Practice guidelines for the renal biopsy

Retrieval of kidney tissue for light microscopy from frozen tissue processed for immunofluorescence: A simple procedure to avoid repeat kidney biopsies

We highlight a method that is helpful in situations where the tissue sent for LM is inadequate whereas the tissue sent for IF showed glomeruli useful for interpretation. We utilized the leftover frozen tissue after the sections for IF were taken. This tissue was post-fixed in formalin for the purpose of light microscopic diagnosis. The glomerular pathology could be commented upon with a fair degree of accuracy and a repeat biopsy was avoided in 74.7% of the cases. However, the tubules showed marked fixation artefact and tubular pathology was distorted. This procedure can help to reach a correct diagnosis in large percentage of cases otherwise labeled as inadequate biopsy and hence, save the patient from the trauma of a repeat biopsy.

Determination of primary versus secondary membranous glomerulopathy utilizing phospholipase A2 receptor staining in renal biopsies

Autoantibody formation directed against phospholipase A2 receptor (PLA2R)1 is the underlying etiology in most cases of primary membranous glomerulopathy. This new understanding of the pathogenesis of primary membranous is in the process of transforming the way the disease is diagnosed. We validated an indirect immunofluorescence assay to examine PLA2R1 in renal biopsies utilizing a commercially available antibody and standard indirect immunofluorescence. Using this assay, we examined a total of 165 cases of membranous glomerulopathy including 85 primary and 80 secondary. We found tissue staining for PLA2R1 to have a sensitivity of 75% (95% CI 65-84%) and a specificity of 83% (95% CI 72-90%) for primary membranous glomerulopathy. Hepatitis C virus was the secondary etiology with the most number of cases staining positive for PLA2R1 (7/11, 64%) followed by sarcoidosis (3/4, 75%) and neoplasm (3/12, 25%). Autoimmune etiologies showed rare PLA2R1-positive staining (1/46, 2%). All cases of secondary membranous glomerulopathy with positive PLA2R1 showed IgG4-predominant staining, which is typically associated with primary membranous glomerulopathy. This IgG4 predominance raises the possibility that these cases are more pathogenically related to primary membranous glomerulopathy than secondary. We present the largest case series to date examining PLA2R1 involvement in membranous glomerulopathy utilizing a technique that is readily adoptable by most renal pathology laboratories.

Renal medullary angiitis: a case series from a single institution

Renal medullary angiitis is a lesion involving the vasa recta of the medulla. The characteristic morphologic findings on renal biopsy include interstitial hemorrhage with associated polymorphonuclear leukocyte infiltration and karyorrhectic debris. A total of 18 cases have been described in three publications, all in the setting of antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated disease. We sought to detail the morphology and clinical significance of this lesion. A total of 38 cases of medullary angiitis were identified in our case files from January 2008 through August 2011. The clinical history was reviewed and pertinent information including patient age, gender, indication for biopsy, serum creatinine, and any positive serologic tests (ANCA) was collected for each biopsy. Cases with known and unknown ANCA status were reported separately. In total, 19 (63%) of 30 cases of medullary angiitis with known ANCA antibody status were ANCA positive, whereas 11 (37%) of 30 were determined to be secondary to other etiologies. The most common non-ANCA etiology of medullary angiitis was immunoglobulin A nephropathy (20%) followed by antibiotic treatment in the setting of infection. In ANCA-unknown cases, 4 (50%) of 8 had pauci-immune crescentic glomerulonephritis. No cases had renal cortex involvement. This is the largest study to date detailing the morphology of medullary angiitis and the first to show medullary angiitis outside the setting of ANCA-associated disease. It is an important lesion to recognize as it frequently suggests the presence of a systemic vasculitis and could be mistaken for interstitial nephritis.

A position paper on standardizing the nonneoplastic kidney biopsy report

The biopsy report for nonneoplastic kidney diseases represents a complex integration of clinical data with light, immunofluorescence, and electron microscopic findings. Practice guidelines for the handling and processing of the renal biopsy have previously been created. However, specific guidelines for essential pathologic parameters that should be included in these pathology reports do not exist. The Renal Pathology Society has coordinated an effort through the formation of an ad hoc committee to enumerate the essential elements and pathologic parameters that should be reported for every biopsy specimen. This endeavor aims to establish a minimum reporting standard and to improve communication between pathologists and other physicians. This document represents the collective effort and consensus opinions of this ad hoc committee of the Renal Pathology Society.

