Promoter opening by sigma(54) and sigma(70) RNA polymerases: sigma factor-directed alterations in the mechanism and tightness of control

Interactions of regulated and deregulated forms of the sigma54 holoenzyme with heteroduplex promoter DNA

The bacterial sigma54 RNA polymerase holoenzyme binds to promoters as a stable closed complex that is silent for transcription unless acted upon by an enhancer-bound activator protein. Using DNA binding and transcription assays the ability of the enhancer-dependent sigma54 holoenzyme to interact with promoter DNA containing various regions of heteroduplex from -12 to -1 was assessed. Different DNA regions important for stabilising sigma54 holoenzyme-promoter interactions, destabilizing binding, limiting template utilisation in activator-dependent transcription and for stable binding of a deregulated form of the holoenzyme lacking sigma54 Region I were identified. It appears that homoduplex structures are required for early events in sigma54 holoenzyme promoter binding and that disruption of a repressive fork junction structure only modestly deregulates transcription. DNA opening from -5 to -1 appears important for stable engagement of the holoenzyme following activation. The regulatory Region I of sigma54 was shown to be involved in interactions with the sequences in the -5 to -1 area.

Correlating protein footprinting with mutational analysis in the bacterial transcription factor sigma54 (sigmaN)

Protein footprints of the enhancer-dependent sigma54 protein, upon binding the Escherichia coli RNA polymerase core enzyme or upon forming closed promoter complexes, identified surface-exposed residues in sigma54 of potential functional importance at the interface between sigma54 and core RNA polymerases (RNAP) or DNA. We have now characterised alanine and glycine substitution mutants at several of these positions. Properties of the mutant sigma54s correlate protein footprints to activity. Some mutants show elevated DNA binding suggesting that promoter binding by holoenzyme may be limited to enable normal functioning. One such mutant (F318A) within the DNA binding domain of sigma54 shows a changed interaction with the promoter regulatory region implicated in transcription silencing and fails to silence transcription in vitro. It appears specifically defective in preferentially binding to a repressive DNA structure believed to restrict RNA polymerase isomerisation and is largely intact for activator responsiveness. Two mutants, one in the regulatory region I and the other within core interacting sequences of sigma54, failed to stably bind the activator in the presence of ADP-aluminium fluoride, an analogue of ATP in the transition state for hydrolysis. Overall, the data presented describe a collection sigma54 mutants that have escaped previous analysis and display an array of properties which allows the role of surface-exposed residues in the regulation of open complex formation and promoter DNA binding to be better understood. Their properties support the view that the interface between sigma54 and core RNAP is functionally specialised.

DNA supercoiling allows enhancer action over a large distance

Enhancers are regulatory DNA elements that can activate their genomic targets over a large distance. The mechanism of enhancer action over large distance is unknown. Activation of the glnAp2 promoter by NtrC-dependent enhancer in Escherichia coli was analyzed by using a purified system supporting multiple-round transcription in vitro. The data suggest that DNA supercoiling is an essential requirement for enhancer action over a large distance (2,500 bp) but not over a short distance (110 bp). DNA supercoiling facilitates functional enhancer-promoter communication over a large distance, probably by bringing the enhancer and promoter into close proximity.

The regulatory N-terminal region of the aromatic-responsive transcriptional activator DmpR constrains nucleotide-triggered multimerisation

The transcriptional promoting activity of DmpR is under the strict control of its aromatic effector ligands that are bound by its regulatory N-terminal domain. The positive control function of DmpR resides within the central C-domain that is highly conserved among activators of sigma(54)-RNA polymerase. The C-domain mediates ATP hydrolysis and interaction with sigma(54)-RNA polymerase that are essential for open-complex formation and thus initiation of transcription. Wild-type and loss-of-function derivatives of DmpR, which are defective in distinct steps in nucleotide catalysis, were used to address the consequences of nucleotide binding and hydrolysis with respect to the multimeric state of DmpR and its ability to promote in vitro transcription. Here, we show that DmpR derivatives deleted of the regulatory N-terminal domain undergo an aromatic-effector independent ATP-binding triggered multimerisation as detected by cross-linking. In the intact protein, however, aromatic effector activation is required before ATP-binding can trigger an apparent dimer-to-hexamer switch in subunit conformation. The data suggest a model in which the N-terminal domain controls the transcriptional promoting property of DmpR by constraining ATP-mediated changes in its oligomeric state. The results are discussed in the light of recent mechanistic insights from the AAA(+) superfamily of ATPases that utilise nucleotide hydrolysis to restructure their substrates.

