Reverse Brazil nut problem: competition between percolation and condensation

Effects of packing density on the segregative behaviors of granular systems

We present results concerning the important role of system packing in the processes of density- and inelasticity-induced segregation in vibrofluidized binary granular beds. Data are acquired through a combination of experimental results acquired from positron emission particle tracking and simulations performed using the discrete particle method. It is found that segregation due to inelasticity differences between particle species is most pronounced in moderately dense systems, yet still exerts a significant effect in all but the highest density systems. Results concerning segregation due to disparities in particles' material densities show that the maximal degree to which a system can achieve segregation is directly related to the density of the system, while the rate at which segregation occurs shows an inverse relation. Based on this observation, a method of minimizing the time and energy requirements associated with producing a fully segregated system is proposed.

Spin Brazil-nut effect and its reverse in a rotating double-walled drum

The segregation of binary mixtures in a filled rotating double-walled drum is explored by simulations. Based on the characteristics of self-gravity and the centrifugal force, we argue that both percolation and buoyancy effects dominate the segregation process. The simulational results show that up to long enough times the segregation state is controlled by the rotational speed, the particle radius and density. At low rotational speeds, the smaller and heavier particles tend to accumulate towards the inner drum wall and the bigger and lighter ones towards the outer drum wall, while the segregation pattern reverses completely at higher rotational speeds. Two typical phase diagrams in the space of the density and radius ratio of bigger particles to smaller particles further confirm the predictions.

Segregation in mixtures of granular chains and spherical grains under vertical vibration

We experimentally investigate segregation behaviors of binary granular mixtures consisting of granular chains and spherical grains with different interstitial media under vertical vibrations. A quantitative criterion is proposed to locate the boundaries between different vibrating phases. The water-immersed granular mixture exhibits two interesting types of segregation behaviors: chain-on-top and sandwich patterns. However, the phenomenon of sandwich segregation is absent for the air-immersed mixture. The topological differences of phase diagrams between two different environments indicate that the interstitial fluid plays an important role on the granular demixing. Additionally, the phase behaviors of mixtures for the different chain lengths show a not significant discrepancy. Finally, the vibrating thickness ratio determining the phase boundary characterizes the mixing extent of the granular bed. The estimated ratios for various chain lengths exhibit a monotonically decreasing dependence, when the vibration frequency increases.

Separation patterns between Brazilian nut and reversed Brazilian nut of a binary granular system

This paper studies the segregation behavior of binary granular particles with diameters at approximately 10:1 in a vertically vibrated container. An array of transitional separation patterns between reversed Brazilian nut (RBN) and Brazilian nut (BN) separations are observed, with their geometrical features carefully measured. The binary particle system develops into either a stable separation pattern when f and Γ are relatively low or an oscillating pattern when f and Γ are relatively high. We regard these patterns as different phases, in which the stable patterns can be divided into phases of RBN, RBN transitional (RBNT), BNT, and BN. A phase parameter λ between-1 and 1 is defined to describe the separation patterns based on the mass center height difference in large and small particles. By drawing f-Γ-λ phase diagrams, the system's tendency toward BN separation was found to increase with f and decrease with Γ. Furthermore, the range of the tendency toward BN separation expands when the size of small particles rises. As the total mass of the small particles increases, the system's tendency toward RBN separation is enhanced. Abnormal points are also observed in the stable phase regions, and the oscillating phase shifts among the four stable phases with time. These stable phases can be explained via an analysis of the distribution of the dissipation energy, whereas the mechanism of the oscillating phase remains to be discovered.

Nonadditivity of fluctuation-induced forces in fluidized granular media

We investigate the effective long-range interactions between intruder particles immersed in a randomly driven granular fluid. The effective Casimir-like force between two intruders, induced by the fluctuations of the hydrodynamic fields, can change its sign when varying the control parameters: the volume fraction, the distance between the intruders, and the restitution coefficient. More interestingly, by inserting more intruders, we verify that the fluctuation-induced interaction is not pairwise additive. The simulation results are qualitatively consistent with the theoretical predictions based on mode coupling calculations. These results shed new light on the underlying mechanisms of collective behaviors in fluidized granular media.

