Direct Evidence of Subsurface Oxygen Formation in Oxide-Derived Cu by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy

Impact of Subsurface Oxygen on CO2 Charging Energy Changes in Cu Surfaces

Subsurface oxygen in oxide-derived copper catalysts significantly influences CO2 activation. However, its effect on the molecular charging process, the key to forming the CO2δ- intermediate, remains poorly understood. We employ many-body perturbation theory to investigate the impact of the structural factors induced by the subsurface oxygen on the charged activation of CO2. By computing the molecular single-particle state energy of the electron-accepting orbital on the Cu (111) surface, we examined how this molecular quasi-particle (QP) energy changes with the varying vicinity of adsorption and multiple-subsurface oxygen configuration. We demonstrate that subsurface oxygen impairs CO2 charging, with its presence and coverage being influential factors. However, we remark that density functional theory calculations do not predict such an excitation energy discrepancy induced by subsurface oxygen. The nonlocal potential proves to be substantial for accurate excitation energy predictions yet is not sensitive to minor atomic structural changes. More importantly, state delocalization and hybridization are critical for determining QP energy. These insights are enlightening for designing atomic architectures to optimize catalytic performance on modified surfaces.

Interfacial Metal Oxides Stabilize Cu Oxidation States for Electrocatalytical CO2 Reduction

Modulating the oxidation state of copper (Cu) is crucial for enhancing the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), particularly for facilitating deep reductions to produce methane (CH4) or multi-carbon (C2+) products. However, Cuδ+ sites are thermodynamically unstable, fluctuating their oxidation states under reaction conditions, which complicates their functionality. Incorporating interfacial metal oxides has emerged as an effective strategy for stabilizing these oxidation states. This review provides an in-depth examination of the reaction mechanisms occurring at oxide-modified Cuδ+ sites, offering a comprehensive understanding of their behavior. We explore how Cu/metal oxide interfaces stabilize Cu oxidation states, showing that oxides-modified Cu catalysts often enhance selectivity for C2+ or CH4 products by stabilizing Cu+ or Cu2+ sites. In addition, we discuss innovative strategies for the rational design of efficient Cu catalytic sites tailored for specific deep CO2RR products. The review concludes with an outlook on current challenges and future directions, offering new insights into the rational design of selective and efficient CO2RR catalysts.

Role of Cu Oxide and Cu Adatoms in the Reactivity of CO2 on Cu(110)

We investigate the interaction of CO2 with metallic and oxidized Cu(110) surfaces using a combination of near-ambient pressure scanning tunneling microscopy (NAP-STM) and theoretical calculations. While the Cu(110) and full CuO films are inert, the interface between bare Cu(110) and the CuO film is observed to react instantly with CO2 at a 10 mbar pressure. The reaction is observed to proceed from the interfacial sites of CuO/Cu(110). During reaction with CO2, the CuO/Cu(110) interface releases Cu adatoms which combine with CO3 to produce a variety of added Cu-CO3 structures, whose stability depends on the gas pressure of CO2. A main implication for the reactivity of Cu(110) is that Cu adatoms and highly undercoordinated CuO segments are created on the Cu(110) surface through the interaction with CO2, which may act as reaction-induced active sites. In the case of CO2 hydrogenation to methanol, our theoretical assessment of such sites indicates that their presence may significantly promote CH3OH formation. Our study thus implies that the CuO/Cu(110) interfacial system is highly dynamic in the presence of CO2, and it suggests a possible strong importance of reaction-induced Cu and CuO sites for the surface chemistry of Cu(110) in CO2-related catalysis.

Stabilizing the oxidation state of catalysts for effective electrochemical carbon dioxide conversion

In the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), metal catalysts with an oxidation state generally demonstrate more favorable catalytic activity and selectivity than their corresponding metallic counterparts. However, the persistence of oxidative metal sites under reductive potentials is challenging since the transition to metallic states inevitably leads to catalytic degradation. Herein, a thorough review of research on oxidation-state stabilization in the CO2RR is presented, starting from fundamental concepts and highlighting the importance of oxidation state stabilization while revealing the relevance of dynamic oxidation states in product distribution. Subsequently, the functional mechanisms of various oxidation-state protection strategies are explained in detail, and in situ detection techniques are discussed. Finally, the prevailing and prospective challenges associated with oxidation-state protection research are discussed, identifying innovative opportunities for mechanistic insights, technology upgrades, and industrial platforms to enable the commercialization of the CO2RR.