Binding of transcriptional activators to sigma 54 in the presence of the transition state analog ADP-aluminum fluoride: insights into activator mechanochemical action

Conformational changes in sigma 54 (sigma(54)) and sigma(54)-holoenzyme depend on nucleotide hydrolysis by an activator. We now show that sigma(54) and its holoenzyme bind to the central ATP-hydrolyzing domains of the transcriptional activators PspF and NifA in the presence of ADP-aluminum fluoride, an analog of ATP in the transition state for hydrolysis. Direct binding of sigma(54) Region I to activator in the presence of ADP-aluminum fluoride was shown and inferred from in vivo suppression genetics. Energy transduction appears to occur through activator contacts to sigma(54) Region I. ADP-aluminum fluoride-dependent interactions and consideration of other AAA+ proteins provide insight into activator mechanochemical action.

Function of the bacterial TATAAT -10 element as single-stranded DNA during RNA polymerase isomerization

The bacterial TATAAT -10 region sequence was the first promoter element to be identified, but how it functions is still not clear. Because the duplex element is melted during initiation, the effects of substitutions were studied in both single-and double-strand contexts. Band-shift results were particularly unexpected in the context of melted DNA. The effect of the lac UV5-melted -10 region on polymerase binding was found to include a large sequence nonspecific contribution. Instead the dominant role of single-stranded -10 region nucleotides was in directing the isomerization of the RNA polymerase to its heparin resistant form. This role becomes minimal when the melting is extended beyond the -10 region to encompass the transcription start site, as in the final open complex. The duplex binding results are in agreement with previous reports that showed positions -12T and -11A are of primary importance for promoter recognition. Thus the consensus -10 region sequences function in two ways, both before full promoter melting. They stabilize initial polymerase binding via duplex interactions and subsequently as single-stranded DNA they promote enzyme isomerization to the functional form.

The RNA polymerase III transcription initiation factor TFIIIB participates in two steps of promoter opening

Evidence for post-recruitment functions of yeast transcription factor (TF)IIIB in initiation of transcription was first provided by the properties of TFIIIB-RNA polymerase III-promoter complexes assembled with deletion mutants of its Brf and B" subunits that are transcriptionally inactive because they fail to open the promoter. The experiments presented here show that these defects can be repaired by unpairing short (3 or 5 bp) DNA segments spanning the transcription bubble of the open promoter complex. Analysis of this suppression phenomenon indicates that TFIIIB participates in two steps of promoter opening by RNA polymerase III that are comparable to the successive steps of promoter opening by bacterial RNA polymerase holoenzyme. B" deletions between amino acids 355 and 421 interfere with the initiating step of DNA strand separation at the upstream end of the transcription bubble. Removing an N-terminal domain of Brf interferes with downstream propagation of the transcription bubble to and beyond the transcriptional start site.

How sigma docks to RNA polymerase and what sigma does

It is clear that multiple sites of interaction exist between sigmas and core subunits, likely reflecting the changing pattern of interactions that occur sequentially during the complex process of holoenzyme formation, open promoter formation, and initiation of transcription. Recent studies have revealed that a major site of interaction of Escherichia coli sigma factors is the amino acid 260-309 coiled-coil region of the beta' subunit of core RNA polymerase. This region of beta' interacts with region 2.1-2.2 of sigma(70). Binding of this region of beta' to sigma(70) triggers a conformational change in sigma that allows it to bind to a -10 nontemplate promoter DNA strand oligonucleotide.

