Structural cassette mutagenesis in a de novo designed protein: proof of a novel concept for examining protein folding and stability

A segment of cold shock protein directs the folding of a combinatorial protein

It has been suggested that protein domains evolved by the non-homologous recombination of building blocks of subdomain size. In earlier work we attempted to recapitulate domain evolution in vitro. We took a polypeptide segment comprising three beta-strands in the monomeric, five-stranded beta-barrel cold shock protein (CspA) of Escherichia coli as a building block. This segment corresponds to a complete exon in homologous eukaryotic proteins and includes residues that nucleate folding in CspA. We recombined this segment at random with fragments of natural proteins and succeeded in generating a range of folded chimaeric proteins. We now present the crystal structure of one such combinatorial protein, 1b11, a 103-residue polypeptide that includes segments from CspA and the S1 domain of the 30S ribosomal subunit of E. coli. The structure reveals a segment-swapped, six-stranded beta-barrel of unique architecture that assembles to a tetramer. Surprisingly, the CspA segment retains its structural identity in 1b11, recapitulating its original fold and deforming the structure of the S1 segment as necessary to complete a barrel. Our work provides structural evidence that (i) random shuffling of nonhomologous polypeptide segments can lead to folded proteins and unique architectures, (ii) many structural features of the segments are retained, and (iii) some segments can act as templates around which the rest of the protein folds.

Importance of secondary structural specificity determinants in protein folding: insertion of a native beta-sheet sequence into an alpha-helical coiled-coil

To examine how a short secondary structural element derived from a native protein folds when in a different protein environment, we inserted an 11-residue beta-sheet segment (cassette) from human immunoglobulin fold, Fab new, into an alpha-helical coiled-coil host protein (cassette holder). This de novo design protein model, the structural cassette mutagenesis (SCM) model, allows us to study protein folding principles involving both short- and long-range interactions that affect secondary structure stability and conformation. In this study, we address whether the insertion of this beta-sheet cassette into the alpha-helical coiled-coil protein would result in conformational change nucleated by the long-range tertiary stabilization of the coiled-coil, therefore overriding the local propensity of the cassette to form beta-sheet, observed in its native immunoglobulin fold. The results showed that not only did the nucleating helices of the coiled-coil on either end of the cassette fail to nucleate the beta-sheet cassette to fold with an alpha-helical conformation, but also the entire chimeric protein became a random coil. We identified two determinants in this cassette that prevented coiled-coil formation: (1) a tandem dipeptide NN motif at the N-terminal of the beta-sheet cassette, and (2) the hydrophilic Ser residue, which would be buried in the hydrophobic core if the coiled-coil structure were to fold. By amino acid substitution of these helix disruptive residues, that is, either the replacement of the NN motif with high helical propensity Ala residues or the substitution of Ser with Leu to enhance hydrophobicity, we were able to convert the random coil chimeric protein into a fully folded alpha-helical coiled-coil. We hypothesized that this NN motif is a "secondary structural specificity determinant" which is very selective for one type of secondary structure and may prevent neighboring residues from adopting an alternate protein fold. These sequences with secondary structural specificity determinants have very strong local propensity to fold into a specific secondary structure and may affect overall protein folding by acting as a folding initiation site.

The unusually stable coiled-coil domain of COMP exhibits cold and heat denaturation in 4-6 M guanidinium chloride

A high thermal stability is observed for the five-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil domain of cartilage oligomeric matrix protein COMP. It does not unfold in non-denaturing buffer between 0 and 100 degrees C and thermal denaturation is only achieved at high concentrations of guanidinium chloride (4-6 M). In these solutions the protein structure is lost at decreasing (cold denaturation) and increasing temperatures (heat denaturation). In the cold denaturation region, the melting profile showed deviations from the theory of Privalov et al. [P.L. Privalov, V. Griko Yu, S. Venyaminov, V.P. Kutyshenko, Cold denaturation of myoglobin, J. Mol. Biol. 190 (1986) 487-498] probably due to deviations from a two-state mechanism. High thermal stability as well as cold and heat denaturation was also observed for a mutant of the coiled-coil domain of COMP in which glutamine 54 was replaced by isoleucine but it still forms pentamer. The melting temperatures in plain buffer for the heat denaturation of COMP coiled-coil domain and its mutant obtained by extrapolation to zero molar guanidinium chloride concentration are approximately 160 and 220 degrees C, respectively, which groups them among the most stable proteins.

Salmonella enteritidis fimbriae displaying a heterologous epitope reveal a uniquely flexible structure and assembly mechanism

Two distinct Salmonella fimbrins, AgfA and SefA, comprising thin aggregative fimbriae SEF17 and SEF14, respectively, were each genetically engineered to carry PT3, an alpha-helical 16-amino acid Leishmania T-cell epitope derived from the metalloprotease gp63. To identify regions within AgfA and SefA fimbrins amenable to replacement with this epitope, PCR-generated chimeric fimbrin genes were constructed and used to replace the native chromosomal agfA and sefA genes in Salmonella enteritidis. Immunoblot analysis using anti-SEF17 and anti-PT3 sera demonstrated that all ten AgfA chimeric fimbrin proteins were expressed by S. enteritidis under normal growth conditions. Immunoelectron microscopy confirmed that eight of the AgfA::PT3 proteins were effectively assembled into cell surface-exposed fimbriae. The PT3 replacements in AgfA altered Congo red (CR) binding, cell-cell adhesion and cell surface properties of S. enteritidis to varying degrees. However, these chimeric fimbriae were still highly stable, being resistant to proteinase K digestion and requiring harsh formic acid treatment for depolymerization. In marked contrast to AgfA, none of the chimeric SefA proteins were expressed or assembled into fimbriae. Since each PT3 replacement constituted over 10% of the AgfA amino acid sequence and all ten replacements collectively represented greater than 75% of the entire AgfA primary sequence, the ability of AgfA to accept large sequence substitutions and still assemble into fibers is unique among fimbriae and other structural proteins. This structural flexibility may be related to the novel fivefold repeating sequence of AgfA and its recently proposed structure Proper formation of chimeric fimbrial fibers suggests an unusual assembly mechanism for thin aggregative fimbriae which tolerates aberrant structures. This study opens a range of possibilities for Salmonella thin aggregative fimbriae as a carrier of heterologous epitopes and as an experimental model for studies of protein structure.

Helical peptide and protein design

The design of dimeric coiled-coils has ultimately led to novel applications, such as self-replicating peptide systems, whereas the structural features of the less common trimeric coiled-coil continue to be elucidated. Novel topologies have been discovered in designed proteins, as exemplified by the right-handed tetrameric coiled-coil and the inverted U four-helix bundle, and a single switch of two amino acids within a protein has been shown to be sufficient to designate a new protein fold. Conformational switching from helix to sheet has been observed for designed peptides and transcription factors, whereas peptides designed from beta-amino acids have been found to adopt a helical conformation in aqueous solution.