Studies on antioxidants: their carcinogenic and modifying effects on chemical carcinogenesis

Inhibitory effects of antioxidants on N-bis(2-hydroxypropyl)nitrosamine-induced lung carcinogenesis in rats

Potential second-stage modifying effects of 8 antioxidants on lung tumorigenesis initiated by N-bis(2-hydroxypropyl)nitrosamine (DHPN) were examined in male F344 rats. After an initial 2-week treatment with DHPN (0.1% in drinking water), rats were administered one of the antioxidants supplemented in the diet for 30 weeks. Although the incidences of lung adenomas were not affected, those of carcinomas were lowered by 2% butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA, 2 rats/20 rats), 1% butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT, 1/20), 0.8% ethoxyquin (EQ, 3/20) and 1% a-tocopherol (a-TP, 2/20) treatments as compared to the control level (9/20), while 5% sodium L-ascorbate (SA), 0.8% catechol (CC), 0.8% resorcinol (RN), and 0.8% hydroquinone (HQ) did not exert any significant effect on incidence. Quantitative analysis of adenomas and carcinomas (numbers and areas of lesions per unit area of lung section) revealed obvious inhibitory effects of SA, CC, and RN as well as BHA, BHT, EQ, and a-TP. Among the antioxidants, BHT exerted the strongest inhibitory activity. In contrast, DHPN-induced thyroid tumorigenesis was significantly enhanced by BHT (14/20) and EQ (20/20) treatments (control = 5/20). Thus the antioxidants showed opposite effects on lung and thyroid carcinogenesis in the rat.

Mutagenicity of 3-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyanisole (BHA) and its metabolites in short-term tests in vitro

The mutagenicity of 3-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyanisole (BHA) and its metabolites was investigated in the reverse mutation assay using S. typhimurium strains and the chromosomal aberration test in vitro using a Chinese hamster fibroblast cell line, CHL. BHA, tert-butylhydroquinone (BHQ), tert-butylquinone (BQ) and BHA dimer (diBHA) did not show any mutagenic potential with and without S9 mix in the reverse mutation assay. In addition to the above 4 chemicals, 3-tert-butyl-4,5-dihydroxyanisole (BHA-OH), 3-tert-butylanisole-4,5-quinone (BHA-o-Q), and tert-butylquinone oxide (BQO) were tested in the chromosomal aberration test. BHA, BHQ and BQ induced chromosomal aberrations only in the presence of S9 mix, while BHA-OH, BHA-o-Q and BQO induced chromosomal aberrations only without S9 mix. DiBHA, however, showed no clastogenic potential with and without S9 mix. The present findings suggest that BHA-OH, BHA-o-Q or BQO may contribute to the clastogenicity of BHA in the presence of S9 mix.

Microsome-mediated clastogenicity of butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) in cultured Chinese hamster ovary cells: the possible role of reactive oxygen species

Butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) was found to induce chromosome aberrations in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells in the presence of Aroclor-induced rat-liver S9. The effects were more marked when washed microsomes were employed and chromosome damage was considerably reduced in the presence of catalase, suggesting that hydrogen peroxide was involved. Stimulation of H2O2 production by BHA in S9 or microsome incubation mixtures was demonstrated using the catalase-mediated production of formaldehyde from methanol. One of the major microsomal metabolites of BHA, tert.-butyl hydroquinone (t-BHQ), which autoxidises in solution producing H2O2 also induced extensive catalase-sensitive chromosome damage in the absence of metabolic activation. These observations suggest that extracellular generation of reactive oxygen species may be implicated in the mechanism of BHA clastogenicity in vitro. However, chromosome damage was not completely abolished by catalase and the end product of t-BHQ oxidation, tert.-butyl quinone, was also weakly clastogenic, suggesting that intracellular effects of quinone metabolites may also be involved in the clastogenicity of BHA.

International Commission for Protection Against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. ICPEMC publication No. 17. Can a mechanistic rationale be provided for non-genotoxic carcinogens identified in rodent bioassays?

In a recent survey of the results of the National Cancer Institute/National Toxicology Program's Carcinogenesis Bioassay Program, Ashby and Tennant (1988) drew attention to the high proportion of carcinogens that were non-genotoxic insofar as their response to the Salmonella-microsome test was concerned. The present review contrasts these findings with what is known mechanistically about non-genotoxic carcinogens that affect the tissues which are considered to be particularly prone to non-genotoxic tumor induction. Excessive and often thresholded increases in cellular proliferation in the affected tissues appear to be one common feature in tumor induction by these agents, which act either through cytotoxicity followed by regeneration or through hormone-mimetic action. It is suggested that a weight of the evidence approach on a chemical by chemical basis is necessary to decide the relevance of these agents to the human situation.