Co-sensitization of Copper Indium Gallium Disulfide and Indium Sulfide on Zinc Oxide Nanostructures: Effect of Morphology in Electrochemical Carbon Dioxide Reduction

Recent advances in nanoparticle materials can facilitate the electro-reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) to form valuable products with high selectivity. Copper (Cu)-based electrodes are promising candidates to drive efficient and selective CO2 reduction. However, the application of Cu-based chalcopyrite semiconductors in the electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 is still limited. This study demonstrated that novel zinc oxide (ZnO)/copper indium gallium sulfide (CIGS)/indium sulfide (InS) heterojunction electrodes could be used in effective CO2 reduction for formic acid production. It has been determined that Faradaic efficiencies for formic acid production using ZnO nanowire (NW) and nanoflower (NF) structures vary due to structural and morphological differences. A ZnO NW/CIGS/InS heterojunction electrode resulted in the highest efficiency of 77.2% and 0.35 mA cm-2 of current density at a -0.24 V (vs. reversible hydrogen electrode) bias potential. Adding a ZTO intermediate layer by the spray pyrolysis method decreased the yield of formic acid and increased the yield of H2. Our work offers a new heterojunction electrode for efficient formic acid production via cost-effective and scalable CO2 reduction.

Cooperation of Different Active Sites to Promote CO2 Electroreduction to Multi-carbon Products at Ampere-Level

Electroreduction of CO2 to C2+ products provides a promising strategy for reaching the goal of carbon neutrality. However, achieving high selectivity of C2+ products at high current density remains a challenge. In this work, we designed and prepared a multi-sites catalyst, in which Pd was atomically dispersed in Cu (Pd-Cu). It was found that the Pd-Cu catalyst had excellent performance for producing C2+ products from CO2 electroreduction. The Faradaic efficiency (FE) of C2+ products could be maintained at approximately 80.8 %, even at a high current density of 0.8 A cm-2 for at least 20 hours. In addition, the FE of C2+ products was above 70 % at 1.4 A cm-2. Experiments and density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealed that the catalyst had three distinct catalytic sites. These three active sites allowed for efficient conversion of CO2, water dissociation, and CO conversion, ultimately leading to high yields of C2+ products.

Dynamics of bulk and surface oxide evolution in copper foams for electrochemical CO2 reduction

Oxide-derived copper (OD-Cu) materials exhibit extraordinary catalytic activities in the electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR), which likely relates to non-metallic material constituents formed in transitions between the oxidized and the reduced material. In time-resolved operando experiment, we track the structural dynamics of copper oxide reduction and its re-formation separately in the bulk of the catalyst material and at its surface using X-ray absorption spectroscopy and surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. Surface-species transformations progress within seconds whereas the subsurface (bulk) processes unfold within minutes. Evidence is presented that electroreduction of OD-Cu foams results in kinetic trapping of subsurface (bulk) oxide species, especially for cycling between strongly oxidizing and reducing potentials. Specific reduction-oxidation protocols may optimize formation of bulk-oxide species and thereby catalytic properties. Together with the Raman-detected surface-adsorbed *OH and C-containing species, the oxide species could collectively facilitate *CO adsorption, resulting an enhanced selectivity towards valuable C2+ products during CO2RR.

In Situ Infrared Spectroscopic Evidence of Enhanced Electrochemical CO2 Reduction and C-C Coupling on Oxide-Derived Copper

The reaction mechanism of CO2 electroreduction on oxide-derived copper has not yet been unraveled even though high C2+ Faradaic efficiencies are commonly observed on these surfaces. In this study, we aim to explore the effects of copper anodization on the adsorption of various CO2RR intermediates using in situ surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (SEIRAS) on metallic and mildly anodized copper thin films. The in situ SEIRAS results show that the preoxidation process can significantly improve the overall CO2 reduction activity by (1) enhancing CO2 activation, (2) increasing CO uptake, and (3) promoting C-C coupling. First, the strong *COO- redshift indicates that the preoxidation process significantly enhances the first elementary step of CO2 adsorption and activation. The rapid uptake of adsorbed *COatop also illustrates how a high *CO coverage can be achieved in oxide-derived copper electrocatalysts. Finally, for the first time, we observed the formation of the *COCHO dimer on the anodized copper thin film. Using DFT calculations, we show how the presence of subsurface oxygen within the Cu lattice can improve the thermodynamics of C2 product formation via the coupling of adsorbed *CO and *CHO intermediates. This study advances our understanding of the role of surface and subsurface conditions in improving the catalytic reaction kinetics and product selectivity of CO2 reduction.

