Posttranscriptional silencing of reporter transgenes in tobacco correlates with DNA methylation

Applications and advantages of virus-induced gene silencing for gene function studies in plants

Virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) is a recently developed gene transcript suppression technique for characterizing the function of plant genes. The approach involves cloning a short sequence of a targeted plant gene into a viral delivery vector. The vector is used to infect a young plant, and in a few weeks natural defense mechanisms of the plant directed at suppressing virus replication also result in specific degradation of mRNAs from the endogenous plant gene that is targeted for silencing. VIGS is rapid (3-4 weeks from infection to silencing), does not require development of stable transformants, allows characterization of phenotypes that might be lethal in stable lines, and offers the potential to silence either individual or multiple members of a gene family. Here we briefly review the discoveries that led to the development of VIGS and what is known about the experimental requirements for effective silencing. We describe the methodology of VIGS and how it can be optimized and used for both forward and reverse genetics studies. Advantages and disadvantages of VIGS compared with other loss-of-function approaches available for plants are discussed, along with how the limitations of VIGS might be overcome. Examples are reviewed where VIGS has been used to provide important new insights into the roles of specific genes in plant development and plant defense responses. Finally, we examine the future prospects for VIGS as a powerful tool for assessing and characterizing the function of plant genes.

Geminivirus VIGS of endogenous genes requires SGS2/SDE1 and SGS3 and defines a new branch in the genetic pathway for silencing in plants

Virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) is a sequence-specific RNA degradation process that can be used to downregulate plant gene expression. Both RNA and DNA viruses have been used for VIGS, but they differ in their mode of replication, gene expression, and cellular location. This study examined silencing mediated by a DNA virus, cabbage leaf curl virus (CaLCuV), in several silencing-deficient Arabidopsis mutants. A DNA VIGS vector derived from CaLCuV, which silenced chlorata42 (ChlI) needed for chlorophyll formation, was used to test endogenous gene silencing responses in suppressor of gene silencing (sgs)1, sgs2, sgs3, and Argonaute (ago)1 mutants defective in sense transgene-mediated post-transcriptional silencing (S-PTGS). SGS2/silencing defective (SDE)1, SGS3, and AGO1 are each dispensable for silencing mediated by transgenes containing inverted repeats (IR-PTGS), and SGS2/SDE1 is dispensable for RNA VIGS. We show that DNA VIGS requires both SGS2/SDE1 and SGS3, regardless of the orientation of 362 nt ChlI transcripts produced from the viral DNA promoter. Viral DNA accumulation is slightly higher, and viral symptoms increase in sgs2 and sgs3, whereas overexpression of SGS2/SDE1 mRNA results in decreased viral symptoms. Mutants affected in SGS1 and AGO1 function are only delayed in the onset of silencing, and have a small effect on chlorophyll accumulation. DNA VIGS is unaffected in defective DNA methylation (ddm)1/somniferous (som)8 and maintenance of methylation (mom)1 mutants, impaired for TGS. These results demonstrate that SGS2/SDE1 and SGS3 are needed for endogenous gene silencing from DNA viruses, and suggest that SGS2/SDE1 may reduce geminivirus symptoms by targeting viral mRNAs.

Planting the seeds of a new paradigm

RNA-mediated gene silencing has emerged in recent years as an important mechanism for regulating gene expression. Some of the key discoveries have been made in plants

The role of MET1 in RNA-directed de novo and maintenance methylation of CG dinucleotides

A genetic screen for mutants defective in RNA-directed DNA methylation and transcriptional silencing of the constitutive nopaline synthase (NOS) promoter in Arabidopsis identified two independent mutations in the gene encoding the DNA methyltransferase MET1. Both mutant alleles are disrupted structurally in the MET1 catalytic domain, suggesting that they are complete loss of function alleles. Experiments designed to test the effect of a met1 mutation on both RNA-directed de novo and maintenance methylation of the target NOS promoter revealed in each case approximately wild type levels of non-CG methylation together with significant reductions of CG methylation. These results confirm a requirement for MET1 to maintain CG methylation induced by RNA. In addition, the failure to establish full CG methylation in met1 mutants, despite normal RNA-directed de novo methylation of Cs in other sequence contexts, indicates that MET1 is required for full de novo methylation of CG dinucleotides. We discuss MET1 as a site-specific DNA methyltransferase that is able to maintain CG methylation during DNA replication and contribute to CG de novo methylation in response to RNA signals.

RNA interference: biology, mechanism, and applications

Double-stranded RNA-mediated interference (RNAi) is a simple and rapid method of silencing gene expression in a range of organisms. The silencing of a gene is a consequence of degradation of RNA into short RNAs that activate ribonucleases to target homologous mRNA. The resulting phenotypes either are identical to those of genetic null mutants or resemble an allelic series of mutants. Specific gene silencing has been shown to be related to two ancient processes, cosuppression in plants and quelling in fungi, and has also been associated with regulatory processes such as transposon silencing, antiviral defense mechanisms, gene regulation, and chromosomal modification. Extensive genetic and biochemical analysis revealed a two-step mechanism of RNAi-induced gene silencing. The first step involves degradation of dsRNA into small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), 21 to 25 nucleotides long, by an RNase III-like activity. In the second step, the siRNAs join an RNase complex, RISC (RNA-induced silencing complex), which acts on the cognate mRNA and degrades it. Several key components such as Dicer, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, helicases, and dsRNA endonucleases have been identified in different organisms for their roles in RNAi. Some of these components also control the development of many organisms by processing many noncoding RNAs, called micro-RNAs. The biogenesis and function of micro-RNAs resemble RNAi activities to a large extent. Recent studies indicate that in the context of RNAi, the genome also undergoes alterations in the form of DNA methylation, heterochromatin formation, and programmed DNA elimination. As a result of these changes, the silencing effect of gene functions is exercised as tightly as possible. Because of its exquisite specificity and efficiency, RNAi is being considered as an important tool not only for functional genomics, but also for gene-specific therapeutic activities that target the mRNAs of disease-related genes.

