Disruption of small RNA signaling caused by competition for Hfq

Genetic screens to identify bacterial sRNA regulators

Small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) are versatile regulators that have been shown to be involved in the gene regulation of a growing number of biological pathways in bacteria. While finding the targets of a given sRNA has been the focus of many studies, fewer methods have been described to uncover which, if any, sRNAs regulate a given gene. Here I present two genetic screens that are designed to search for sRNAs regulating a gene of interest. Before the screens are performed, a translational fusion is made between the gene of interest and lacZ, designed so that mostly post-transcriptional effects on the gene's expression can be analyzed. I describe here a simple and rapid way to obtain this fusion, even when the transcriptional start site is unknown, by combining PCR or 5'RACE with recombination in the chromosome of a special strain of Escherichia coli. The first genetic screen uses a genomic multicopy library to find regulator genes that, when overexpressed, affect the expression of the fusion. While this technique is a classical genetic screen, particular attention is paid to how it can be used to specifically find sRNAs. A second screen is described that takes advantage of a specific library of sRNAs of E. coli that provides an easier and more rapid way to look for sRNA regulation. The library is transformed into the fusion containing strain using a serial transformation protocol developed in microtiter plates. The transformants can then be directly assayed for effects on the beta-galactosidase activity of the fusion in liquid, providing a precise and rapid way to evaluate sRNA regulation. Use of one or both of these screens should help uncover new pathways of regulation by sRNAs.

Cooperation of Escherichia coli Hfq hexamers in DsrA binding

Hfq is a bacterial post-transcriptional regulator. It facilitates base-pairing between sRNA and target mRNA. Hfq mediates DsrA-dependent translational activation of rpoS mRNA at low temperatures. rpoS encodes the stationary-phase σ factor σ(S), which is the central regulator in general stress response. However, structural information on Hfq-DsrA interaction is not yet available. Although Hfq is reported to hydrolyze ATP, the ATP-binding site is still unknown. Here, we report a ternary crystal complex structure of Escherichia coli Hfq bound to a major Hfq recognition region on DsrA (AU(6)A) together with ADP, and a crystal complex structure of Hfq bound to ADP. AU(6)A binds to the proximal and distal sides of two Hfq hexamers. ADP binds to a purine-selective site on the distal side and contacts conserved arginine or glutamine residues on the proximal side of another hexamer. This binding mode is different from previously postulated. The cooperation of two different Hfq hexamers upon nucleic acid binding in solution is verified by fluorescence polarization and solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments using fragments of Hfq and DsrA. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer conducted with full-length Hfq and DsrA also supports cooperation of Hfq hexamers upon DsrA binding. The implications of Hfq hexamer cooperation have been discussed.

Competition among Hfq-binding small RNAs in Escherichia coli

A major class of small bacterial RNAs (sRNAs) regulate translation and mRNA stability by pairing with target mRNAs, dependent upon the RNA chaperone Hfq. Hfq, related to the Lsm/Sm families of splicing proteins, binds the sRNAs and stabilizes them in vivo and stimulates pairing with mRNAs in vitro. Although Hfq is abundant, the sRNAs, when induced, are similarly abundant. Therefore, Hfq may be limiting for sRNA function. We find that, when overexpressed, a number of sRNAs competed with endogenous sRNAs for binding to Hfq. This correlated with lower accumulation of the sRNAs (presumably a reflection of the loss of Hfq binding), and lower activity of the sRNAs in regulating gene expression. Hfq was limiting for both positive and negative regulation by the sRNAs. In addition, deletion of the gene for an expressed and particularly effective competitor sRNA improved the regulation of genes by other sRNAs, suggesting that Hfq is limiting during normal growth conditions. These results support the existence of a hierarchy of sRNA competition for Hfq, modulating the function of some sRNAs.

Regulation by small RNAs in bacteria: expanding frontiers

Research on the discovery and characterization of small, regulatory RNAs in bacteria has exploded in recent years. These sRNAs act by base pairing with target mRNAs with which they share limited or extended complementarity, or by modulating protein activity, in some cases by mimicking other nucleic acids. Mechanistic insights into how sRNAs bind mRNAs and proteins, how they compete with each other, and how they interface with ribonucleases are active areas of discovery. Current work also has begun to illuminate how sRNAs modulate expression of distinct regulons and key transcription factors, thus integrating sRNA activity into extensive regulatory networks. In addition, the application of RNA deep sequencing has led to reports of hundreds of additional sRNA candidates in a wide swath of bacterial species. Most importantly, recent studies have served to clarify the abundance of remaining questions about how, when, and why sRNA-mediated regulation is of such importance to bacterial lifestyles.