Pilot evaluation of a vacuum-assisted biopsy instrument for percutaneous renal biopsy in dogs

Kidney biopsies in dogs are commonly obtained using automated spring-loaded biopsy instruments. Interpretation of biopsies from dogs with glomerular disease requires examination of at least 5-10 glomeruli, with at least two biopsies usually required for full evaluation. The purpose of this study was to compare quality and interpretability of renal biopsies obtained from healthy dogs with a large-gauge, vacuum-assisted biopsy instrument versus two biopsies obtained with a spring-loaded biopsy needle. Twenty dogs were randomized into two groups, and percutaneous, ultrasound-guided renal biopsies were evaluated using standard criteria. There were no significant differences in the number of biopsies that contained renal tissue, cortex, or medulla. Biopsies obtained with either instrument contained an adequate number of glomeruli and an equivalent number of arterioles and severity of tissue compression. Differences included easier penetration of the renal capsule and collection of sufficient tissue for interpretation with only one instrument pass when using the vacuum-assisted device (vs two passes required with the spring-loaded instrument). Before use in client-owned dogs, future studies should evaluate whether these differences are clinically relevant advantages in the diagnostic evaluation of dogs with kidney disease, and determine the prevalence and severity of complications when using this larger gauge device.

Early ultrastructural changes in renal allografts: correlation with antibody-mediated rejection and transplant glomerulopathy

Transplant glomerulopathy (TG) is associated with antibody-mediated renal allograft rejection (AMR) and reduced graft survival. Histologically, TG is typically seen >1 year posttransplantation. However, ultrastructural changes including glomerular endothelial swelling, subendothelial widening and early glomerular basement membrane duplication are associated with development of TG but appear much earlier. We examined the specificity of these changes for AMR, and whether these are inevitably associated with development of TG. Of 98 for cause renal allograft biopsies carried out within 3 months of transplantation with available serologic data, 17 showed C4d-positive AMR and 16 had histologic changes of AMR and donor-specific antibodies (DSA), but no C4d. All three ultrastructural changes were seen in 11 of 17 biopsies with C4d-positive AMR, 8 of 16 with histologic changes of AMR and DSA but no C4d, and 0 of 65 without histologic changes of AMR and/or DSA (p < 0.0001 for both of the former groups vs. the latter). Twenty patients with positive DSA (18 with histologic changes of AMR and 11 C4d-positive) had ≥1 follow-up biopsy; eight developed overt TG 3.5-30 months posttransplantation. Among the 18 patients with DSA and histologic changes of AMR, 11 C4d-positive and 7 C4d-negative, treatment for AMR after the early biopsy significantly reduced subsequent development of overt TG.

Histological diagnosis determines complications of percutaneous renal biopsy: a single-center experience in 353 patients

BACKGROUND

We studied the connection between complication occurrence related to renal biopsies and histological diagnoses of the biopsy specimen. We also analyzed the distribution of diagnoses in our population.

METHODS

We retrospectively studied 353 patients undergoing renal biopsy at the same center. Biopsies were performed after marking the site of puncture by ultrasound imaging. Connection of complications with diagnoses and clinical parameters was evaluated.

RESULTS

Complication rate was 44.5% in our study. There was a significantly lower rate of complications in patients with diabetic nephropathy (likelihood ratio, LR = 0.44) or acute tubular necrosis (LR = 0.38), while patients with thin basement membrane syndrome had a more than 6-fold higher risk for development of intrarenal hemorrhage than others. Patients with vasculitis (LR = 2.88) and acute interstitial nephritis (LR = 3.18) have a more than doubled risk for arteriovenous shunts, while in patients with severe arteriosclerosis the prevalence of this complication was lower (LR = 0.46). Arteriovenous shunts developed also at a significantly higher rate in patients with rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis.

CONCLUSION

Patients with thin basement membrane syndrome, vasculitis, rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis or acute interstitial nephritis should be observed more carefully after renal biopsy due to the significantly higher risk for certain complications.

The prognostic value of frozen section preimplantation graft biopsy in the outcome of renal transplantation

INTRODUCTION

Preimplantation biopsy provides a window on the state of the renal allograft. In this study, the prognostic value of frozen section preimplantation graft biopsy was estimated and compared to regularly processed formalin-fixed biopsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-four renal allograft recipients were studied. The degree of glomerulosclerosis, acute tubular necrosis, interstitial fibrosis, arteriosclerosis, and arteriolosclerosis was rapidly estimated in frozen sections and correlated to the renal function in the immediate posttransplantation period and 3 months thereafter. The histological changes were also examined in paraffin-embedded sections.

