several catabolic operons in bacteria by transcription antitermination is mediated by RNA-binding proteins that consist of an RNA-binding domain and two reiterated phosphotransferase system regulation domains (PRDs). The Bacillus subtilis GlcT antitermination protein regulates the expression of the ptsG gene, encoding the glucose-specific enzyme II of the phosphotransferase system. In the absence of glucose, GlcT becomes inactivated by enzyme II-dependent phosphorylation at its PRD1, whereas the phosphotransferase HPr phosphorylates PRD2. However, here we demonstrate by NMR analysis and mass spectrometry that HPr also phosphorylates PRD1 in vitro but with low efficiency. Size exclusion chromatography revealed that non-phosphorylated PRD1 forms dimers that dissociate upon phosphorylation. The effect of HPr on PRD1 was also investigated in vivo. For this purpose, we used GlcT variants with altered domain arrangements or domain deletions. Our results demonstrate that HPr can target PRD1 when this domain is placed at the C terminus of the protein. In agreement with the in vitro data, HPr exerts a negative control on PRD1. This work provides the first insights into how specificity is achieved in a regulator that contains duplicated regulatory domains with distinct dimerization properties that are controlled by phosphorylation by different phosphate donors. Moreover, the results suggest that the domain arrangement of the PRD-containing antitermination proteins is under selective pressure to ensure the proper regulatory output, i.e. transcription antitermination of the target genes specifically in the presence of the corresponding sugar.

Transcriptomic responses of germinating Bacillus subtilis spores exposed to 1.5 years of space and simulated martian conditions on the EXPOSE-E experiment PROTECT

Because of their ubiquity and resistance to spacecraft decontamination, bacterial spores are considered likely potential forward contaminants on robotic missions to Mars. Thus, it is important to understand their global responses to long-term exposure to space or martian environments. As part of the PROTECT experiment, spores of B. subtilis 168 were exposed to real space conditions and to simulated martian conditions for 559 days in low-Earth orbit mounted on the EXPOSE-E exposure platform outside the European Columbus module on the International Space Station. Upon return, spores were germinated, total RNA extracted, fluorescently labeled, and used to probe a custom Bacillus subtilis microarray to identify genes preferentially activated or repressed relative to ground control spores. Increased transcript levels were detected for a number of stress-related regulons responding to DNA damage (SOS response, SPβ prophage induction), protein damage (CtsR/Clp system), oxidative stress (PerR regulon), and cell envelope stress (SigV regulon). Spores exposed to space demonstrated a much broader and more severe stress response than spores exposed to simulated martian conditions. The results are discussed in the context of planetary protection for a hypothetical journey of potential forward contaminant spores from Earth to Mars and their subsequent residence on Mars.

Global impact of protein arginine phosphorylation on the physiology of Bacillus subtilis

Reversible protein phosphorylation is an important and ubiquitous protein modification in all living cells. Here we report that protein phosphorylation on arginine residues plays a physiologically significant role. We detected 121 arginine phosphorylation sites in 87 proteins in the gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis in vivo. Moreover, we provide evidence that protein arginine phosphorylation has a functional role and is involved in the regulation of many critical cellular processes, such as protein degradation, motility, competence, and stringent and stress responses. Our results suggest that in B. subtilis the combined activity of a protein arginine kinase and phosphatase allows a rapid and reversible regulation of protein activity and that protein arginine phosphorylation can play a physiologically important and regulatory role in bacteria.

Concerted actions of a thermo-labile regulator and a unique intergenic RNA thermosensor control Yersinia virulence

Expression of all Yersinia pathogenicity factors encoded on the virulence plasmid, including the yop effector and the ysc type III secretion genes, is controlled by the transcriptional activator LcrF in response to temperature. Here, we show that a protein- and RNA-dependent hierarchy of thermosensors induce LcrF synthesis at body temperature. Thermally regulated transcription of lcrF is modest and mediated by the thermo-sensitive modulator YmoA, which represses transcription from a single promoter located far upstream of the yscW-lcrF operon at moderate temperatures. The transcriptional response is complemented by a second layer of temperature-control induced by a unique cis-acting RNA element located within the intergenic region of the yscW-lcrF transcript. Structure probing demonstrated that this region forms a secondary structure composed of two stemloops at 25°C. The second hairpin sequesters the lcrF ribosomal binding site by a stretch of four uracils. Opening of this structure was favored at 37°C and permitted ribosome binding at host body temperature. Our study further provides experimental evidence for the biological relevance of an RNA thermometer in an animal model. Following oral infections in mice, we found that two different Y. pseudotuberculosis patient isolates expressing a stabilized thermometer variant were strongly reduced in their ability to disseminate into the Peyer's patches, liver and spleen and have fully lost their lethality. Intriguingly, Yersinia strains with a destabilized version of the thermosensor were attenuated or exhibited a similar, but not a higher mortality. This illustrates that the RNA thermometer is the decisive control element providing just the appropriate amounts of LcrF protein for optimal infection efficiency.

CtsR regulation in mcsAB-deficient Gram-positive bacteria

CtsR is an important repressor that modulates the transcription of class III stress genes in Gram-positive bacteria. In Bacillus subtilis, a model Gram-positive organism, the DNA binding activity of CtsR is regulated by McsAB-mediated phosphorylation of the protein where phosphorylated CtsR is a substrate for degradation by the ClpCP complex. Surprisingly, the mcsAB genes are absent from many Gram-positive bacteria, including streptococci; therefore, how CtsR activity is modulated in those bacteria remains unknown. Here we show that the posttranslational modulation of CtsR activity is different in Streptococcus mutans, a dental pathogen. We observed that of all of the Clp-related proteins, only ClpL is involved in the degradation of CtsR. Neither ClpP nor ClpC had any effect on the degradation of CtsR. We also found that phosphorylation of CtsR on a conserved arginine residue within the winged helix-turn-helix domain is necessary for modulation of the repressor activity of CtsR, as demonstrated by both in vitro and in vivo assays. We speculate that CtsR is regulated posttranslationally by a different mechanism in S. mutans and possibly in other streptococci.

