Considerations from an International Regulatory and Pharmaceutical Industry (IQ MPS Affiliate) Workshop on the Standardization of Complex In Vitro Models in Drug Development

Application of new approach methodologies for nonclinical safety assessment of drug candidates

The development of new approach methodologies (NAMs) and advances with in vitro testing systems have prompted revisions in regulatory guidelines and inspired dedicated in vitro/ex vivo studies for nonclinical safety assessment. This Review by a safety reflection initiative subgroup of the European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations (EFPIA)/Preclinical Development Expert Group (PDEG) summarizes the current state and potential application of in vitro studies using human-derived material for safety assessment in drug development. It focuses on case studies from recent projects in which animal models alone proved to be limited or inadequate for safety testing. It further highlights four categories of drug candidates for which alternative in vitro approaches are applicable and discusses progress in using in vitro testing solutions for safety assessment in these categories. Finally, the article highlights new risk assessment strategies, initiatives and consortia promoting the advancement of NAMs. This collective work is meant to encourage the use of NAMs for more human-relevant safety assessment, which should ultimately result in reduced animal testing for drug development.

Validation of microphysiological systems for interpreting patient heterogeneity requires robust reproducibility analytics and experimental metadata

Multi-cell-type, 3D microphysiological systems (MPS) that recapitulate normal organ/organ system functions and the progression of diseases are being applied in drug discovery and development programs to enable precision medicine. A critical step for this application is to demonstrate the reproducibility of the MPS and its ability to identify biologic/clinical heterogeneity from experimental variability, which requires capturing detailed metadata associated with MPS studies as well as a strong analytical approach for assessing reproducibility. Detailed metadata ensure that identical study parameters are being compared when evaluating reproducibility. We have developed the Pittsburgh reproducibility protocol (PReP), which uses a set of common statistical metrics, the coefficient of variation (CV), ANOVA, and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), in a pipeline as a standard approach to evaluate the intra- and interstudy reproducibility of MPS performance. The PReP can be employed to identify biological/clinical heterogeneity relevant to precision medicine.

Human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes and their use in a cardiac organ-on-a-chip to assay electrophysiology, calcium and contractility

Cardiac organs-on-a-chip (OoCs) or microphysiological systems have the potential to predict cardiac effects of new drug candidates, including unanticipated cardiac outcomes, which are among the main causes for drug attrition. This protocol describes how to prepare and use a cardiac OoC containing cardiomyocytes differentiated from human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPS cells). The use of cells derived from hiPS cells as reliable sources of human cells from diverse genetic backgrounds also holds great potential, especially when cultured in OoCs that are physiologically relevant culture platforms. To promote the broad adoption of hiPS cell-derived cardiac OoCs in the drug development field, there is a need to first ensure reproducibility in their preparation and use. This protocol aims to provide key information on how to reduce sources of variability during hiPS cell maintenance, differentiation, loading and maturation in OoCs. Variability in these procedures can lead to inconsistent purity after differentiation and variable function between batches of microtissues formed in OoCs. This protocol also focuses on describing the handling and functional assessment of cardiac microtissues using live-cell microscopy approaches to quantify parameters of cellular electrophysiology, calcium transients and contractility. The protocol consists of five stages: (1) thaw and maintain hiPS cells, (2) differentiate hiPS cell cardiomyocytes, (3) load differentiated cells into OoCs, (4) maintain and characterize loaded cells, and (5) evaluate and utilize cardiac OoCs. Execution of the entire protocol takes ~40 days. The required skills to carry out the protocol are experience with sterile techniques, mammalian cell culture and maintaining hiPS cells in a pluripotent state.

Organoids-on-a-chip: microfluidic technology enables culture of organoids with enhanced tissue function and potential for disease modeling

Organoids are stem-cell derived tissue structures mimicking specific structural and functional characteristics of human organs. Despite significant advancements in the field over the last decade, challenges like limited long-term functional culture and lack of maturation are hampering the implementation of organoids in biomedical research. Culture of organoids in microfluidic chips is being used to tackle these challenges through dynamic and precise control over the organoid microenvironment. This review highlights the significant breakthroughs that have been made in the innovative field of "organoids-on-chip," demonstrating how these have contributed to advancing organoid models. We focus on the incorporation of organoids representative for various tissues into chips and discuss the latest findings in multi-organoids-on-chip approaches. Additionally, we examine current limitations and challenges of the field towards the development of reproducible organoids-on-chip systems. Finally, we discuss the potential of organoids-on-chip technology for both in vitro and in vivo applications.