Epigenetic switch from posttranscriptional to transcriptional silencing is correlated with promoter hypermethylation

Changes in the distribution of methylcytosine residues along a transgene locus of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) in relation to the type of gene silencing were studied in parental plant leaves, calli, and regenerated plants derived thereof. Parental-silenced HeLo1 (hemizygous for locus 1) plants show posttranscriptional silencing of the residing nptII (neomycin phosphotransferase II) transgene and cytosine methylation restricted to the 3' end and center part of the transcribed region. Here, we report that with an increasing number of cell cycles, DNA methylation changes gradually, and methylation is introduced into the promoter during cell culture and more slowly in vegetatively propagated plants. After 24 months of callus in vitro cultivation, an epigenetic variant, designated locus 1E, was obtained in which cytosine methylation of symmetrical (CG and CNG) sites was almost complete within the 5' end of the nptII-transcribed region and the 35S promoter. Further, methylation of nonsymmetrical sites appeared de novo in the promoter, whereas this type of methylation was significantly reduced in the 3' end of the transcribed region when compared with locus 1. The newly established epigenetic patterns were stably transmitted from calli into regenerated plants and their progeny. The protein and steady-state RNA levels remained low in locus 1E, whereas with nuclear run-on assays, no detectable amounts of primary transcripts were found along the nptII gene, indicating that the methylated promoter became inactivated. The results suggest that a switch between posttranscriptional and transcriptional gene silencing could be a mechanism leading to irrevocable shut down of gene expression within a finite number of generations.

Enhancement of the primary flavor compound methional in potato by increasing the level of soluble methionine

The primary flavor compound in potato, methional, is synthesized from methionine by the Strecker degradation reaction. A major problem associated with potato processing is the loss of methional. Methional or its precursor, methionine, is not added back during potato processing due to high costs of production. A novel approach to enhance the methional level in processed potato would be to increase the production of its precursor, soluble methionine (Met). Cystathionine gamma-synthase (CGS) is a key enzyme regulating methionine biosynthesis in plants. To increase the level of soluble methionine in potato, Arabidopsis thaliana CGS cDNA was introduced under transcriptional control of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter into Russet Burbank potato by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Ten different transgenic potato lines (CGS1-10) were analyzed. Immunoblot analysis demonstrated that Arabidopsis CGS is expressed in the leaves, tubers, and roots of transgenic potato plants. CGS enzymatic activity was higher in the leaves and roots of the transgenic potato lines compared to the wild-type potato. Methionine levels in the leaves, roots and tubers of transgenic potato lines were enhanced as high as 6-fold compared to those in wild type potato plants. The methional level in baked tubers of field-grown transgenic potato lines was increased between 2.4- and 4.4-fold in lines CGS1, CGS2, and CGS4. The increase observed in methional levels correlated with the soluble methionine level in the tubers from the same lines measured before processing. These results provide the first evidence that the methional level can be enhanced in processed potatoes by increasing the production of its precursor, methionine.

RNA silencing in the phytopathogenic fungus Magnaporthe oryzae

Systematic analysis of RNA silencing was carried out in the blast fungus Magnaporthe oryzae (formerly Magnaporthe grisea) using the enhanced green fluorescence protein (eGFP) gene as a model. To assess the ability of RNA species to induce RNA silencing in the fungus, plasmid constructs expressing sense, antisense, and hairpin RNAs were introduced into an eGFP-expressing transformant. The fluorescence of eGFP in the transformant was silenced much more efficiently by hairpin RNA of eGFP than by other RNA species. In the silenced transformants, the accumulation of eGFP mRNA was drastically reduced, but no methylation of the promoter or coding region was involved in it. In addition, we found small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) only in the silenced transformants. Interestingly, the siRNAs consisted of RNA molecules with at least three different sizes ranging from 19 to 23 nucleotides, and all of them contained both sense and antisense strands of the eGFP gene. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration in which different molecular sizes of siRNAs have been found in filamentous fungi. Overall, these results indicate that RNA silencing operates in M. oryzae, which gives us a new tool for genome-wide gene analysis in this fungus.

High-frequency gene transfer from the chloroplast genome to the nucleus

Eukaryotic cells arose through endosymbiotic uptake of free-living bacteria followed by massive gene transfer from the genome of the endosymbiont to the host nuclear genome. Because this gene transfer took place over a time scale of hundreds of millions of years, direct observation and analysis of primary transfer events has remained difficult. Hence, very little is known about the evolutionary frequency of gene transfer events, the size of transferred genome fragments, the molecular mechanisms of the transfer process, or the environmental conditions favoring its occurrence. We describe here a genetic system based on transgenic chloroplasts carrying a nuclear selectable marker gene that allows the efficient selection of plants with a nuclear genome that carries pieces transferred from the chloroplast genome. We can select such gene transfer events from a surprisingly small population of plant cells, indicating that the escape of genetic material from the chloroplast to the nuclear genome occurs much more frequently than generally believed and thus may contribute significantly to intraspecific and intraorganismic genetic variation.

Analysis of trans-silencing interactions using transcriptional silencers of varying strength and targets with and without flanking nuclear matrix attachment regions

We investigated the effect of the Rb7 matrix attachment region (MAR) on trans-silencing in tobacco plants, comparing the effects of three transgene silencer loci on ten target loci. Two of the silencer loci, C40 and C190, contain complex and rearranged transgene arrays consisting of 35S:GUS or NOS:NPTII containing plasmids. The third silencer locus, V271, was previously characterized as a complex locus containing rearranged 35S:RiN sequences. Each of these silencers can reduce 35S promoter-driven expression at other loci, albeit with varying efficiencies. The presence of MARs at a target locus does not prevent trans-silencing by the V271 silencer. However, four of seven MAR-containing loci were at least partially resistant to silencing by the C40 and C190 loci. One MAR locus was unaffected by C40, our weakest silencer, and three were silenced only when the silencer locus was maternally inherited. Silencing is progressive in the F1 and F2 generations; two days after germination there is little or no difference between seedlings derived from crosses to silencing or control lines, but seedlings containing silencer loci slowly lose expression during subsequent development. These observations are compatible with the hypothesis that a product of the silencer locus must accumulate before unlinked loci can be affected. However, our silencer loci are themselves silenced for GUS transcription, and coding region homology is not required for their effects on target loci. Our results are consistent with a model in which transcriptional silencing is triggered by transcription of sequences during the early stages of embryo or seedling development.

