Comparison of confocal biomicroscopy and noncontact specular microscopy for evaluation of the corneal endothelium

An Evaluation of the Confoscan3 for Corneal Endothelial Morphology Analysis

PURPOSE

We evaluated the ConfoScan3 confocal microscope and its associated software that allows automated analysis of the corneal endothelial morphology.

METHODS

Images were taken on 30 normal subjects and 29 contact lens wearers with the Konan SP-9000 specular microscope and the ConfoScan3. The Konan images were analyzed with the KSS-300 software (center method). The Confoscan3 images were first analyzed with the automated method and then edited manually (semiautomated method). The agreement between methods was evaluated by calculating the difference between pairs of measurements, determining the mean and standard deviation of these differences, and the 95% limits of agreement.

RESULTS

For normal subjects, all methods gave similar density values. The agreement with the Konan system was slightly better for the semiautomated method than the automated method. The automated method overestimated the degree of polymegethism (p < 0.001) and pleomorphism (p < 0.001). The semiautomated method showed substantial improvement. For contact lens wearers, agreement with the Konan system was poor for both automated and semiautomated methods. The automated method overestimated the degree of pleomorphism (p < 0.001) and the semiautomated method showed only modest improvement (p < 0.1). Both methods overestimated pleomorphism (automated p < 0.001; semiautomated p < 0.025).

CONCLUSIONS

When using ConfoScan3 to evaluate the corneal endothelium of normal subjects, investigators should manually edit the processed images to achieve results comparable with the Konan system. When evaluating contact lens wearers, values from the ConfoScan3 are not interchangeable with those from the Konan system.

Contact lens-induced changes in the anterior eye as observed in vivo with the confocal microscope

The availability of the confocal microscope over the past decade has allowed clinicians and researchers to refine their understanding of the physiological and pathological basis of the ocular response to contact lens wear, and to discover previously unknown phenomena. Mucin balls, which form in the tear layer in patients wearing silicone hydrogel lenses, can penetrate the full thickness of the epithelium, leading to activation of keratocytes in the underlying anterior stroma. Epithelial cell size increases in response to all forms of lens wear, with lenses of higher oxygen transmissibility (Dk/t) interfering least with the normal process of epithelial desquamation. A higher density of Langerhans' cells is observed in the layer of the sub-basal nerve plexus among contact lens wearers, suggesting that contact lens wear may be altering the immune status of the cornea. Dark lines and folds are observed in the oedematous cornea in response to contact lens wear. Mechanical stimulation of the corneal surface, due to the physical presence of a contact lens, and the consequent release of inflammatory mediators, is the likely cause of reduced keratocyte density associated with lens wear. Highly reflective stromal 'microdot deposits' are observed throughout the entire stroma in higher numbers in lens wearers. 'Blebs' in the endothelium have a bright centre surrounded by a dark annular shadow; this appearance is explained with the aid of an optical model. The confocal microscope has considerable clinical utility in diagnosing Acanthamoeba and fungal keratitis. At the limbus, contact lenses can induce structural changes such as increases in basal epithelial cell size. An increased number of rolling leucocytes is observed in limbal vessels in response to low Dk/t lenses. It is concluded that the confocal microscope has considerable utility in contact lens research and practice.

Comparison of in vivo confocal microscopy of human cornea by white light scanning slit and laser scanning systems

PURPOSE

To compare in vivo corneal imaging by scanning slit white light and laser confocal microscopy systems.

METHODS

Twenty healthy individuals and 10 patients with corneal dystrophies including Fuchs, granular, Map-Dot-Fingerprint dystrophies, and amiodarone-induced keratopathy were examined with the ConfoScan 3 (Nidek Technologies) scanning slit white light confocal microscope equipped with x40 front lens (Zeiss) and the Rostock Cornea Module (RCM) for HRT II (Heidelberg Engineering) laser confocal microscopy system equipped with Olympus x60 front lens. The endothelial cell density counts were performed and results were compared. For additional validation of endothelial cells density results, separate counts were carried out using the specular microscope SP-1000 (Topcon).

RESULTS

The healthy and pathologically changed corneal structures are imaged in a similar manner by both systems. The differences in quality of acquired images in contrast and brightness between the systems are debatable, although the laser system was more efficient for epithelium imaging and white light scanning slit was better for evaluation of endothelium. Some of the examinations completed with the laser system, which requires applanating its front lens to the cornea, imaged dark striae in posterior stroma and Descemet membrane folds, resembling those observed in corneal pathologies, whereas most were probably induced by the pressure applied to the cornea during examination. All the results of cell density (for patients and for subjects with no ophthalmic disease) counts performed with the RCM (laser system) were higher than those with the ConfoScan 3 (scanning slit system) by 36.7% +/- 11.9% (SD) and 30.2% +/- 11.3% higher than SP-1000 (specular). The difference in cell counts between the RCM and other methods was increasing at higher cell densities.

