Point mutation in intron 10 of FMR1 is unlikely to be a cause of fragile X syndrome

Beyond Trinucleotide Repeat Expansion in Fragile X Syndrome: Rare Coding and Noncoding Variants in FMR1 and Associated Phenotypes

FMR1 (FMRP translational regulator 1) variants other than repeat expansion are known to cause disease phenotypes but can be overlooked if they are not accounted for in genetic testing strategies. We collected and reanalyzed the evidence for pathogenicity of FMR1 coding, noncoding, and copy number variants published to date. There is a spectrum of disease-causing FMR1 variation, with clinical and functional evidence supporting pathogenicity of five splicing, five missense, one in-frame deletion, one nonsense, and four frameshift variants. In addition, FMR1 deletions occur in both mosaic full mutation patients and as constitutional pathogenic alleles. De novo deletions arise not only from full mutation alleles but also alleles with normal-sized CGG repeats in several patients, suggesting that the CGG repeat region may be prone to genomic instability even in the absence of repeat expansion. We conclude that clinical tests for potentially FMR1-related indications such as intellectual disability should include methods capable of detecting small coding, noncoding, and copy number variants.

Loss of the KH1 domain of FMR1 in humans due to a synonymous variant causes global developmental retardation

BACKGROUND

Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is a monogenic disorder and a common cause of intellectual disability (ID). Up to now, very few pathological variants other than the typical CGG-repeat expansion have been reported in the FMR1 gene.

METHODS

A panel of 56 intellectual disability (ID) genes including the FMR1 gene was sequenced in a cohort of 300 patients with unexplained ID. To determine the effect of a new FMR1 variant, total RNA from peripheral blood cells was reverse transcribed, amplified by polymerase chain reaction and sequenced.

RESULTS

We report a novel G to A point variant (c.801G > A) located at the last nucleotide of exon 8 in the FMR1 gene in one patient with ID. Direct sequencing of the RT-PCR products revealed that the transcript from the allele with G to A variant skips exon 8 entirely, resulting in a joining of exons 7 and 9. Skipping of exon 8 may result in an abnormal FMR1 protein (FMRP), which removes the highly conserved region that encoding the KH1 domain of FMRP.

CONCLUSIONS

This report describes for the first time that a synonymous variant in the FMR1 gene is associated with an error in mRNA processing, leading preferentially to the production of an aberrant transcript without exon 8. This splice variant was associated with an unspecific clinical presentation, suggesting the need for more detailed investigation of silent variants in ID patients with a large spectrum of phenotypes.

Intragenic FMR1 disease-causing variants: a significant mutational mechanism leading to Fragile-X syndrome

Fragile-X syndrome (FXS) is a frequent genetic form of intellectual disability (ID). The main recurrent mutagenic mechanism causing FXS is the expansion of a CGG repeat sequence in the 5'-UTR of the FMR1 gene, therefore, routinely tested in ID patients. We report here three FMR1 intragenic pathogenic variants not affecting this sequence, identified using high-throughput sequencing (HTS): a previously reported hemizygous deletion encompassing the last exon of FMR1, too small to be detected by array-CGH and inducing decreased expression of a truncated form of FMRP protein, in three brothers with ID (family 1) and two splice variants in boys with sporadic ID: a de novo variant c.990+1G>A (family 2) and a maternally inherited c.420-8A>G variant (family 3). After clinical reevaluation, the five patients presented features consistent with FXS (mean Hagerman's scores=15). We conducted a systematic review of all rare non-synonymous variants previously reported in FMR1 in ID patients and showed that six of them are convincing pathogenic variants. This study suggests that intragenic FMR1 variants, although much less frequent than CGG expansions, are a significant mutational mechanism leading to FXS and demonstrates the interest of HTS approaches to detect them in ID patients with a negative standard work-up.

Point mutation frequency in the FMR1 gene as revealed by fragile X syndrome screening

Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is a common cause of intellectual disability, developmental delay and autism spectrum disorders. This syndrome is due to a functional loss of the FMR1 gene product FMRP, and, in most cases, it is caused by CGG repeat expansion in the FMR1 promoter. Yet, also other FMR1 mutations may cause a FXS-like phenotype. Since standard molecular testing does not include the analysis of the FMR1 coding region, the prevalence of point mutations causing FXS is not well known. Here, high resolution melting (HRM) was used to screen for FMR1 gene mutations in 508 males with clinical signs of mental retardation and developmental delay, but without CGG and GCC repeat expansions in the FMR1 gene and AFF2 genes, respectively. Sequence variations were identified by HRM analysis and verified by direct DNA sequencing. Two novel missense mutations (p.Gly482Ser in one patient and p.Arg534His in two unrelated patients), one intronic and two 3'-untranslated region (UTR) variations were identified in the FMR1 gene. Missense mutations in the FMR1 gene might account for a considerable proportion of cases in male patients with FXS-related symptoms, such as those linked to mental retardation and developmental delay.