Ringlike spin segregation of binary mixtures in a high-velocity rotating drum

This study presents molecular dynamics simulations on the segregation of binary mixtures in a high-velocity rotating drum. Depending on the ratio between the particle radius and density, similarities to the Brazil-nut effect and its reverse form are shown in the ringlike spin segregation patterns in radial direction. The smaller and heavier particles accumulated toward the drum wall, whereas the bigger and lighter particles accumulated toward the drum center. The effects of particle radius and density on the segregation states were quantified and the phase diagram of segregation in the ρ(b)/ρ(s) - r(b)/r(s) space was plotted. The observed phenomena can be explained by the combined percolation and the buoyancy effects.

Thermal segregation of intruders in the Fourier state of a granular gas

A low density binary mixture of granular gases is considered within the Boltzmann kinetic theory. One component, the intruders, is taken to be dilute with respect to the other, and thermal segregation of the two species is described for a special solution to the Boltzmann equation. This solution has a macroscopic hydrodynamic representation with a constant temperature gradient and is referred to as the Fourier state. The thermal diffusion factor characterizing conditions for segregation is calculated without the usual restriction to Navier-Stokes hydrodynamics. Integral equations for the coefficients in this hydrodynamic description are calculated approximately within a Sonine polynomial expansion. Molecular dynamics simulations are reported, confirming the existence of this idealized Fourier state. Good agreement is found for the predicted and simulated thermal diffusion coefficient, while only qualitative agreement is found for the temperature ratio.

Segregation of an intruder in a heated granular dense gas

A recent segregation criterion [Phys. Rev. E 78, 020301(R) (2008)] based on the thermal diffusion factor Λ of an intruder in a heated granular gas described by the inelastic Enskog equation is revisited. The sign of Λ provides a criterion for the transition between the Brazil-nut effect (BNE) and the reverse Brazil-nut effect (RBNE). The present theory incorporates two extra ingredients not accounted for by the previous theoretical attempt. First, the theory is based upon the second Sonine approximation to the transport coefficients of the mass flux of the intruder. Second, the dependence of the temperature ratio (intruder temperature over that of the host granular gas) on the solid volume fraction is taken into account in the first and second Sonine approximations. In order to check the accuracy of the Sonine approximation considered, the Enskog equation is also numerically solved by means of the direct simulation Monte Carlo method to get the kinetic diffusion coefficient D(0). The comparison between theory and simulation shows that the second Sonine approximation to D(0) yields an improvement over the first Sonine approximation when the intruder is lighter than the gas particles in the range of large inelasticity. With respect to the form of the phase diagrams for the BNE-RBNE transition, the kinetic theory results for the factor Λ indicate that while the form of these diagrams depends sensitively on the order of the Sonine approximation considered when gravity is absent, no significant differences between both Sonine solutions appear in the opposite limit (gravity dominates the thermal gradient). In the former case (no gravity), the first Sonine approximation overestimates both the RBNE region and the influence of dissipation on thermal diffusion segregation.

Horizontal segregation in a vertically vibrated binary granular system

We present numerical simulations and experiments on the horizontal transport and segregation of binary granular mixtures with different sizes and/or different densities in a vertically vibrated container with a sawtooth-shaped base. The larger particles migrate to the positive or negative end of the container, depending on the ratios of the diameters and the densities of two kinds of particles, the vibrating frequencies, and the accelerations. In particular, horizontal segregation occurred even if all the particles have the same size but different densities.

