Investigation of oligonucleotide fragmentation with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization Fourier-transform mass spectrometry and sustained off-resonance irradiation

A revisit of high collision energy effects on collision-induced dissociation spectra using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization tandem time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-LIFT-TOF/TOF): application to the sequencing of RNA/DNA chimeras

RATIONALE

High-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID) spectra of isomeric RNA/DNA chimeras using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight LIFT mass spectrometry (MALDI-LIFT-TOF/TOF) can potentially be applied for an exhaustive fragment characterization in a nucleic acid sequencing scheme. These chimeras contain deoxynucleotides and at the 3'-end a ribonucleotide with a 3'-phosphate group.

METHODS

Deprotonated RNA/DNA chimeras of 4-, 5-, 7- and 10-mers are analyzed by CID. This enhances consecutive dissociations from both the precursor and prompt product anions generated by MALDI and metastable fragmentations prior to entering the LIFT cell.

RESULTS

Gas-phase fragmentations of 4- and 5-mers produced many fragment ions, from base release prior to consecutive cleavage of the nucleotide phosphate bond linkage phosphate. The unusual a4(-) product ion is a specific and diagnostic dissociation of the 4-mer if the ribonucleotide contains cytosine. As the size of RNA/DNA chimeras increase, several abundant product ions are generated mainly from zwitterionic forms (deprotonated phosphate ester and protonated base sites): [(M-H)-BiH](-), [ai-BiH](-), wj(-), [wj, (ai-BiH)](-) (if Bi  ≠ T) as internal product ion, and more rarely [wj-BiH](-). The absence of the majority of the [ai-BiH](-) series although the wj (-) series suggested that the higher critical energy processes with a loose transition state are favored yielding the wj(-) series. A large number of abundant fragment ions are detected which enable each isomer to be sequenced.

CONCLUSIONS

This sequencing method is high-throughput, accurate and could be used to sequence isomers of up to 10-mers and also oligonucleotides of unknown sequence. However, RNA/DNA chimeras without thymine must be sufficiently concentrated to reach desorption of deprotonated molecular species to be selected in LIFT to produce all fragment ions within measurable abundances.

Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry: a technique to access the information beyond the molecular weight of the analyte

The Electrospray Ionization (ESI) is a soft ionization technique extensively used for production of gas phase ions (without fragmentation) of thermally labile large supramolecules. In the present review we have described the development of Electrospray Ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) during the last 25 years in the study of various properties of different types of biological molecules. There have been extensive studies on the mechanism of formation of charged gaseous species by the ESI. Several groups have investigated the origin and implications of the multiple charge states of proteins observed in the ESI-mass spectra of the proteins. The charged analytes produced by ESI can be fragmented by activating them in the gas-phase, and thus tandem mass spectrometry has been developed, which provides very important insights on the structural properties of the molecule. The review will highlight recent developments and emerging directions in this fascinating area of research.

Ultra-performance liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC/MS/MS) and UPLC/MS(E) analysis of RNA oligonucleotides

Fast and efficient ultra-performance liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC/MS/MS) analysis of short interfering RNA oligonucleotides was used for identity confirmation of the target sequence-related impurities. Multiple truncated oligonucleotides and metabolites were identified based on the accurate mass, and their presumed sequence was confirmed by MS/MS and MS(E) (alternating low and elevated collision energy scanning modes) methods. Based on the resulting fragmentation of native and chemically modified oligonucleotides, it was found that the MS(E) technique is as efficient as the traditional MS/MS method, yet MS(E) is more general, faster, and capable of producing higher signal intensities of fragment ions. Fragmentation patterns of modified oligonucleotides were investigated using RNA 2'-ribose substitutions, phosphorothioate RNA, and LNA modifications. The developed sequence confirmation method that uses the MS(E) approach was applied to the analysis of in vitro hydrolyzed RNA oligonucleotide. The target RNA and metabolites, including the structural isomers, were resolved by UPLC, and their identity was confirmed by MS(E). Simultaneous RNA truncations from both termini were observed. The UPLC quadrupole time-of-flight (QTOF) MS/MS and MS(E) methods were shown to be an effective tool for the analysis and sequence confirmation of complex oligonucleotide mixtures.

