Haplotype analysis at the FRAXA locus in the Japanese population

FMR1 CGG Repeats: Reference Levels and Race-Ethnic Variation in Women With Normal Fertility (Study of Women's Health Across the Nation)

FMR1 premutation carriers (55-199 CGG repeats), and potentially women with high normal (35-44) or low normal (<28) CGG repeats, are at risk of premature ovarian aging. The scarcity of population data on CGG repeats <45 CGG, and variation in race-ethnicity, makes it difficult to determine true associations. DNA was analyzed for FMR1 CGG repeat lengths from 803 women (386 caucasians, 219 African Americans, 102 Japanese, and 96 Chinese) from the US-based Study of Women's Health Across the Nation (SWAN). Participants had ≥1 menses in the 3 months before enrollment, ≥1 pregnancy, no history of infertility or hormonal therapy, and menopause ≥46 years. Statistical analyses used Fisher exact tests. Among these women with normal reproductive histories, significant FMR1 repeat length differences were found across race-ethnicity for both the longer (P = .0002) and the shorter (P < .0001) alleles. The trinucleotide length variance was greater for non-Asian than Asian women (P < .0001), despite identical median values. Our data indicate that short allele lengths <25 CGG on one or both alleles are more common in non-Asian than Asian women. We confirm the minor allele in the 35 to 39 CGG range among Asians as reported previously. Only 2 (0.3%) premutation carriers were identified. These data demonstrate that FMR1 distributions do vary by race-ethnicity, even within the "normal" range. This study indicates the need to control for race-ethnicity in FMR1 ovarian aging research and provides race-ethnic population data for females separated by allele.

Distribution of fragile X mental retardation 1 CGG repeat and flanking haplotypes in a large Chinese population

Fragile X syndrome is mainly caused by a CGG repeat expansion within the 5' UTR of the fragile X mental retardation 1 (FMR1) gene. Previous analyses of the FMR1 CGG repeat patterns and flanking haplotypes in Caucasians and African Americans have identified several factors that may influence repeat instability. However, the CGG repeat patterns and distribution for FRAXAC2 have not yet been investigated in mainland Chinese. We surveyed the CGG repeat lengths in 1113 Han Chinese (534 males and 579 females), and the CGG repeat patterns of 534 males were determined by sequence analysis. We also explored the flanking haplotypes (DXS548-FRAXAC1-FRAXAC2) in 566 unaffected and 28 unrelated fragile X Chinese males. The most frequent alleles for DXS548 and FRAXAC1 were identical between our Chinese population and other Asian populations. We identified several low-abundance alleles for DXS548 and FRAXAC1 not found in previous studies in mainland Chinese and Taiwanese cohorts. The most frequent allele was (CGG)29 followed by (CGG)30, and the most frequent patterns were 9 + 9 + 9, 10 + 9 + 9, and 9 + 9 + 6 + 9, similar to those in Singaporeans. We identified only one premutation female carrier with 89 CGG repeats in the 1113 Han Chinese. A few associations between the CGG repeat patterns and flanking haplotypes were determined in this study. In general, the Chinese population had a smaller number of alleles and lower expected heterozygosity for all three STR markers and FRAXA locus when compared with Caucasians and African Americans. We identified a novel haplotype 7-3-5 + that is significantly associated with the full mutation.

Haplotype analysis at the FRAXA locus in an Indian population

The FRAXA locus is flanked by three polymorphic STR markers DXS548, FRAXAC1, and FRAXAC2. Allele frequencies of these markers were determined on a population representing the eastern part of India comprising of 69 normal controls and 69 unrelated subjects with mental retardation, among whom 21 were fragile X patients. These frequencies were compared with published data on other Indian population and the major populations of the world. The allele and haplotype distribution of the studied population were significantly different in some respects from the major populations of the world. The increase of heterozygosities in fragile X samples (DXS548 67.5%, FRAXAC1 63.5%, FRAXAC2 68.5%) relative to the controls (DXS548 63.3%, FRAXAC1 51.0%, FRAXAC2 67.2%) suggests a multimodal distribution of fragile X associated alleles. Haplotype analyses with DXS548 and FRAXAC1 markers revealed that haplotype distribution in the normal controls and fragile X groups were significantly different, suggesting a weak founder effect.