Swimming in granular media

A class of reptiles known as sand swimmers adapts to hot environments by submerging beneath desert sands during the day and so provide a unique probe into the dynamics of intruders in granular beds. To understand the mechanism for swimming in an otherwise solid bed, we study a simple model of periodic contraction and extension of large intruders in a granular bed. Using an event-driven simulation, we find optimal conditions that idealized swimmers must use to critically fluidize a sand bed so that it is rigid enough to support a load when needed, but fluid enough to permit motion with minimal resistance. Swimmers-or other intruders-that agitate the bed too rapidly produce large voids that prevent traction from being achieved, while swimmers that move too slowly cannot travel before the bed resolidifies around them, i.e., the swimmers locally probe the fundamental time scale in a granular packing.

Segregation by thermal diffusion in moderately dense granular mixtures

A theory based on a solution of the inelastic Enskog equation that goes beyond the weak dissipation limit is used to determine the thermal diffusion factor of a binary granular mixture under gravity. The Enskog equation that aims to describe moderate densities neglects velocity correlations but retains spatial correlations arising from volume exclusion effects. As expected, the thermal diffusion factor provides a segregation criterion that shows the transition between the Brazil-nut effect (BNE) and the reverse Brazil-nut effect (RBNE) by varying the parameters of the system (masses, sizes, composition, density and coefficients of restitution). The form of the phase diagrams for the BNE/RBNE transition is illustrated in detail in the tracer limit case, showing that the phase diagrams depend sensitively on the value of gravity relative to the thermal gradient. Two specific situations are considered: i) absence of gravity, and ii) homogeneous temperature. In the latter case, after some approximations, our results are consistent with previous theoretical results derived from the Enskog equation. Our results also indicate that the influence of dissipation on thermal diffusion is more important in the absence of gravity than in the opposite limit. The present analysis, which is based on a preliminary short report of the author (Phys. Rev. E 78, 020301(R) (2008)), extends previous theoretical results derived in the dilute limit case.

Rise of a Brazil nut: a transition line

Using molecular dynamics we study the behavior of a large particle immersed in a bed of smaller ones. The system is bidimensional, consisting of many rough inelastic hard disks of equal size plus a larger one: the intruder. All possible parameters of the system are kept fixed except for two dimensionless parameters determining the frequency and amplitude of the vibrating base. A systematic exploration of this parameter space leads to determining a transition line separating a zone in which the Brazil nut effect is observed and one in which it is not. The results strongly suggest that, in the region of the parameter space in which the study is made, there is a minimum amplitude and a maximum frequency for the Brazil nut effect to take place. These results compare well with isolated results from other authors.

Brazil-nut effect versus reverse Brazil-nut effect in a moderately dense granular fluid

A segregation criterion based on the inelastic Enskog kinetic equation is derived to show the transition between the Brazil-nut effect (BNE) and the reverse Brazil-nut effect (RBNE) by varying the different parameters of the system. In contrast to previous theoretical attempts, the approach is not limited to the near-elastic case, takes into account the influence of both thermal gradients and gravity, and applies for moderate densities. The form of the phase diagrams for the BNE-RBNE transition depends sensitively on the value of gravity relative to the thermal gradient, so that it is possible to switch between both states for given values of the mass and size ratios, the coefficients of restitution, and the solid volume fraction. In particular, the influence of collisional dissipation on segregation becomes more important when the thermal gradient dominates over gravity than in the opposite limit. The present analysis extends previous results derived in the dilute limit case and is consistent with the findings of some recent experimental results.

Spiral trajectory in the horizontal Brazil nut effect

An intruder to a group of identical beads contained in a circular plate which is subjected to a circular vibration will trace approximately a cyclic spiral. The trajectory is a result of both migration and rotation. The intruder migrates in the radial direction while rotating with a constant speed with respect to the center of mass of the whole group of beads. The rotation velocity is due to friction between the beads and the container wall and determined by the vibration amplitude and the number of beads. The migration direction is dependent on the size ratio and mass ratio of the intruder to the background beads. The migration speed is constant for the outward migration, but decreases gradually when the intruder migrates toward the center of mass of the whole cluster for the inward case.