CONCLUSIONS

The morphologic findings in examinations performed with the laser confocal microscopy system are generally comparable to white light scanning slit confocal microscopy. Direct applanation of the front lens of the laser system to the cornea may generate certain changes in confocal microscopy outcomes, including imaging of Descemet membrane folds and dark lines in stroma, which should be differentiated from pathologic alterations. Comparison of the endothelium cell density counts obtained with the 2 systems should be made cautiously because significant differences might occur--RCM configured with the Olympus x60 front lens was found to overestimate the results compared with both CS3 and SP-1000 microscopes, with the range of disparity increasing for higher cell densities.

Contemporary in vivo confocal microscopy of the living human cornea using white light and laser scanning techniques: a major review

In vivo confocal imaging of the cornea has evolved exponentially over the last few decades and it has increasingly emerged from the laboratory to be used in the clinical setting in relation to inherited corneal diseases, corneal infections, contact lens wear and the effects of corneal surgery. This evolution has led to significant enhancement of our knowledge of the living cornea in both its physiological and pathological states. A number of in vivo confocal microscope devices using white, and more recently coherent, light sources have been developed to provide non-invasive assessment of the corneal microstructure at a lateral resolution of 1-2 microm. The fundamental principles of in vivo confocal microscopy and the key differences between these devices are highlighted in this review. By providing a systematic review of the extensive literature on the human cornea, this perspective paper aims to provide an overview of how in vivo confocal microscopy has contributed to our greater understanding of the human cornea in health, in disease, and following surgery, with a particular emphasis on quantitative data. The utility and limitations of available data are highlighted as are possibilities for the future development of this innovative technology.

Diabetes and corneal cell densities in humans by in vivo confocal microscopy

PURPOSE

Diabetes is accompanied by an increased autofluorescence of the cornea, probably because of accumulation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs). The pathogenic mechanism is still unknown. This study aimed to quantify differences in corneal cell densities between diabetic patients and healthy controls.

METHODS

The left cornea of 15 patients with non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) with level of retinopathy 20 according to the Early Treatment of Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) and of 15 healthy controls were examined by noninvasive in vivo confocal microscopy in an observational prospective study. The cell densities in 6 corneal layers were determined along the optical axis of the cornea by using stereologic methods.

RESULTS

The average cell density per unit area in the superficial and basal epithelium and the endothelial layer was 725 +/- 171, 5950 +/- 653, and 2690 +/- 302 cells/mm in controls and 815 +/- 260, 5060 +/- 301, and 2660 +/- 364 cells/mm in diabetic patients. The cell density per unit volume in the anterior, mid-, and posterior stroma was 26,300 +/- 4090, 19,390 +/- 3120, and 25,700 +/- 3260 cells/mm in controls and 27,560 +/- 3880, 21,930 +/- 2110, and 25,790 +/- 3090 cells/mm in patients with diabetes. In both groups, the density in the midstroma was significantly lower than in both the anterior stroma and the posterior stroma (P < 0.02). The cell density in the basal layer of diabetic patients was significantly lower than in healthy controls (-15.0%, P < 0.0004). In the other layers, no significant differences between both groups (P > 0.07) were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

The lower basal cell density found in patients with diabetes may result from a combination of different mechanisms including decreased innervation at the subbasal nerve plexus, basement membrane alterations, and higher turnover rate in basal epithelial cells. The lower cell density in the midstroma of diabetic patients and healthy controls may be attributed in part to differences in oxygen concentration in the stromal layers (depths). Changes in cellular density did not seem to be responsible for the increased autofluorescence in diabetes.

Clinical corneal confocal microscopy

Confocal microscopy allows non-invasive in vivo imaging of the ocular surface. Its unique physical properties enable microscopic examination of all layers of the cornea and have been used to investigate numerous corneal diseases: epithelial changes, numerous stromal degenerative or dystrophic diseases, endothelial pathologies, corneal deposits, infections, and traumatic lesions. It offers a new approach to study the physiological reactions of the cornea to different stimuli and the pathophysiologic events leading to corneal dysfunction in certain diseases. Confocal microscopy proves to be a powerful diagnostic tool and is especially of value in certain corneal diseases by allowing straightforward and non-invasive recognition of the pathologic conditions.

In vivo three-dimensional confocal laser scanning microscopy of the epithelial nerve structure in the human cornea

PURPOSE

Evaluation of a new method for in vivo visualization of the distribution and morphology of human anterior corneal nerves.

