Operative treatment of acetabular fractures in an older population through a limited ilioinguinal approach

How often does open reduction and internal fixation of geriatric acetabular fractures lead to hip arthroplasty?

OBJECTIVES

We hypothesized that open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) of displaced acetabular fractures in geriatric patients result in a low rate of conversion to hip arthroplasty and satisfactory hip-specific validated outcome scores at medium-term follow-up.

DESIGN

Retrospective review.

SETTING

Level I trauma center.

PATIENTS

One hundred forty-seven consecutive patients who were 60 years or older who had acetabular fractures were treated at our center from 2001 through 2006. During this time period, fractures meeting operative criteria were treated with ORIF unless medical conditions warranted nonoperative treatment. Twenty-nine patients were lost to follow-up, 46 were deceased, and 11 declined to participate, leaving 61 potential patients for inclusion, 46 of whom were treated with ORIF (average follow-up, 4.4 years; range, 1.1-8.0 years).

INTERVENTION

Standardized telephone interviews included hip-specific questions and validated outcome measures.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Rates of conversion to hip arthroplasty and hip-specific validated outcome scores.

RESULTS

Among 46 patients treated with ORIF (15 others were treated nonoperatively or with percutaneous screw fixation), 28% underwent hip arthroplasty an average 2.5 years after injury (range, 0.4-5.5 years) and had an average Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Index of Osteoarthritis score of 17 (range, 0-56; n = 38). This score is similar to or better than the typical scores after elective arthroplasty for arthritis and much better than the scores for patients with established arthritis (P < 0.05). The average SF-8 Health Survey physical component score was 46.1 (range, 31-62), similar to US population norms for the geriatric age group (P > 0.20).

CONCLUSIONS

Few data exist regarding the treatment outcomes for geriatric acetabular fractures. It is difficult for clinicians to decide among ORIF, percutaneous fixation, acute arthroplasty, and nonoperative treatment. Our protocol of mostly ORIF showed a high 1-year mortality rate of 25% and a rate of conversion to arthroplasty after ORIF of 28%.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Randomized, controlled trial of the modified Stoppa versus the ilioinguinal approach for acetabular fractures

The objective of this study was to determine whether the modified Stoppa approach or the ilioinguinal approach is better for the treatment of acetabular fractures by comparing the results of those 2 approaches. A randomized trial was undertaken of 60 consecutive patients with acetabular fractures treated with either the modified Stoppa or the ilioinguinal approach. In addition to the patients' demographics, the assessed preoperative parameters included fracture pattern, associated injuries, time to surgery, and Injury Severity Score; intraoperative parameters included blood loss and operative time for each procedure; and postoperative parameters included wound drainage, blood transfusion, perioperative complications, early operative complications, late operative complications, quality of reduction, radiological results, and clinical outcomes. The study showed no significant differences in all measured preoperative variables between the 2 groups (all P>.05). In addition, no significant differences were found in the intraoperative complication rate, early operative complication rate, late operative complication rate, quality of reduction, radiological results, and clinical outcomes (all P>.05). However, compared with the ilioinguinal approach, the modified Stoppa approach reduced intraoperative blood loss-and in doing so decreased wound drainage and the need for blood transfusion-and shortened operative time (all P<.05). The authors recommend using the modified Stoppa approach rather than the classical ilioinguinal approach to treat acetabular fractures when anterior exposure of the acetabulum is required.

Biomechanical analysis of the acetabular buttress-plate: are complex acetabular fractures in the quadrilateral area stable after treatment with anterior construct plate-1/3 tube buttress plate fixation?

OBJECTIVE

The acetabular buttress-plate has been widely used in treating difficult cases with satisfying clinical results. However, the biomechanical properties of a postoperative acetabular fracture fixed by the buttress-plate are not clear. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical properties of stability after the anterior tube buttress-plate fixation of complex acetabular fractures in the quadrilateral area.

METHODS

A construct was proposed based on anterior construct plate - 1/3 tube buttress plate fixation for acetabular both-column fractures. Two groups of six formalin-preserved cadaveric pelvises were analyzed: (1) group A, the normal pelvis and (2) group B, anterior construct plate-1/3 tube buttress plate with quadrilateral area fixation. The displacements were measured, and cyclical loads were applied in both standing and sitting simulations.