CbpA acts as a modulator of HspR repressor DNA binding activity in Helicobacter pylori

The ability of pathogens to cope with disparate environmental stresses is a crucial feature for bacterial survival and for the establishment of a successful infection and colonization of the host; in this respect, chaperones and heat shock proteins (HSPs) play a fundamental role in host-pathogen interactions. In Helicobacter pylori, the expression of the major HSPs is tightly regulated through dedicated transcriptional repressors (named HspR and HrcA), as well as via a GroESL-dependent posttranscriptional feedback control acting positively on the DNA binding affinity of the HrcA regulator itself. In the present work we show that the CbpA chaperone also participates in the posttranscriptional feedback control of the H. pylori heat shock regulatory network. Our experiments suggest that CbpA specifically modulates HspR in vitro binding to DNA without affecting HrcA regulator activity. In particular, CbpA directly interacts with HspR, preventing the repressor from binding to its target operators. This interaction takes place only when HspR is not bound to DNA since CbpA is unable to affect HspR once the repressor is bound to its operator site. Accordingly, in vivo overexpression of CbpA compromises the response kinetics of the regulatory circuit, inducing a failure to restore HspR-dependent transcriptional repression after heat shock. The data presented in this work support a model in which CbpA acts as an important modulator of HspR regulation by fine-tuning the shutoff response of the regulatory circuit that governs HSP expression in H. pylori.

The operonic location of auto-transcriptional repressors is highly conserved in bacteria

Bacterial genes are commonly encoded in clusters, known as operons, which share transcriptional regulatory control and often encode functionally related proteins that take part in certain biological pathways. Operons that are coregulated are known to colocalize in the genome, suggesting that their spatial organization is under selection for efficient expression regulation. However, the internal order of genes within operons is believed to be poorly conserved, and hence expression requirements are claimed to be too weak to oppose gene rearrangements. In light of these opposing views, we set out to investigate whether the internal location of the regulatory genes within operons is under selection. Our analysis shows that transcription factors (TFs) are preferentially encoded as either first or last in their operons, in the two diverged model bacteria Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. In a higher resolution, we find that TFs that repress transcription of the operon in which they are encoded (autorepressors), contribute most of this signal by specific preference of the first operon position. We show that this trend is strikingly conserved throughout highly diverged bacterial phyla. Moreover, these autorepressors regulate operons that carry out highly diverse biological functions. We propose a model according to which autorepressors are selected to be located first in their operons in order to optimize transcription regulation. Specifically, the first operon position helps autorepressors to minimize leaky transcription of the operon structural genes, thus minimizing energy waste. Our analysis provides statistically robust evidence for a paradigm of bacterial autorepressor preferential operonic location. Corroborated with our suggested model, an additional layer of operon expression control that is common throughout the bacterial domain is revealed.

Activity control of the ClpC adaptor McsB in Bacillus subtilis

Controlled protein degradation is an important cellular reaction for the fast and efficient adaptation of bacteria to ever-changing environmental conditions. In the low-GC, Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis, the AAA+ protein ClpC requires specific adaptor proteins not only for substrate recognition but also for chaperone activity. The McsB adaptor is activated particularly during heat stress, allowing the controlled degradation of the CtsR repressor by the ClpCP protease. Here we report how the McsB adaptor becomes activated by autophosphorylation on specific arginine residues during heat stress. In nonstressed cells McsB activity is inhibited by ClpC as well as YwlE.

YjbH-enhanced proteolysis of Spx by ClpXP in Bacillus subtilis is inhibited by the small protein YirB (YuzO)

The Spx protein of Bacillus subtilis is a global regulator of the oxidative stress response. Spx concentration is controlled at the level of proteolysis by the ATP-dependent protease ClpXP and a substrate-binding protein, YjbH, which interacts with Spx. A yeast two-hybrid screen was carried out using yjbH as bait to uncover additional substrates or regulators of YjbH activity. Of the several genes identified in the screen, one encoded a small protein, YirB (YuzO), which elevated Spx concentration and activity in vivo when overproduced from an isopropyl-β-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG)-inducible yirB construct. Pulldown experiments using extracts of B. subtilis cells producing a His-tagged YirB showed that native YjbH interacts with YirB in B. subtilis. Pulldown experiments using affinity-tagged Spx showed that YirB inhibited YjbH interaction with Spx. In vitro, YjbH-mediated proteolysis of Spx by ClpXP was inhibited by YirB. The activity of YirB is similar to that of the antiadaptor proteins that were previously shown to reduce proteolysis of a specific ClpXP substrate by interacting with a substrate-binding protein.

Regulation of CtsR activity in low GC, Gram+ bacteria

CtsR is the global transcriptional regulator of the core protein quality networks in low GC, Gram+ bacteria. Balancing these networks during environmental stress is of considerable importance for moderate survival of the bacteria, and also for virulence of pathogenic species. Therefore, inactivation of the CtsR repressor is one of the major cellular responses for fast and efficient adaptation to different protein stress conditions. Historically, CtsR inactivation was mainly studied for the heat stress response, and recently it has been shown that CtsR is an intrinsic thermosensor. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that CtsR degradation is regulated by a two-step mechanism during heat stress, dependent on the arginine kinase activity of McsB. Interestingly, CtsR is also inactivated during oxidative stress, but by a thiol-dependent regulatory pathway. These observations suggest that dual activity control of CtsR activity has developed during the course of evolution.