Model for the three-dimensional folding of 16 S ribosomal RNA

Protein-induced conformational changes in 16 S ribosomal RNA during the initial assembly steps of the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit

The mechanism of 16 S ribosomal RNA folding into its compact form in the native 30 S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli was studied by scanning transmission electron microscopy and circular dichroism spectroscopy. This approach made it possible to visualize and quantitatively analyze the conformational changes induced in 16 S rRNA under various ionic conditions and to characterize the interactions of ribosomal proteins S4, S8, S15, S20, S17 and S7, the six proteins known to bind to 16 S rRNA in the initial assembly steps. 16 S rRNA and the reconstituted RNA-protein core particles were characterized by their mass, morphology, radii of gyration (RG), and the extent and stability of 16 S rRNA secondary structure. The stepwise binding of S4, S8 and S15 led to a corresponding increase of mass and was accompanied by increased folding of 16 S rRNA in the core particles, as evident from the electron micrographs and from the decrease of RG values from 114 A and 91 A. Although the binding of S20, S17 and S7 continued the trend of mass increase, the RG values of these core particles showed a variable trend. While there was a slight increase in the RG value of the S20 core particles to 94 A, the RG value remained unchanged (94 A) with the further addition of S17. With subsequent addition of S7 to the core particles, the RG values showed an increase to 108 A. Association with S7 led to the formation of a globular mass cluster with a diameter of about 115 A and a mass of about 300 kDa. The rest of the mass (about 330 kDa) remained loosely coiled, giving the core particle a "medusa-like" appearance. Morphology of the 16 S rRNA and 16 S rRNA-protein core particles, even those with all six proteins, does not resemble the native 30 S subunit, contrary to what has been reported by others. The circular dichroism spectra of the 16 S rRNA-protein complexes and of free 16 S rRNA indicate a similarity of RNA secondary structure in the core particles with the first four proteins, S4, S8, S15, S20. The circular dichroism melting profiles of these core particles show only insignificant variations, implying no obvious changes in the distribution or the stability of the helical segments of 16 S rRNA. However, subsequent binding of proteins S17 and S7 affected both the extent and the thermal stability of 16 S rRNA secondary structure.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Ribosomal proteins S7 and L1 are located close to the decoding site of E. coli ribosome--affinity labeling studies with modified tRNAs carrying photoreactive probes attached adjacent to the 3'-end of the anticodon

Two photoreactive azidonitrophenyl probes have been attached to Yeast methionine elongator tRNA by chemical modification of the N6-(threoninocarbonyl)adenosine located next to the 3'-end of the anticodon. The maximum distance between the purine ring and the azido group estimated for the two probes is 16-17 and 23-24A, respectively. Binding and cross-linking of the uncharged, modified tRNAs to E. coli ribosomes have been studied with and without poly(A,U,G) as a message, under conditions directing uncharged tRNAs preferentially to the P-site. The modified tRNAs retain their binding activity and upon irradiation bind covalently to the ribosome with very high yields. Protein S7 is the major cross-linking target for both modified tRNAs, in the presence or absence of poly(A,U,G). Protein L1 and to a lesser extent proteins L33 and L27 have been found to be cross-linked with the short probe. Cross-linking to 168 rRNA reaches significant levels only in the absence of the message.

RNA folding: pseudoknots, loops and bulges

The three-dimensional structures adopted by RNA molecules are crucial to their biological functions. The nucleotides of an RNA molecule interact to form characteristic secondary-structure motifs. Tertiary interactions orient these secondary-structure elements with respect to each other to form the functional RNA. Here we describe the basic structural elements with special emphasis on a novel tertiary motif, the pseudoknot.