Multi-spectroscopic study of electrochemically-formed oxide-derived gold electrodes

Oxide-derived metals are produced by reducing an oxide precursor. These materials, including gold, have shown improved catalytic performance over many native metals. The origin of this improvement for gold is not yet understood. In this study, operando non-resonant sum frequency generation (SFG) and ex situ high-pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (HP-XPS) have been employed to investigate electrochemically-formed oxide-derived gold (OD-Au) from polycrystalline gold surfaces. A range of different oxidizing conditions were used to form OD-Au in acidic aqueous medium (H3PO4, pH = 1). Our electrochemical data after OD-Au is generated suggest that the surface is metallic gold, however SFG signal variations indicate the presence of subsurface gold oxide remnants between the metallic gold surface layer and bulk gold. The HP-XPS results suggest that this subsurface gold oxide could be in the form of Au2O3 or Au(OH)3. Furthermore, the SFG measurements show that with reducing electrochemical treatments the original gold metallic state can be restored, meaning the subsurface gold oxide is released. This work demonstrates that remnants of gold oxide persist beneath the topmost gold layer when the OD-Au is created, potentially facilitating the understanding of the improved catalytic properties of OD-Au.

Steering CO2 Electroreduction Selectivity U-Turn to Ethylene by Cu-Si Bonded Interface

Copper (Cu), with the advantage of producing a deep reduction product, is a unique catalyst for the electrochemical reduction of CO2 (CO2RR). Designing a Cu-based catalyst to trigger CO2RR to a multicarbon product and understanding the accurate structure-activity relationship for elucidating reaction mechanisms still remain a challenge. Herein, we demonstrate a rational design of a core-shell structured silica-copper catalyst (p-Cu@m-SiO2) through Cu-Si direct bonding for efficient and selective CO2RR. The Cu-Si interface fulfills the inversion in CO2RR product selectivity. The product ratio of C2H4/CH4 changes from 0.6 to 14.4 after silica modification, and the current density reaches a high of up to 450 mA cm-2. The kinetic isotopic effect, in situ attenuated total reflection Fourier-transform infrared spectra, and density functional theory were applied to elucidate the reaction mechanism. The SiO2 shell stabilizes the *H intermediate by forming Si-O-H and inhibits the hydrogen evolution reaction effectively. Moreover, the direct-bonded Cu-Si interface makes bare Cu sites with larger charge density. Such bare Cu sites and Si-O-H sites stabilized the *CHO and activated the *CO, promoting the coupling of *CHO and *CO intermediates to form C2H4. This work provides a promising strategy for designing Cu-based catalysts with high C2H4 catalytic activity.

Spectroscopically Visualizing the Evolution of Hydrogen-Bonding Interactions

Understanding chemical bond variations is the soul of chemistry as it is essential for any chemical process. The evolution of hydrogen bonds is one of the most fundamental and emblematic events during proton transfer; however, its experimental visualization remains a formidable challenge because of the transient timescales. Herein, by subtly regulating the proton-donating ability of distinct proton donors (zeolites or tungstophosphoric acid), a series of different hydrogen-bonding configurations were precisely manipulated. Then, an advanced two-dimensional (2D) heteronuclear correlation nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopic technique was utilized to simultaneously monitor the electronic properties of proton donors and acceptors (2-13C-acetone or trimethylphosphine oxide) through chemical shifts. Parabolic 1H-13C NMR relationships combined with single-well and double-well potential energy surfaces derived from theoretical simulations quantitatively identified the hydrogen bond types and allowed the evolution of hydrogen bonds to be visualized in diverse acid-base interaction complexes during proton transfer. Our findings provide a new perspective to reveal the nature and evolution of hydrogen bonds and confirm the superiority of 2D NMR techniques in identifying the subtle distinctions of various hydrogen-bonding configurations.