Association and transmission analysis of the FMR1 IVS10 + 14C-T variant in autism

Evidence from the high male to female ratio of individuals with autism as well as suggestive linkage data have implicated the possible involvement of X chromosomal loci in the aetiology of autism. Studies of the FMR1 gene on Xq27 have shown that occasionally individuals, and particularly females, with the [CGG] repeat expansion and methylation mutation may present with autistic symptoms. However, molecular studies suggest that such mutations are not a major cause of autism. Previously, we have screened autism probands for mutations in regions of the FMR1 gene downstream of the [CGG] repeat and identified an intronic variant in the FMR1 gene, IVS10 + 14C-T, which was present at a significantly higher frequency in autistic individuals compared to controls individuals. We have now investigated this variant in a further 136 autism families and 186 control individuals. We have established that the variant is significantly more frequent among East Asian individuals within our affected and control groups (P < 0.0001) and although we observed a trend of higher transmission frequency of the rare allele to affected individuals, there was no significant evidence in either family-based or case/control association studies for this variant in autism (P > 0.05).

The Fragile X mental retardation protein

The clinical features of the Fragile X mental retardation syndrome are linked to the absence of the set of protein isoforms, derived from alternative splicing of the Fragile X mental retardation gene 1 (FMR1), and collectively termed FMRP. FMRP is an RNA binding protein that is part of a ribonucleoprotein particle associated to actively translating polyribosomes, and which can shuttle between nucleus and cytoplasm. Two highly homologous human proteins, FXR1P and FXR2P, share the same domain structure as FMRP, and probably similar functions. The properties of FMRP suggested that it is involved in nuclear export, cytoplasmic transport, and/or translational control of target mRNAs. In particular, it may play a role in regulation of protein synthesis at postsynaptic sites of dendrites, and in maturation of dendritic spines. Efforts are underway to identify the putative specific mRNA targets of FMRP, and study the effect of FMRP absence on the corresponding proteins. Other approaches have led to the identification of proteins that interact with FMRP. Some of them discriminate between FMRP and the homologous FXR1/2P proteins, and may thus be important for defining unique functions of FMRP that are deficient in Fragile X patients. The physiological functions of FMRP are notably approached through the study of a FMR1 knock-out mouse model. The recent identification in Drosophila melanogaster of genes encoding homologs of FMRP/FXRP and of their interacting proteins, open the way to use of Drosophila genetics to study FMRP function.

FMR1 gene and fragile X syndrome

Taxonomic features of fragile X syndrome (FXS) associated with the fragile X mutation have evolved over several decades. Males are more severely impacted cognitively than females, but both show declines in IQ scores as they age. Although many males with FXS exhibit autistic-like features, autism does not occur more frequently in males with FXS than among males with mental retardation (MR). FXS is caused by inactivation of the FMR1 gene located on Xq27.3. FMRP, the protein produced by FMR1, has been detected in most organs and in brain. In cells, it is located primarily in cytoplasm and contains motifs found in RNA-binding proteins. The FMRP N-terminal contains a functional nuclear localization signal which permits the protein to shuttle between cytoplasm and nucleus. FMR1 knockout mice show subtle behavioral and visual-spatial difficulties. Analysis of their brain tissue suggests absence of FMRP impairs synaptic maturation. Individuals with the fragile premutation produce FMRP, and the phenotype associated with the premutation has been controversial. However, there seems to be a higher incidence of premature ovarian failure in women with the premutation than is found in the general female population. This may be related to unusual increases in mRNA levels in premutation carriers.

Rare variants in the promoter of the fragile X syndrome gene (FMR1)

Fragile X syndrome, the most common form of familial mental retardation, is mainly caused by the expansion of an unstable region of CGG repeats in the 5' untranslated region of the FMR1 (Fragile X Mental Retardation-1) gene. Molecular tools to detect an abnormal CGG expansion in FMR1 include Southern blot hybridization and PCR amplification. Southern blotting with the StB12.3 probe and Eco RI/Eag I double digestion is widely used as a routine test for fragile X syndrome diagnosis in laboratories around the world. A patient with mental retardation of unknown origin showed absence of digestion for Eag I due to a -149C-->G substitution in the CpG island of the FMR1 gene, which destroys that restriction enzyme site. Screening for other changes around that region also detected a -154insGGC in a patient with a phenotype highly suggestive of fragile X syndrome but without CGG expansion. Expression studies did not show any abnormal changes in FMR1 function. In summary, we have identified two different changes (a C to G substitution at -149 and a GGC insertion at -154) in the promoter of the FMR1 gene. These are the first variants described in the promoter of the FMR1 gene.