Short-term effects of butylated hydroxytoluene on the Wistar rat liver, urinary bladder and thyroid gland

Long-term feeding of butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) to rats and mice has been linked to the enhancement of the incidence of liver tumors. It is shown in this paper that in the liver, urinary bladder and thyroid of the male Wistar rat, feeding the highest tolerated doses of BHT for 30 days does not lead to detectable increases in [3H]thymidine labeling. On the other hand, treatment of rats with 0.5% dietary BHT leads to a time-limited increase in liver cell [3H]thymidine labeling that subsided to control values within 8 days. This increase in [3H]thymidine labeling in the liver is accompanied by an unexpectedly large increase in the mitotic index. These results are discussed in the light of the behavior of certain rodent liver tumorigens.

Absence of effect in stochastic processes: its influence on test validation and test use

Negativity in stochastic processes presents problems in interpretation because it is never possible to attain an absolutely adequate assurance of safety with such processes. Thus, it is extremely difficult to have complete confidence in the utility of validation studies of new methods in comparison to those that are accepted to be well established, especially when these processes are stochastic in the statistical sense of this term. The regulatory scientist who must make decisions on the basis of available evidence, therefore, has to make a number of assumptions in dealing with negativity. It is important to review the validity and usefulness of these assumptions from time to time to ensure that they cannot be replaced by improved methodology in the light of new scientific knowledge.

Antioxidants--carcinogenic and chemopreventive properties

Synthetic and naturally occurring antioxidants have a wide variety of biological actions in rodents in addition to their primary antioxidant activity. Some of the included biological effects are of direct interest in relation to studies of carcinogenicity and/or modulation of carcinogenesis. Since the synthetic antioxidant BHA was first found to exert carcinogenic potential in rat and hamster forestomach epithelium, many other synthetic and naturally occurring antioxidants have been examined for their ability to induce proliferative activity in the alimentary canal. These studies have revealed that caffeic acid and sesamol are also tumorigenic for rat forestomach epithelium, whereas catechol and p-methylcatechol induce neoplasia in rat glandular stomach epithelium. Although the proliferative response is very rapid, with inflammation and ulceration, it takes a very long time before carcinomas develop. The proliferative lesions in the forestomach induced by BHA or caffeic acid are largely reversible, in contrast to those induced by genotoxic carcinogens, which generally persist and develop into cancer. Therefore, chronic irritation is considered to be responsible for the induction of stomach cancer by antioxidants. Butylated hydroxyanisole can undergo oxidative metabolism in vitro, and some of the metabolites formed have the potential for binding to proteins. Neither BHA nor its metabolites binds to DNA in vivo, but protein binding in the forestomach was greater than 10 times higher than that in the glandular stomach. It is thus conceivable that BHA is oxidatively metabolized in the forestomach epithelium (possibly entering into redox cycling), and reactive metabolites including semiquinone radicals or active oxygen species are responsible for the carcinogenesis by a mechanism involving binding to macromolecules. Many antioxidants have been shown to modify carcinogenesis, and as a rule, they inhibit the initiation stage by reducing the interaction between carcinogen and DNA. However, both promotion and inhibition have been reported for second-stage carcinogenesis, depending on the organ site, species of animal, or initiating carcinogen. They can also block reaction of amine and nitrite to form nitrosamines or reduce TPA promotion of skin carcinogenesis. Generally high doses of antioxidants are required for carcinoma induction or modification of chemical carcinogenesis. The significance of the reported tumorigenicity and strong promoting activity of antioxidants for forestomach epithelium of animals to the development of human cancer appears limited mainly because humans do not have a forestomach. The carcinogenic and strong promoting activities of catechol and its structurally related compounds on rat glandular stomach epithelium are of greater concern because this tissue is directly analogous to human gastric epithelium.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A carcinogenesis reversibility study of the effects of butylated hydroxyanisole on the forestomach and urinary bladder in male Fischer 344 rats