RNA target sequences promote spreading of RNA silencing

It is generally recognized that a silencing-inducing locus can efficiently reduce the expression of genes that give rise to transcripts partially homologous to those produced by the silencing-inducing locus (primary targets). Interestingly, the expression of genes that produce transcripts without homology to the silencing-inducing locus (secondary targets) can also be decreased dramatically via transitive RNA silencing. This phenomenon requires primary target RNAs that contain sequences homologous to secondary target RNAs. Sequences upstream from the region homologous to the silencing inducer in the primary target transcripts give rise to approximately 22-nucleotide small RNAs, coinciding with the region homologous to the secondary target. The presence of these small RNAs corresponds with reduced expression of the secondary target whose transcripts are not homologous to the silencing inducer. The data suggest that in transgenic plants, targets of RNA silencing are involved in the expansion of the pool of functional small interfering RNAs. Furthermore, methylation of target genes in sequences without homology to the initial silencing inducer indicates not only that RNA silencing can expand across target RNAs but also that methylation can spread along target genes.

Locus-specific control of asymmetric and CpNpG methylation by the DRM and CMT3 methyltransferase genes

Many plant, animal, and fungal genomes contain cytosine DNA methylation in asymmetric sequence contexts (CpHpH, H = A, T, C). Although the enzymes responsible for this methylation are unknown, it has been assumed that asymmetric methylation is maintained by the persistent activity of de novo methyltransferases (enzymes capable of methylating previously unmodified DNA). We recently reported that the DOMAINS REARRANGED METHYLASE (DRM) genes are required for de novo DNA methylation in Arabidopsis thaliana because drm1 drm2 double mutants lack the de novo methylation normally associated with transgene silencing. In this study, we have used bisulfite sequencing and Southern blot analysis to examine the role of the DRM loci in the maintenance of asymmetric methylation. At some loci, drm1 drm2 double mutants eliminated all asymmetric methylation. However, at the SUPERMAN locus, asymmetric methylation was only completely abolished in drm1 drm2 chromomethylase 3 (cmt3) triple mutant plants. drm1 drm2 double mutants also showed a strong reduction of CpNpG (n = A, T, C, or G) methylation at some loci, but not at others. The drm1 drm2 cmt3 triple mutant plants did not affect CpG methylation at any locus tested, suggesting that the primary CpG methylases are encoded by the MET1 class of genes. Although neither the drm1 drm2 double mutants nor the cmt3 single mutants show morphological defects, drm1 drm2 cmt3 triple mutant plants show pleiotropic effects on plant development. Our results suggest that the DRM and CMT3 genes act in a partially redundant and locus-specific manner to control asymmetric and CpNpG methylation.

Two classes of short interfering RNA in RNA silencing

RNA silencing is a eukaryotic genome defence system that involves processing of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) into 21-26 nt, short interfering RNA (siRNA). The siRNA mediates suppression of genes corresponding to the dsRNA through targeted RNA degradation. In some plant systems there are additional silencing processes, involving systemic spread of silencing and RNA-directed methylation/transcriptional suppression of homologous genomic DNA. We show here that siRNAs produced in plants from a green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene are in short (21-22 nt) and long (24-26 nt) size classes, whereas those from endogenous retroelements are only in the long class. Viral suppressors of RNA silencing and mutations in Arabidopsis indicate that these classes of siRNA have different roles. The long siRNA is dispensable for sequence-specific mRNA degradation, but correlates with systemic silencing and methylation of homologous DNA. Conversely, the short siRNA class correlates with mRNA degradation but not with systemic signalling or methylation. These findings reveal an unexpected level of complexity in the RNA silencing pathway in plants that may also apply in animals.

Silencing of a viral RNA silencing suppressor in transgenic plants

High expression levels of the helper component proteinase (HC(pro)), a known virus suppressor of RNA silencing, were attained in Nicotiana benthamiana transformed with the HC(pro) cistron of Potato virus A (PVA, genus Potyvirus). No spontaneous silencing of the HC(pro) transgene was observed, in contrast to the PVA coat protein (CP)-encoding transgene in other transgenic lines. HC(pro)-transgenic plants were initially susceptible to PVA and were systemically infected by 14 days post-inoculation (p.i.) but, 1 to 2 weeks later, the new expanding leaves at positions +6 and +7 above the inoculated leaf showed a peculiar recovery phenotype. Leaf tips (the oldest part of the leaf) were chlorotic and contained high titres of PVA, whereas the rest of the leaf was symptomless and contained greatly reduced or non-detectable levels of viral RNA, CP and transgene mRNA. The spatial recovery phenotype suggests that RNA silencing is initiated in close proximity to meristematic tissues. Leaves at position +8 and higher were symptomless and virus-free but not completely resistant to mechanical inoculation with PVA. However, they were not infected with the virus systemically transported from the lower infected leaves, suggesting a vascular tissue-based resistance mechanism. Recovery of the HC(pro)-transgenic plants from infection with different PVA isolates was dependent on the level of sequence homology with the transgene. Methylation of the HC(pro) transgene followed recovery. These data show that the transgene mRNA for a silencing suppressor can be silenced by a presumably 'strong' silencing inducer (replicating homologous virus).

Progression of geminivirus-induced transgene silencing is associated with transgene methylation

•  The association of viral-induced gene silencing (VIGS) elicited by a DNA virus with DNA methylation of the silenced transgene was studied. •  35S-Green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana were treated with an inhibitor of DNA methylation, 5-azacytidine (5-Aza-C), and VIGS of the transgene was observed upon inoculation with tomato golden mosaic virus carrying the GFP coding sequence. •  The onset of VIGS of the 35S-GFP transgene occurred 14-16 d after inoculation in both control and 5-Aza-C-treated plants. At this stage, the silencing was observed in localized regions. Silencing was uniform by 30 d after inoculation in plants that had methylated GFP-DNA, whereas plants that continued to display the same phenotype as seen at 14-15 d after inoculation had hypomethylated GFP-DNA. Viral expression of GFP persisted in pockets throughout the life of infected plants. •  This is the first demonstration of a correlation between post transcriptional gene silencing induced by a DNA virus, and transgene methylation. The results suggest that, while DNA methylation is not necessary for the initiation of silencing, the progression of silencing is affected by inhibition of DNA methylation.