RESULTS

The histological changes observed in rapidly processed frozen sections were comparable to those observed on regularly processed sections and their differences did not reach statistical significance. Glomerulosclerosis and arteriolosclerosis were underestimated, whereas acute tubular necrosis and interstitial fibrosis were overestimated, in the frozen sections compared to permanent ones, but those differences were not statistically significant. Immediate graft function was observed in 45 patients (61%). Delayed graft function was more frequently observed among recipients with donor age above 60 years (57% vs. 32%). Serum creatinine 3 months after transplantation was above 2 mg/dL in 33 recipients (44.5%) and was positively correlated to the degree of tubular necrosis (p = 0.04) and donor age (p = 0.03). Donor age was correlated to the degree of arteriolosclerosis (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Frozen section preimplantation biopsy gives reliable information for the situation of the graft that is related to the outcome of renal transplantation.

Expression of eNOS in kidneys from hypertensive patients

Endothelium-derived nitric oxide (NO) is essential for maintenance and regulation of blood pressure. In animal models, altered endothelium-derived nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) expression and impaired NO generation are important factors for renal injury. However, the pattern of eNOS expression in the kidneys from hypertensive patients has not been well established. We have studied the eNOS immuno-expression in kidney biopsies from hypertensive patients. Compared to kidneys from normotensive individuals, there were no significant alterations of eNOS immuno-expression in the vasculature of patients with chronic essential hypertension. In contrast, the expression of eNOS was significantly decreased in the glomeruli and arterioles/small arteries of patients with malignant hypertension, particularly in those with significant intimal edema and myxoid degeneration or thrombi. Endothelial dysfunction is an important pathogenetic factor for chronic primary hypertension and eNOS plays a major role in the regulation of vascular tone and function. Unchanged eNOS in the kidney vasculature in chronic primary hypertension indicates that these patients have an ability to compensate. In patients with malignant hypertension, the expression of eNOS protein was diminished in the injured vasculature. Loss of the compensatory mechanism via continued release of NO to prevent vascular injury may be responsible for morphological changes typically seen in the renal vasculature in patients with accelerated hypertension.

Role of immunofluorescence and electron microscopy in the evaluation of renal biopsies in nephrotic syndrome in a developing country

To determine the role of immunofluorescence (IF) and electron microscopy (EM) in the evaluation of renal biopsies in a developing country, the authors carried out a study in 200 patients with nephrotic syndrome. Renal biopsies were studied by light microscopy, IF, and EM. IF study was useful in all, being essential in 23.5% and helpful in remaining cases. EM was useful in 94.5% cases, being essential in 43% and helpful in 51.5% cases. The results demonstrate that IF and EM are essential in the evaluation of renal biopsies in nephrotic syndrome and these should be employed in the pathologic evaluation of renal biopsies.

Morphologic Manifestations of Combined Light-chain Deposition Disease and Light-chain Cast Nephropathy

There are few data on morphology of light-chain deposition disease (LCDD) of kidney with coexistent light-chain cast nephropathy (LCCN). Here, the authors report the morphology in 23 cases of LCDD and LCCN. They retrospectively evaluated 23 renal biopsies with light (LM), immunofluorescence (IF), and electron microscopy (EM). Twenty-one patients had myeloma, 1 had a monoclonal gammopathy, and in 1 no illness was found. Nodular glomerulosclerosis, the LM lesion suggestive of LCDD, was noted in only 3 of 23 cases. Glomeruli were unremarkable in 16 (69%) cases. The diagnostic casts of LCCN were seen in all biopsies. Linear light chain (LC) immunoreactivity was observed in 23 (100%) cases (18 kappa, 5 lambda); GBM + TBM in 13, TBM only in 7, GBM only in 1, TBM and interstitium in 1, GBM, TBM and mesangium in 1. Casts were positive with same LC in all cases (100%). Fifteen cases (65%) showed granular electron-dense deposits; GBM only in 5, TBM only in 5, GBM and TBM in 4, mesangium in 1. In 8 patients without EM deposits, the diagnosis of LCDD was rendered by IF. Fifteen (65%) had deposits detectable by IF and EM, 8 (37%) had deposits with IF only. LCCN dominated the LM findings in all patients. There were minimal or no glomerular changes by LM. This study shows the lack of characteristic LM findings of LCDD in combined cases of LCDD and LCCN and emphasizes the difficulty for-definitive diagnosis-without IF and EM.