Gas-phase ion/ion reactions of transition metal complex cations with multiply charged oligodeoxynucleotide anions

Multiply deprotonated hexadeoxyadenylate anions, (A6-nH)(n-), where n = 3-5, have been subjected to reaction with a range of divalent transition-metal complex cations in the gas phase. The cations studied included the bis- and tris-1,10-phenanthroline complexes of CuII, FeII, and CoII, as well as the tris-1,10-phenanthroline complex of RuII. In addition, the hexadeoxyadenylate anions were subjected to reaction with the singly charged FeIII and CoIIIN,N'-ethylenebis(salicylideneiminato) complexes. The major competing reaction channels are electron-transfer from the oligodeoxynucleotide anion to the cation, the formation of a complex between the anion and cation, and the incorporation of the transition-metal into the oligodeoxynucleotide. The latter process proceeds via the anion/cation complex and involves displacement of the ligand(s) in the transition-metal complex by the oligodeoxynucleotide. Competition between the various reaction channels is governed by the identity of the transition-metal cation, the coordination environment of the metal complex, and the oligodeoxynucleotide charge state. In the case of the divalent metal phenanthroline complexes, competition between electron-transfer and metal ion incorporation is particularly sensitive to the coordination number of the reagent metal complexes. Both electron-transfer and metal ion incorporation occur to significant extents with the bis-phenanthroline ions, whereas the tris-phenanthroline ions react predominantly by metal ion incorporation. To our knowledge this work reports the first observations of the gas-phase incorporation of multivalent transition-metal cations into oligodeoxynucleotide anions and represents a means for the selective incorporation of transition-metal counter-ions into gaseous oligodeoxynucleotides.

Detection of the common RNA nucleoside pseudouridine in mixtures of oligonucleotides by mass spectrometry

Pseudouridine, an isomer of uridine, is probably the most common of many posttranscriptional RNA modifications found in nature. Although mass spectrometry has become widely used in the characterization of modified nucleic acids, its application to the recognition and sequence placement of pseudouridine has not been straightforward, particularly in the case of complex mixtures such as those resulting from selective enzymatic hydrolysis of RNA into oligonucleotides. We report results of a study of the characteristic dissociation reactions of pseudouridine-containing oligonucleotides following ionization by electrospray and use of those pathways in an LC/MS-based method applicable to direct analysis of RNase digests of RNA. As a consequence of the C-C (rather than C-N) glycosidic bond of pseudouridine, the otherwise common dissociation paths involving base loss do not occur, resulting in characteristic formation of a set of low-mass negative ions containing the intact glycosidic bond (m/z 225, 207, 189, 165, 164, 139), which permit recognition of pseudouridine-containing oligonucleotides. Those components can subsequently be subjected to sequence analysis by MS/MS, in which enhancement of selective sequence-determining ions (a-, w-, y-types), and absence of a - base ions, are observed at the site of pseudouridylation. Also, selected reaction pathways can be monitored in the LC/MS/MS analysis that are indicative of pseudouridine at the 5' terminus (m/z 225 --> 165), internal positions (m/z 207 --> 164), and in the RNase T1-derived product Psi pGp (m/z 668 --> 207) arising from the RNA sequence ...G Psi G... These procedures can be effectively integrated into an existing suite of LC/ESI-MS-based methods designed for the analysis of posttranscriptionally modified sites in RNA.

Infrared multiphoton dissociation of O-linked mucin-type oligosaccharides

Oligosaccharides are known to play important roles in many biological processes. In the study of oligosaccharides, collision-induced dissociation (CID) is the most common dissociation method to elucidate the sequence and connectivity. However, a disadvantage of CID is the decrease in both the degree and efficiency of dissociation with increasing mass. In the present study, we have successfully performed infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) on 39 O-linked mucin-type oligosaccharide alditols (both neutral and anionic). CID and IRMPD spectra of several oligosaccharides were also compared. They yielded nearly identical fragment ions corresponding to the lowest energy fragmentation pathways. The characteristic fragmentations of structural motifs, which can provide the linkage information, were similarly presented in both CID and IRMPD spectra. Multistage of CID (MS(3) or MS(4)) is commonly needed to completely sequence the oligosaccharides, while IRMPD of the same compounds yielded the fragment ions corresponding to the loss of the first residue to the last residue during a single-stage tandem MS (MS(2)). Finally, it is shown that the fragmentation efficiency of IRMPD increases with the increasing size of oligosaccharides.