S4-16 S ribosomal RNA complex. Binding constant measurements and specific recognition of a 460-nucleotide region

The region of the Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA recognized by the ribosomal protein S4 has been defined by assaying a set of 13 16 S rRNA fragments for S4 binding. The fragments were prepared by transcription in vitro, and binding constants were measured in three ways: retention of labeled RNA fragments on nitrocellulose filters by S4; co-sedimentation of labeled S4 with RNA fragments in sucrose gradients; and the distribution of labeled S4 between two RNAs of different sizes in a sucrose gradient. All three methods gave similar relative binding strengths for a variety of 16 S rRNA and non-specific (23 S rRNA) sequences, with the exception of two of the largest 16 S rRNA fragments; these gave smaller association constants in the filter retention assay than in the other methods. We found that specific complexes of S4 with these larger RNAs do not bind well to filters, leaving non-specific complexes to dominate the assay. Specific complexes with RNAs less than or equal to 891 nucleotides were retained efficiently by S4 on filters, and gave reliable binding constants. All 16 S rRNA fragments containing nucleotides 39 to 500 bound S4 with the same affinity as intact 16 S rRNA, while all fragments with endpoints within 39 to 500 bound at least tenfold more weakly. This sequence must be able to fold independently of the rest of the rRNA. Comparison of this minimal 462-nucleotide S4 binding site with S4 footprinting results suggests that S4 binding might alter the conformations of RNA neighboring the 39 to 500 region in the intact 16 S rRNA. Specific S4-rRNA binding is not sensitive to KCl concentration, but a more normal salt dependence is seen in K2SO4 (delta logK/delta log[K+] approximately -3.3). This duplicates the behavior of the specific S4-alpha mRNA translational repression complex, arguing that S4 recognizes both the mRNA and rRNA substrates by the same mechanism. Mg2+ is not required to form the specific rRNA complex, at least under conditions which stabilize RNA structure (0.35 M-KCl, 5 degrees C).

Conformation and dynamics of an RNA internal loop

The conformation and the dynamics of an RNA oligonucleotide (26 nucleotides) which is a model for loop E in eukaryotic 5S RNA have been investigated by one- and two-dimensional NMR. The central portion of the oligonucleotide contains two G A oppositions, a common feature of ribosomal RNAs. The exchangeable proton spectrum indicates that an internal loop separates two stems of four and five base pairs. This observation is not consistent with structures for loop E containing mismatched G.A base pairs proposed from chemical and enzymatic studies on Xenopus laevis 5S RNA. The nonexchangeable proton spectrum has been assigned by two-dimensional NMR. Scalar couplings from correlated experiments and interproton distances from NOESY experiments at short mixing times have been used to determine glycosidic angles, sugar puckers, and other conformational features. The conformation of the stems is very close to standard A-form RNA, and extensive base stacking continues into the internal loop. This result provides a structural basis for the large favorable enthalpy of duplex formation determined in thermodynamic studies. Unusual structural and dynamic features are localized in the nucleotides connecting the loop to the stems.

Mutations in ribosomal proteins S4 and S12 influence the higher order structure of 16 S ribosomal RNA