FMR1 haplotype analyses among Indians: a weak founder effect and other findings

This study on allelic/haplotypic fragile X associations evaluated using STR (DXS548, FRAXAC1, FRAXAC2) and SNP (ATL1) markers flanking the (CGG)(n) locus of FMR1is the first report from the large ethnically complex Indian population. Results have been compared with allele/haplotype distributions reported for other major ethnic groups, including White Caucasians, Africans, and Pacific Asians. Though overall allele frequency distributions at the individual loci are more similar to Western Caucasians compared with others, significant differences are observed in haplotypic associations with the mutated X. The striking findings are: (1) high diversity and heterozygosity of haplotypes among fragile X chromosomes ( n=40) and controls ( n=262), including four haplotypes found exclusively in this study sample; (2) weak association of DXS548-FRAXAC1-FRAXAC2 haplotypes, 2-1-3, 6-3-3+ and 7-4-6+ with the disorder, and absence of White Caucasian fragile X haplotypes 6-4-4 and 6-4-5; (3) weak founder effect for the fragile X expansion mutation in the Indians; (4) lack of a continuum of haplotype-based FMR1 alleles between intermediate (CGG)(n) size ranges and expanded alleles; (5) exclusion of ATL1 as a candidate genetic indicator of FMR1 instability. The high STR-based haplotype diversity observed among fragile X lineages, irrespective of ethnic alliances, strongly suggests the inappropriateness of using STR haplotypes to infer predisposition to instability among ethnically separated fragile X pedigrees and may reiterate the need for identifying newer SNPs from this region to not only determine true founder effects for the fragile X mutation, but also decipher possible mechanisms leading to CGG instability.

Expansion mutation frequency and CGG/GCC repeat polymorphism in FMR1 and FMR2 genes in an Indian population

Based on molecular screening, we estimated the frequencies of fragile X syndrome and FRAXE syndrome in an institutionalized population (n = 130) in New Delhi, India. Eligibility criteria for inclusion of subjects in the study were mild/moderate mental retardation, with/without family history, and the fragile X clinical phenotype. Screening by Southern hybridization revealed an overall frequency of 0.077 of the syndrome in the sample population. The disorder was observed with a high frequency (0.1) among males as compared to females (0.027). No expansions of FMR2 allele were observed in the same study sample. CGG/GCC allelic polymorphism of FMR1 and FMR2 were established from a total of 392 X chromosomes, using the radioactive polymerase chain reaction-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis method. Distinct repeat sizes, repeat ranges, and repeat modes characterised the FMR1 and FMR2 alleles. In the X chromosomes of both MR individuals and unaffected controls, unimodal values of 29 and 15 repeats in FMR1 and FMR2 genes, respectively, were observed. Allele frequency distribution was symmetrical at the FMR1 locus whereas a significant positive skew was observed for the FMR2 alleles. The observed heterozygosity of the FMR1 gene was 0.772 compared to 0.839 of FMR2. Correlation of CGG/GCC repeats of FMR1 and FMR2 did not show any association of repeat sizes at these two loci (correlation coefficient, rho = 0.09). CGG/GCC repeat variation at FMR1 and FMR2 loci observed in this study sample are different from that reported for the other Caucasian and Asian populations.

Survey of the fragile X syndrome CGG repeat and the short-tandem-repeat and single-nucleotide-polymorphism haplotypes in an African American population

Previous studies have shown that specific short-tandem-repeat (STR) and single-nucleotide-polymorphism (SNP)-based haplotypes within and among unaffected and fragile X white populations are found to be associated with specific CGG-repeat patterns. It has been hypothesized that these associations result from different mutational mechanisms, possibly influenced by the CGG structure and/or cis-acting factors. Alternatively, haplotype associations may result from the long mutational history of increasing instability. To understand the basis of the mutational process, we examined the CGG-repeat size, three flanking STR markers (DXS548-FRAXAC1-FRAXAC2), and one SNP (ATL1) spanning 150 kb around the CGG repeat in unaffected (n=637) and fragile X (n=63) African American populations and compared them with unaffected (n=721) and fragile X (n=102) white populations. Several important differences were found between the two ethnic groups. First, in contrast to that seen in the white population, no associations were observed among the African American intermediate or "predisposed" alleles (41-60 repeats). Second, two previously undescribed haplotypes accounted for the majority of the African American fragile X population. Third, a putative "protective" haplotype was not found among African Americans, whereas it was found among whites. Fourth, in contrast to that seen in whites, the SNP ATL1 was in linkage equilibrium among African Americans, and it did not add new information to the STR haplotypes. These data indicate that the STR- and SNP-based haplotype associations identified in whites probably reflect the mutational history of the expansion, rather than a mutational mechanism or pathway.