The Use of MPS in Three Rs and Regulatory Applications: Perspectives From Developers on Stakeholder Responsibilities

Increasing the use of microphysiological systems (MPS) in Three Rs and regulatory applications is a nuanced but important goal, which would also help increase their scientific impact. There are three distinct and important stakeholder groups that each play a unique role in expediting the use of MPS for regulatory purpose - namely, commercial MPS developers, end-users and regulators. Additionally, non-profit organisations, such as the 3Rs Collaborative (3RsC), can help coordinate these efforts. This paper introduces the MPS Initiative, as organised by the 3RsC, and clarifies the potential for MPS to benefit all Three Rs. Key differences in the use of MPS-derived data for regulatory evidence of efficacy versus safety, and for various other contexts of use, are discussed. Finally, the results are presented from a survey of primarily commercial MPS developers, that collected their views on the realistic responsibilities of each stakeholder group. The results also highlight their key perspectives on the use of MPS, in the context of Three Rs and regulatory applications.

Considering future qualification for regulatory science in the early development of microphysiological systems: a case study of microthrombosis in a Vessel-on-Chip

Microphysiological systems (MPS) and Organs-on-Chips (OoCs) hold significant potential for replicating complex human biological processes in vitro. However, their widespread adoption by industry and regulatory bodies depends on effective qualification to demonstrate that these models are fit for purpose. Many models developed in academia are not initially designed with qualification in mind, which limits their future implementation in end-user settings. Here, we explore to which extent aspects of qualification can already be performed during early development stages of MPS and OoCs. Through a case study of our blood-perfused Vessel-on-Chip model, we emphasize key elements such as defining a clear context-of-use, establishing relevant readouts, ensuring model robustness, and addressing inherent limitations. By considering qualification early in development, researchers can streamline the progression of MPS and OoCs, facilitating their adoption in biomedical, pharmaceutical, and toxicological research. In addition, all in vitro methods must be independent of animal-derived materials to be considered fully fit for purpose. Ultimately, early qualification efforts can enhance the availability, reliability, and regulatory as well as ethical acceptance of these emerging New Approach Methodologies.

Improving tumor microenvironment assessment in chip systems through next-generation technology integration

The tumor microenvironment (TME) comprises a diverse array of cells, both cancerous and non-cancerous, including stromal cells and immune cells. Complex interactions among these cells play a central role in driving cancer progression, impacting critical aspects such as tumor initiation, growth, invasion, response to therapy, and the development of drug resistance. While targeting the TME has emerged as a promising therapeutic strategy, there is a critical need for innovative approaches that accurately replicate its complex cellular and non-cellular interactions; the goal being to develop targeted, personalized therapies that can effectively elicit anti-cancer responses in patients. Microfluidic systems present notable advantages over conventional in vitro 2D co-culture models and in vivo animal models, as they more accurately mimic crucial features of the TME and enable precise, controlled examination of the dynamic interactions among multiple human cell types at any time point. Combining these models with next-generation technologies, such as bioprinting, single cell sequencing and real-time biosensing, is a crucial next step in the advancement of microfluidic models. This review aims to emphasize the importance of this integrated approach to further our understanding of the TME by showcasing current microfluidic model systems that integrate next-generation technologies to dissect cellular intra-tumoral interactions across different tumor types. Carefully unraveling the complexity of the TME by leveraging next generation technologies will be pivotal for developing targeted therapies that can effectively enhance robust anti-tumoral responses in patients and address the limitations of current treatment modalities.