Virus-induced gene silencing in transgenic plants expressing the minor capsid protein of Beet western yellows virus

Transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana expressing the minor coat protein P74 of the phloem-limited Beet western yellows virus (BWYV) exhibited an unusual spatial pattern of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) when infected with BWYV or related viruses. Following infection, transgenic P74 and its mRNA accumulated to only low levels, 21 to 23 nucleotide RNAs homologous to the transgene appeared, and the transgene DNA underwent methylation. The infecting viral RNA, however, was not subject to significant silencing but multiplied readily and produced P74 in the phloem tissues, although the P74 encoded by the transgene disappeared from the phloem as well as the nonvascular tissues.

Transcriptional cosuppression of yeast Ty1 retrotransposons

Cosuppression, the silencing of dispersed homologous genes triggered by high copy number, may have evolved in eukaryotic organisms to control molecular parasites such as viruses and transposons. Ty1 retrotransposons are dispersed gene repeats in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, where no cosuppression has been previously observed. Ty1 elements are seemingly expressed undeterred to a level as high as 10% of total mRNA. Using Ty1-URA3 reporters and negative selection with 5-fluoroorotic acid, it is shown that Ty1 genes can undergo transcriptional cosuppression that is independent of DNA methylation and polycomb-mediated repression. Expression of Ty1-related genes was shown to be in one of two states, the coexpressed state with all Ty1-related genes transcribed or the cosuppressed state with all Ty1-related genes shut off, without uncoordinated or mosaic expression in any individual cell. Rapid switches between the two states were observed. A high copy number of Ty1 elements was shown to be required for the initiation of Ty1 homology-dependent gene silencing, implying that Ty1 gene expression is under negative feedback control. Ty1 transcriptional repressors facilitated the onset of Ty1 cosuppression, and the native Ty1 promoters were required for Ty1 cosuppression, indicating that Ty1 cosuppression occurs at the transcriptional level.

5S rRNA genes expression is not inhibited by DNA methylation in Arabidopsis

Methylation has often been correlated with transcriptional inhibition of genes transcribed by polymerase II, but its role on polymerase III genes is less well understood. Using the genomic sequencing technique, we have analysed the methylation pattern of the different 5S-rDNA arrays of the Arabidopsis genome. Every cytosine position within the 5S sequence is highly methylated whatever the context - CpG, CpNpG or non-symmetrical. The methylation pattern of both transcribed and non-transcribed 5S units is similar, with no preferential methylated or unmethylated site. These results, taken together with 5-azacytidine treatments and in vitro transcription experiments using methylated 5S templates, demonstrate that 5S rRNA gene transcription is not inhibited by methylation. Non-transcribed 5S arrays are more subject to transition mutations resulting from deamination of 5-methylcytosines, leading to CpG depletions and an increasing A + T content. As there were no detectable differences in methylation, this implies more efficient repair and/or selection pressure in transcribed 5S-blocks.

De novo methylation of an embryonic globin gene during normal development is strand specific and spreads from the proximal transcribed region

The recently discovered de novo methyltransferases DNMT3a and DNMT3b have been shown to be critical to embryonic development. However, at a single gene level, little is known about how the methylation pattern is established during development. The avian embryonic rho-globin gene promoter is completely unmethylated in 4-day-old chicken embryonic erythroid cells, where it is expressed at a high level, and completely methylated in adult erythroid cells, where it is silent. The methylation pattern of the rho-globin gene promoter, proximal transcribed region, and distal transcribed region on both DNA strands was examined during development in chicken erythroid cells. It was found that de novo methylation targets the CpG-dense proximal transcribed region on the coding (top) strand initially, followed by spreading into the 3' region and into the promoter region. Methylation of the template (bottom) strand lags behind that of the coding strand, and complete methylation of both strands occurs only after the gene has been silenced. The results of the study indicate that establishment of the de novo methylation pattern involves strand-specificity and methylation spreading.

The rest is silence

Over the past several years, RNAi and its related phenomena have emerged not only as a powerful experimental tool but also as a new mode of gene regulation. Through a combination of genetic and biochemical approaches we have learned much about the mechanisms underlying dsRNA responses. However, many of the most intriguing aspects of dsRNA-induced gene silencing have yet to be illuminated. What has become abundantly clear is that the complex and highly conserved biology underlying RNA interference is critical both for genome maintenance and for the development of complex organisms. However, it seems probable that we have only begun to reveal the diversity of biological roles played by RNAi-related processes.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in plants

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in plants is an RNA-degradation mechanism that shows similarities to RNA interference (RNAi) in animals. Indeed, both involve double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), spread within the organism from a localised initiating area, correlate with the accumulation of small interfering RNA (siRNA) and require putative RNA-dependent RNA polymerases, RNA helicases and proteins of unknown functions containing PAZ and Piwi domains. However, some differences are evident. First, PTGS in plants requires at least two genes – SGS3 (which encodes a protein of unknown function containing a coil-coiled domain) and MET1 (which encodes a DNA-methyltransferase) – that are absent in C. elegans and thus are not required for RNAi. Second, all Arabidopsis mutants that exhibit impaired PTGS are hypersusceptible to infection by the cucumovirus CMV, indicating that PTGS participates in a mechanism for plant resistance to viruses. Interestingly, many viruses have developed strategies to counteract PTGS and successfully infect plants – for example, by potentiating endogenous suppressors of PTGS. Whether viruses can counteract RNAi in animals and whether endogenous suppressors of RNAi exist in animals is still unknown.

