Controlling π-π Interactions of Highly Soluble Naphthalene Diimide Derivatives for Neutral pH Aqueous Redox Flow Batteries

4,4'-Hydrazobis(1-methylpyridinium) as a Two-Electron Posolyte Molecule for Aqueous Organic Redox Flow Batteries

Aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFBs) are a safe and sustainable solution for the storage of intermittent renewable energy. While several highly soluble two-electron organic molecule negolytes have been developed for AORFBs, most reported organic posolyte species exchange only one electron. Herein, readily available 4,4'-hydrazobis(1-methylpyridinium) dichloride (HydBPyMeCl) is described as a novel two-electron posolyte molecule for AORFBs. The synthesis of HydBPyMeCl was accomplished by a three-step process, yielding multiple grams of the compound. HydBPyMeCl exhibited a reversible two-electron transfer at high redox potential (+0.64 V vs Ag/AgCl reference electrode, pH = 0). When evaluated at 1 M concentration and low pH (2 M HCl) with V3+/V2+ on the negative side, HydBPyMeCl showed high stability. A capacity retention of 99.997% per cycle (99.980% per day measured over 70 days) was achieved, coupled with a high volumetric specific capacity of 47.1 Ah/L (87.2% of capacity utilization at 80 mA/cm2).

Synergistic ionic modification strategy enhances the stability of naphthalene diimide zwitterions for cost-effective aqueous organic redox flow batteries

Aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFBs) hold significant promise for energy storage due to their unique advantages and characteristics. However, their development is hindered by the lack of decomposition resistance and cycle stability over long periods. In this study, we synthesized naphthalene diimide (NDI) derivatives with zwitterions in their side chains via the atmospheric pressure method, namely (CBu)2NDI and (SPr)2NDI. The electrostatic repulsion between (CBu)2NDI precisely regulates π-π stacking into a parallel-staggered pattern. The synergistic zwitterions strategy effectively mitigates the positive charge of N+ in (CBu)2NDI compared with (NPr)2NDI and dex-NDI; this not only enhances the aromaticity of the naphthalene diimide core but also inhibits the side chain decomposition caused by the SN2 nucleophilic attack of hydroxyl ions (OH-) on the C=O. The calculation of the single point energy proves that during the charging processes of (CBu)2NDI, the K+ will be close to the naphthalene core to form dimers or monomers with lower energy configurations under electrostatic attraction. (CBu)2NDI achieved a water solubility up to 1.49 M, which can be paired with K4Fe(CN)6 under two-electron transfer with total electrolyte costs as low as $6.58 Ah-1. The 0.1 M battery maintains full capacity after 5070 cycles. Furthermore, the battery delivers an impressive 100% capacity retention under 2 M e- during 220 cycles.

Manipulating Aggregate Electrochemistry for High-Performance Organic Redox Flow Batteries

Organic molecule in solutions is the energy storage unit in the organic redox flow batteries (ORFBs), of which the aggregation is acknowledged pivotal but has been rarely investigated. By establishing a pyridinium library, the manipulation over the aggregation in solutions is investigated at the molecular level. Both theoretical calculations and physiochemical methods are used to characterize the aggregate's structure, and salient findings are as follows. First, the singly-reduced monoradicals simultaneously aggregate in a concentrated solution, which is driven by the solvation effect, orbital overlap and dispersion interaction. Second, the aggregation can be manipulated by the molecular engineering strategy and counteracted by introducing either electrostatic repulsive force or twisted geometry. Third, the monoradical's aggregation yields a decrease in the molecular singly occupied molecular orbital energy level and a linear scaling relationship with its thermodynamic potential. As a result, the increase in the concentration lowers the battery's voltage, which counteracts its effort to increase the battery's energy density. The anti-aggregation is proven effective in breaking the scaling relationship and accordingly, a molecular strategy to manipulate aggregate electrochemistry is developed. This work provides physical insights into the electrolytic solution and chemical strategy for optimizing the flow battery.