Transcriptional regulation at a distance in bacteria

Transcriptional enhancers are cis-acting DNA elements that are binding sites for regulatory proteins and function at large distances from promoter elements to stimulate transcription. Once thought to be unique to eukaryotes, enhancer-like elements have been discovered in a wide variety of bacteria. The regulatory proteins that bind to these bacterial enhancers must contact RNA polymerase to activate transcription. In principle, interactions between bacterial enhancer-binding proteins and RNA polymerase can occur by either DNA looping or tracking of the enhancer-binding protein along the DNA. Paradigms for each of these methods are found in bacterial systems. Activators of sigma(54)-RNA polymerase holoenzyme contact polymerase by DNA looping, while bacteriophage T4 gp45 functions as a sliding clamp that tracks along DNA until it engages RNA polymerase. Significant advances have been made over the last few years towards understanding the mechanisms by which bacterial enhancer-binding proteins activate transcription, but important aspects of these mechanisms are still poorly defined.

Roles for the C-terminal region of sigma 54 in transcriptional silencing and DNA binding

Twenty-one conserved positively charged and aromatic amino acids between residues 331 and 462 of sigma 54 were changed to alanine, and the mutant proteins were studied by transcription, band shift analysis, and footprinting in vitro. A small segment corresponding to the rpoN box was found to be most important for binding duplex DNA. Two amino acids, 52 residues apart, were found to be critical for maintaining transcriptional silencing in the absence of activator. These two activator bypass mutants and several other mutants failed to bind the type of fork junction DNA thought to be required to maintain silencing. The two bypass mutants showed a binding pattern to DNA probes that was unique, both in comparison to other C-terminal mutants and to previously known N-terminal bypass mutants. On this basis, a model is proposed for the role of the C terminus and the N terminus of sigma 54 in enhancer-dependent transcription.

Regulatory sequences in sigma 54 localise near the start of DNA melting

Transcription initiation by the enhancer-dependent sigma(54) RNA polymerase holoenzyme is positively regulated after promoter binding. The promoter DNA melting process is subject to activation by an enhancer-bound activator protein with nucleoside triphosphate hydrolysis activity. Tethered iron chelate probes attached to amino and carboxyl-terminal domains of sigma(54) were used to map sigma(54)-DNA interaction sites. The two domains localise to form a centre over the -12 promoter region. The use of deletion mutants of sigma(54) suggests that amino-terminal and carboxyl-terminal sequences are both needed for the centre to function. Upon activation, the relationship between the centre and promoter DNA changes. We suggest that the activator re-organises the centre to favour stable open complex formation through adjustments in sigma(54)-DNA contact and sigma(54) conformation. The centre is close to the active site of the RNA polymerase and includes sigma(54) regulatory sequences needed for DNA melting upon activation. This contrasts systems where activators recruit RNA polymerase to promoter DNA, and the protein and DNA determinants required for activation localise away from promoter sequences closely associated with the start of DNA melting.

DNA melting within a binary sigma(54)-promoter DNA complex

The final sigma(54) subunit of the bacterial RNA polymerase requires the action of specialized enhancer-binding activators to initiate transcription. Here we show that final sigma(54) is able to melt promoter DNA when it is bound to a DNA structure representing the initial nucleation of DNA opening found in closed complexes. Melting occurs in response to activator in a nucleotide-hydrolyzing reaction and appears to spread downstream from the nucleation point toward the transcription start site. We show that final sigma(54) contains some weak determinants for DNA melting that are masked by the Region I sequences and some strong ones that require Region I. It seems that final sigma(54) binds to DNA in a self-inhibited state, and one function of the activator is therefore to promote a conformational change in final sigma(54) to reveal its DNA-melting activity. Results with the holoenzyme bound to early melted DNA suggest an ordered series of events in which changes in core to final sigma(54) interactions and final sigma(54)-DNA interactions occur in response to activator to allow final sigma(54) isomerization and the holoenzyme to progress from the closed complex to the open complex.