Density-driven segregation in vertically vibrated binary granular mixtures

Segregation in vertically vibrated binary granular mixtures with the same size is studied experimentally. The partially segregated state occurring in this system is observed carefully. We find that the characteristic of the partially segregated state is that the lighter particles tend to rise and form a pure layer on the top of the system while the heavier particles and some of the lighter ones stay at the bottom and form a mixed layer. The ratio of the thickness of the pure top layer to that of the whole system can be taken as an order parameter, which describes the degree of the segregation quantitatively and is useful in the investigation of the system. By use of it, we find that the segregation state is only dependent on the density ratio of the two kinds of particles. The dependent of the segregation on the vibration frequency is also studied by use of this order parameter, and finally, two typical phase diagrams are given.

Experimental observation of structural crossover in binary mixtures of colloidal hard spheres

Using confocal microscopy, we investigate the structure of binary mixtures of colloidal hard spheres with size ratio q=0.61. As a function of the packing fraction of the two particle species, we observe a marked change of the dominant wavelength in the pair-correlation function. This behavior is in excellent agreement with a recently predicted structural crossover in such mixtures. In addition, the repercussions of structural crossover on the real-space structure of a binary fluid are analyzed. We suggest a relation between crossover and the lateral extension of networks containing only equally-sized particles that are connected by nearest-neighbor bonds. This is supported by Monte Carlo simulations which are performed at different packing fractions and size ratios.

Intruder clustering in three-dimensional granular beds

We present results of computer simulations for neutrally buoyant intruders in a vertically vibrated three-dimensional granular bed of smaller host particles. Under sinusoidal excitation, pairs of intruders interact over a distance of several intruder diameters; a group of intruders forms a cluster. The strength of the interaction grows as the number of intruders is increased. We show that the tendency to cluster may be manipulated through the use of nonsinusoidal excitation, which allows partial mixing. Finally, we investigate the effects of walls on the clustering of intruders.

Experimental observations of oscillations and segregation in a binary granular mixture

We present experimental evidence for a "granular clock." We use a setup in which vertical vibrations (10-20 Hz) of a bidisperse granular medium cause horizontal oscillations (periods in the order of minutes) between two connected compartments. Moreover, we present the first experimental evidence for full segregation of smaller particles into one compartment, leaving the larger ones in the other compartment. Simulations, using a simple model, describe phenomenologically the observed oscillations.

Mechanisms in the size segregation of a binary granular mixture

A granular mixture of particles of two sizes that is shaken vertically will in most cases segregate. If the larger particles accumulate at the top of the sample, this is called the Brazil-nut effect (BNE); if they accumulate at the bottom, it is called the reverse Brazil-nut effect (RBNE). While this process is of great industrial importance in the handling of bulk solids, it is not well understood. In recent years ten different mechanisms have been suggested to explain when each type of segregation is observed. However, the dependence of the mechanisms on driving conditions and material parameters and hence their relative importance is largely unknown. In this paper we present experiments and simulations where both types of particles are made from the same material and shaken under low air pressure, which reduces the number of mechanisms to be considered to seven. We observe both BNE and RBNE by varying systematically the driving frequency and amplitude, diameter ratio, ratio of total volume of small to large particles, and overall sample volume. All our results can be explained by a combination of three mechanisms: a geometrical mechanism called void filling, transport of particles in sidewall-driven convection rolls, and thermal diffusion, a mechanism predicted by kinetic theory.

Hydrodynamic profiles for an impurity in an open vibrated granular gas

The hydrodynamic state of an impurity immersed in a low density granular gas is analyzed. Explicit expressions for the temperature and density fields of the impurity in terms of the hydrodynamic fields of the gas are derived. It is shown that the ratio between the temperatures of the two components, measuring the departure from the energy equipartition, only depends on the mechanical properties of the particles, being therefore constant in the bulk of the system. This ratio plays an important role in determining the density profile of the intruder and its position with respect to the gas, since it determines the sign of the pressure diffusion coefficient. The theoretical predictions are compared with molecular dynamics simulation results for the particular case of the steady state of an open vibrated granular system in the absence of macroscopic fluxes, and a satisfactory agreement is found.