RESULTS

As the load was added, the displacements were A<B, increasing in line. In the 600 N physiological loading, the differences were significant (standing position: p=0.013; sitting position: p=0.009) between groups A and B.

CONCLUSION

The anterior construct plate - 1/3 tube buttress plate fixation provided a better stable construct for early sitting. The standing mode yielded more significant differences between the groups. Placing a 1/3 tube buttress-plate via an anterior approach is a novel method of providing quadrilateral area support in this setting.

The osteoporotic acetabular fracture

Fractures of the acetabulum are some of the most challenging fractures that face orthopedic surgeons. In geriatric patients, these challenges are enhanced by the complexity of fracture patterns, the poor biomechanical characteristics of osteoporotic bone, and the comorbidities present in this population. Nonsurgical management is preferable when the fracture is stable enough to allow mobilization, and healing in a functional position can be expected. When significant displacement and/or hip instability are present, operative management is preferred in most patients, which may include open reduction and internal fixation with or without total hip arthroplasty.

Predictors of clinical outcomes after surgical treatment of displaced acetabular fractures in the elderly

Outcomes following the open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) of displaced acetabular fractures in the elderly have been inconsistent. Several factors associated with significant poor clinical outcomes have been reported; however, the factor that contributes independently to the outcomes remains unknown. This study aims to identify independent prognostic factors for the outcomes of surgically treated displaced acetabular fractures in the elderly. A total of 86 elderly patients with displaced acetabular fractures were treated by ORIF between May 1990 and June 2010. Matta's criteria and modified Merle d'Aubigne-Postel score were used as reduction grades and clinical outcome measures, respectively. Reduction grades and six radiographic features were identified as prognostic factors. The six radiographic features include quadrilateral plate fracture, Gull sign, posterior dislocation of hip, femoral head injury (FHI), comminuted posterior wall fracture (CPWF), and posterior wall marginal impaction. The average clinical score of the patients associated with the six radiographic features was 14.4 ± 3.1, whereas the average clinical score for those without was 17.2 ± 1.6 points. The average clinical score of the patients with anatomical, imperfect, and poor reduction were 16.8 ± 2.4, 14.5 ± 2.3, and 11.3 ± 1.4 points, respectively. Multivariate analysis identified three independent predictors of clinical outcomes: reduction grades (t = -10.45, p = 0.000), CPWF (t = -2.74, p = 0.008), and FHI (t = -3.51, p = 0.000). Both CPWF and FHI are important risk factors for clinical outcome. The postoperative quality of reduction independently predicted patient prognosis, and anatomical reduction is predictive of a good prognosis.

Rationales for the Bernese approaches in acetabular surgery

Purpose

To present two new approaches to acetabular surgery that were established in Berne, and which aim at enhanced visualization and anatomical reconstruction of acetabular fractures.

Method

The trochanteric flip osteotomy allows for surgical hip dislocation, and was introduced as a posterior approach for acetabular fracture management involving the posterior column and wall. For acetabular fractures predominantly involving the anterior column and the quadrilateral plate, the Pararectus approach is described.

Results

Full exposure of the hip joint, as provided by the trochanteric flip osteotomy, facilitates anatomical reduction of acetabular or femoral head fractures and safe positioning of the anterior column screw in transverse or T-shaped fractures. Additionally, the approach enables osteochondral transplantation as a salvage procedure for severe chondral femoral head damage and osteoplasty of an associated inadequate offset at the femoral head–neck junction. The Pararectus approach allows anatomical restoration with minimal access morbidity, and combines advantages of the ilioinguinal and modified Stoppa approaches.

Conclusions

Utilization of the trochanteric flip osteotomy eases visualization of the superior aspect of the acetabulum, and enables the evaluation and treatment of chondral lesions of the femoral head or acetabulum and labral tears. Displaced fractures of the anterior column with a medialized quadrilateral plate can be addressed successfully through the Pararectus approach, in which surgical access is associated with minimal morbidity. However, long-term results following the two presented Bernese approaches are needed to confirm that in the treatment of complex acetabular fractures the rate of poor results in almost one-third of all cases (as currently yielded using traditional approaches) might be reduced by the utilization of the presented novel approaches.