METHOD

The anterior cornea was examined to a depth of 100 microm in four human volunteers with a confocal laser scanning microscope (CLSM) using a Rostock Cornea Module (developed in house) attached to a Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II (Heidelberg Engineering, Germany). Optical sections were digitally reconstructed in 3D using AMIRA (TGS Inc., USA). The scanned volumes had a greatest size of 300 x 300 x 40 microm and voxel size of 0.78 x 0.78 x 0.95 microm.

RESULTS

The spatial arrangement of the epithelium, nerves and keratocytes was visualized by in vivo 3D-CLSM. The 3D-reconstruction of the volunteers' corneas in combination with the oblique sections gave a picture of the nerves in the central human cornea. Thin nerves run in the subepithelial plexus aligned parallel to Bowman's layer and are partially interconnected. The diameter of these fibres varied between 1.0 and 5 microm. Thick fibres rose out of the deeper stroma. The diameter of the main nerve trunks was 12+/-2 microm. Branches penetrating the anterior epithelial cell layer could not be visualized.

CONCLUSIONS

3D-CLSM allows analysis of the spatial arrangement of the anterior corneal nerves and visualization of the epithelium and keratocytes in the living human cornea. The developed method provides a basis for further studies of alterations of the cellular arrangement and epithelial innervation in corneal disease. This may help to clarify alterations of nerve fibre patterns under various clinical and experimental conditions.

In vivo fibreoptic confocal imaging (FOCI) of the human ocular surface

Recent developments in the miniaturization of confocal imaging technology have resulted in the development of a hand-held confocal microscope probe. There are many structures of interest in the human eye that are within reach of a fluorescence-mode confocal microscope; this study assessed the feasibility of in vivo human ocular imaging. Safety analysis was undertaken to ensure that the laser light applied to the ocular surface structures constituted no threat to patient safety. A fibreoptic confocal imaging (FOCI) probe using an illumination wavelength of 488 nm was applied to the ocular surface of four volunteers after topical administration of sodium fluorescein. Stabilization of the probe on the ocular surface was difficult, but movement artefacts could be minimized to a satisfactory level in most subjects by a variety of procedures. High-quality images of conjunctival epithelial and goblet cells, lamina propria structures, accessory lacrimal glands, lacrimal ducts and superficial sclera were obtained. Lateral resolution was 1-1.5 microm and axial resolution was approximately 30 microm; individual erythrocytes could be seen in conjunctival vessels. The rete ridges and intervening epithelial components, including the probable location of corneal limbal stem cells, could be viewed, although it was not possible to distinguish cell subgroups. The study showed that fluorescence-mode imaging of the ocular surface is a viable and promising tool for assessment of diseases and processes involving superficial ocular structures. Refinement of equipment and techniques, particularly probe stabilization, is necessary to realize fully the potential of FOCI for ocular use.

Comparison of Corneal Endothelial Cell Images From a Noncontact Specular Microscope and a Scanning Confocal Microscope

PURPOSE

We compared endothelial cell density (ECD) from images recorded by the ConfoScan 3 confocal microscope and a noncontact specular microscope.

METHODS

Endothelial micrographs of 50 normal corneas of 25 subjects were acquired by a Konan Noncon Robo noncontact specular microscope (Konan Medical, Inc., Hyogo, Japan) and a ConfoScan 3 confocal microscope (Nidek Technologies, Inc, Greensboro, NC). ECD was determined in images from both instruments by using the HAI CAS System Corners Method (HAI Labs, Inc., Lexington, MA). Distances in the images from both machines were calibrated from images of an external scale. Images from the ConfoScan 3 were also assessed using the automated endothelial analysis software provided by the manufacturer, with and without manual correction.

RESULTS

The ECD was 2634 +/- 186 cells/mm(2) (mean +/- SD) and 2664 +/- 173 cells/mm(2) by the Robo and ConfoScan 3 Corners methods, respectively. Differences between these 2 methods were not significant. When the automated analysis software was used, however, significant differences were found (P = 0.001). The uncorrected analysis program provided with the ConfoScan 3 indicated a higher ECD (2742 +/- 284 cells/mm(3)) than the Corners method did with images from the Robo and ConfoScan 3. The ECD from the manually corrected ConfoScan 3 method was 2716 +/- 229 cells/mm(3), not significantly different from the ConfoScan 3 Corners method but significantly different from the Robo Corners method.

CONCLUSIONS

The ConfoScan 3 can be used interchangeably with the Robo when the Corners method is used to assess ECD and the magnification of both microscopes is calibrated with an external scale. If the proprietary software provided with the ConfoScan 3 is used, it should be manually corrected.

Epithelial Innervation of Human Cornea

PURPOSE

Evaluation of a new method to visualize distribution and morphology of human corneal nerves (Adelta- and C-fibers) by means of fluorescence staining, confocal laser scanning microscopy, and 3-dimensional (3D) reconstruction.