The influence of Escherichia coli Hfq mutations on RNA binding and sRNA•mRNA duplex formation in rpoS riboregulation

The Escherichia coli RNA binding protein Hfq plays an important role in regulating mRNA translation through its interactions with small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs) and specific mRNAs sites. The rpoS mRNA, which codes for a transcription factor, is regulated by several sRNAs. DsrA and RprA enhance translation by pairing to a site on this mRNA, while OxyS represses rpoS mRNA translation. To better understand how Hfq interacts with these sRNAs and rpoS mRNA, the binding of wt Hfq and eleven mutant Hfqs to DsrA, RprA, OxyS and rpoS mRNA was examined. Nine of the mutant Hfq had single-residue mutations located on the proximal, distal, and outer-edge surfaces of the Hfq hexamer, while two Hfq had truncated C-terminal ends. Hfq with outer-edge mutations and truncated C-terminal ends behaved similar to wt Hfq with regard to binding the sRNAs, rpoS mRNA segments, and stimulating DsrA•rpoS mRNA formation. Proximal surface mutations decreased Hfq binding to the three sRNAs and the rpoS mRNA segment containing the translation initiation region. Distal surface mutations lowered Hfq's affinity for the rpoS mRNA segment containing the (ARN)(4) sequence. Strong Hfq binding to both rpoS mRNA segments appears to be needed for maximum enhancement of DsrA•rpoS mRNA annealing. OxyS bound tightly to Hfq but exhibited weak affinity for rpoS mRNA containing the leader region and 75 nt of coding sequence in the absence or presence of Hfq. This together with other results suggest OxyS represses rpoS mRNA translation by sequestering Hfq rather than binding to rpoS mRNA.

Essential requirements for robust signaling in Hfq dependent small RNA networks

Bacteria possess networks of small RNAs (sRNAs) that are important for modulating gene expression. At the center of many of these sRNA networks is the Hfq protein. Hfq's role is to quickly match cognate sRNAs and target mRNAs from among a large number of possible combinations and anneal them to form duplexes. Here we show using a kinetic model that Hfq can efficiently and robustly achieve this difficult task by minimizing the sequestration of sRNAs and target mRNAs in Hfq complexes. This sequestration can be reduced by two non-mutually exclusive kinetic mechanisms. The first mechanism involves heterotropic cooperativity (where sRNA and target mRNA binding to Hfq is influenced by other RNAs bound to Hfq); this cooperativity can selectively decrease singly-bound Hfq complexes and ternary complexes with non-cognate sRNA-target mRNA pairs while increasing cognate ternary complexes. The second mechanism relies on frequent RNA dissociation enabling the rapid cycling of sRNAs and target mRNAs among different Hfq complexes; this increases the probability the cognate ternary complex forms before the sRNAs and target mRNAs degrade. We further demonstrate that the performance of sRNAs in isolation is not predictive of their performance within a network. These findings highlight the importance of experimentally characterizing duplex formation in physiologically relevant contexts with multiple RNAs competing for Hfq. The model will provide a valuable framework for guiding and interpreting these experiments.

Bacteria have small RNAs (sRNAs) which are important modulators of gene expression. Many of these sRNAs require the Hfq protein to mediate their binding to specific target mRNAs which alters the translation and/or degradation of the mRNAs. The Hfq protein has a difficult task; it has to correctly pair cognate sRNAs and target mRNAs from among a large number of possible combinations and anneal them before the RNAs degrade. Furthermore, the process must be robust to changes in the number and types of sRNAs and target mRNAs that are transcribed and changes in the Hfq concentration. Here we show that Hfq can most successfully achieve its task when sRNAs and target mRNAs are not unnecessarily sequestered in Hfq complexes. The cell can accomplish this via cooperative binding of sRNAs and target mRNAs to Hfq and/or by rapid RNA dissociation from Hfq complexes. These findings reveal the requirements for efficient and robust sRNA signaling which are important for understanding the regulation of gene expression in diverse cell processes, for devising strategies that inhibit Hfq activity during pathogenesis and for the rational construction of synthetic circuits.