The renal biopsy

CONTEXT

The first renal biopsy was carried out more than a century ago, but its widespread introduction into clinical use, beginning in the 1950s, helped develop nephrology into the powerful subspecialty of internal medicine that it is today. In the past 25 years, the use of the spring-loaded biopsy gun, in combination with newer visualization techniques, including ultrasound and computed axial tomography scanning, has led to greater tissue yield and to a much lower risk of complication. During this same time, our understanding of renal pathology has increased many fold. Correct fixation and processing of renal biopsy tissue is critical, and the laboratory must be skilled with renal biopsy light microscopy, immunohistochemistry, and transmission electron microscopy preparation.

OBJECTIVES

To provide an overview of the renal biopsy, including the techniques and its complications, and to summarize proper laboratory methods for processing renal biopsy tissue.

DATA SOURCES

This article is based on a review of the literature and on the experience of the author.

CONCLUSIONS

The experienced nephropathologist, knowledgeable in both renal medicine and pathology and thus able to correlate subtle tissue-derived information with appropriate clinical data, remains the most important key to the development of an accurate clinicopathologic diagnosis.

Spectrum of glomerulonephritides in adults with nephrotic syndrome in Pakistan

BACKGROUND

There is currently little information in literature about the pattern of glomerulonephritides (GN) in adults with nephrotic syndrome in this part of the world, particularly that involving the use of immunofluorescence (IMF) and electron microscopy (EM). A few studies reported are based on light microscopic study alone and hence do not reflect the true pattern of GN underlying nephrotic syndrome. We carried out this study in the Department of Histopathology, Sindh Institute of Urology and Transplantation (SIUT), Karachi, Pakistan to determine, for the first time, the true pattern of GN in adult nephrotic patients from Pakistan. SIUT is a tertiary care center for renal and urologic disease in Pakistan. The Histopathology Laboratory of SIUT is equipped with all the modalities, including EM, required for precise diagnosis of glomerular disease.

METHODS

This is a retrospective clinicopathologic study involving retrieval of clinical and pathological data from a review of original renal biopsy reports of adult patients with nephrotic syndrome who presented at the adult nephrology clinic of SIUT from July 1996 till July 2006. Two cores of renal tissue were routinely obtained. One core was fixed in 10% buffered formalin and processed for light microscopy; the other core was divided into two halves, for EM and the IMF study.

RESULTS

A total of 316 adult patients were included. Of these, 201 (63.6%) were male and 115 (36.4%) were female. Mean age was 28.4 +/- 10.51 years with a range of 16-78 years. The spectrum of pathological lesions in the adult nephrotic population was wide and comprised focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) (39.87%), followed by membranous GN (MGN) (26.58%), minimal change disease (MCD) (14.82%), mesangiocapillary GN (4.3%), mesangioproliferative GN (4.11%), post-infectious GN (2.84%), IgA nephropathy (2.53%), and other rare lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

Results from this study indicate that FSGS is the single most common cause of nephrotic syndrome in adult nephrotic patients, followed by MGN, and MCD. Our data are similar to those reported in recent series from the US. The study defines the pattern of glomerular disease in adult nephrotic patients for the first time in this region, because it is based on light microscopy, serology, IMF, and EM findings.

Kidney biopsy findings in heterozygous Fabry disease females with early nephropathy

Fabry disease is an X-linked glycosphingolipidosis caused by deficiency of alpha-galactosidase. Progressive chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in males. Although 40% of heterozygous females may develop renal involvement, pathologic data on Fabry nephropathy in heterozygotes are scarce. We reviewed the kidney biopsies of four affected females who had normal to slightly sub-normal renal function, two of them with overt proteinuria. Chronic non-specific degenerative lesions and glycosphingolipid accumulation per cell type were semi-quantitatively assessed by light and electron microscopy. Cellular distribution of glycosphingolipid deposits was best assessed on semithin sections. Podocyte effacement was seen only in proteinuric patients. Combined analysis of our data with those of two earlier series showed that glomerular sclerosis and tubulointerstitial fibrosis are predictors of proteinuria and CKD stage. There was no histopathological evidence supporting a major role of vascular damage in the early pathogenesis of Fabry nephropathy in females.