Maize chromomethylase Zea methyltransferase2 is required for CpNpG methylation

A cytosine DNA methyltransferase containing a chromodomain, Zea methyltransferase2 (Zmet2), was cloned from maize. The sequence of ZMET2 is similar to that of the Arabidopsis chromomethylases CMT1 and CMT3, with C-terminal motifs characteristic of eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA methyltransferases. We used a reverse genetics approach to determine the function of the Zmet2 gene. Plants homozygous for a Mutator transposable element insertion into motif IX had a 13% reduction in methylated cytosines. DNA gel blot analysis of these plants with methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes and bisulfite sequencing of a 180-bp knob sequence showed reduced methylation only at CpNpG sites. No reductions in methylation were observed at CpG or asymmetric sites in heterozygous or homozygous mutant plants. Our research shows that chromomethylase Zmet2 is required for in vivo methylation of CpNpG sequences.

Maize chromomethylase Zea methyltransferase2 is required for CpNpG methylation

A cytosine DNA methyltransferase containing a chromodomain, Zea methyltransferase2 (Zmet2), was cloned from maize. The sequence of ZMET2 is similar to that of the Arabidopsis chromomethylases CMT1 and CMT3, with C-terminal motifs characteristic of eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA methyltransferases. We used a reverse genetics approach to determine the function of the Zmet2 gene. Plants homozygous for a Mutator transposable element insertion into motif IX had a 13% reduction in methylated cytosines. DNA gel blot analysis of these plants with methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes and bisulfite sequencing of a 180-bp knob sequence showed reduced methylation only at CpNpG sites. No reductions in methylation were observed at CpG or asymmetric sites in heterozygous or homozygous mutant plants. Our research shows that chromomethylase Zmet2 is required for in vivo methylation of CpNpG sequences.

Maize chromomethylase Zea methyltransferase2 is required for CpNpG methylation

A cytosine DNA methyltransferase containing a chromodomain, Zea methyltransferase2 (Zmet2), was cloned from maize. The sequence of ZMET2 is similar to that of the Arabidopsis chromomethylases CMT1 and CMT3, with C-terminal motifs characteristic of eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA methyltransferases. We used a reverse genetics approach to determine the function of the Zmet2 gene. Plants homozygous for a Mutator transposable element insertion into motif IX had a 13% reduction in methylated cytosines. DNA gel blot analysis of these plants with methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes and bisulfite sequencing of a 180-bp knob sequence showed reduced methylation only at CpNpG sites. No reductions in methylation were observed at CpG or asymmetric sites in heterozygous or homozygous mutant plants. Our research shows that chromomethylase Zmet2 is required for in vivo methylation of CpNpG sequences.

RNA silencing in plants--defense and counterdefense

RNA silencing is a remarkable type of gene regulation based on sequence-specific targeting and degradation of RNA. The term encompasses related pathways found in a broad range of eukaryotic organisms, including fungi, plants, and animals. In plants, it serves as an antiviral defense, and many plant viruses encode suppressors of silencing. The emerging view is that RNA silencing is part of a sophisticated network of interconnected pathways for cellular defense, RNA surveillance, and development and that it may become a powerful tool to manipulate gene expression experimentally.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in plum pox virus resistant transgenic European plum containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein gene

Transgenic plums containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein (PPV-CP) gene were inoculated with PPV. Infection was monitored by evaluating symptoms, ELISA, and IC-RT-PCR. Transgenic clone C5 was highly resistant to PPV during four years of testing and displayed characteristics typical of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS), including a high level of transgene transcription in the nucleus, low levels of transgene mRNA in the cytoplasm, a complex multicopy transgene insertion with aberrant copies, and methylation of the silenced PPV-CP transgene. The PPV-CP transgene was also methylated in seedlings of C5 and these seedlings were resistant to PPV. Our results show, for the first time, that PTGS functions as a mechanism for virus resistance in a woody perennial species.

RNA-directed transcriptional gene silencing in plants can be inherited independently of the RNA trigger and requires Met1 for maintenance

BACKGROUND

The association between DNA methylation and gene silencing has long been recognized; however, signals that initiate de novo methylation are largely unknown. In plants, recognition of RNAs that are inducers of posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) can result in sequence-specific DNA methylation, and the aim of this work was to investigate whether heritable epigenetic changes can occur by this mechanism and if the Met1 methyltransferase is required.

RESULTS

RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) was initiated in 35S-GFP transgenic plants following infection with plant RNA viruses modified to carry portions of either the 35S promoter or the GFP coding region. Targeting of the promoter sequence resulted in both methylation and transcriptional gene silencing (TGS) that was inherited independently of the RNA trigger. Targeting the coding region also resulted in methylation; however, this was not inherited. Expression of Met1 was suppressed in order to investigate its role in initiation and maintenance of RdDM. Initiation of RdDM was found to be Met1-independent, whereas maintenance of methylation and TGS in the subsequent generations in the absence of the RNA trigger was Met1-dependent. Maintenance of methylation associated with systemic PTGS was also found to be Met1-independent.

CONCLUSIONS

RNA-triggered events can lead to heritable changes in gene expression, and it is possible that initiation of other epigenetic phenomena such as trans-silencing and paramutation may have an RNA component.

A link between DNA methylation and epigenetic silencing in transgenic Volvox carteri

Epigenetic silencing of foreign genes introduced into plants poses an unsolved problem for transgenic technology. Here we have used the simple multicellular green alga VOLVOX: carteri as a model to analyse the relation of DNA methylation to transgenic silencing. VOLVOX: DNA contains on average 1.1% 5-methylcytosine and 0.3% N6-methyladenine, as revealed by electrospray mass spectrometry and phosphoimaging of chromatographically separated (32)P-labelled nucleotides. In two nuclear transformants of V.carteri, produced in 1993 by biolistic bombardment with a foreign arylsulphatase gene (C-ars), the transgene is still expressed in one (Hill 181), but not in the other (Hill 183), after an estimated 500-1000 generations. Each transformant clone contains multiple intact copies of C-ars, most of them integrated into the genome as tandem repeats. When the bisulphite genomic sequencing protocol was applied to examine two select regions of transgenic C-ars, we found that the inactivated copies (Hill 183) exhibited a high-level methylation (40%) of CpG dinucleotides, whereas the active copies (Hill 181) displayed low-level (7%) CpG methylation. These are average values from 40 PCR clones sequenced from each DNA strand in the two portions of C-ars. The observed correlation of CpG methylation and transgene inactivation in a green alga will be discussed in the light of transcriptional silencing.