Stable-isotope-assisted MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry for accurate determination of nucleotide compositions of PCR products

In parallel with a large-scale sequencing effort, the human genome project will need next-generation tools for accurate and efficient analyses of the enormous pool of DNA sequences. Such analyses are required for (a) validation of DNA sequences, (b) comparison of a parent (known) sequence with a related (unknown) sequence, and (c) characterization of sequence polymorphisms in various genes, especially those associated with genetically inherited human diseases. Here, we report a novel method that combines stable isotope 13C/15N labeling of PCR products of the target sequences with analysis of the mass shifts by mass spectrometry (MS). The mass shift due to the labeling of a single type of nucleotide (i.e., A, T, G, or C) reveals the number of that type of nucleotide in a given DNA fragment. Using this technique, we have accurately determined nucleotide compositions of DNA fragments. The method has also been applied to score a known single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). The comparisons of nucleotide compositions determined by our method among homologous sequences are useful in sequence validation, sequence comparison, and characterizations of sequence polymorphisms.

Possible founder effects for FRAXE alleles

To determine if FRAXE alleles may have haplotype associations with nearby microsatellites, we analyzed 149 unrelated control Caucasian X chromosomes for FRAXE GCC alleles along with five nearby microsatellites. The microsatellites included three that are new; GT25, CA4, and CA5 located approximately 24, approximately 48, and approximately 50 kb proximal to the FRAXE GCC repeat, and two that were identified previously: DXS8091 and DXS1691, located approximately 90 and approximately 5 kb distal. No significant correlations between haplotypes for the proximal microsatellites were found. Significant correlations of FRAXE GCC repeats and distal microsatellite allele sizes, DXS8091 (r = 0.24) and DXS1691 (r = -0.40), were found. One haplotype, 18-19 of DXS8091-DXS1691, was present on 57% of chromosomes with > or =22 FRAXE repeats but present on only 10% with <22 repeats. We conclude that this distal haplotype association likely reflects a FRAXE allele founder effect. The lack of association or founder effects seen for the three newly identified proximal markers, located within 50 kb of FRAXE GCC, may reflect an unusually high rate of mutation for these microsatellites or a higher rate of recombination in the proximal region.

FRAXAC1 and DXS548 polymorphisms in the Chinese population

The fragile X syndrome is the most common inherited form of mental retardation. Haplotype studies using FRAXAC1 and DXS548 polymorphic markers flanking the fragile site have demonstrated linkage disequilibrium at the FMR1 locus. We investigated the association of the FRAXAC1, DXS548 and CGG alleles between normal subjects and mentally retarded (MR) patients of unspecified cause who do have fragile X syndrome. We have evaluated the FRAXAC1 site in 390 normal subjects and 321 MR patients and the DXS548 site in 146 normal and 319 MR subjects. Both FRAXAC1 and DXS548 alleles were determined by application of the polymerase chain reaction. When compared with Caucasians, the normal Chinese population has a different FRAXAC1 allele distribution. There are more AC18 repeat alleles and fewer AC19 repeat alleles. The DXS548 allele distributions were similar between Chinese and Caucasians. The same distribution pattern of FRAXAC1 alleles was found in both normal subjects and MR patients, but there were significant differences in the distribution patterns of DXS548 alleles. The FMR1 CGG-DXS548 and FRAXAC1-DXS548 haplotype distribution between normal subjects and MR patients also differed significantly. Our results suggest a possible association between DXS548 alleles and non-FRAXA mental retardation.