A reversibility study was initiated to determine if the length of feeding with 2% butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) altered the incidence of forestomach lesions observed after a 24-month observation period. Groups of male Fischer 344 rats were fed 2% BHA for 0, 3, 6, 12, and 24 months and then the basal diet for the completion of the 24-month experimental period. Subgroups were serially sacrificed for histopathological examination and [methyl-3H]thymidine radioautography at the time when each group of animals was transferred to the basal diet and also at 15 months. The results showed that except for carcinomas and some epithelial downgrowths, cellular proliferation, measured by radioautography in the epithelium lining the greater and the lesser curvature of the forestomach, remained dependent on the continuous presence of 2% BHA for, at least, 12 months. Superficial hyperplasias, inflammatory lesions and many of the papillomas regressed after cessation of treatment at 12 months. The epithelial downgrowths did not appear to enlarge after the BHA was withdrawn. The squamous cell carcinomas occurred in almost identical yields whether the rats were fed 2% BHA for 12 months and then returned to the basal diet for 12 months or received 2% BHA continuously for 24 months. It is shown here that at several times, 2% BHA stimulated the [methyl-3H]thymidine labelling index of the transitional epithelium of the urinary bladder and that at 3 months the no observed effect level was greater than 0.5% BHA. The significance of the studies on the forestomach and bladder epithelia are discussed. It is concluded that the lesions induced by BHA are most unlikely to be relevant to humans exposed to much lower levels of BHA.

International Commission for Protection against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. ICPEMC working paper No. 5. Genotoxicity tests as predictors of carcinogens: an analysis

Differences between the results of numerical validation studies comparing in vitro and in vivo genotoxicity tests with the rodent cancer bioassay are leading to the perception that short-term tests predict carcinogenicity only with uncertainty. Consideration of factors such as the pharmacokinetic distribution of chemicals, the systems available for metabolic activation and detoxification, the ability of the active metabolite to move from the site of production to the target DNA, and the potential for expression of the induced lesions, strongly suggests that the disparate sensitivity of the different test systems is a major reason why numerical validation is not more successful. Furthermore, genotoxicity tests should be expected to detect only a subset of carcinogens, namely genotoxic carcinogens, rather than those carcinogens that appear to act by non-genetic mechanisms. Instead of relying primarily on short-term in vitro genotoxicity tests to predict carcinogenic activity, these tests should be used in a manner that emphasizes the accurate determination of mutagenicity or clastogenicity. It must then be determined whether the mutagenic activity is further expressed as carcinogenicity in the appropriate studies using test animals. The prospects for quantitative extrapolation of in vitro or in vivo genotoxicity test results to carcinogenicity requires a much more precise understanding of the critical molecular events in both processes.

Protective effect of dietary brussels sprouts against mammary carcinogenesis in Sprague-Dawley rats

The effect of dietary brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea, L.) on mammary carcinogenesis induced by 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene (DMBA) was studied in Sprague-Dawley female rats. Rats fed a 20% brussels sprouts diet only during the initiation period of carcinogenesis had a palpable mammary tumor incidence of 13%, while those fed a casein-cornstarch semi-purified diet during this initiation period had a tumor incidence of 77% after 15 weeks post DMBA dose. When the rats were switched from the semi-purified diet to the 20% brussels sprouts diet at this time, there appeared to be a regression of small mammary tumors after 6 weeks on this dietary treatment. This regression was transitory since during the final 10 weeks of this 1 year study, 100% of this group of rats developed tumors. The rats fed the 20% brussels sprouts diet during tumor initiation exhibited a 67% incidence of fibroadenomas. The rats fed the semi-purified diet during initiation, but switched later to the brussels sprouts diet, showed over a 90% incidence of adenocarcinomas.

Co-carcinogenic effect of retinyl acetate on forestomach carcinogenesis of male F344 rats induced with butylated hydroxyanisole

The potential modifying effect of retinyl acetate (RA) on butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA)-induced rat forestomach tumorigenesis was examined. Male F344 rats, 5 weeks of age, were maintained on diet containing 1% or 2% BHA by weight and simultaneously on drinking water supplemented with RA at various concentrations (w/v) for 52 weeks. In groups given 2% BHA, although marked hyperplastic changes of the forestomach epithelium were observed in all animals, co-administration of 0.25% RA significantly (P less than 0.05) increased the incidence of forestomach tumors (squamous cell papilloma and carcinoma) to 60% (9/15, 2 rats with carcinoma) from 15% (3/20, one rat with carcinoma) in the group given RA-free water. In rats given 1% BHA, RA co-administered at a dose of 0.05, 0.1, 0.2 or 0.25% showed a dose-dependent enhancing effect on the development of the BHA-induced epithelial hyperplasia. Tumors, all papillomas, were induced in 3 rats (17%) with 0.25% RA and in one rat (10%) with 0.05% RA co-administration. RA alone did not induce hyperplastic changes in the forestomach. These findings indicate that RA acted as a co-carcinogen in the BHA forestomach carcinogenesis of the rat.