Organic redox flow batteries in non-aqueous electrolyte solutions

Redox flow batteries (RFBs) are gaining significant attention due to the growing demand for sustainable energy storage solutions. In contrast to conventional aqueous vanadium RFBs, which have a restricted voltage range resulting from the use of water and vanadium, the utilization of redox-active organic molecules (ROMs) as active materials broadens the range of applicable liquid media to include non-aqueous electrolyte solutions. The extended voltage range of non-aqueous media, exceeding 2 V, facilitates the establishment of high-energy storage systems. Additionally, considering the higher cost of non-aqueous solvents compared to water, the objective in developing non-aqueous electrolyte solution-based organic RFBs (NRFBs) is to efficiently install these systems in a compact manner and explore unique applications distinct from those associated with aqueous RFBs, which are typically deployed for grid-scale energy storage systems. This review presents recent research progress in ROMs, electrolytes, and membranes in NRFBs. Furthermore, we address the prevailing challenges that require revolution, encompassing a narrow cell voltage range, insufficient solubility, chemical instability, and the crossover of ROMs. Through this exploration, the review contributes to the understanding of the current landscape and potential advancements in NRFB technology and encourages researchers and professionals in the energy field to explore this emerging technology as a potential solution to global environmental challenges.

Intermolecular Anionic Mixed-Valence and π-Dimer Complexes of ortho-Pentannulated Bisazacoronene Diimide

This study reports the serendipitous discovery of intermolecular anionic mixed-valence (MV) and π-dimer species in ortho-pentannulated BisAzaCoroneneDiimides (BACDs) during their electrochemical reduction in a non-aqueous solvent. A library of nitrogen-containing extended PDIs was synthesized via an aza-benzannulation reaction followed by a Pd-catalysed ortho-pentannulation reaction. Ortho-pentannulated BACDs revealed strong aggregation abilities in solution. Concentration-dependent UV/Vis absorption spectra, variable temperature 1H NMR experiments, and atomic force microscopy coupled to molecular dynamics support their self-assembly into columnar aggregates. Cyclic voltammetry experiments in dichloromethane reveal prominent splitting of the first reduction wave, attributed to the formation of unprecedented intermolecular anionic MV and π-dimers in organic solvent. These species were thoroughly characterized by real-time spectroelectrochemistry, electrochemical simulations and theoretical calculations. Remarkably, this work underscores the tuneable nature of AzaBenzannulatedPerylene Diimides (AzaBPDIs) and BACDs, emphasizing their potential as a promising scaffold for designing supramolecular materials with long-range radical anion delocalization. The observation of this phenomenon provides insights into the fundamental behaviour of supramolecular organic semiconductors, thereby paving the way for the development of novel electronic devices and electron-deficient materials.

Adjusting Hirshfeld charge of TEMPO catholytes for stable all-organic aqueous redox flow batteries

2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO) derivatives are typical catholytes in aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFBs), but reported lifetime of them is limited. We find that the increase of Hirshfeld charge decreases the Gibbs free energy change (ΔG) values of side reactions of TEMPO, a near-linear relationship, and then exacerbates their degradation. Here we predict and synthesize a TEMPO derivative, namely TPP-TEMPO, by analyzing the Hirshfeld charge. TPP-TEMPO, with the smallest Hirshfeld charge and highest ΔG, is an order of magnitude more stable than TMA-TEMPO (N,N,N-2,2,6,6-heptamethylpiperidinyl oxy-4-ammonium chloride, a control with the largest Hirshfeld charge and lowest ΔG). We further elaborate on their decomposition pathways, identify byproducts, and mitigate degradation by supporting electrolyte engineering. Finally, a TPP-TEMPO/BTMAP-Vi (1,1'-bis[3-(trimethylammonio)propyl]-4,4'-bipyridinium tetrachloride) cell achieves a capacity density of ~12 Ah L-1 and a low capacity fade rate of 0.0018% per cycle (or 0.0067% per hour).

In Situ Molecular Reconfiguration of Pyrene Redox-Active Molecules for High-Performance Aqueous Organic Flow Batteries

Aqueous organic flow batteries (AOFBs) hold great potential for large-scale energy storage, however, scalable, green, and economical synthetic methods for stable organic redox-active molecules (ORAMs) are still required for their practical applications. Herein, pyrene-based ORAMs are obtained via an in situ organic electrolysis strategy in a flow cell. It is revealed that the water attacking pyrenes restructured molecules to produce a variety of isomers and dimers during the electrolysis, which can be modulated by regulating the local electron cloud density and steric hindrance of pyrene precursors. As a result, the molecularly reconfigured pyrene-based catholytes, even without any further purification, achieved a high electrolyte utilization of ≈96% and volumetric capacity above 50 Ah L-1. Inspiringly, remarkable cell stability with almost no capacity decay for ≈70 days is achieved, benefiting from the robust aromatic structure of the pyrene cores. The insights into the in situ electrosynthesis of pyrene-based ORAMs provided in the work will provide guidance for designing ultra-stable ORAMs for AOFB applications.