Charge dependent behavior of PNA/DNA/PNA triplexes in the gas phase

Intact noncovalent complexes were studied in the gas phase using negative ion nano-ESI mass spectrometry. Among various noncovalent systems studied in the gas phase, the interaction of DNA strands with peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) presents a strong interest as biologically relevant systems. PNAs originally described by Nielsen are used as DNA mimics as possible medical agents by imprisoning DNA single strands into stable noncovalent complexes. Two types of PNAs were investigated in the PNA/DNA multiplex: the original Nielsen's PNA and a modified backbone PNA by the introduction of syn- and anti-(aminoethyl)thiazolidine rings. We first investigated the stoichiometry of PNA/DNA multiplexes formed in solution and observed them in the gas phase via qualitative kinetics of complementary strand associations. It resulted in observing PNA2/DNA triplexes (ts) as the multiply deprotonated species, most stable in both the solution and gas phase. Second, charge-dependant decompositions of these species were undertaken under low-energy collision conditions. It appears that covalent bond cleavages (base releasing or skeleton cleavage) occur from lower ts charge states rather than ts unzipping, which takes place from higher charge states. This behavior can be explained by considering the presence of zwitterions depending on the charge state. They result in strong salt-bridge interactions between the positively charged PNA side chain and the negatively charged DNA backbone. We propose a general model to clearly display the involved patterns in the noncovalent triplex decompositions. Third, the relative stability of three PNA2/DNA complexes was scrutinized in the gas phase by acquiring the breakdown curves of their ts(6-) form, corresponding to the ts unzipping. The chemical structures of the studied PNAs were chosen in order to evidence the possible influence of backbone stereochemistry on the rigidity of PNA2/DNA complexes. It provided significantly different stabilities via V(m) measurements. The relative gas-phase stability order obtained was compared to that found in solution by Chassaing et al., and shows qualitative agreement.

Activation of large ions in FT-ICR mass spectrometry

The advent of soft ionization techniques, notably electrospray and laser desorption ionization methods, has enabled the extension of mass spectrometric methods to large molecules and molecular complexes. This both greatly extends the applications of mass spectrometry and makes the activation and dissociation of complex ions an integral part of these applications. This review emphasizes the most promising methods for activation and dissociation of complex ions and presents this discussion in the context of general knowledge of reaction kinetics and dynamics largely established for small ions. We then introduce the characteristic differences associated with the higher number of internal degrees of freedom and high density of states associated with molecular complexity. This is reflected primarily in the kinetics of unimolecular dissociation of complex ions, particularly their slow decay and the higher energy content required to induce decomposition--the kinetic shift (KS). The longer trapping time of Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) significantly reduces the KS, which presents several advantages over other methods for the investigation of dissociation of complex molecules. After discussing general principles of reaction dynamics related to collisional activation of ions, we describe conventional ways to achieve single- and multiple-collision activation in FT-ICR MS. Sustained off-resonance irradiation (SORI)--the simplest and most robust means of introducing the multiple collision activation process--is discussed in greatest detail. Details of implementation of this technique, required control of experimental parameters, limitations, and examples of very successful application of SORI-CID are described. The advantages of high mass resolving power and the ability to carry out several stages of mass selection and activation intrinsic to FT-ICR MS are demonstrated in several examples. Photodissociation of ions from small molecules can be effected using IR or UV/vis lasers and generally requires tuning lasers to specific wavelengths and/or utilizing high flux, multiphoton excitation to match energy levels in the ion. Photodissociation of complex ions is much easier to accomplish from the basic physics perspective. The quasi-continuum of vibrational states at room temperature makes it very easy to pump relatively large amounts of energy into complex ions and infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) is a powerful technique for characterizing large ions, particularly biologically relevant molecules. Since both SORI-CID and IRMPD are slow activation methods they have many common characteristics. They are also distinctly different because SORI-CID is intrinsically selective (only ions that have a cyclotron frequency close to the frequency of the excitation field are excited), whereas IRMPD is not (all ions that reside on the optical path of the laser are excited). There are advantages and disadvantages to each technique and in many applications they complement each other. In contrast with these slow activation methods, the less widely appreciated activation method of surface induced dissociation (SID) appears to offer unique advantages because excitation in SID occurs on a sub-picosecond time scale, instantaneously relative to the observation time of any mass spectrometer. Internal energy deposition is quite efficient and readily adjusted by altering the kinetic energy of the impacting ion. The shattering transition--instantaneous decomposition of the ion on the surface--observed at high collision energies enables access to dissociation channels that are not accessible using SORI-CID or IRMPD. Finally, we discuss some approaches for tailoring the surface to achieve particular aims in SID.