Size constraints for targeting post-transcriptional gene silencing and for RNA-directed methylation in Nicotiana benthamiana using a potato virus X vector

Using a recombinant potato virus X (PVX) vector, we investigated the relationship between the length of RNA sequence identity with a transgene and the ability to promote post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) and transgene methylation. The lower size limit required for targeting reporter transgene mRNA de novo using PTGS was 23 nucleotides (nt) of complete identity, a size corresponding to that of small RNAs associated with PTGS in plants and RNA interference (RNAi) in animals. The size and sequence specificity were also explored for PTGS-associated transgene methylation and for the targeting of the vector RNA. The PTGS-competent short sequences resulted in similar patterns of methylation. In all cases, including specific sequences of 33 nt with or without symmetrical cytosine residues, the methylation was distributed throughout the transcribed region of the transgene. In contrast, short sequences lacking symmetrical cytosines were less efficient at promoting PTGS of the transgene mRNA. Short gfp sequences in the PVX vector provided as effective a target for the degradation of viral RNA as was found for PVX carrying the complete gfp cDNA. Short sequences were able to initiate PTGS of an endogenous gene, phyotene desaturase, although this occurred in the absence of DNA methylation. This experimental approach provides important insights into the relationship between short RNA sequences and PTGS.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing by double-stranded RNA

Imagine being able to knock out your favourite gene with only a day's work. Not just in one model system, but in virtually any organism: plants, flies, mice or cultured cells. This sort of experimental dream might one day become reality as we learn to harness the power of RNA interference, the process by which double-stranded RNA induces the silencing of homologous endogenous genes. How this phenomenon works is slowly becoming clear, and might help us to develop an effortless tool to probe gene function in cells and animals.

AGO1, QDE-2, and RDE-1 are related proteins required for post-transcriptional gene silencing in plants, quelling in fungi, and RNA interference in animals

Introduction of transgene DNA may lead to specific degradation of RNAs that are homologous to the transgene transcribed sequence through phenomena named post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in plants, quelling in fungi, and RNA interference (RNAi) in animals. It was shown previously that PTGS, quelling, and RNAi require a set of related proteins (SGS2, QDE-1, and EGO-1, respectively). Here we report the isolation of Arabidopsis mutants impaired in PTGS which are affected at the Argonaute1 (AGO1) locus. AGO1 is similar to QDE-2 required for quelling and RDE-1 required for RNAi. Sequencing of ago1 mutants revealed one amino acid essential for PTGS that is also present in QDE-2 and RDE-1 in a highly conserved motif. Taken together, these results confirm the hypothesis that these processes derive from a common ancestral mechanism that controls expression of invading nucleic acid molecules at the post-transcriptional level. As opposed to rde-1 and qde-2 mutants, which are viable, ago1 mutants display several developmental abnormalities, including sterility. These results raise the possibility that PTGS, or at least some of its elements, could participate in the regulation of gene expression during development in plants.

Expression of a yeast RNase III gene in transgenic tobacco silences host nitrite reductase genes

When a gene encoding the Schizosaccharomyces pombe dsRNA-specific RNase III, pac1, was expressed in transgenic tobacco plants, six out of thirteen transformed plants gave progeny among which were individuals displaying a distinctive chlorotic phenotype. These chlorotic plants strongly resemble those transformed with a 35S-Nii (nitrite reductase) transgene, in which both Nii host genes and the 35S-Nii transgene are silenced by co-suppression. RNA blots showed that the host Nii genes were silenced in chlorotic 35S-pac1 plants but not in individuals with a normal green phenotype. Neither the transcript levels of the other cellular genes tested nor the transcription of Nii genes was significantly affected by the expression of pac1. This is the first observation of post-transcriptional silencing of host genes by a transgene with no apparent sequence similarity to the target gene.

Transgene silencing in monocots

Plant gene silencing was originally thought to be a quirk of transformation procedures, but is now recognized to be a facet of vitally important gene regulatory systems, present in all organisms. Monocot plants, especially the grasses, play a foremost role in the agricultural economy of all nations, and their biotechnological manipulation offers great potential for both developed and developing countries. Here, we review reported instances of transgene silencing in monocots and relate the processes of transcriptional and post-transcriptional gene silencing (TGS, PTGS) in perspective to the rapidly burgeoning knowledge of these phenomena in many organisms. Recent findings include the involvement of an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and a nuclease in PTGS systems and the close relationship between methylation and chromatin structure in TGS events.

RNA viruses as inducers, suppressors and targets of post-transcriptional gene silencing

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) is a fundamental regulatory mechanism operating in diverse types of organisms, but the cellular components of the gene silencing machinery and the regulation of the process are not understood. Recent findings that cytoplasmically replicating RNA viruses act as both targets and inducers of PTGS has led to the idea that PTGS may have evolved as an anti-viral defense mechanism in plants. Consistent with this hypothesis, it has been found that certain plant viruses encode proteins that suppress PTGS. From a practical standpoint, an understanding of the mechanisms by which viruses regulate PTGS may well lead to better ways to control gene expression in plants. It is often desirable to overexpress selected beneficial genes or to silence detrimental ones in order to confer a particular phenotype. Induction of PTGS using RNA viruses as vectors or as transgenes provides a reliable and efficient way to interfere with the expression of a specific gene or with a family of genes. Conversely, expression of viral suppressors has significant potential to improve yields in technologies that use plants to express beneficial gene products. Given the antiviral nature of gene silencing in plants and the indications that PTGS is an ancient mechanism in eukaryotic organisms, understanding the phenomenon in plants could well lead to the development of anti-viral strategies in both plants and animals.