Segregation of large granules from close-packed cluster of small granules due to buoyancy

Segregation of large granules in a vibrofluidized granular bed with inhomogeneous granular number density distribution is studied by an event-driven algorithm. Simulation results show that the mean vertical position of large granules decreases with the increase of the density ration of the large granules to the small ones. This conclusion is consistent with the explanation that the net pressure due to the small surrounding particle impacts balances the large granular weight, and indict that the upward movement of the large granules is driven by the buoyancy. The values of temperature, density, and pressure of the systems are also computed by changing the conditions such as heating temperature on the bottom and restitution coefficient of particles. These results indicate that the segregation of large granules also happen in the systems with density inversion or even close-packed cluster of particles floating on a low-density fluid, due to the buoyancy. An equation of state is proposed to explain the buoyancy.

Granular species segregation under vertical tapping: effects of size, density, friction, and shaking amplitude

We present extensive molecular dynamics simulations on species segregation in a granular mixture subject to vertical taps. We discuss how grain properties, e.g., size, density, friction, as well as shaking properties, e.g., amplitude and frequency, affect such a phenomenon. Both the Brazil nut effect (larger particles on the top, BN) and the reverse Brazil nut effect (larger particles on the bottom, RBN) are found and we derive the system comprehensive "segregation diagram" and the BN to RBN crossover line. We also discuss the role of friction and show that particles which differ only for their frictional properties segregate in states depending on the tapping acceleration and frequency.

Cluster kinetics model of particle separation in vibrated granular media

We model the Brazil-nut effect (BNE) by hypothesizing that granules form clusters that fragment and aggregate. This provides a heterogeneous medium in which the immersed intruder particle rises (BNE) or sinks (reverse BNE) according to relative convection currents and buoyant and drag forces. A simple relationship proposed for viscous drag in terms of the vibrational intensity and the particle to grain density ratio allows simulation of published experimental data for rise and sink times as functions of particle radius, initial depth of the particle, and particle-grain density ratio. The proposed model correctly describes the experimentally observed maximum in risetime.

Reversing the Brazil nut effect

We propose a lattice model for studying the Brazil Nut Effect (BNE), i.e. the phase segregation occurring when a granular material is vertically shaked. The model considers the tap intensity and the mobility mu of the grains as the main physical parameters. Different mobilities for different grain species lead to segregation (BNE) patterns, reverse segregation (RBNE) patterns, "sandwhich" layered structures or vertical domains. A phase diagram (decompaction chi, mobility difference between both species Delta mu) is obtained in which the different phases are emphasized. In a narrow region of the diagram, different phases coexist. It is shown that the BNE segregation could be reversed by increasing the tap intensity or the characteristics of the grains. Numerical results are compared with earlier experimental works.

Energy partition and segregation for an intruder in a vibrated granular system under gravity

The difference of temperatures between an impurity and the surrounding gas in an open vibrated granular system is studied. It is shown that, in spite of the high inhomogeneity of the state, the temperature ratio remains constant in the bulk of the system. The lack of energy equipartition is associated to the change of sign of the pressure diffusion coefficient for the impurity at certain values of the parameters of the system, leading to a segregation criterium. The theoretical predictions are consistent with previous experimental results, and also in agreement with molecular dynamics simulation results reported in this Letter.

Size segregation in granular media induced by phase transition

In order to study analytically the nature of the size segregation in granular mixtures, we introduce a mean field theory in the framework of a statistical mechanics approach, based on Edwards' original ideas. For simplicity we apply the theory to a lattice model for a hard sphere binary mixture under gravity, and we find a new purely thermodynamic mechanism that gives rise to the size segregation phenomenon. By varying the number of small grains and the mass ratio, we find a crossover from the Brazil nut to the reverse Brazil nut effect, which becomes a true phase transition when the number of small grains is larger then a critical value. We suggest that this transition is induced by the effective attraction between large grains due to the presence of small ones (depletion force). Finally the theoretical results are confirmed by numerical simulations of the 3d system under taps.