Yttrium atomically incorporated into Co(OH)F nanowires enables efficient electrochemical reduction of nitrate to ammonia

A new kind of electrocatalyst consisting of yttrium-doped Co(OH)F (Y-Co(OH)F) nanowires was synthesized by one hydrothermal method for nitrate electroreduction to ammonia. It was demonstrated that the rare earth element Y, as an oxophilic metal, can be approximated as Lewis acid sites enhancing nitrate adsorption on the catalyst surface. Therefore, the Y-Co(OH)F exhibits excellent nitrate reduction performance, reaching an optimal ammonia production rate of 0.2149 mmol h-1 cm-2 and ammonia faradaic efficiency of 91.81%.

Ambient Pressure X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy Study of Oxidation Phase Transitions on Cu(111) and Cu(110)

The surface structure effect on the oxidation of Cu has been investigated by performing ambient-pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (APXPS) on Cu(111) and Cu(110) surfaces under oxygen pressures ranging from 10-8 to 1 mbar and temperatures from 300 to 750 K. The APXPS results show a subsequential phase transition from chemisorbed O/Cu overlayer to Cu2 O and then to CuO on both surfaces. For a given temperature, the oxygen pressure needed to induce initial formation of Cu2 O on Cu(110) is about two orders of magnitude greater than that on Cu(111), which is in contrast with the facile formation of O/Cu overlayer on clean Cu(110). The depth profile measurements during the initial stage of Cu2 O formation indicate the distinct growth modes of Cu2 O on the two surface orientations. We attribute these prominent effects of surface structure to the disparities in the kinetic processes, such as the dissociation and surface/bulk diffusion over O/Cu overlayers. Our findings provide new insights into the kinetics-controlled process of Cu oxidation by oxygen.

In Situ Studies of Copper-Based CO2 Reduction Electrocatalysts by Scanning Transmission Soft X-ray Microscopy

A microfluidic-enabled electrochemical device has been developed to investigate electrochemically active nanomaterials under reaction conditions using in situ scanning transmission soft X-ray microscopy (STXM). In situ STXM measurements were conducted on electrodeposited Cu catalysts under electrochemical CO2 reduction (CO2R) conditions. The study provides detailed, quantitative results about the changes in the morphology and chemical structure of the catalytic nanoparticles as a function of applied potentials. The deposited Cu nanoparticles initially contain both Cu(0) and Cu(I). As an increasingly cathodic potential is applied, the Cu(I) species gradually convert to Cu(0) over the potential range of +0.4 to 0 V versus the reversible hydrogen electrode (VRHE). During this process, Cu(I) particles of various sizes are converted to metallic Cu at different reaction rates and at slightly different potentials, indicating a degree of heterogeneity in the electrochemical response of discrete particles. At CO2R relevant potentials, only metallic Cu is observed, and the morphology of the particles is fairly stable within the spatial resolution limits of STXM (∼40 nm). We also report in situ STXM studies of a working electrode with relatively thick Cu-based electrodeposits. The spatially resolved chemical analysis identifies that Cu-oxide species can persist under CO2R conditions, but only when the catalytic nanoparticles are electronically isolated from the working electrode and therefore are catalytically irrelevant. In summary, in situ STXM is presented as a technique to gain advanced morphological and spatially resolved chemical structure insights into electrochemically active nanomaterials, which was used to provide improved understanding regarding Cu nanomaterial catalysts under CO2 reduction conditions.

Gaining Deep Understanding of Electrochemical CO2 RR with In Situ/Operando Techniques

Electrocatalysis for CO2 conversion has been extensively studied to mitigate the energy shortage and environmental issues, which are gaining ever-increasing attention. However, the complicated CO2 reduction process and the dynamic evolution occurring on electrocatalyst surface make it hard to understand the catalytic mechanism. The development of advanced in situ/operando techniques intelligently coupled with electrochemical cells sheds light on the related study via capturing surface atomic rearrangement, tracing chemical state change of catalysts, monitoring the behavior of intermediates and products, and depicting microenvironment near the electrode surface. In this review, fundamentals of the state-of-the-art in situ/operando techniques are clarified first. Case studies on the in situ/operando techniques performed to probe the CO2 reduction reaction processes are then discussed in detail. Finally, conclusions and outlook on this field are presented.