Challenges and Future Perspectives in Modeling Neurodegenerative Diseases Using Organ-on-a-Chip Technology

Neurodegenerative diseases (NDDs) affect more than 50 million people worldwide, posing a significant global health challenge as well as a high socioeconomic burden. With aging constituting one of the main risk factors for some NDDs such as Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD), this societal toll is expected to rise considering the predicted increase in the aging population as well as the limited progress in the development of effective therapeutics. To address the high failure rates in clinical trials, legislative changes permitting the use of alternatives to traditional pre-clinical in vivo models are implemented. In this regard, microphysiological systems (MPS) such as organ-on-a-chip (OoC) platforms constitute a promising tool, due to their ability to mimic complex and human-specific tissue niches in vitro. This review summarizes the current progress in modeling NDDs using OoC technology and discusses five critical aspects still insufficiently addressed in OoC models to date. Taking these aspects into consideration in the future MPS will advance the modeling of NDDs in vitro and increase their translational value in the clinical setting.

Bioprinting Soft 3D Models of Hematopoiesis using Natural Silk Fibroin-Based Bioink Efficiently Supports Platelet Differentiation

Hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) continuously generate platelets throughout one's life. Inherited Platelet Disorders affect ≈ 3 million individuals worldwide and are characterized by defects in platelet formation or function. A critical challenge in the identification of these diseases lies in the absence of models that facilitate the study of hematopoiesis ex vivo. Here, a silk fibroin-based bioink is developed and designed for 3D bioprinting. This bioink replicates a soft and biomimetic environment, enabling the controlled differentiation of HSPCs into platelets. The formulation consisting of silk fibroin, gelatin, and alginate is fine-tuned to obtain a viscoelastic, shear-thinning, thixotropic bioink with the remarkable ability to rapidly recover after bioprinting and provide structural integrity and mechanical stability over long-term culture. Optical transparency allowed for high-resolution imaging of platelet generation, while the incorporation of enzymatic sensors allowed quantitative analysis of glycolytic metabolism during differentiation that is represented through measurable color changes. Bioprinting patient samples revealed a decrease in metabolic activity and platelet production in Inherited Platelet Disorders. These discoveries are instrumental in establishing reference ranges for classification and automating the assessment of treatment responses. This model has far-reaching implications for application in the research of blood-related diseases, prioritizing drug development strategies, and tailoring personalized therapies.

Project-Based Public-Private Collaborations

Project-based collaborations between a single academic group and a single pharmaceutical company arguably are the most frequent form of public-private partnership in preclinical research and development of new drugs. This chapter discusses the benefits of such collaborations for both sides and potential challenges that can arise before and during the conduct of a project. This is largely based on a survey of expectations and experience by 134 academic investigators with a history of engagement in a project-based collaboration with a pharmaceutical company as well as unstructured experience directly, and learned through discussions with colleagues, from the authors. Obviously, a key benefit for both sides is achieving goals that neither could easily achieve by itself. Scientific discovery, and publications, may be a shared benefit, while for academics, funding and access to compounds, and for industry, access to assay technology and reputational factors may be important. Major hurdles can be freedom to publish and assignment of intellectual property rights. On pragmatic grounds, reaching a contract can be cumbersome, which is largely attributable to the legal expectations and needs of both parties. However, overall satisfaction with project-based collaborations appears very high for academic investigators.

Microphysiological systems as reliable drug discovery and evaluation tools: Evolution from innovation to maturity

Microphysiological systems (MPSs), also known as organ-on-chip or disease-on-chip, have recently emerged to reconstitute the in vivo cellular microenvironment of various organs and diseases on in vitro platforms. These microfluidics-based platforms are developed to provide reliable drug discovery and regulatory evaluation testbeds. Despite recent emergences and advances of various MPS platforms, their adoption of drug discovery and evaluation processes still lags. This delay is mainly due to a lack of rigorous standards with reproducibility and reliability, and practical difficulties to be adopted in pharmaceutical research and industry settings. This review discusses the current and potential use of MPS platforms in drug discovery processes while considering the context of several key steps during drug discovery processes, including target identification and validation, preclinical evaluation, and clinical trials. Opportunities and challenges are also discussed for the broader dissemination and adoption of MPSs in various drug discovery and regulatory evaluation steps. Addressing these challenges will transform long and expensive drug discovery and evaluation processes into more efficient discovery, screening, and approval of innovative drugs.