Paramutation in maize

Paramutation is a heritable change in gene expression induced by allele interactions. This review summarizes key experiments on three maize loci, which undergo paramutation. Similarities and differences between the phenomenology at the three loci are described. In spite of many differences with respect to the stability of the reduced expression states at each locus or whether paramutation correlates with DNA methylation and repeated sequences within the loci, recent experiments are consistent with a common mechanism underlying paramutation at all three loci. Most strikingly, trans-acting mutants have been isolated that prevent paramutation at all three loci and lead to the activation of silenced Mutator transposable elements. Models consistent with the hypothesis that paramutation involves heritable changes in chromatin structure are presented. Several potential roles for paramutation are discussed. These include localizing recombination to low-copy sequences within the genome, establishing and maintaining chromatin domain boundaries, and providing a mechanism for plants to transmit an environmentally influenced expression state to progeny.

RNA degradation and models for post-transcriptional gene-silencing

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) is a form of stable but potentially reversible epigenetic modification, which frequently occurs in transgenic plants. The interaction in trans of genes with similar transcribed sequences results in sequence-specific degradation of RNAs derived from the genes involved. Highly expressed single-copy loci, transcribed inverted repeats, and poorly transcribed complex loci can act as sources of signals that trigger PTGS. In some cases, mobile, sequence-specific silencing signals can move from cell to cell or even over long distances in the plant. Several current models hold that silencing signals are 'aberrant' RNAs (aRNA), which differ in some way from normal mRNAs. The most likely candidates are small antisense RNAs (asRNA) and double-stranded RNAs (dsRNA). Direct evidence that these or other aRNAs found in silent tissues can induce PTGS is still lacking. Most current models assume that silencing signals interact with target RNAs in a sequence-specific fashion. This results in degradation, usually in the cytoplasm, by exonucleolytic as well as endonucleolytic pathways, which are not necessarily PTGS-specific. Biochemical-switch models hold that the silent state is maintained by a positive auto-regulatory loop. One possibility is that concentrations of hypothetical silencing signals above a critical threshold trigger their own production by self-replication, by degradation of target RNAs, or by a combination of both mechanisms. These models can account for the stability, reversibility and multiplicity of silent states; the strong influence of transcription rate of target genes on the incidence and stability of silencing, and the amplification and systemic propagation of motile silencing signals.

(TRANS)GENE SILENCING IN PLANTS: How Many Mechanisms?

Epigenetic silencing of transgenes and endogenous genes can occur at the transcriptional level (TGS) or at the posttranscriptional level (PTGS). Because they can be induced by transgenes and viruses, TGS and PTGS probably reflect alternative (although not exclusive) responses to two important stress factors that the plant's genome has to face: the stable integration of additional DNA into chromosomes and the extrachromosomal replication of a viral genome. TGS, which results from the impairment of transcription initiation through methylation and/or chromatin condensation, could derive from the mechanisms by which transposed copies of mobile elements and T-DNA insertions are tamed. PTGS, which results from the degradation of mRNA when aberrant sense, antisense, or double-stranded forms of RNA are produced, could derive from the process of recovery by which cells eliminate pathogens (RNA viruses) or their undesirable products (RNA encoded by DNA viruses). Mechanisms involving DNA-DNA, DNA-RNA, or RNA-RNA interactions are discussed to explain the various pathways for triggering (trans)gene silencing in plants.

RNA-directed DNA methylation

RNA-DNA interactions can serve as a signal that triggers de novo DNA methylation in plants. As yet, this RNA-directed DNA methylation mechanism merely targets transgenes, but it appears likely that methylation of some endogenous sequences is also directed by RNA. RNA-directed methylation of cytosine residues specifically occurs along the DNA regions that are complementary to the directing RNA pointing to the formation of a putative RNA-DNA duplex. Dense methylation patterns and the methylation of cytosine residues at symmetric and asymmetric sites are detectable on both DNA strands within these regions. Methylation progressively decreases in the sequences adjacent to the putative RNA-DNA duplex. The extreme sensitivity of RNA-directed DNA methylation was demonstrated by analysing a short 30 bp DNA region that was complementary to the targeting RNA. Association of RNA-directed DNA methylation with homology-dependent gene silencing indicated that the methylation-directing RNA molecules may be double-stranded or may contain double-stranded regions. Whereas the function of DNA methylation in transcriptional gene silencing is nearly understood, its role in post-transcriptional gene silencing is still under discussion. In mammals, X-chromosome inactivation and genomic imprinting are associated with DNA methylation but how methylation is initiated is unclear. The observation of a correlation between specific antisense RNAs and transcriptional and post-transcriptional gene silencing may indicate that RNA-directed DNA methylation is involved in epigenetic gene regulation throughout eukaryotes.

Plant viral suppressors of post-transcriptional silencing do not suppress transcriptional silencing

Homology-dependent gene silencing is a regulatory mechanism that limits RNA accumulation from affected loci either by suppression of transcription (transcriptional gene silencing, TGS) or by activation of a sequence-specific RNA degradation process (post-transcriptional gene silencing, PTGS). The P1/HC-Pro sequence of plant potyviruses and the 2b gene of the cucumber mosaic virus have been shown to interfere with PTGS. The ability of these viral suppressors of PTGS to interfere with TGS was tested using the 271 locus which imposes TGS on transgenes under 35S or 19S promoters and PTGS on the endogenous nitrite reductase gene (Nii). Both P1/HC-Pro and 2b reversed PTGS of Nii genes in 271-containing tobacco plants, but failed to reverse TGS of 35S-GUS transgenes in the same plant. P1/HC-Pro expression from a transgene also failed to suppress either the initiation or maintenance of TGS imposed by the NOSpro-silencing locus, H2. These results indicate that PTGS and TGS operate through unlinked pathways or that P1/HC-Pro and 2b interfere at step(s) in PTGS that are downstream of any common components in the two pathways. The data suggest a simple assay to identify post-transcriptionally silenced transgenic lines with the potential to be stably converted to high expressing lines.