Population genetics of the FRAXE and FRAXF GCC repeats, and a novel CGG repeat, in Xq28

Most of the rare folate sensitive fragile sites cloned to date arise from expansion of a CGG:CCG trinucleotide repeat array. Analysis of the CAG repeat at the Huntington Disease (HD) locus showed a positively skewed repeat distribution leading to the proposal that microsatellites are subject to a mutational bias toward expansion. Such a mutational bias predicts an increase in mean repeat size at all microsatellite loci. We present an analysis of repeats at two fragile site loci, FRAXE and FRAXF, and a novel CGG repeat in Xq28, in five different human populations, which suggests that these loci may also be subject to the same mutation process. The novel repeat array may represent the first evidence for the existence of a fourth fragile site in Xq27.3-28.

Dynamic mutation loci: allele distributions in different populations

To assess the relative contributions of trans-acting factors (replication and repair functions) and cis-acting elements (repeat and flanking DNA composition) to the mechanism of trinucleotide repeat sequence mutation we have analysed the distribution of copy number polymorphisms at 12 loci associated with dynamic mutations in 15 populations of different ethnic origins. Genome wide instability of repeats in a particular population would be evidence of trans-acting factor instigation of the mutation process, whereas instability at a particular locus (perhaps even in several populations) would be evidence that the composition of the particular locus was the most significant factor contributing to mutation. The FRA16A locus is highly polymorphic in only the European population. Some other loci exhibit distinct distributions of alleles between different populations. Therefore sequences in the vicinity of the repeat -- the cis component of a particular locus -- appear(s) to be more important in the mutation mechanism than sporadic genome-wide instability induced by trans-acting factors such as the DNA mismatch repair enzymes.

Fragile X founder chromosomes in Italy: a few initial events and possible explanation for their heterogeneity

A total of 137 fragile X and 235 control chromosomes from various regions of Italy were haplotyped by analyzing two neighbouring marker microsatellites, FRAXAC1 and DXS548. The number of CGG repeats at the 5' end of the FMR1 gene was also assessed in 141 control chromosomes and correlated with their haplotypes. Significant linkage disequilibrium between some "major" haplotypes and fragile X was observed, while other "minor" haplotypes may have originated by subsequent mutation at the marker microsatellite loci and/or recombination between them. Recent evidence suggests that the initial mechanism leading to CGG instability might consist of rare (10 (-6/-7)) CGG repeat slippage events and/or loss of a stabilizing AGG via A-to-C transversion. Also, the apparently high variety of fragile X chromosomes may be partly due to the relatively high mutation rate (10 (-4/-5)) of the microsatellite markers used in haplotyping. Our fragile X sample also showed a higher than expected heterozygosity when compared to the control sample and we suggest that this might be explained by the chance occurrence of the few founding events on different chromosomes, irrespective of their actual frequency in the population. Alternatively, a local mechanism could enhance the microsatellite mutation rate only on fragile X chromosomes, or fragile X mutations might occur more frequently on certain background haplotypes.

Extended gene diversity at the FMR1 locus and neighbouring CA repeats in a sub-Saharan population

We report on the allele distributions in a normal black African population at two microsatellite loci neighbouring the FRAXA locus and at the CGG repeat in the 5' end of the FMR-1 gene, which causes the fragile X syndrome. The CGG repeat distribution was found to be similar to that of other ethnic groups, as well as to that of other nonhuman primates, possibly predicting a comparable prevalence of fragile X in Africa. Significant linkage disequilibrium has been observed between fragile X mutations and alleles of the DXS548 and FRAXAC1 loci in European and Asian populations, and some founder chromosomes may be extremely old. Those associated with FRAXAC1-A and DXS548-2 alleles are not present in the Asian fragile X samples. We searched for these alleles and their frequency in the well defined Bamileke population of Cameroon. All previously described alleles and some new ones were found in this sample, supporting the hypothesis of their pre-existence and subsequent loss in Asian populations. Finally, the heterozygosity of the Bamileke sample was significantly higher at both marker loci and comparable to that of Europeans at the CGG repeat, confirming the notion that genetic diversity is greater in Africans than in other groups and supporting the view that evolution of modern man started in Africa.