Unraveling Catalytic Reaction Mechanism by In Situ Near Ambient Pressure X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy

Probing surface chemistry during reactions closer to realistic conditions is crucial for the understanding of mechanisms in heterogeneous catalysis. Near ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (NAP-XPS) is one of the state-of-the-art surface-sensitive techniques used to characterize catalyst surfaces in gas phases. This Perspective begins with a brief overview of the development of the NAP-XPS technique and its representative applications in identifying the active sites at a molecular level. Next, recent in situ NAP-XPS investigations of several model catalysts in the CO₂ hydrogenation reaction are mainly discussed. Finally, we highlight the major challenges facing NAP-XPS and future improvements to facilities for probing intermediates with higher resolutions under real ambient pressure reactions in heterogeneous catalysis.

In Situ Monitoring of H2-Induced Nonstoichiometry in Cu2O

Using ambient-pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and Auger electron spectroscopy to monitor the reduction of Cu₂O in H₂, we identify the formation of an intermediate, oxygen-deficient Cu₂O phase and its progressive inward growth into the deeper region of the oxide. Complemented by atomistic modeling, we show that the oxygen-deficient Cu₂O formation occurs via molecular H₂ adsorption at the Cu₂O surface, which results in the loss of lattice oxygen from the formation of H₂O molecules that desorb spontaneously from the oxide surface. The resulting oxygen-deficient Cu₂O is a stable intermediate that persists before the Cu₂O is fully reduced to metallic Cu. The oxygen vacancy-induced charge of the coordinating Cu atoms results in a satellite feature in Cu LMM, which can be used as a fingerprint to identify nonstoichiometry in oxides and local charge transfer induced by the nonstoichiometry.

Modeling Operando Electrochemical CO2 Reduction

Since the seminal works on the application of density functional theory and the computational hydrogen electrode to electrochemical CO₂ reduction (eCO₂R) and hydrogen evolution (HER), the modeling of both reactions has quickly evolved for the last two decades. Formulation of thermodynamic and kinetic linear scaling relationships for key intermediates on crystalline materials have led to the definition of activity volcano plots, overpotential diagrams, and full exploitation of these theoretical outcomes at laboratory scale. However, recent studies hint at the role of morphological changes and short-lived intermediates in ruling the catalytic performance under operating conditions, further raising the bar for the modeling of electrocatalytic systems. Here, we highlight some novel methodological approaches employed to address eCO₂R and HER reactions. Moving from the atomic scale to the bulk electrolyte, we first show how ab initio and machine learning methodologies can partially reproduce surface reconstruction under operation, thus identifying active sites and reaction mechanisms if coupled with microkinetic modeling. Later, we introduce the potential of density functional theory and machine learning to interpret data from Operando spectroelectrochemical techniques, such as Raman spectroscopy and extended X-ray absorption fine structure characterization. Next, we review the role of electrolyte and mass transport effects. Finally, we suggest further challenges for computational modeling in the near future as well as our perspective on the directions to follow.

Structure-Function Correlation and Dynamic Restructuring of Cu for Highly Efficient Electrochemical CO2 Conversion

The increasing global demand for sustainable energy sources and emerging environmental issues have pushed the development of energy conversion and storage technologies to the forefront of chemical research. Electrochemical carbon dioxide (CO₂ ) conversion provides an attractive approach to synthesizing fuels and chemical feedstocks using renewable energy. On the path to deploying this technology, basic and applied scientific hurdles remain. Copper, as the only metal catalyst that is capable to produce C₂₊ fuels from CO₂ reduction (CO₂ R), still faces challenges in the improvement of electrosynthesis pathways for highly selective fuel production. In this regard, mechanistically understanding CO₂ R on Cu-based electrocatalysts, particularly identifying the structure-function correlation, is crucial. Here, a broad view of the variable structural parameters and their complex interplay in CO₂ R catalysis on Cu was given, with the purpose of providing deep insights and guiding the future rational design of CO₂ R electrocatalysts. First, this Review described the progress and recent advances in the development of well-defined nanostructured catalysts and the mechanistic understanding on the influences from a particular structure of a catalyst, such as facet, defects, morphology, oxidation state, composition, and interface. Next, the in-situ dynamic restructuring of Cu was presented. The importance of operando characterization methods to understand the catalyst structure-sensitivity was also discussed. Finally, some perspectives on the future outlook for electrochemical CO₂ R were offered.