Analysis of nucleic acids by FTICR MS

Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometry represents a unique platform with which to study nucleic acids and non-covalent complexes containing nucleic acids moieties. In particular, systems in which very high mass measurement accuracy is required, very complex mixtures are to be analyzed, or very limited amounts of sample are available may be uniquely suited to interrogation by FTICR mass spectrometry. Although the FTICR platform is now broadly deployed as an integral component of many high-end proteomics-based research efforts, momentum is still building for the application of the platform towards nucleic acid-based analyses. In this work, we review fundamental aspects of nucleic acid analysis by FTICR, focusing primarily on the analysis of DNA oligonucleotides but also describing applications related to the characterization of RNA constructs. The goal of this review article is to give the reader a sense of the breadth and scope of the status quo of FTICR analysis of nucleic acids and to summarize a few recently published reports in which researchers have exploited the performance attributes of FTICR to characterize nucleic acids in support of basic and applied research disciplines including genotyping, drug discovery, and forensic analyses.

Mass spectrometry of oligosaccharides

Glycosylation is a common post-translational modification to cell surface and extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins as well as to lipids. As a result, cells carry a dense coat of carbohydrates on their surfaces that mediates a wide variety of cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions that are crucial to development and function. Because of the historical difficulties with the analysis of complex carbohydrate structures, a detailed understanding of their roles in biology has been slow to develop. Just as mass spectrometry has proven to be the core technology behind proteomics, it stands to play a similar role in the study of functional implications of carbohydrate expression, known as glycomics. This review summarizes the state of knowledge for the mass spectrometric analysis of oligosaccharides with regard to neutral, sialylated, and sulfated compound classes. Mass spectrometric techniques for the ionization and fragmentation of oligosaccharides are discussed so as to give the reader the background to make informed decisions to solve structure-activity relations in glycomics.

A study of fast and metastable dissociations of adenine-thymine binary-base oligonucleotides by using positive-ion MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry

In the present study, fast and metastable dissociations of a number of adenine-thymine binary-base oligonucleotides under the conditions of UV matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry were investigated. 2-Aminobenzoic acid/ammonium fluoride (ABA/NH4F) matrix system was used. The spectra obtained under metastable and fast dissociation conditions exhibit distinctive dissociation products. From the post-source-decay analysis, all oligonucleotides underwent predominantly metastable dissociations at the 3' C-O linkages to form [a(n)-B]+ and w(n)+ complimentary ion series. Based on the present results, the so-called "[wn+80]+" ions were postulated to be the complimentary [Z(8-n)AH]+ ions rather than the expected phosphate rearrangement products. In addition, these oligonucleotides were found to generate fast dissociation products of b(n)+, d(N)+, w(N)+ and y(N)+ ions through backbone cleavages at 5' C-O, 5' O-P, 3' C-O and 3' P-O linkages, respectively. Product ion series formed under PSD conditions were not observed. The implications of this mutually exclusive occurrence of the two sets of fragment ions under fast and metastable conditions using ABA/NH4F matrix would be discussed. A model of ion activation under UV-MALDI conditions was also proposed.

A general method for precalculation of parameters for sustained off resonance irradiation/collision-induced dissociation

Sustained off resonance irradiation (SORI) collision-induced dissociation (CID) is a commonly used method of collisionally activating ions for fragmentation in Fourier transform mass spectrometric experiments. To achieve the degree of fragmentation desired, both the irradiation frequency and amplitude must be optimized. This is a time-consuming procedure, particularly when the m/z values of the precursor ions vary over a broad range. We present an approach that simplifies this optimization by precalculating the irradiation frequency of the ions to be fragmented as a constant percentage of the reduced cyclotron frequency. Using this approach, the optimal amplitude was found to be significantly less dependent on the m/z value of the precursor ion, and therefore required little or no adjustment. This method considerably simplified optimization of SORI-CID for analysis of carbohydrates, glycoconjugates, and peptides over the mass range m/z 300-3500, requiring optimization of only a single experimental parameter, the irradiation amplitude, and only for the first MS/MS stage.

Dissociation energies of deoxyribose nucleotide dimer anions measured using blackbody infrared radiative dissociation

The dissociation kinetics of deprotonated deoxyribose nucleotide dimers were measured using blackbody infrared radiative dissociation. Experiments were performed with noncovalently bound dimers of phosphate, adenosine (dAMP), cytosine (dCMP), guanosine (dGMP), thymidine (dTMP), and the mixed dimers dAMP.dTMP and dGMP.dCMP. The nucleotide dimers fragment through two parallel pathways, resulting in formation of the individual nucleotide or nucleotide + HPO3 ion. Master equation modeling of this kinetic data was used to determine threshold dissociation energies. The dissociation energy of (dGMP.dCMP-H)- is much higher than that for the other nucleotide dimers. This indicates that there is a strong interaction between the nucleobases in this dimer, consistent with the existence of Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding between the base pairs. Molecular mechanics simulations indicate that Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding occurs in the lowest energy structures of (dGMP.dCMP-H)-, but not in (dAMP.dTMP-H)-. The trend in gas phase dissociation energies is similar to the trend in binding energies measured in nonaqueous solutions within experimental error. Finally, the acidity ordering of the nucleotides is determined to be dTMP < dGMP < dCMP < dAMP, where dAMP has the highest acidity (largest delta Gacid).