Fragile X founder effects and new mutations in Finland

The apparent associations between fragile X mutations and nearby microsatellites may reflect both founder effects and microsatellite instability. To gain further insight into their relative contributions, we typed a sample of 56 unrelated control and 37 fragile X chromosomes from an eastern Finnish population for FMR1 CGG repeat lengths, AGG interspersion patterns, DXS548, FRAXAC1, FRAXE and a new polymorphic locus, Alu-L. In the controls, the most common FMR1 allele was 30 repeats with a range of 20 to 47 and a calculated heterozygosity of 88%. A strong founder effect was observed for locus DXS548 with 95% of fragile X chromosomes having the 21 CA repeat (196 bp) allele compared to 17% of controls, while none of the fragile X but 69% of controls had the 20 repeat allele. Although the FRAXAC1 locus is much closer than DXS548 to FMR1 (7 kb vs. 150 kb), there was no significant difference between fragile X and control FRAXAC1 allele distributions. The FRAXE repeat, located 600 kb distal to FMR1, was found to show strong linkage disequilibrium as well. A newly defined polymorphism, Alu-L, located at approximately 40 kb distal to the FMR1 repeat, showed very low polymorphism in the Finnish samples. Analysis of the combined loci DXS548-FRAXAC1-FRAXE showed three founder haplotypes. Haplotype 21-19-16 was found on 27 (75%) of fragile X chromosomes but on none of controls. Three (8.4%) fragile X chromosomes had haplotypes 21-19-15, 21-19-20, and 21-19-25 differing from the common fragile X haplotype only in FRAXE. These could have arisen by recombination or from mutations of FRAXE. A second haplotype 21-18-17 was found in four (11.1%) fragile X chromosomes but only one (1.9%) control. This may represent a more recent founder mutation. A third haplotype 25-21-15, seen in two fragile X chromosomes (5.6%) and one (1.9%) control, was even less common and thus may represent an even more recent mutation or admixture of immigrant types. Analysis of the AGG interspersions within the FMR1 CGG repeat showed that 7/8 premutation chromosomes lacked an AGG whereas all controls had at least one AGG. This supports the hypothesis that the mutation of AGG to CGG leads to repeat instability and mutational expansion.

FMR1 triplet arrays: paying the price for perfection

Our understanding of FMRI trinucleotide instability has increased dramatically with knowledge of its detailed structures. While most arrays seem to be protected by interspersions, for a few the price of perfection is instability. Although there remain many unanswered questions, diagnosis in the “grey zone” can be greatly improved by studying array content. For the future, as we strive to delineate normal from premutation, we should increasingly be able to estimate rates of instability for future generations and predict the risk of conversion to the full mutation.

Evolutionary dynamics of the FMR1 locus

Rare haplotypes for close flanking markers are associated with increased allele size and frequency of the fragile X mutation. Exceptional founder haplotypes can be identified, but many haplotypes with rare alleles contribute to full mutations. A transition matrix constructed from the data predicts that a population with reduced variability will manifest a slowly increasing frequency of premutations and full mutations, reach a distribution close to the observed one after a few hundred generations, and then slowly be depleted of these alleles. This prediction is opposite to less well supported inference of increasing frequency of progressive amplification, but the data are inadequate to reach any firm conclusions. Factors that may determine the evolution of these systems, but cannot now be evaluated, are discussed.

Distribution of FMR-1 and associated microsatellite alleles in a normal Chinese population

The CGG repeat size distribution of the fragile X mental retardation gene (FMR-1) was studied in a population of normal Chinese X chromosomes along with that of two proximal microsatellite polymorphic markers: FRAXAC1 and DXS548. The most common CGG repeat allele was 29 (47.2%) with 30 being second most common (26%). This distribution was different from that seen in Caucasian controls, where the most common allele was 30 repeats. Other differences with Caucasian controls included a secondary modal peak at 36 repeats and the absence of peaks at 20 or 23 repeats. There were only two FRAXAC1 and five DXS548 alleles found in the Chinese sample. A striking linkage disequilibrium of FMR-1 alleles with FRAXAC1 alleles was observed, in that 90% of the 29 CGG repeat alleles but only 41% of the 30 CGG repeat alleles had the FRAXAC1 152 bp allele (18 AC repeats). This disequilibrium suggests that slippage between the closely spaced normal CGG repeat alleles, 29 and 30, and between 152 and 154 FRAXAC1 alleles is very rare. This study lays the groundwork for an understanding of founder chromosome effects in comparing Asian and Caucasian populations.