We have studied the effects of protein mutations on the higher order structure of 16 S rRNA in Escherichia coli ribosomes, using a set of structure-sensitive chemical probes. Ten mutant strains were studied, which contained alterations in ribosomal proteins S4 and S12, including double mutants containing both altered S4 and S12. Two ribosomal ambiguity (ram) S4 mutant strains, four streptomycin resistant (SmR) S12 mutant strains, one streptomycin pseudodependent (SmP) S12 mutant strain, one streptomycin dependent (SmD) S12 mutant strain and two streptomycin independent (Sm1) double mutants (containing both-SmD and ram mutations) were probed and compared to an isogenic wild-type strain. In ribosomes from strains containing S4 ram mutations, nucleotides A8 and A26 become more reactive to dimethyl sulfate (DMS) at their N-1 positions. In ribosomes from strains bearing the SmD allele, A908, A909, A1413 and G1487 are significantly less reactive to chemical probes. These same effects are observed when the S4 and S12 mutations are present simultaneously in the double mutants. An interesting correlation is found between the reactivity of A908 and the miscoding potential of SmR, SmD, SmP and wild-type ribosomes; the reactivity of A908 increases as the translational error frequency of the ribosomes increases. In the case of ram ribosomes, the reactivity of A908 resembles that of wild-type, unless tRNA is bound, in which case it becomes hyper-reactive. Similarly, streptomycin has little effect on A908 in wild-type ribosomes unless tRNA is bound, in which case its reactivity increases to resemble that of ram ribosomes with bound tRNA. Finally, interaction of streptomycin with SmP and SmD ribosomes causes the reactivity of A908 to increase to near-wild-type levels. A simple model is proposed, in which the reactivity of A908 reflects the position of an equilibrium between two conformational states of the 30 S subunit, one of which is DMS-reactive, and the other DMS-unreactive. In this model, the balance between these two states would be influenced by proteins S4 and S12. Mutations in S12 generally cause a shift toward the unreactive conformer, and in the case of SmD and SmP ribosomes, this shift can be suppressed phenotypically by streptomycin, ram mutations in protein S4 cause a shift toward the reactive conformer, but only when tRNA is bound. This suggests that the opposing effects of these two classes of mutations influence the proof-reading process by somewhat different mechanisms.

Models for two tRNAs bound to successive codons on mRNA on the ribosome

We have investigated the structural changes necessary to build a model complex of two molecules of phenylalanine transfer RNA (tRNA(Phe) bound to successive codons in a short segment of a model messenger RNA (mRNA), consisting of U6. We keep the mRNA in an ideal helical conformation, deforming the tRNAs as necessary to eliminate steric overlaps while bringing the two 3' termini together. The resulting model has the two tRNAs oriented relative to one another in a manner that is very similar to a model developed by McDonald and Rein (1) in which the tRNAs maintain their ideal crystallographic conformations and all of the deformations are introduced into the mRNA. Consequently, regardless of how one divides the deformations between the tRNAs and the mRNA it is clear that, on the ribosome, the tRNA in the P site has its "front" side (that side with the variable loop) close to the "back" side of the tRNA in the A site (that side with the D loop). The space between the two molecules must be left free on the ribosome, in order to facilitate the transition from the A site to the P site. A detailed pathway is also proposed for changing the anticodon loop structure from that of the A site to that of the P site. The anticodon loop is always kept in a 3'-stacked conformation, since we find that the shift between the 3'-stacked and 5'-stacked structures proposed by Woese (2) is not feasible.

RNA-protein interactions in 30S ribosomal subunits: folding and function of 16S rRNA

Chemical probing methods have been used to "footprint" 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) at each step during the in vitro assembly of twenty 30S subunit ribosomal proteins. These experiments yield information about the location of each protein relative to the structure of 16S rRNA and provide the basis for derivation of a detailed model for the three-dimensional folding of 16S rRNA. Several lines of evidence suggest that protein-dependent conformational changes in 16S rRNA play an important part in the cooperativity of ribosome assembly and in fine-tuning of the conformation and dynamics of 16S rRNA in the 30S subunit.

Evidence for several higher order structural elements in ribosomal RNA

Comparative analysis of small subunit ribosomal RNA sequences suggests the existence of two new higher order interactions: (i) a double-helical structure involving positions 505-507 and 524-526 (Escherichia coli numbering) and (ii) an interaction between the region of position 130 and the helix located approximately between positions 180 and 195. In the first of these, one of the strands of the helix exists in the bulge loop, and the other strand exists in the terminal loop of a previously recognized compound helix involving positions 500-545. Therefore, the new structure formally represents a pseudoknot. In the second, the insertion/deletion of a nucleotide in the vicinity of position 130 correlates with the length of the helix in the 180-195 region, the latter having a 3-base-pair stalk when the base in question is deleted and a stalk of approximately 10 pairs when it is inserted.