Hfq and its constellation of RNA

Hfq is an RNA-binding protein that is common to diverse bacterial lineages and has key roles in the control of gene expression. By facilitating the pairing of small RNAs with their target mRNAs, Hfq affects the translation and turnover rates of specific transcripts and contributes to complex post-transcriptional networks. These functions of Hfq can be attributed to its ring-like oligomeric architecture, which presents two non-equivalent binding surfaces that are capable of multiple interactions with RNA molecules. Distant homologues of Hfq occur in archaea and eukaryotes, reflecting an ancient origin for the protein family and hinting at shared functions. In this Review, we describe the salient structural and functional features of Hfq and discuss possible mechanisms by which this protein can promote RNA interactions to catalyse specific and rapid regulatory responses in vivo.

Negative effect of glucose on ompA mRNA stability: a potential role of cyclic AMP in the repression of hfq in Escherichia coli

Glucose is a carbon source that is capable of modulating the level of cyclic AMP (cAMP)-regulated genes. In the present study, we found that the stability of ompA mRNA was reduced in Escherichia coli when glucose (40 mM) was present in Luria-Bertani (LB) medium. This effect was associated with a low level of cAMP induced by the glucose. The results were confirmed with an adenylyl cyclase mutant with low levels of cAMP that are not modulated by glucose. Northern blot and Western blot analyses revealed that the host factor I (Hfq) (both mRNA and protein) levels were downregulated in the presence of cAMP. Furthermore, we showed that a complex of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) and cAMP binds to a specific P3(hfq) promoter region of hfq and regulates hfq expression. The regulation of the hfq gene was confirmed in vivo using an hfq-deficient mutant transformed with an exogenous hfq gene containing the promoter. These results demonstrated that expression of hfq was repressed by the CRP-cAMP complex. The presence of glucose resulted in increased Hfq protein levels, which decreased ompA mRNA stability. An additional experiment showed that cAMP also increased the stability of fur mRNA. Taken together, these results suggested that the repression of Hfq by cAMP may contribute to the stability of other mRNA in E. coli.

Pervasive post-transcriptional control of genes involved in amino acid metabolism by the Hfq-dependent GcvB small RNA

GcvB is one of the most highly conserved Hfq-associated small RNAs in Gram-negative bacteria and was previously reported to repress several ABC transporters for amino acids. To determine the full extent of GcvB-mediated regulation in Salmonella, we combined a genome-wide experimental approach with biocomputational target prediction. Comparative pulse expression of wild-type versus mutant sRNA variants revealed that GcvB governs a large post-transcriptional regulon, impacting ~1% of all Salmonella genes via its conserved G/U-rich domain R1. Complementary predictions of C/A-rich binding sites in mRNAs and gfp reporter fusion experiments increased the number of validated GcvB targets to more than 20, and doubled the number of regulated amino acid transporters. Unlike the previously described targeting via the single R1 domain, GcvB represses the glycine transporter CycA by exceptionally redundant base-pairing. This novel ability of GcvB is focused upon the one target that could feedback-regulate the glycine-responsive synthesis of GcvB. Several newly discovered mRNA targets involved in amino acid metabolism, including the global regulator Lrp, question the previous assumption that GcvB simply acts to limit unnecessary amino acid uptake. Rather, GcvB rewires primary transcriptional control circuits and seems to act as a distinct regulatory node in amino acid metabolism.

Despite similar binding to the Hfq protein regulatory RNAs widely differ in their competition performance

The binding of nine noncoding regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) to the E. coli Hfq protein was compared using a high-throughput double filter retention assay. Despite the fact that these sRNAs have different lengths, sequences and secondary structures their Hfq binding affinities were surprisingly uniform. The analysis of sRNAs binding to Hfq mutants showed that the proximal face of Hfq, known as the binding site for DsrA RNA, is a universal sRNA binding site. Moreover, all sRNAs bound Hfq with similar association rates limited only by the rate of diffusion, while the rates of dissociation, measured in the dilution experiments, were uniformly slow. Despite that, the data showed that there was a hierarchy of sRNAs in regard to their performance in competition for access to Hfq and in their ability to facilitate the dissociation of other sRNAs from Hfq. The sRNAs also differed in their salt dependence of binding to this protein. Overall, the results suggest that despite the uniform binding of different sRNAs to the same site on Hfq their exchange on this protein is dependent on the identities of the competing sRNAs.