Formation and characterization of iron-oligonucleotide complexes with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry

Iron-containing oligonucleotide negative ions can be generated by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization from a stainless steel target disk (by either defocusing the laser beam or by mixing iron salts such as FeCl3 with the matrix compound during the sample preparation). High resolution mass measurements reveal the presence of both Fe2+ (as M + Fe - 3H)- and Fe3+ (as M + Fe - 4H)- in the metal-oligonucleotide ions. The presence of Fe3+ is unexpected, and must involve replacement of protons from the nucleic bases or ribose groups as well as the phosphate groups of the oligonucleotides. Inspection of a range of small oligonucleotides and mononucleotides reveals that the presence of both Fe2+ and Fe3+ in the iron-biomolecule complexes is dependent on the number of acidic hydrogens that can be replaced in the oligonucleotide or nucleotide. Collisional dissociation of several metal-tetranucleotide ions revealed that the presence of the iron ion alters the fragmentation observed. The iron atom was observed to be present in all of the fragment ions, and, whenever possible, seemed to enhance the abundance of fragment ions containing both iron and a guanine nucleic base. These results suggest that iron may serve as a useful probe for characterizing phosphorylated biomolecules.

Structure and fragmentation mechanisms of isomeric T-rich oligodeoxynucleotides: a comparison of four tandem mass spectrometric methods

Understanding the product-ion spectra of T-rich tetradeoxynucleotides is a starting point in the development of a mass spectrometric scheme to determine the mutagenicity of individual types of DNA damage. We obtained product-ion spectra for electrospray-produced ions that were activated in the ion source (electrospray ionization-source collision-activated-dissociation) and by high-energy collisions in the MS/MS mode of a four-sector instrument. We also activated singly and doubly charged ions by low-energy collisions in an ion-trap mass spectrometer and investigated post source decompositions of matrix-assisted laser desorbed ions in a time-of-flight mass spectrometer. The various methods of extracting structural information give remarkably consistent results. The difference in the relative abundances of wn and dn ions of the singly charged oligonucleotides and the formation of [a3-B3] ions, where B3 is the base on the third position, are effective for identification and distinction of pairs of isomeric tetranucleotides. A sufficient number of tetramers and pentamers were studied to enable us to propose a charge-remote mechanism for the formation of site-specific [an-Bn] ion.

Fourier transform mass spectrometry-advancing years (1992-mid. 1996)

This article is one of a series of Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS) reviews that has appeared in this journal at ca. 3-4 year intervals. A comprehensive review of the recent theoretical developments, instrumental developments, electrospray ionization (ESI), and MALDI is given. Ion dissociation techniques are also discussed because of their contributions to gaining insight into chemical structure. Special sections have been devoted to discussing the emerging fields of surface analysis, polymer analysis, Buckminsterfullerenes (buckyballs), and hydrogen/deuterium exchange studies. This review, although not all-inclusive, is intended to be a starting point for those wishing to learn more about the current status of FTMS, and also as a representative cross-section of the literature for those familiar with the technique. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Mass spectrometry of nucleic acids

The present article is a survey of ESI and MALDI mass spectrometric analysis of nucleic acid oligomers and polymers. In order to limit the extent of the review, mass spectrometry of mononucleotides is generally not considered, except where such data are important for an understanding of the analysis of larger nucleic acids. The first part of the review is a condensed description of the structure and the acid-base properties of nucleic acids. The remaining part is divided into three main sections, dealing with the practical aspects of the two ionization techniques, fragmentation, and applications, respectively. The first section includes an extensive discussion of experimental parameters and problems, which are important for the analysis of different types of nucleic acid samples, including noncovalent complexes and mixtures. At the end of this section, as well as the following one, a comparison between MALDI and ESI as ionization techniques for nucleic acid is given. In addition to a detailed discussion of ion fragmentation, the fragmentation section includes an overview of the direct mass spectrometric sequencing of nucleic acids performed with either technique. The fragmentation reactions occurring upon MALDI and ESI are compared. The last section describes the life science applications of ESI-MS and MALDI-MS of nucleic acids; an account of experiments demonstrating the potential of a method, and of the bona fide solving of problems by ESI and MALDI is given. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.