A genetic link between co-suppression and RNA interference in C. elegans

Originally discovered in plants, the phenomenon of co-suppression by transgenic DNA has since been observed in many organisms from fungi to animals: introduction of transgenic copies of a gene results in reduced expression of the transgene as well as the endogenous gene. The effect depends on sequence identity between transgene and endogenous gene. Some cases of co-suppression resemble RNA interference (the experimental silencing of genes by the introduction of double-stranded RNA), as RNA seems to be both an important initiator and a target in these processes. Here we show that co-suppression in Caenorhabditis elegans is also probably mediated by RNA molecules. Both RNA interference and co-suppression have been implicated in the silencing of transposons. We now report that mutants of C. elegans that are defective in transposon silencing and RNA interference (mut-2, mut-7, mut-8 and mut-9) are in addition resistant to co-suppression. This indicates that RNA interference and co-suppression in C. elegans may be mediated at least in part by the same molecular machinery, possibly through RNA-guided degradation of messenger RNA molecules.

Potato virus X amplicons in arabidopsis mediate genetic and epigenetic gene silencing

Amplicon transgenes from potato virus X (PVX) are based on a modified version of the viral genome and are efficient activators of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS). To determine whether PVX amplicons activate PTGS in Arabidopsis, we used constructs based on the genome of PVX carrying a green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter gene. Our analysis of the transgene phenotype exploited previous observations indicating that PTGS is associated with short 25-nucleotide RNA species, transgene methylation, and homology-dependent virus resistance. We also used the ability of turnip mosaic virus to suppress gene silencing as a means of dissecting stages of the mechanism. The results showed that a PVX:GFP amplicon induces weak PTGS and that this PTGS was enhanced in the presence of a GFP reporter gene. Our interpretation of these data is that the PTGS induced by the amplicon was genetically determined and equivalent to the initiation stage of the PTGS mechanism. The PTGS induced by the combined amplicon and reporter gene was equivalent to the maintenance stage and was associated with an epigenetic conversion of the transgene. The distinction between genetic and epigenetic PTGS explains the well-characterized effects of transgene dosage on PTGS that have been previously interpreted in terms of RNA expression thresholds.

Drug-induced hypomethylation of a posttranscriptionally silenced transgene locus of tobacco leads to partial release of silencing

The effect of DNA methylation upon posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) has been investigated in transgenic tobacco lines showing PTGS and methylation of the neomycin phosphotransferase II (nptII) reporter genes. Application of the hypomethylation drugs dihydroxypropyladenine or 5-azacytidine resulted in approximately 30% reduced methylation of cytosines located in a non-symmetrical context in the 3' untranslated region of the nptII transgenes. The hypomethylation was accompanied by up to 12-fold increase in NPTII protein levels, suggesting that methylation of non-symmetrical motifs may account for an increased degree of PTGS. Models for the possible role of DNA methylation in PTGS are discussed.

Cross-talk between posttranscriptionally silenced neomycin phosphotransferase II transgenes

Tobacco plants containing a transgene locus with two chimeric neomycin phosphotransferase II (nptII) genes in tail-to-tail orientation (locus 1) show posttranscriptional gene silencing. The silenced nptII transgenes of locus 1 can downregulate the expression of homologous nptII transgenes in hybrid plants. The 3' region of the silenced nptII genes located in the center of the inverted repeat locus 1 is extensively methylated. Moreover, 3' segments of in trans-inactivated transgenes also become methylated, suggesting cross-talk between homologous posttranscriptionally silenced genes. Our results are in accordance with the hypothesis that this cross-talk can be mediated by specially featured RNAs.

A DNA target of 30 bp is sufficient for RNA-directed DNA methylation

In higher plants, RNA-DNA interactions can trigger de novo methylation of genomic sequences via a process that is termed RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM). In potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd)-infected tobacco plants, this process can potentially lead to methylation of all C residues at symmetrical and nonsymmetrical sites within chromosomal inserts that consist of multimers of the 359-bp-long PSTVd cDNA. Using PSTVd cDNA subfragments, we found that genomic targets with as few as 30 nt of sequence complementarity to the viroid RNA are detected and methylated. Genomic sequencing analyses of genome-integrated 30- and 60-bp-long PSTVd subfragments demonstrated that de novo cytosine methylation is not limited to the canonical CpG, CpNpG sites. Sixty-base-pair-long PSTVd cDNA constructs appeared to be densely methylated in nearly all tobacco leaf cells. With the 30-bp-long PSTVd-specific construct, the proportion of cells displaying dense transgene methylation was significantly reduced, suggesting that a minimal target size of about 30 bp is necessary for RdDM. The methylation patterns observed for two different 60-bp constructs further suggested that the sequence identity of the target may influence the methylation mechanism. Finally, a link between viroid pathogenicity and PSTVd RNA-directed methylation of host sequences is proposed.

DNA methylation represses the expression of the human erythropoietin gene by two different mechanisms

The human erythropoietin gene is expressed predominantly in the kidney and liver in response to hypoxia. Although the signaling cascade for hypoxia is present in many different cell types, the expression of erythropoietin is restricted to only a few tissues. The authors show that the promoter and 5′-untranslated region (5′-UTR) of the erythropoietin gene comprise a CpG island and that methylation of the CpG island correlates inversely with expression. Methylation represses the expression of the erythropoietin gene in 2 ways: high-density methylation of the 5′-UTR recruits a methyl-CpG binding protein to the promoter, and methylation of CpGs in the proximal promoter blocks the association of nuclear proteins. (Blood. 2000;95:111-119)

DNA methylation represses the expression of the human erythropoietin gene by two different mechanisms

The human erythropoietin gene is expressed predominantly in the kidney and liver in response to hypoxia. Although the signaling cascade for hypoxia is present in many different cell types, the expression of erythropoietin is restricted to only a few tissues. The authors show that the promoter and 5′-untranslated region (5′-UTR) of the erythropoietin gene comprise a CpG island and that methylation of the CpG island correlates inversely with expression. Methylation represses the expression of the erythropoietin gene in 2 ways: high-density methylation of the 5′-UTR recruits a methyl-CpG binding protein to the promoter, and methylation of CpGs in the proximal promoter blocks the association of nuclear proteins. (Blood. 2000;95:111-119)