Commercializable Naphthalene Diimide Anolytes for Neutral Aqueous Organic Redox Flow Batteries

Neutral aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFBs) hold the potential to facilitate the transition of renewable energy sources from auxiliary to primary energy, the commercial production of anolyte materials still suffers from insufficient performance of high-concentration and the high cost of the preparation problem. To overcome these challenges, this study provides a hydrothermal synthesis methodology and introduces the charged functional groups into hydrophobic naphthalene diimide cores, and prepares a series of high-performance naphthalene diimide anolytes. Under the synergistic effect of π-π stacking and H-bonding networks, the naphthalene diimide exhibits excellent structural stability and the highest water solubility (1.85 M for dex-NDI) reported to date. By employing the hydrothermal method, low-cost naphthalene diimides are successfully synthesized on a hundred-gram scale of $0.16 g-1 ($2.43 Ah-1), which is also the lowest price reported to date. The constructed full battery achieves a high electron concentration of 2.4 M, a high capacity of 54.4 Ah L-1, and a power density of 318 mW cm-2 with no significant capacity decay observed during long-duration cycling. These findings provide crucial support for the commercialization of AORFBs and pave the way for revolutionary developments in neutral AORFBs.

Realizing one-step two-electron transfer of naphthalene diimides via a regional charge buffering strategy for aqueous organic redox flow batteries

Naphthalene diimide derivatives show great potential for application in neutral aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFBs) due to their highly conjugated molecular structure and stable two-electron storage capacity. However, the two-electron redox process of naphthalene diimides typically occurs via two separate steps with the transfer of one electron per step ("two-step two-electron" transfer process), which leads to an inevitable loss of voltage and energy. Herein, we report a novel regional charge buffering strategy that utilizes the core-substituted electron-donating group to adjust the redox properties of naphthalene diimides, realizing two electron transfer via a single-step redox process ("one-step two-electron" transfer process). The symmetrical battery testing of NDI-DEtOH revealed exceptional intrinsic stability lasting for 11 days with a daily decay rate of only 0.11%. Meanwhile, AORFBs with NDI-DMe/FcNCl and NDI-DEtOH/FcNCl exhibited a remarkable 40% improvement in peak power density at 50% state of charge (SOC) in comparison to NDI/FcNCl-based AORFBs. In addition, the battery's energy efficiency has increased by 24%, resulting in much more stable output power and significantly improved energy efficiency. These results are of great significance to practical applications of AORFBs.

Stabilization of Naphthalene Diimide Anions by Ion Pair Formation in Nonaqueous Organic Redox Flow Batteries

In redox flow batteries, a compelling strategy for enhancing the charge capacity of redox-active organic molecules involves storing multiple electrons within a single molecule. However, this approach poses unique challenges such as chemical instability by forming radicals, elevated energy requirements, and unsustainable charge concentration. Ion pairing is a possible solution to achieve charge neutrality and engineer redox potential shifts but has received limited attention. In this study, we demonstrate that Li+ can stabilize naphthalene diimide (NDI) anions dissolved in acetonitrile and significantly shift the second cathodic potential close to the first. Our findings, supported by density functional theory calculations and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, indicate that dimeric NDI species form stable ion pairs with Li+. Conversely, K+ ions exhibit weak interactions, and cyclic voltammograms confirm significant potential shifts when stronger Lewis acids and solvents with lower donor numbers are employed. Galvanostatic examinations reveal a single voltage plateau with Li+, which indicates a rapid redox process involving doubly charged NDI2- with Li+. These aggregated ion pairs offer the additional benefits of hindering crossover events, contributing to excellent cyclability, and suppressing undesirable side reactions even after 1000 redox cycles.

Enantiomer Recognition Based on Chirality Transfer from Chiral Amines to Ternary Dynamic Covalent Systems

Enantiomer recognition is usually required in organic synthesis and materials and life sciences. This paper describes an enantiomer recognition method based on ternary dynamic covalent systems constructed via the complexation of chiral amines with a chiral boronate derived from 1,4-phenylenediboric acid and an L-DOPA-modified naphthalenediimide. The ternary systems aggregate into chiral assemblies driven by π-π interactions, and the chirality is transferred from the chiral amines to assemblies with high stereospecificity. Consequently, the enantiomer composition of chiral amines and the absolute configuration of the major enantiomer can be determined according to the sign of the Cotton effect of the ternary system by using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. This method offers the advantage of using the long wavelength CD signals of the boronate at around 520 nm, thereby avoiding interference with those of the carbon skeleton. This ternary system provides a novel approach to the design of enantiomer recognition systems.