Microbial linguistics: perspectives and applications of microbial cell-to-cell communication

Inter-cellular communication via diffusible small molecules is a defining character not only of multicellular forms of life but also of single-celled organisms. A large number of bacterial genes are regulated by the change of chemical milieu mediated by the local population density of its own species or others. The cell density-dependent "autoinducer" molecules regulate the expression of those genes involved in genetic competence, biofilm formation and persistence, virulence, sporulation, bioluminescence, antibiotic production, and many others. Recent innovations in recombinant DNA technology and micro-/nano-fluidics systems render the genetic circuitry responsible for cell-to-cell communication feasible to and malleable via synthetic biological approaches. Here we review the current understanding of the molecular biology of bacterial intercellular communication and the novel experimental protocols and platforms used to investigate this phenomenon. A particular emphasis is given to the genetic regulatory circuits that provide the standard building blocks which constitute the syntax of the biochemical communication network. Thus, this review gives focus to the engineering principles necessary for rewiring bacterial chemo-communication for various applications, ranging from population-level gene expression control to the study of host-pathogen interactions.

Small RNA biology is systems biology

During the last decade small regulatory RNA (srRNA) emerged as central players in the regulation of gene expression in all kingdoms of life. Multiple pathways for srRNA biogenesis and diverse mechanisms of gene regulation may indicate that srRNA regulation evolved independently multiple times. However, small RNA pathways share numerous properties, including the ability of a single srRNA to regulate multiple targets. Some of the mechanisms of gene regulation by srRNAs have significant effect on the abundance of free srRNAs that are ready to interact with new targets. This results in indirect interactions among seemingly unrelated genes, as well as in a crosstalk between different srRNA pathways. Here we briefly review and compare the major srRNA pathways, and argue that the impact of srRNA is always at the system level. We demonstrate how a simple mathematical model can ease the discussion of governing principles. To demonstrate these points we review a few examples from bacteria and animals.

The Vibrio cholerae quorum sensing response is mediated by Hfq-dependent sRNA/mRNA base pairing interactions

Vibrio cholerae quorum sensing controls expression of four redundant sRNAs, Qrr1-4. The Qrr sRNAs are predicted to alter the translation of several mRNAs, including, hapR, which encodes a transcription factor that controls genes for virulence factors, biofilm formation, protease production and DNA uptake. Each Qrr contains a 21 nucleotide region absolutely conserved among pathogenic Vibrios, and predicted to base pair with mRNA targets, like hapR, aided by the RNA chaperone Hfq. This molecular mechanism was not experimentally tested previously, and we provide here both in vivo and in vitro evidence to validate this model. In Escherichia coli, Qrr expression repressed a HapR-GFP translational fusion, and a specific nucleotide substitution in the 21 nucleotide region eliminated HapR control, while a compensatory mutation in hapR restored it. In V. cholerae, the identical mutations also deregulated HapR-dependent gene expression and corresponding QS phenotypes by altering HapR protein levels. We calculated in vitro binding affinities of a Qrr/hapR complex and show that Hfq stabilizes complex formation. Finally, the Qrr mutation with in vivo defects also prevented Qrr/hapR binding, while the compensatory hapR mutation restored binding. These results demonstrate that the V. cholerae QS response is mediated by base pairing interactions between Qrr sRNAs and hapR mRNA.

The RpoS-mediated general stress response in Escherichia coli

Under conditions of nutrient deprivation or stress, or as cells enter stationary phase, Escherichia coli and related bacteria increase the accumulation of RpoS, a specialized sigma factor. RpoS-dependent gene expression leads to general stress resistance of cells. During rapid growth, RpoS translation is inhibited and any RpoS protein that is synthesized is rapidly degraded. The complex transition from exponential growth to stationary phase has been partially dissected by analyzing the induction of RpoS after specific stress treatments. Different stress conditions lead to induction of specific sRNAs that stimulate RpoS translation or to induction of small-protein antiadaptors that stabilize the protein. Recent progress has led to a better, but still far from complete, understanding of how stresses lead to RpoS induction and what RpoS-dependent genes help the cell deal with the stress.