Study of photoablation of rabbit corneas by Er:YAG laser

Laser-assisted corneal transplantation surgery

Corneal transplant surgeries have a broad range of indications with outcomes largely dependent on surgeon experience. Traditional manual techniques have certain limitations pertaining to the preparation of donor tissue and the recipient bed that might affect the predictability of visual outcomes. Use of lasers for keratoplasty procedures not only improves the repeatability and consistency of the technique, but also enables the surgeon to control the thickness and shape of the transplant tissue tailored to the specific condition. Despite the advantages, cost-effectiveness and technical know-how remain the major challenges. We discuss the various techniques of laser-assisted keratoplasties with respect to their methods, precision, and efficacy in various corneal indications.

Q-Switched Erbium:YAG Laser Corneal Trephination

PURPOSE

To assess stromal thermal damage and cut regularity induced by nonmechanical Q-switched Er:YAG laser corneal trephination for penetrating keratoplasty.

METHODS

Corneal trephination was performed in 80 enucleated porcine eyes by Q-switched (2.94-microm) Er:YAG laser, along with donor and recipient masks made of metal or ceramic. All combinations of 0.65- or 0.96-mm spot diameter and 45- or 50-mJ/pulse energy setting were used with each of the masks at a 5-Hz repetition rate. Corneas were processed for histologic examinations. Stromal thermal damage was quantified on PAS-stained slides, and cut regularity was assessed semiquantitatively on a scale from 0 (regular) to 3 (highly irregular). Transmission electron microscopy and scanning electron microscopy were performed on selected specimens.

RESULTS

The least thermal damage (mean +/- SD = 6.2 +/- 0.7 microm) was found in the donor ceramic group with 50-mJ/pulse energy and 0.65-mm spot diameter, while the best regularity of the cut (1.2 +/- 0.4) was found in the donor ceramic group with 45-mJ pulse energy and 0.65-mm spot diameter. Thermal damage was less pronounced in donor than in recipient corneas (P < 0.01). Smaller spot diameter (0.65 mm) led to less thermal damage (P < 0.01) than the use of a 0.96-mm spot diameter. The differences in thermal damage between ceramic and metal masks were minimal.

CONCLUSIONS

After Q-switched Er:YAG laser corneal trephination for nonmechanical penetrating keratoplasty, reproducible high cut regularity and low concomitant thermal damage were observed. This is an encouraging finding in the search for a nonmechanical trephine for penetrating keratoplasty combining high precision and low cost.

Q-Switched 2.94-microm Er:YAG laser trephination with convergent and divergent cut angles for penetrating keratoplasty

PURPOSE

To study the morphologic properties of perpendicular (P), convergent (C), and divergent (D) cut angles using different speeds of rotations during donor and recipient nonmechanical trephination for experimental penetrating keratoplasty.

METHODS

With a Q-switched 2.94-microm Er:YAG laser corneal trephination was performed in 150 enucleated porcine eyes using ceramic open masks with 8 "orientation teeth/notches" and an automated globe rotation device allowing different cut angles [0 degree (P), 10 and 20 degrees (C and D)] toward the optical axis and variation of the rotation speed [3, 7, and 11 rotations per minute (rpm)]. The regularity of the cut (I, regular; II, slightly irregular; III, irregular) was assessed by light microscopy. The area of thermal damage and the number and size of "spikes" in the stroma at the superficial, intermediate and deep level of the excision were analyzed using digital images and the Optimas image processing software.

RESULTS

The regularity of the cut was classified as I in 42%/22% of donor/recipient and as II in 41%/56%, respectively. The thermal damage was least expressed with D20 degree cut angle and donor mask (P < 0.01). With all cut angles and speeds of rotation, thermal damage at the deep level of excision was significantly smaller (P < 0.01). With different speeds of donor rotations, the thermal damage showed no significant difference. With recipient trephination, the thermal damage at the deep level was greatest with 7 rpm (P < 0.01). The number and size of spikes of thermal damage with donor and recipient masks were significantly smaller in the deep stroma (P < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Q-switched Er:YAG laser trephination with appropriate settings results in low thermal damage zones at the cut margin. Different cut angles and speeds of trephination may affect the cut performance and quality of the excision. In our study, low rotation speed and divergent donor cut angles showed the best results. The cut quality and the small thermal damage with the Q-switched 2.94-microm Er:YAG laser seem to be tolerable for corneal trephination. Therefore, this modality may be a low-cost, easy-to-handle alternative for nonmechanical corneal transplantation in humans.

In-vivo response to free electron laser incision of the rabbit cornea

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

We analyzed the in vivo ocular response to corneal incisions made by Medical Free Electron Laser (MFEL) as a function of scan rate and incision depth. Additionally, we compared biomicroscopy, optical coherence tomography (OCT), and light microscopy as ocular response diagnostic tools.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Rabbit corneas were incised with pulsed MFEL radiation at 2.94 microm wavelength, scalpel incisions or focal cautery treatment were used as controls. The MFEL beam scan rate ranged from 0.2 to 1.0 mm/second. Ocular effects were monitored for 2 hours postoperatively using OCT and slit lamp examination. Ocular tissue was fixed for light microscopic examination.

RESULTS

Anterior chamber fibrin formation correlated with MFEL incision depth. Slower scan rates resulted in deeper incisions and greater fibrin formation. OCT was better than slit lamp biomicroscopy at identifying fibrin attachments. OCT and light microscopy proved to be excellent companion technologies.

CONCLUSIONS

Deep corneal incisions in the rabbit produced by the MFEL resulted in fibrin formation in the anterior chamber.

Limitations of Erbium:YAG Laser Photorefractive Keratectomy

PURPOSE

The erbium:YAG laser (lambda = 2.94 microm) has been considered promising as an alternative to the ArF excimer laser in photorefractive keratectomy (PRK). However, corneal application of this mid-infrared solid state laser is still plagued with various disadvantages compared to that of the ArF excimer laser (lambda = 193 nm). We discuss the limitations of PRK with the erbium:YAG laser.

METHODS

Measurements of ablation threshold, ablation efficiency, and thermal damage were done to compare the process of erbium:YAG laser photoevaporization to the ArF excimer laser. PRK procedures were performed on fresh enucleated pig corneas to investigate the morphology and surface roughness of the cornea after scanning-spot and fundamental mode photoablation. Surface roughness was measured by using a tactile surface reprofiling system.

RESULTS

The ablation threshold and the ablation efficiencies for the erbium:YAG laser are significantly higher compared to the ArF excimer laser. Collateral thermal damage decreases with a reduction of laser pulse duration to a minimum of approximately 5 microm. Scanning electron microscopy and surface roughness measurements of the corneal surface after erbium:YAG laser treatment demonstrated higher surface roughness compared to ArF excimer laser treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

The erbium:YAG laser is not at present an alternative to the ArF excimer laser for photorefractive keratectomy.