Enabling Long-Life Aqueous Organic Redox Flow Batteries with a Highly Stable, Low Redox Potential Phenazine Anolyte

Aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFBs) are considered a promising energy storage technology due to the sustainability and designability of organic active molecules. Despite this, most of AORFBs suffer from limited stability and low voltage because of the chemical instability and high redox potential of organic molecules in anolyte. Herein, we propose a new phenazine derivative, 4,4'-(phenazine-2,3-diylbis(oxy))dibutyric acid (2,3-O-DBAP), as a water-soluble and chemically stable anodic active molecules. By combining calculations and experiments, we demonstrate that 2,3-O-DBAP exhibits a higher solubility, a lower redox potential (-0.699 V vs SHE), and greater chemical stability than other O-DBAP isomers. Then, we demonstrate a long-lasting flow cell with an average discharge voltage of 1.12 V, a low fade rate of 0.0127%, and a lifespan of 62 days at pH 14 using 2,3-O-DBAP paired with ferri/ferrocyanide. The negligible self-discharge behavior also verifies the high stability of 2,3-O-DBAP. These results highlight the importance of molecular engineering for AORFBs.

Functional materials for aqueous redox flow batteries: merits and applications

Redox flow batteries (RFBs) are promising electrochemical energy storage systems, offering vast potential for large-scale applications. Their unique configuration allows energy and power to be decoupled, making them highly scalable and flexible in design. Aqueous RFBs stand out as the most promising technologies, primarily due to their inexpensive supporting electrolytes and high safety. For aqueous RFBs, there has been a skyrocketing increase in studies focusing on the development of advanced functional materials that offer exceptional merits. They include redox-active materials with high solubility and stability, electrodes with excellent mechanical and chemical stability, and membranes with high ion selectivity and conductivity. This review summarizes the types of aqueous RFBs currently studied, providing an outline of the merits needed for functional materials from a practical perspective. We discuss design principles for redox-active candidates that can exhibit excellent performance, ranging from inorganic to organic active materials, and summarize the development of and need for electrode and membrane materials. Additionally, we analyze the mechanisms that cause battery performance decay from intrinsic features to external influences. We also describe current research priorities and development trends, concluding with a summary of future development directions for functional materials with valuable insights for practical applications.

Benzidine Derivatives: A Class of High Redox Potential Molecules for Aqueous Organic Flow Batteries

The development of water-soluble redox-active molecules with high potentials is one of the effective ways to enhance the energy density of aqueous organic flow batteries (AOFBs). Herein, a series of promising N-substituted benzidine analogues as water-soluble catholyte candidates with controllable redox potentials (0.78-1.01 V vs. standard hydrogen electrode (SHE)) were obtained by the molecular engineering of aqueous irreversible benzidines. Theoretical calculations reveal that the redox potentials of these benzidine derivatives in acidic solution are determined by their electronic structure and alkalinity. Among these benzidine derivatives, N,N,N',N'-tetraethylbenzidine(TEB) shows both high redox potential (0.82 V vs. SHE) and good solubility (1.1 M). Pairing with H4 [Si(W3 O10 )4 ] anolyte, the cell displayed discharge capacity retention of 99.4 % per cycle and a high coulombic efficiency (CE) of ∼100 % over 1200 cycles. The stable discharge capacity of 41.8 Ah L-1 was achieved at the 1.0 M TEB catholyte with a CE of 97.2 % and energy efficiency (EE) of 91.2 %, demonstrating that N-substituted benzidines could be promising for AOFBs.

Organic Electroactive Materials for Aqueous Redox Flow Batteries

Organic electroactive materials take advantage of potentially sustainable production and structural tunability compared to present commercial inorganic materials. Unfortunately, traditional redox flow batteries based on toxic redox-active metal ions have certain deficiencies in resource utilization and environmental protection. In comparison, organic electroactive materials in aqueous redox flow batteries (ARFBs) have received extensive attention in recent years for low-cost and sustainable energy storage systems due to their inherent safety. This review aims to provide the recent progress in organic electroactive materials for ARFBs. The main reaction types of organic electroactive materials are classified in ARFBs to provide an overview of how to regulate their solubility, potential, stability, and viscosity. Then, the organic anolyte and catholyte in ARFBs are summarized according to the types of quinones, viologens, nitroxide radicals, hydroquinones, etc, and how to increase the solubility by designing various functional groups is emphasized. The research advances are presented next in the characterization of organic electroactive materials for ARFBs. Future efforts are finally suggested to focus on building neutral ARFBs, designing advanced electroactive materials through molecular engineering, and resolving problems of commercial applications.