Brazil nut effect and excluded volume attraction in vibrofluidized granular mixtures

A two dimensional bi-disperse vibrofluidized granular mixture is studied in the rapid flow regime, where particle interactions occur due to instantaneous collisions. Both experiments and simulations are carried out, and these show the existence of two phenomena which have been observed only in very dense granular flows or in equilibrium systems. The Brazil nut phenomenon, which involves the rise of larger particles in a granular mixture upon vibration, has been observed in dense systems due to the percolation of small particles though the interstitial spaces between the large particles, or due to convection rolls. In the present case, where neither effect is present, it is observed that the fluidization of the smaller particles by vibration results in an exponentially decaying density profile, at heights large compared to the particle diameter, and thereby a pressure field that decreases with height. The larger particles, suspended in this decaying pressure field, experience a larger pressure at the bottom and a smaller pressure on top, and they rise to a height where the net force caused by the decreasing pressure is balanced by the weight of the particle. An attractive force between the large particles, similar to the entropic attraction effect in mixtures of colloids and polymers, is also observed in this nonequilibrium system, because when the distance between the large particles is less than the small particle diameter, the pressure between the large particles is smaller than that on the outside. Analytical results are derived for each of these effects, and these are in agreement with the experimental and simulation results.

A horizontal Brazil-nut effect and its reverse

Transport effects in a monolayer consisting of a binary granular mixture, confined in a horizontally vibrating circular dish, are studied experimentally and compared with a reduced theoretical model. Depending on the ratio of the particles' material density and size, migration of the larger particles occurs either towards the boundary or to the center of the circular container. These directed motions show similarities to the Brazil-nut effect and its reverse form.

Effect of air on granular size separation in a vibrated granular bed

Using high-speed video and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) we study the motion of a large sphere in a vertically vibrated bed of smaller grains. As previously reported we find a nonmonotonic density dependence of the rise and sink time of the large sphere. We show that air drag causes relative motion between the intruder and the bed during the shaking cycle and is ultimately responsible for the observed density dependence of the risetime. We investigate in detail how the motion of the intruder sphere is influenced by size of the background particles, initial vertical position in the bed, ambient pressure, and convection. We explain our results in the framework of a simple model and find quantitative agreement in key aspects with numerical simulations to the model equations.

Jamming transition in a highly dense granular system under vertical vibration

The dynamics of the jamming transition in a three-dimensional granular system under vertical vibration is studied using diffusing-wave spectroscopy. When the maximum acceleration of the external vibration is large, the granular system behaves like a fluid, with the dynamic correlation function G (t) relaxing rapidly. As the acceleration of vibration approaches the gravitational acceleration g , the relaxation of G (t) slows down dramatically, and eventually stops. Thus the system undergoes a phase transition and behaves like a solid. Near the transition point, we find that the structural relaxation shows a stretched exponential behavior. This behavior is analogous to the behavior of supercooled liquids close to the glass transition.

Combined size and density segregation and mixing in noncircular tumblers

Flowing granular materials segregate due to differences in particle size (driven by percolation) and density (driven by buoyancy). For noncircular tumblers the additional interaction between the segregation mechanisms and chaotic advection complicates the physics. Experiments are performed using a bi-disperse mixture of equal volumes of different sizes of steel and glass beads in a quasi-two-dimensional square tumbler. Mixing is observed instead of segregation when the denser beads are larger than the lighter beads so that the ratio of particle sizes is greater than the ratio of particle densities. This can be expressed in terms of the particle diameters and masses as d(heavy)/d(light) >(m(heavy)/m(light))(1/4) . Segregation patterns vary from a semicircular core when the fill level is below 50% to more complicated patterns including lobes and streaks for fill levels above 50%. Temporal evolution of segregated patterns is quantified in terms of a "segregation index" (based on the area of the segregated pattern) to capture both the rate and extent of segregation at different particle properties. The circular and noncircular tumblers have no significant difference in the segregation index, even though the segregation patterns differ significantly.