METHODS

Trephinates of corneas with a diagnosis of Fuchs corneal dystrophy were sliced into layers of 200 microm thickness using a Draeger microkeratome (Storz, Germany). The anterior lamella was stained with the Life/Dead-Kit (Molecular Probes Inc.), examined by the confocal laser scanning microscope "Odyssey XL," step size between 0.5 and 1 microm, and optical sections were digitally 3D-reconstructed.

RESULTS

Immediate staining of explanted corneas by the Life/Dead-Kit gave a complete picture of the nerves in the central human cornea. Thin nerves running parallel to the Bowman layer in the subepithelial plexus perforate the Bowman layer orthogonally through tube-like structures. Passing the Bowman layer, Adelta- and C-fibers can be clearly distinguished by fiber diameter, and, while running in the basal epithelial plexus, by their spatial arrangement. Adelta-fibers run straight and parallel to the Bowman layer underneath the basal cell layer. C-fibers, after a short run parallel to the Bowman layer, send off multiple branches penetrating epithelial cell layers orthogonally, ending blindly in invaginations of the superficial cells. In contrast to C-fibers, Adelta-fibers show characteristic bulbous formations when kinking into the basal epithelial plexus.

CONCLUSIONS

Ex-vivo fluorescence staining of the cornea and 3D reconstructions of confocal scans provide a fast and easily reproducible tool to visualize nerves of the anterior living cornea at high resolution. This may help to clarify gross variations of nerve fiber patterns under various clinical and experimental conditions.

Confocal microscopy used as the definitive, early diagnostic method in Chandler syndrome

PURPOSE

To report the early, rapid diagnosis of the Chandler variant of the iridocorneal endothelial (ICE) syndrome using confocal light microscopy.

METHODS

A 62-year-old man with a long history of unilateral glaucoma reported progressively blurred vision in his right eye. Examination of both eyes included visual acuity, slit-lamp examination, pneumotonometry, visual field, gonioscopy, and confocal microscopy.

RESULTS

On examination, visual acuity was 20/80 and 20/20 and the IOPs were 26 and 12. The anterior segment OD revealed 1+ inferior and axial corneal edema, while the OS was normal to biomicroscopy and posterior segment. Chandler syndrome or Fuchs endothelial dystrophy was suspected. In the affected eye, confocal light microscopy clearly showed an "epithelium-like" transformation of the corneal endothelium with irregularly shaped cells and hyperreflective nuclei, establishing the diagnosis of Chandler syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

In the presence of corneal edema or haze, corneal endothelium can be clearly visualized by confocal microscopy. "Epithelium-like" endothelial cells with highly reflective nuclei characteristic of Chandler syndrome were easily identified by confocal light microscopy to establish the diagnosis, despite the presence of corneal edema. Thus, confocal microscopy is a sensitive tool for the rapid, early diagnosis of ICE syndrome and may help distinguish among its variants.

Long-term results of implantation of phakic posterior chamber intraocular lenses

PURPOSE

To study the incidence and progression of lens opacification after implantation of phakic posterior chamber intraocular lenses for myopia and its correlation with vaulting and endothelial cell density (ECD).

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, University of Vienna Medical School, Vienna, Austria.

METHODS

An implantable contact lens (ICL V4, Staar Surgical Inc.) was inserted in 76 myopic eyes. Patients were prospectively followed preoperatively and at 1, 3, 6, 12, 24, and 36 months. The uncorrected visual acuity and best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) were determined. Vaulting was measured optically with a Jaeger II pachymeter, and the crystalline lens was examined at the slitlamp for the presence and characteristics of opacification. Endothelial cell morphometry was performed by specular microscopy, and the ECD was calculated. Eyes in which lens opacification developed were followed for at least 12 months to determine the degree and course of visual impairment.

RESULTS

Lens opacification occurred in 11 eyes (14.5%). Opacification was correlated with intraoperative trauma to the crystalline lens, age older than 50 years, and decreased ECD values throughout the observation period. Vaulting of the ICL did not correlate with the risk for lens opacification. After onset of lens opacification, 6 eyes (55%) had a stable BCVA within +/-0.5 lines and 5 eyes had progressive opacification, losing between 3.5 lines and 0.5 lines (mean 1.8 lines +/- 1.1 [SD]). Three eyes (3.9%) in the progressive group had a 1- to 2-line loss of BCVA over preoperative values and subsequently had cataract surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Risk factors for lens opacification after implantation of the model V4 ICL included intraoperative trauma to the crystalline lens and older age. Decreased ECD in eyes with opacification suggests ongoing inflammation as a cause. Patients younger than 45 years may have a significantly lower incidence of opacification.