Actual practices in nephropathology: a survey and comparison with best practices

Nephropathology is a specialized field requiring routine tissue evaluation by immunofluorescence (IF), electron microscopy (EM), and light microscopy, and has published standards of best practice. Actual practices are less well documented. We therefore evaluated actual practices in nephropathology and their divergence from best practices. One hundred and twenty Renal Pathology Society members were given questionnaires regarding tissue handling, processing, and staining. Appropriate statistics for each question were calculated from results compiled into Microsoft Excel. Responses from 75 members showed that most received 16 or 18 gauge core biopsies, examined 9 slides for native kidneys, 8 slides for transplant kidneys, and for both used hematoxylin and eosin, periodic acid-Schiff, trichrome, and silver stains. For native kidney biopsies, most collected for IF and EM if tissue was adequate, while clinical input could influence the rest. Almost all performed IF on adequate samples, with a minimum of 8 antibodies, including both light chains, those from Europe sometimes without proof of adequacy. Half performed EM unconditionally, the remainder based on specimen adequacy or clinical input. For transplant kidney biopsies, most collected tissue for IF and EM only with specific clinical indications, performed C4d IF on frozen tissue if available, but few used the native kidney IF panel. Very few performed EM unconditionally, but most would if given specific indications. We conclude that actual nephropathology practices within the Renal Pathology Society are geographically uniform and similar to published best practices, with divergence in performing IF and EM on the basis of specimen adequacy and clinical input, particularly in transplant biopsies.

Original research in pathology: judgment, or evidence-based medicine?

Pathology is both a medical specialty and an investigative scientific discipline, concerned with understanding the essential nature of human disease. Ultimately, pathology is accountable as well, as measured by the accuracy of our diagnoses and the resultant patient care outcomes. As such, we must consider the evidence base underlying our practices. Within the realm of Laboratory Medicine, extensive attention has been given to testing accuracy and precision. Critical examination of the evidence base supporting the clinical use of specific laboratory tests or technologies is a separate endeavor, to which specific attention must be given. In the case of anatomic pathology and more specifically surgical pathology, the expertise required to render a diagnosis is derived foremost from experience, both personal and literature-based. In the first instance, knowledge of the linkage between one's own diagnoses and individual patient outcomes is required, to validate the role of one's own interpretations in the clinical course of patients. Experience comes from seeing this linkage first hand, from which hopefully comes wisdom and, ultimately, good clinical judgment. In the second instance, reading the literature and learning from experts is required. Only a minority of the relevant literature is published in pathology journals to which one may subscribe. A substantial portion of major papers relevant to the practice of anatomic pathology are published in collateral clinical specialty journals devoted to specific disease areas or organs. Active effort is therefore required to seek out the literature beyond the domain of pathology journals. In examining the published literature, the essential question then becomes: Does the practice of anatomic pathology fulfill the tenets of 'evidence-based medicine' (EBM)? If the pinnacle of EBM is 'systematic review of randomized clinical trials, with or without meta-analysis', then anatomic pathology falls far short. Our published literature is largely observational in nature, with reports of case series (with or without statistical analysis) constituting the majority of our 'evidence base'. Moreover, anatomic pathology is subject to 'interobserver variation', and potentially to 'error'. Taken further, individual interpretation of tissue samples is not an objective endeavor, and it is not easy to fulfill the role of a 'gold standard'. Both for rendering of an overall interpretation, and for providing the semi-quantitative and quantitative numerical 'scores' which support evidence-based clinical treatment algorithms, the Pathologist has to exercise a high level of interpretive judgment. Nevertheless, the contribution of anatomic pathology to 'EBM' is remarkably strong. To the extent that our judgmental interpretations become data, our tissue interpretations become the arbiters of patient care management decisions. In a more global sense, we support highly successful cancer screening programs, and play critical roles in the multidisciplinary management of complex patients. The true error is for the clinical practitioners of 'EBM' to forget the contribution to the supporting evidence base of the physicians that are Anatomic Pathologists. Finally, the academic productivity of pathology faculty who operate in the clinical realm must be considered. A survey of six North American academic pathology departments reveals that 26% of all papers published in 2005 came from 'unfunded' clinical faculty. While it is likely that their academic productivity is lower than that of 'funded' research faculty, the contribution of clinical faculty to the knowledge base for the practice of modern medicine, and to the academic reputation of the department, must not be overlooked. The ability of clinical faculty in academic departments of pathology to pursue original scholarship must be supported if our specialty is to retain its preeminence as an investigative scientific discipline in the age of EBM.